Dentists warn of taking fluoride out of NY water. But many counties already don't have it
Dentists warn of taking fluoride out of NY water. But many counties already don't have it
Show Caption
Hide Caption
Fluoridated water important, stresses Ossining NY Supervisor Feldman
Elizabeth Feldman, who worked as a dental hygienist, is joining the effort to push back against groups seeking to remove fluoride from public water.
In New York, 336 community water systems, out of a total of 2,790, have fluoridated water.
These 336 community water systems provide water to more than 13 million people, or about 72% of all New Yorkers.
Now the nation's top health official, RFK Jr., is pushing for bans on water fluoridation, prompting pushback from many public health officials and local leaders in NY.
Elizabeth Feldman sees her dental X-rays as a warning of the life-altering consequences of living in a community that doesn't add fluoride to its drinking water.
The stark black-and-white images are rife with cavity-riddled translucent teeth. Bright white spots cover most teeth, revealing an extensive patchwork of dental fillings and crowns. Screws dig into parts of the jaw pockmarked by root canals.
Taken together, the X-rays tell the story of a lifetime of dental pain and suffering.
But Feldman, a town supervisor in New York's Hudson Valley who's worked as a dental hygienist for 30 years, believes she would have avoided most of that dental work, which cost thousands of dollars, if her childhood home had access to fluoridated drinking water.
Instead, Feldman grew up drinking unfluoridated well water, and she missed out on the lifelong oral health benefits that many New Yorkers get from living in towns, cities and neighborhoods that have added fluoride to community water systems.
Now Feldman is fighting to protect others from her fate as New York becomes a key battleground of the anti-fluoride movement being led by the nation's top health official, Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
'I just wish people would get educated and look at real science and not be led astray,' Feldman said.
New York's fluoride fight
Kennedy has endorsed claims that fluoride is behind a host of health conditions, from Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder and hypothyroidism to lowering IQ. Dentists and epidemiologists have hit back at those accusations as scientifically unproven.
At the same time, public health officials in New York are pushing back against anti-fluoride groups seeking to pass state or local measures to remove fluoride from public drinking water.
Decades of research, health officials noted, has shown water fluoridation reduces tooth decay for entire populations, while uniquely benefiting poor and marginalized New Yorkers.
"Because the fluoridated water supply reaches everyone equally, health disparities decrease, as we know not everyone has access to regular dentist checkups,' state Health Commissioner Dr. James McDonald said.
'Water fluoridation provides everyone with the same starting opportunity of having a healthy smile,' he added.
Dental care: More than 30,000 wait for care as NY's dental crisis grows
Overall, cavities drop by about 25% for those who drink fluoridated water when compared to others who don't, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Still, some states are considering passing measures that ban fluoride from community water systems, with Republican-controlled state governments in Utah and Florida recently taking that step.
While a statewide ban is unlikely in deep blue New York, the fluoride debate has exploded at the local level in recent years. It was the focus of a class-action lawsuit filed in Buffalo in 2023 after residents learned the city quietly removed fluoride from drinking water, and it sits at the center of emotionally-charged town hearings that divide even the most close-knit communities from Ithaca to Westchester County.
How many New York towns have fluoride in water?
In New York, 336 community water systems, out of a total of 2,790, have fluoridated water. But these 336 community water systems provide water to more than 13 million people, or about 72% of all New Yorkers served by community water systems.
That percentage mirrored the national average, as many of the largest water systems in the U.S. have added fluoride for the past nearly 80 years.
But major disparities in water fluoridation persist. New York City and some upstate counties, such as Monroe and Onondaga, have nearly 100% coverage, while other counties, such as Rockland and Tompkins, have never added fluoride to public drinking water.
Health care: As flu kills record number of NY kids, a mom who lost a child fights vaccine hesitancy
The stakes of that disparity are unfolding in real time for Dr. Fanny Vainer. They are written on the faces of scores of parents who were stunned to learn their child has advanced tooth decay during visits to Vainer's Sparkill Dental practice in a tiny Rockland County hamlet.
Many of those parents were simply unaware that Rockland County's lack of water fluoridation played a role in rotting out their kids' teeth, Vainer said.
Recalling her talks with the guilt-ridden parents looking for ways to reverse the damage, she said, in many ways, 'It's already too late when you arrive here in the dentist's chair.'
Further, Rockland's overall oral health should be studied, Vainer suggested, to improve understanding of the extent of damage done in communities with unfluoridated drinking water.
If conducted, that research would seek to build upon a landmark 2010 state Health Department study that found, in part, the use of serious dental procedures and tooth extractions for New York kids on Medicaid was 33% higher in communities without water fluoridation.
'An unnecessary public health crisis'
Meanwhile, in neighboring Westchester County, one town's leadership has already reversed course on its approach to adding fluoride to its water.
Town leaders in Yorktown, a wealthy New York City suburb, voted in December to remove fluoride from their community drinking water system. Yorktown Supervisor Ed Lachterman spearheaded the action, citing in part a federal court ruling that asserted water fluoridation presents an 'unreasonable risk of injury to health or the environment.'
The American Dental Association has since criticized that federal court ruling, however, noting it was based largely on an August 2024 report from the federal National Toxicology Program that included invalid biomarkers and insufficient sample sizes.
Put simply, the federal court ruling reflects a 'fundamental misunderstanding and misapplication of the prevailing scientific literature on the safety of fluoride and community water fluoridation,' the national dental group added.
At the same time, Yorktown's decision captured national attention, prompting public health officials across the Hudson Valley to launch new efforts to combat medical misinformation, citing rising distrust in everything from water fluoridation to vaccines.
Investigation: Trust in science, medicine plummeted because of COVID. See inside the fight to rebuild it
'Like measles, this is catching on and once the anti-fluoride groups win in one community, they go on to the others,' said Susan Siegel, the lone Yorktown council member to oppose removing fluoride from drinking water.
Westchester Health Commissioner Dr. Sherlita Amler attended Yorktown public hearings last year to provide facts about the benefits of water fluoridation. But she left them feeling concerned about how deeply anti-science sentiments had taken hold in some households.
Recalling the conspiracy theories and debunked science claims being raised during the hearings, Amler said, 'I don't know how you wrap your head around that.'
The Yorktown fluoride removal vote was also a call-to-arms for Feldman, who's been supervisor of nearby Ossining for three years and vowed to quell any anti-fluoride incursions in her community.
'So few things can be done so inexpensively to impact positively the lives and health outcomes of all the residents,' Feldman said of water fluoridation.
How we reported it: NY, facing dental crisis, taking on RFK Jr.'s anti-fluoride push
Addressing claims that people get enough benefits from fluoridated toothpastes or dental treatments, Feldman noted those do indeed help but are incapable of achieving the level of protection from drinking fluoridated water.
Put differently, ingested fluoride becomes part of the tooth before it erupts and strengthens kids' teeth in a way that nothing else in dentistry comes close to, and adults with limited access to dental care benefit from drinking fluoridated water, too.
'It's baffling to me that they would want to create an unnecessary public health crisis and walk back on a proven public health achievement,' Feldman added.
Includes reporting by Cybele Mayes-Osterman of USA TODAY.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
2 days ago
- USA Today
Dentists warn of taking fluoride out of NY water. But many counties already don't have it
Dentists warn of taking fluoride out of NY water. But many counties already don't have it Show Caption Hide Caption Fluoridated water important, stresses Ossining NY Supervisor Feldman Elizabeth Feldman, who worked as a dental hygienist, is joining the effort to push back against groups seeking to remove fluoride from public water. In New York, 336 community water systems, out of a total of 2,790, have fluoridated water. These 336 community water systems provide water to more than 13 million people, or about 72% of all New Yorkers. Now the nation's top health official, RFK Jr., is pushing for bans on water fluoridation, prompting pushback from many public health officials and local leaders in NY. Elizabeth Feldman sees her dental X-rays as a warning of the life-altering consequences of living in a community that doesn't add fluoride to its drinking water. The stark black-and-white images are rife with cavity-riddled translucent teeth. Bright white spots cover most teeth, revealing an extensive patchwork of dental fillings and crowns. Screws dig into parts of the jaw pockmarked by root canals. Taken together, the X-rays tell the story of a lifetime of dental pain and suffering. But Feldman, a town supervisor in New York's Hudson Valley who's worked as a dental hygienist for 30 years, believes she would have avoided most of that dental work, which cost thousands of dollars, if her childhood home had access to fluoridated drinking water. Instead, Feldman grew up drinking unfluoridated well water, and she missed out on the lifelong oral health benefits that many New Yorkers get from living in towns, cities and neighborhoods that have added fluoride to community water systems. Now Feldman is fighting to protect others from her fate as New York becomes a key battleground of the anti-fluoride movement being led by the nation's top health official, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. 'I just wish people would get educated and look at real science and not be led astray,' Feldman said. New York's fluoride fight Kennedy has endorsed claims that fluoride is behind a host of health conditions, from Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder and hypothyroidism to lowering IQ. Dentists and epidemiologists have hit back at those accusations as scientifically unproven. At the same time, public health officials in New York are pushing back against anti-fluoride groups seeking to pass state or local measures to remove fluoride from public drinking water. Decades of research, health officials noted, has shown water fluoridation reduces tooth decay for entire populations, while uniquely benefiting poor and marginalized New Yorkers. "Because the fluoridated water supply reaches everyone equally, health disparities decrease, as we know not everyone has access to regular dentist checkups,' state Health Commissioner Dr. James McDonald said. 'Water fluoridation provides everyone with the same starting opportunity of having a healthy smile,' he added. Dental care: More than 30,000 wait for care as NY's dental crisis grows Overall, cavities drop by about 25% for those who drink fluoridated water when compared to others who don't, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Still, some states are considering passing measures that ban fluoride from community water systems, with Republican-controlled state governments in Utah and Florida recently taking that step. While a statewide ban is unlikely in deep blue New York, the fluoride debate has exploded at the local level in recent years. It was the focus of a class-action lawsuit filed in Buffalo in 2023 after residents learned the city quietly removed fluoride from drinking water, and it sits at the center of emotionally-charged town hearings that divide even the most close-knit communities from Ithaca to Westchester County. How many New York towns have fluoride in water? In New York, 336 community water systems, out of a total of 2,790, have fluoridated water. But these 336 community water systems provide water to more than 13 million people, or about 72% of all New Yorkers served by community water systems. That percentage mirrored the national average, as many of the largest water systems in the U.S. have added fluoride for the past nearly 80 years. But major disparities in water fluoridation persist. New York City and some upstate counties, such as Monroe and Onondaga, have nearly 100% coverage, while other counties, such as Rockland and Tompkins, have never added fluoride to public drinking water. Health care: As flu kills record number of NY kids, a mom who lost a child fights vaccine hesitancy The stakes of that disparity are unfolding in real time for Dr. Fanny Vainer. They are written on the faces of scores of parents who were stunned to learn their child has advanced tooth decay during visits to Vainer's Sparkill Dental practice in a tiny Rockland County hamlet. Many of those parents were simply unaware that Rockland County's lack of water fluoridation played a role in rotting out their kids' teeth, Vainer said. Recalling her talks with the guilt-ridden parents looking for ways to reverse the damage, she said, in many ways, 'It's already too late when you arrive here in the dentist's chair.' Further, Rockland's overall oral health should be studied, Vainer suggested, to improve understanding of the extent of damage done in communities with unfluoridated drinking water. If conducted, that research would seek to build upon a landmark 2010 state Health Department study that found, in part, the use of serious dental procedures and tooth extractions for New York kids on Medicaid was 33% higher in communities without water fluoridation. 'An unnecessary public health crisis' Meanwhile, in neighboring Westchester County, one town's leadership has already reversed course on its approach to adding fluoride to its water. Town leaders in Yorktown, a wealthy New York City suburb, voted in December to remove fluoride from their community drinking water system. Yorktown Supervisor Ed Lachterman spearheaded the action, citing in part a federal court ruling that asserted water fluoridation presents an 'unreasonable risk of injury to health or the environment.' The American Dental Association has since criticized that federal court ruling, however, noting it was based largely on an August 2024 report from the federal National Toxicology Program that included invalid biomarkers and insufficient sample sizes. Put simply, the federal court ruling reflects a 'fundamental misunderstanding and misapplication of the prevailing scientific literature on the safety of fluoride and community water fluoridation,' the national dental group added. At the same time, Yorktown's decision captured national attention, prompting public health officials across the Hudson Valley to launch new efforts to combat medical misinformation, citing rising distrust in everything from water fluoridation to vaccines. Investigation: Trust in science, medicine plummeted because of COVID. See inside the fight to rebuild it 'Like measles, this is catching on and once the anti-fluoride groups win in one community, they go on to the others,' said Susan Siegel, the lone Yorktown council member to oppose removing fluoride from drinking water. Westchester Health Commissioner Dr. Sherlita Amler attended Yorktown public hearings last year to provide facts about the benefits of water fluoridation. But she left them feeling concerned about how deeply anti-science sentiments had taken hold in some households. Recalling the conspiracy theories and debunked science claims being raised during the hearings, Amler said, 'I don't know how you wrap your head around that.' The Yorktown fluoride removal vote was also a call-to-arms for Feldman, who's been supervisor of nearby Ossining for three years and vowed to quell any anti-fluoride incursions in her community. 'So few things can be done so inexpensively to impact positively the lives and health outcomes of all the residents,' Feldman said of water fluoridation. How we reported it: NY, facing dental crisis, taking on RFK Jr.'s anti-fluoride push Addressing claims that people get enough benefits from fluoridated toothpastes or dental treatments, Feldman noted those do indeed help but are incapable of achieving the level of protection from drinking fluoridated water. Put differently, ingested fluoride becomes part of the tooth before it erupts and strengthens kids' teeth in a way that nothing else in dentistry comes close to, and adults with limited access to dental care benefit from drinking fluoridated water, too. 'It's baffling to me that they would want to create an unnecessary public health crisis and walk back on a proven public health achievement,' Feldman added. Includes reporting by Cybele Mayes-Osterman of USA TODAY.
New York Post
4 days ago
- New York Post
Two sons who blame Cuomo for elderly dad's COVID death endorse Lander for NYC mayor
Two grieving sons who blame then-Gov. Andrew Cuomo's controversial nursing-home edict for the death of their father and scores of others from COVID-19 have endorsed rival Brad Lander for mayor. Peter and Daniel Arbeeny's dad, Norman, 89, died from COVID after a rehab stint in a nursing home in Cobble Hill, Brooklyn. Under Cuomo's policy, which was instituted in March 2020, patients who were infected with the coronavirus but stabilized were admitted or readmitted to nursing homes at a time when the facilities were not able to test for the deadly bug or provide adequate personal protective equipment to contain the infection, critics said. Cuomo, who resigned as governor in 2021 amid a spate of sexual-misconduct accusations he denies, is now the front-runner in the Democratic primary for New York City mayor. The Arbeeny brothers' endorsement of Lander was held outside the Cobble Hill Nursing Home where their dad had been cared for. 'It is my honor to endorse Brad, because he answered our families call for help during the height of COVID in April of 2020 when the city shut down,' Peter said Monday of the current city comptroller and mayoral candidate. 'Five years ago, when no elected official would meet or stand up for us, Brad Lander was the one public official who fought alongside us to expose Andrew Cuomo's lies, and seek accountability for our father and so many other grieving New the current city comptroller seeking the mayoralty,' the son said. 'Brad has empathy, is a decent, honest and tough person and is exactly what we need in a mayor.' Lander invited Peter as a guest at last week's mayoral debate. He urged the son to stand up and be recognized and demanded that Cuomo apologize to him and other nursing-home families for the disastrous policy, which was revoked six weeks later, after thousands of vulnerable sick New Yorkers had already been either admitted or readmitted into nursing homes. 'I have so much admiration for Peter and Daniel Arbeeny, who have bravely sought accountability from disgraced ex-governor Andrew Cuomo for five years and are still fighting to honor the legacy of their father, Norman. I'm deeply touched to receive their endorsement today,' Lander said. During the debate, Cuomo did not apologize for his nursing-home directive. 'Mr. Arbeeny lost a father,' Cuomo said. 'I am very, very sorry for that.' But Cuomo said Lander and Arbeeny were wrong on the facts. Cuomo noted Arbeeny sued the state and said legal papers in the case found that no COVID-positive person was sent from a hospital to the nursing home where his father was admitted. 'So it is factually impossible, Brad, that he got COVID, OK, from someone coming from a hospital,' Cuomo said. Daniel Arbeeny led a class-action federal lawsuit against Cuomo, which was dismissed by a Brooklyn federal judge. But the COVID-19 controversy continues to haunt Cuomo. Last week, Cuomo said he not only saw a controversial report on nursing-home COVID deaths in the state while he was governor but may have altered the document before its release – a bombshell confession that contradicts his sworn congressional testimony. 'I did not recall seeing the report at the time. I did see the report, it turns out,' Cuomo told PIX11 News. 'I'm sure if I read the report, I made language changes.' The mea culpa comes after the Department of Justice earlier this year reportedly opened a criminal investigation into whether Cuomo lied on Capitol Hill when he adamantly denied that he drafted, reviewed, discussed or consulted on the nursing-home report. Emails obtained by a congressional subcommittee show that Cuomo aides discussed his role in drafting the report and include the former governor's own handwritten edits. The report downplayed the consequences of Cuomo's March 25, 2020, directive that forced recovering COVID patients into senior care facilities without mandated testing to see if they could still infect others. The state also initially underreported the deaths of nursing home residents by nearly 50%. Cuomo has long maintained his administration was following federal guidance when the state Health Department implemented the COVID-19 nursing-home directive and that all COVID deaths were reported. During his grilling by the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic in June 2024, he denied accusations of mishandling the COVID response and pointed to federal guidance as having hampered his administration's response. .
Politico
4 days ago
- Politico
Lawmakers aim to close opioid settlement fund loophole
Beat Memo A linguistic loophole could put an estimated $250 million opioid settlement payout in jeopardy due to New York for addiction treatment, prevention and recovery programs, POLITICO Pro's Maya Kaufman reports. The settlement proceeds were secured earlier this year in part by State Attorney General Letitia James, who worked on a multistate case against members of the Sackler family and their company Purdue Pharma, which developed the opioid painkiller OxyContin. The state's legal definition of opioid settlements is limited to manufacturers, distributors, dispensers, consultants, chain pharmacies and related entities. That means settlement money from the Sacklers themselves would bypass the state's dedicated opioid settlement fund — which, by law, can only be spent on addiction-related programming — and instead end up in the general fund, where there are no strings attached. Legislation that would close the loophole passed the Senate earlier this month and is now awaiting a floor vote in the Assembly as session winds to a close. 'New Yorkers deserve full accountability in how opioid settlement funds are used. (This bill) ensures those funds go directly toward what they were meant for: expanding prevention, treatment, and recovery services in communities hardest hit by the opioid epidemic,' Assembly sponsor Michaelle Solages said in a statement. 'We owe it to the families and communities who continue to carry the weight of this crisis.' The measure is expected to pass the Assembly before the end of session Tuesday. After that, it would require Gov. Kathy Hochul's signature. 'The opioid crisis has devastated communities across the country, and many families are still suffering from immense pain and loss,' James said in a statement. 'This legislation ensures that the $3 billion in settlements secured by my office for New York, including the settlement against the Sackler family, is reinvested in communities to help them heal.' IN OTHER NEWS: — SUNY Downstate Medical Center's former chair of emergency medicine pleaded guilty to a grand larceny charge Friday for stealing approximately $1.4 million from the public hospital between 2016 and 2023, the Brooklyn district attorney's office said.. Physician Michael Lucchesi was found to have used his business credit card to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars on personal travel, a New Jersey pet hotel, New York Sports Club membership and tuition payments for his children, among other expenses. SUNY discovered the thefts during an audit, according to the Brooklyn DA's office. Lucchesi agreed to make restitution of $656,074 to Downstate's clinical practice when he is sentenced in August, the Brooklyn DA's office said. ON THE AGENDA: — Monday at 10 a.m. The NYC Health + Hospitals board of directors' audit committee meets, followed by the strategic planning committee. — Tuesday, 9:30 a.m. to 11 a.m. The New York City Community Services Board's mental health subcommittee meets. — Tuesday at 10 a.m. The state Public Health and Health Planning Council's public health committee will meet. — Wednesday at 10 a.m. The state Public Health and Health Planning Council will meet. GOT TIPS? Send story ideas and feedback to Maya Kaufman at mkaufman@ and Katelyn Cordero at kcordero@ Want to receive this newsletter every weekday? Subscribe to POLITICO Pro. You'll also receive daily policy news and other intelligence you need to act on the day's biggest stories. What you may have missed — Albany Medical Center was fined $375,000 last week for failing to correct violations of the state's clinical staffing law, marking the Department of Health's first settlement to date over hospital understaffing, POLITICO Pro's Katelyn Cordero and Maya Kaufman report. The settlement stemmed from a July 2024 state probe that found hundreds of violations within Albany Medical Center's clinical staffing plans, according to the New York State Nurses Association, which represents nurses there and submitted numerous complaints of understaffing. Over the next several months, the private hospital failed to submit an adequate plan of correction to resolve the staffing violations, the Health Department concluded. ODDS AND ENDS NOW WE KNOW — Less than half of physicians were in private practice last year, per the American Medical Association. TODAY'S TIP — These are the healthiest types of seafood. STUDY THIS — Walking for more than 100 minutes daily was associated with a lower risk of chronic low back pain, according to a study published Friday. WHAT WE'RE READING — In fight over research overhead funding, universities propose alternatives to Trump's cuts. (STAT) — How Kennedy's purge of advisers could disrupt U.S. vaccinations. (New York Times) Around POLITICO — Kennedy's promises on vaccines are being put to the test, Lauren Gardner and Sophie Gardner report. — Children's Hospital Los Angeles to shut gender clinic, Rachel Bluth reports MISSED A ROUNDUP? Get caught up on the New York Health Care Newsletter.
