Opinion: Toxic positivity's hidden harm to mental health
Sometimes it seems like we are a culture addicted to happiness. Social media news feeds are filled with #GoodVibesOnly tweets, self-help books brainwash us to the power of limitless optimism, and good friends teach us to 'just think positive!' when life isn't going so well. What if, rather than keeping us happy, this cultural mandate of optimism is preventing us from being happy?
I mean toxic positivity — the assumption we can only be positive in every situation and cut off all else. On paper it sounds wonderful, even therapeutic-sounding. However, the suppression of bad feelings can cause a rebound.
It was discovered in a 2018 Journal of Personality and Social Psychology study that individuals who embraced their negative emotions had lower depression and anxiety levels than individuals who suppressed or denied them. Suppression of negative emotions was associated with reduced long-term emotional resilience in a 2017 NIH study.
The problem isn't that we're getting too scared—it's that other feelings are being de-legitimized. When you say to someone who's in pain or hurt, 'just be thankful for what you have!' you're hearing it as the message that your pain is not valid. Psychologist and author Susan David argues that emotional well-being is a side effect of accepting all of the feelings, not only the good ones. Social media sites such as Instagram and TikTok engage in toxic positivity by encouraging the airbrushed highlight reel of life. In a 2021 NIH study, researchers found that binge-watching 'positive' content leaves the viewer worse-off since they compare their very real issues to other individuals' seemingly perfect lives.
I've seen it myself. A sophomore at Washington Connections Academy who requested to be anonymous once told me, 'I feel guilty feeling sad because everyone on the internet is so happy.' That guilt only set her further into isolation. Researcher Brené Brown states it more eloquently: 'We cannot selectively numb emotions. When we numb the painful emotions, we also numb the positive emotions.'
Optimism is beautiful, of course — science attaches it to increased physical well-being and durability. But toxic positivity isn't. The first permit struggle; the second closes doors to struggle. As a teaching example, it can be over-loading when telling a patient with cancer 'be positive,' as it represses fear by suggesting restraint on something that should give way. In a 2022 International Journal of Behavioral Medicine article, researchers put cancer patients in a good mood and found they had higher levels of impairment and limited engagement in life after treatment. Sometimes the nicest thing we can tell someone is, 'This really sucks, and I'm here for you.'
What do you do instead? Practice emotional validation – Instead of disqualifying someone else's pain, try: 'That sounds really tough. How can I help you?' In other situations, you can practice 'both-and' thinking – you can love your job and still be outraged about a horrible day. Emotions are not mutually exclusive.
Forcing false happiness isn't liberating us — it's deteriorating us. By eschewing the #PositiveVibesOnly illusion, we're making it easier to live authentic connection and healing. And as psychologist Carl Rogers masterfully explained long ago, 'The curious paradox is that when I accept myself just as I am, then I can change.'
Let's not sweep aside pain in the guise of being optimistic. At times the most kind thing we can do is to say, 'Me too.' Related
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Times
an hour ago
- New York Times
What Is Tapping, and Can It Really Improve Mental Health?
It looks a little goofy. A self-help method called 'tapping,' which involves using the fingertips to perform acupressure while countering negative emotions with breathing exercises and positive affirmations, has elicited eye-rolls from some mental health professionals. 'I'm safe in my car,' a woman on TikTok says as she practices the technique, using a finger to tap the top of her head, then the side of her eyebrow and the middle of her chin. 'I am my safe space.' In the video, she explains that driving by herself is a struggle, but tapping has helped lower her anxiety and refocus her thoughts. Anecdotes like this are easy to find on social media. Over the last 15 years or so, tapping has also popped up on wellness podcasts, TV shows and even the best-seller list. As a result, the practice, also known as the Emotional Freedom Technique or E.F.T., has attracted a devoted following and become a big business. But many experts remain skeptical. Where did tapping come from? Tapping, which falls under the umbrella of energy psychology, originated from a technique called Thought Field Therapy developed by the psychologist Roger Callahan in the 1980s. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Buzz Feed
6 hours ago
- Buzz Feed
30 Beauty Products With Amazing Reviews
A lightweight gel cream from Nivea so shockingly effective, you might trick people into thinking you have a filter on your skin. No, really — it actually happened for one reviewer! This usues the miracle-working abilities of an ingredient called ~Q10~ to deliver plumper, firmer, more moisturized skin. A cult-classic Clinique Almost Lipstick Tinted Lip Balm in Black Honey if you want to keep dry, chapped lips AWAY. This bb is lightweight, slightly glossy, and has a little dash of magic. I mean, I'm guessing it's magic — because the way this glosses you up and complements all different skin tones so beautifully is beyond anything ordinary. A moisturizing hair serum here to breathe some life back into your locks and rescue them from eternal dryness. This delightful blend is derived from seven incredible oils: argan, olive, coconut, apricot, marula, jojoba, and camellia. This reviewer says it gives you gloss without the grease, and that the scent alone makes them want to keep using it! Medicube's "Zero Pore" Pads that do their job so well, they turned this skeptical reviewer into a believer. They contain lactic acid, salicylic acid, and a dual-textured surface to help control excess sebum while exfoliating dead skin and refining pores, all while keeping you looking like a true ~glow-getter~. A pore-clearing cleansing oil because it uses the calming powers of heartleaf oil to soothe irritated skin and eliminate makeup residue, blackheads, and sebum while preventing pore congestion. It's also hypoallergenic and works wonders for sensitive, acne-prone skin. A reviewer-beloved teeth-whitening pen — you'll see the difference almost immediately, and it'll help you avoid having to go get it done by a pro. It's painless, minty fresh, and helps whiten your teeth after years of drinking coffee, tea, wine, and basically anything that isn't water. 🙃 A satin-finish TirTir cushion foundation that's got the whole TikTok beauty community in a chokehold. This all-star gem lets you enjoy 72-hour flawless coverage and offers effortless blending to hide redness, blemishes, and under-eye bags. Plus, it comes in 40 shades and is *packed* with hibiscus and red propolis extracts for a boost in skin elasticity. Perfect for beauty enthusiasts who love effortless applications anytime, anywhere. A TikTok-famous VieBeauti eyelash growth serum to help with upkeep when you can't make it to the esthetician for extensions. Apply to your lashes daily to help them become longer and stronger within just a few weeks! You'll be resisting the urge to flutter your lashes like a cartoon character every time your S.O. walks by in no time. A surprisingly effective instant foot-peeling spray that'll make your footsies so baby-soft and pretty, they'll be a good uh... backup plan (you know, in case your current career doesn't pan out 👀). This not only helps gently remove dead skin, but also moisturizes dry and cracked heels, so you'll really get some refreshing bang for your buck. For an ~extra~ peeling effect, use an exfoliating mitt! A bottle of Elizavecca Hair Treatment some reviewers say is even BETTER than Olaplex, which is over three times the price! It's infused with collagen, ceramides, and protein extracts to help repair your hair if it is damaged, over-processed, or has just spent too much time with that flat iron. Simply apply it on wet hair after shampooing, wait five minutes, and rinse it out. A SeoulCeuticals toner mist — a powerful potion that not only hydrates and plumps your skin but is also a *miracle* worker on blemishes, helping keep those pesky breakouts at bay. It's made with 98% naturally derived ingredients like refreshing cucumber, antioxidant-rich green tea, tamarind, soothing aloe, and rejuvenating marine minerals for a perfect dose of dewy radiance. A cruelty-free under-eye brightener to help balance out the bluish tones of under-eye shadows and dark circles. And bonus! It's infused with hyaluronic acid and shea butter to nourish your skin and give you a radiant glow. Wear it by itself or under your concealer for a more full-coverage look! A paraben-free self-tanner with a dreamy mousse formula that glides over your skin smoothly, ensuring an even application without those pesky streaks. In just one hour, you'll be glowing like you just got back from an exotic, tropical getaway — and you didn't even have to step a foot outside. Dermora's foot exfoliation mask — you apply the two bootie-shaped masks on your feet for an hour, wash your feet, and then, over the next five to seven days, enjoy the disgustingly satisfying experience of watching all of your dead skin fall away to reveal baby-soft feet. Reviewers swear by this for calluses and rough, cracked skin! A light, silky Touch in Sol No Poreblem primer to banish the flaky patches and dryness that dare to mess with your glam. This ultra-hydrating primer will create a base for your makeup that's so satisfyingly smooth, you'll be singin' 🎶smooth operatorrr🎶. It also works *chef's kiss* wonders when it comes to minimizing the appearance of spots, blemishes, and pores! And a tube of Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later eye primer because it'll make the eyeshadow look you created 10 hours ago look like it's only been 10 minutes. It helps keep your eyeshadow from wearing off, smudging, or creasing, and enhances your eyeshadow's color and vibrance! A bestselling Sol De Janeiro firming cream if you want to be known for smelling like a walking Italian bakery, leaving the enchanting scent of salted caramel, pistachio, and vanilla everywhere you go. Enriched with caffeine, guarana extract, and coconut oil, this miraculous little jar of cream will help smooth, firm, and add a glow to your skin. But may I just highlight again its intoxicating scent? According to the reviewers, you might just get a little obsessed. And a Gold Bond neck and chest firming cream, because our décolletage is too often forgotten when it comes to skincare needs. This elixir is a pro at improving your skin's firmness, texture, *and* elasticity. Its salicylic acid gently exfoliates dead skin cells while its stress response proteins boost your skin's moisture retention to help improve smoothness and suppleness. It also contains glycerin and aloe, which adds some extra hydration. Iconic, truly. A pack of two dark spot corrector soap bars, which you can use on your face as well as your hands, neck, bikini area, inner thighs, and underarms. Its wonderful mix of shea butter, olive oil, turmeric, hyaluronic acid, and retinol will give hyper-pigmented areas an even glow by helping to reduce scars and restore moisture. The cult-favorite Cosrx snail mucin repairing essence because it will soothe and rejuvenate your skin so effectively, it'll make you think the exact opposite of "ew" when you think of snail mucin. It can also give your skin a natural "I woke up like this" glow that has earned it over 66,000 5-star ratings! An easy-to-apply fungal nail renewal formula if you wanna get those toes lookin' healthy and sandal-ready for the sunny season. Apply this fast-acting formula, and you can start seeing visual improvements in as little as two days! A cruelty-free Essence Lash Princess mascara, which might make you want to throw out your falsies. It gives you all the length and volume WITHOUT the clumps and globs and has shocked reviewers with how full it leaves their lashes looking compared to other, more expensive brands. It's a fan fave for a reason! A Briotech spray that might even give the pricier Tower 28 spray a run for its money. Packed with the same key ingredient, hypochlorous acid, this skincare gem will quickly become one of your staples as it helps to soothe inflammation, calm angry red patches, and fortify your skin's barrier. A benzene-free mattifying dry shampoo powder to trick people into thinking it most definitely has not been a week since you last washed your hair. This is infused with biotin, black ginseng, and root-boosting powder and comes with a conveniently attached puff so that you can dab, dab, dab away all that excess oil and grease to instantly add some volume back into your hair. Retinol body lotion that'll enhance your already beautiful skin. It's overflowing with powerful ingredients like vitamins A and E, ferulic acid, shea butter, and green tea to help diminish the look of deep wrinkles, fine lines, sagging skin, crepey skin, and even sun damage — all while giving your collagen production a *major* boost to help with firming. An illuminating L'Oreal moisturizer because it'll have you looking glowy, sun-kissed, and ready for that lunchtime walk you planned your whole day around. The glycerin and shea butter in it also give it a mega hydrating factor. It's a lotion, glowy foundation base, and highlighter all in one bottle. Oh, and it has over 33,000 5-star ratings! A Wonderskin lip stain, which reviewers rave about because of how true it is to its long-lasting, transfer-resistant reputation! It glides on as a vibrant blue hue that you can peel off to reveal an adorable, rosy lip stain. So treat yourself, and ~kiss~ those constant lipstick re-applications goodbye. 💋 An *iconic* Revlon one-step hair dryer and volumizer (with over 400,000 5-star ratings!!!) that will save you more than double the time it takes you to style your hair with a traditional blow-dryer and round brush — it'll give you soft, smooth waves with just a few passes! A satin-covered RobeCurls heatless hair rod if you want voluminous, Barbie-worthy curls without the need for heat damage. Wrap your hair into it before bedtime, and you'll wake up with envy-worthy, bouncy curls. A lightly tinted nail concealer to give your nails a milky, healthy-looking glow. It's perfect for covering up any discoloration, or if you're just a minimalist looking for something that'll give your nails a soft, flawless finish.
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Cardiologists Are Begging People To Stop ‘Leaning Too Heavily' on This One Daily Metric
Cardiologists Are Begging People To Stop 'Leaning Too Heavily' on This One Daily Metric originally appeared on Parade. It's really easy to fall into TikTok rabbit holes, especially when it comes to your health, and heart health is no exception. Whether it's dangerous diet culture and weight loss discourse, supplement shilling or anti-vaccine messaging, it's easy to feel anxious that you aren't doing enough to stay healthy when you're there yet another thing you should be doing to track your health, or is the latest TikTok wellness trend just a sales tactic to get you to buy a new device or to download another app that may use your data in potentially questionable ways? Below, cardiologists weigh in on the truth about a heart health metric, called , that influencers are insisting you need to measure—you know, along with everything else you're juggling just to exist in this remember: No one knows more about your actual health and what your body needs than you and your doctor, so check with your physician before implementing any changes one way or the other.🩺SIGN UP for tips to stay healthy & fit with the top moves, clean eats, health trends & more delivered right to your inbox twice a week💊 "Heart rate variability, or HRV, is the variation in time between each heartbeat," , cardiologist and vice president of medical affairs at Hello Heart, tells Parade. "It reflects how well your body can adapt to stress, rest and recovery. A higher HRV generally points to better cardiovascular fitness and resilience.""If your heart rate is 60 beats per minute, your heart doesn't beat exactly once per second," , an interventional cardiologist and chief medical officer at VitalSolution, an Ingenovis Health company, explains further. "There is some variability in time measured in milliseconds. Heart rate is controlled by the autonomic nervous system, which plays a key role in regulating your HRV. When you exercise, your heart speeds up, and when you rest, your heart slows down."Related: Like most other health indicators, there are a lot more factors to HRV than just mere numbers—even sociological and socioeconomic factors play a role."It is influenced by age, race, sex, physical fitness, sleep, medication and health issues," , cardiologist and chief medical officer of L.A. Care Health Plan, Morgan notes that even caffeine intake can play a role in your HRV measurement, so putting too much stock into it may not be the best idea, but in general, there are general ranges. A normal HRV at rest for someone in their 20s is typically around 55 to 105, for example, while for someone in their 60s, it will be more like 25 to Influencer Lucie Fink talks about using Heart Rate Variability to track her COVID journey. That depends on a few factors, experts agree, and it's by far not the most important metric to gauge your cardiovascular health by any means. "For most people, their HRV is stable over time," Dr. Amin tells us. "But some studies have shown a higher risk of heart events or even mortality in those with a reduced HRV."According to Dr. Serwer, a high HRV "means your body can switch efficiently between rest and stress modes which is a sign of good health." Conversely, he notes if you're sick, stressed, fatigued or if you over-exercise, your HRV may be Chances are you don't have the equipment to get a fully accurate picture here. "The gold standard to measure HRV is by performing an EKG and precisely measuring the time between heartbeats," Dr. Serwer says. "Using advanced software, the HRV can be accurately calculated. This, however, isn't practical on a day-to-day basis."That said, Dr. Serwer and Dr. Morgan each note that certain apps and wearable technology (like fitness trackers or smartwatches) may be able to measure, track and store your Honestly, for most healthy people, the answer is probably no: While it doesn't necessarily hurt, it also doesn't reveal as much about your heart health as you think. "HRV is a valuable metric which may lead us to identify stress, illness or overtraining earlier than waiting for apparent symptoms," Dr. Serwer notes, adding, "Like any test or vital sign, it is only helpful when you understand the limitations and the meaning of the value. We are often overwhelmed with data and sometimes don't pay attention to the apparent issues. HRV is a tool and when used appropriately, can be helpful." People who may benefit from HRV monitoring are athletes and anyone worried about over-exerting themselves through exercise, or potentially recovering from an illness, and even then, your doctor will be able to make much more sense of it than most of us laypeople can. "Monitoring HRV can offer a window into how your body is responding to stress, illness or physical overexertion," Dr. Morgan advises. "It's not all-encompassing, but it's a peek into the performance of your autonomic nervous system. Knowing this information and sharing it with your physician can help you make more informed decisions about your health and wellness." Related: For one, it's just not that useful, Dr. Amin says. "In general, I wouldn't suggest leaning too heavily on this measurement," he explains. "Generally, it would be best to focus on tracking more traditional markers of increased heart risk, including blood pressure, cholesterol and diabetes control." Dr. Morgan notes that it's easy for people to get too obsessive over their heart rate variability when it can change for purely benign reasons. "The main downside is over-interpreting the data and, frankly, worrying too much about it," she says. "HRV can fluctuate due to many factors, like sleep, hydration or even caffeine intake. It's a useful tool, but it shouldn't be the sole measure of your health. Don't worry too much if one or two readings are off—that's not good for your heart, either." "Think of HRV as part of the bigger picture," she adds. "Trends matter more than single readings, and HRV should be viewed alongside other metrics like blood pressure, cholesterol and lifestyle habits (for example, getting eight hours of sleep per night, standing up and moving at least once per hour, taking any heart medications as prescribed, etc.). Always consult your physician if you notice concerning changes or have questions about your heart rate." Up Next:Dr. Sameer Amin, MD Dr. Jayne Morgan, MD Dr. Bradley Serwer, MD How to Use Heart Rate Variability Data In Your Training, HSS Cardiologists Are Begging People To Stop 'Leaning Too Heavily' on This One Daily Metric first appeared on Parade on Jun 19, 2025 This story was originally reported by Parade on Jun 19, 2025, where it first appeared.
