‘Ruben Amorim backed himself into a corner - but can make Man Utd mistake right'

Ruben Amorim was appointed as Manchester United manager in November, but has struggled since, with the club finishing 15th in the Premier League and losing the Europa League final
Former Manchester United coach Rene Meulensteen has slammed Ruben Amorim for his unwavering commitment to his favoured 3-4-3 formation, despite results not going United's way since he took over at Old Trafford. After taking the reins in November, following an impressive stint at Sporting CP, Amorim struggled to hit the ground running with the Red Devils.
He ultimately steered them to a 15th place finish in the league and defeat to Tottenham Hotspur in the Europa League final.
‌
Amorim, 40, managed a meagre seven wins out of 27 league games and subsequently missed out on European football qualification. Now, his relentless use of his preferred system has drawn criticism from Meulensteen.
‌
'I find it, in my personal opinion, a bit short-sighted in that respect,' Meulensteen said on the High Performance podcast. 'I think if he worded it differently from the start, he would not have got hunted by it every single day because constantly the media will come back to him. 'You're losing again today, is it because of the system?'
"I think he should have said, 'Listen, I prefer a 3-4-3 system. I had a lot of success with it. I know it can work. I'm going to try to make it work at Manchester United. However, I need to have a look at the squad first. I need to look at how I can best use the players and utilise their strengths because that's what you need to do. And I need to get to know the Premier League and the opponents and everything.'
"There's so many variables that have an effect on whether that system is going to work or not," Meulensteen continued. "So if he would have done that, he would have been more flexible in getting to grips with the size of the task anyway, never mind losing or winning games. Now, when you win games, things become easier, because you can get your message across easier."
Meulensteen, who worked under Sir Alex Ferguson for the last six years of the Scotsman's reign, fears that Amorim's determination to stick to his principles could prove to be an error. However, he has argued that it is not too late for Amorim to change his ways, as per the Manchester Evening News.
"It is hard to say what kind of advice you would give him, because if he diverts from that, he sees it as a weakness," Meulensteen added. "So that's why he's been, maybe, stubborn and stuck to it . 'I'm going to make it work, no matter what.'
‌
"I don't think it would be a sign of weakness. He comes across a lot of times as very, very honest. Why couldn't you say, 'Listen I know I've said this. However, the experiences I've had over the last few months make me rethink and review. I genuinely believe that it is in the best interests of all of us–the team, the squad–-that I tweak a few things.'
"He has tweaked a few things, when he's played Garnacho in that number eight role on the left-hand side. He gave him the leeway to go to the wide areas because that's where Garnacho's strength is, and then run at people and come inside.
"I also do think that you never should stick yourself to one particular system, because a system is nothing else than a framework. How you're going to start the game. The moment the whistle goes, a 4-4-2 flows into a 4-3-3, a 2-4-4, however the game pans out. So that is not the most important thing."
Regardless of whether Amorim makes a tactical switch or not, United are facing a crucial summer transfer window as they gear up for next season without the prospect of European football. The club have already signed Matheus Cunha from Wolves and are targeting Brentford forward Bryan Mbeumo.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Sun

17 minutes ago

• The Sun

Man Utd transfer news LIVE: Italian giants ‘join race for Hojlund', Rashford sends Barcelona PLEA, Mbeumo makes ‘U-TURN'

Bryan Mbeumo U-turn Manchester United have reportedly been dealt a transfer blow amid their pursuit of Brentford star Bryan Mbeumo. Mbeumo appeared to have been prioritising a move to United despite Tottenham's attempts to reunite him with his former manager Thomas Frank. But latest reports suggest the winger has made a major U-turn regarding his preference. According to journalist Duncan Castles, the Cameroon international favours a move to Spurs rather than Man Utd. The North Londoners can offer the 25-year-old something the Red Devils can't - and that's Champions League football.

Belfast Telegraph

38 minutes ago

• Belfast Telegraph

Why Irish League's European quartet will be hopeful after finding out fate... and why it's crucial we get some positive results

This week's European draws proved something of an anomaly for Irish League sides in that not a single one landed a nightmare outcome. All four of our representatives will fancy their chances of negotiating the first hurdle of continental action — and if truth be told, we're in dire need of a positive summer on the UEFA stage.

Daily Mirror

an hour ago

• Daily Mirror

Isak 'taking things into own hands' claim shows what Liverpool and Arsenal need

Alexander Isak has been linked with a move to Liverpool and Arsenal in the summer transfer window, but he has been told he doesn't need to leave Newcastle United to realise his ambitions Liverpool and Arsenal need Alexander Isak to take matters into his own hands if they are to have any chance of signing the Newcastle striker this summer. That's according to former Magpies midfielder Geremi, who also insists the Swede doesn't need to leave St James' Park to take his career to the next level. The Gunners, who are in the market for a top-class number nine this summer, are long-term admirers of Isak. Meanwhile, Liverpool have also emerged as potential suitors as they look for an upgrade on Darwin Nunez, who's available for sale. ‌ However, Newcastle are under no pressure to sell and would only consider letting him leave for a fee in excess of £150million, reports The Telegraph. ‌ There has been no suggestion that Isak – whose Magpies contract has another three years left to run – is really angling for a move. That stance from the player would need to change, says Geremi, for either of last season's top two to land the prolific 25-year-old. 'First of all, they [Newcastle] need to keep their best players at all costs,' said Geremi, speaking to BoyleSports, who offer the latest Club World Cup odds. 'I'm not sure Newcastle would sell Isak for any fee, but it would become an issue if the player took the decision into his own hands.' Having won the Carabao Cup earlier this year and qualified for the Champions League, the former Chelsea midfielder and Cameroon international insists the Magpies are now on the 'same level' as Liverpool and Arsenal. ‌ Geremi added: 'He had a great season and is at one of the biggest teams in the world when it comes to financial backing. 'The environment is all there and I don't think he would gain anything by moving to Liverpool or Arsenal. I think Newcastle are at the same level. Newcastle are now contenders to win the Premier League and the Champions League. 'When they got new owners, I said it would take them three or four years and a trophy to put them in that position and now they are there. They are ready to compete because they have been built under Eddie Howe, they have the right finances and they are an attractive proposition for new players. ‌ 'New signings will have no doubt about joining the club this summer and I wouldn't be surprised if they have an incredible season.' For Arsenal, a deal for either Benjamin Seskso or Viktor Gyokeres looks much more likely at this stage. A new number nine is seen as critical as Arsenal look to go from 'nearly men' to winners following three successive runner-up finishes in the Premier League. Meanwhile, Liverpool have already been busy this summer, signing Bayer Leverkusen pair Florian Wirtz and Jeremie Frimpong. The former has now completed his transfer, which could rise to £116m – meaning the Reds have already broken the British record this summer.