We Were Liars Author Explains What That Chilling Finale Ending Means for Potential Season 2

If you just finished bingeing the eight-episode first season of We Were Liars, you could probably use a big hug right now. Well, a hug… and some answers.
While the Prime Video adaptation largely follows the blueprint of E. Lockhart's 2014 novel, it ends on a note that even book readers may not necessarily anticipate. As in the original text, we learn that Cadence convinced the Liars to help her set fire to Clairmont, the main house on the Sinclair family's private island of Beechwood. Unfortunately, we also learn that Cadence was the only survivor of the blaze; Mirren, Johnny and Gat all perished in the blaze, and Cadence has been hallucinating their collective existence ever since.
More from TVLine
Eric Dane: My Countdown Task Force Leader Is 'Unapologetic, Determined' - and Wears the Hell Out of a Suit
We Were Liars EPs Talk Book-to-Show Changes, Including Which Sinclair Family Member Didn't Make the Cut
Does Jensen Ackles' Countdown Hero Have BDE - Big Dean (Winchester) Energy? 'There Are Familiar Aspects,' Says Supernatural Vet
As she does in the book, Cadence processes this information — which her grandfather attempts to use against her, agreeing to stay silent if she takes her place as his new heir — and decides to abandon the Sinclair ways once and for all, dropping her grandmother's prized pearl necklace in the murky depths of the Atlantic Ocean.
But wait, there's… more? Following Cadence's final act of defiance, we then see Carrie (Mamie Gummer) back at Red Gate, one of the other houses on the island. After popping a pill, she's surprised to see Johnny (Joseph Zada) appear to her in ghost form. 'I thought you left,' she tells him, to which he ominously replies, 'I don't think I can.'
So, what's the deal with this unsettling, not-from-the-book ending? As it turns out, it is from one of Lockhart's books — just not the first one.
'That final scene with Carrie and Johnny is very close to the opening of my second book in the We Were Liars universe, which is called Family of Liars,' Lockhart tells TVLine. 'Really, it's a tip forward into Season 2 — should we get a Season 2 — but it's also a tip forward to the book that comes after We Were Liars. We all hope for a Season 2, and I know the showrunners have all kinds of plans.'
Indeed they do. According to showrunner Julie Plec, the first season 'involves a lot of elements that we borrowed from the prequel, Family of Liars, that we now get to take into future seasons because we've done all the foundational work with the adult characters.'
If you're unfamiliar with Family of Liars, which hit shelves in 2022, the follow-up book serves as a prequel to We Were Liars, taking readers back to Beechwood in the late 1980s. It's largely told from Carrie's perspective, as she tells Johnny's ghost about the worst things she did when she was younger.
'I wrote the finale, and that was a great chance to basically write a different version of the story that I had already written,' Lockhart says of Episode 8. 'I wrote a television version, and even though the same basic thing happens, it's paced differently. The action is built out, the drama is heightened, the reveals are done in a different way — and there are some additional reveals that aren't in the book.'
Did you enjoy your summer with the Sinclairs? Grade the finale and the season in our polls below, then drop a comment with your thoughts on Prime Video's adaptation of .
Best of TVLine
Yellowjackets' Tawny Cypress Talks Episode 4's Tai/Van Reunion: 'We're All Worried About Taissa'
Vampire Diaries Turns 10: How Real-Life Plot Twists Shaped Everything From the Love Triangle to the Final Death
Vampire Diaries' Biggest Twists Revisited (and Explained)

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

UPI

18 minutes ago

• UPI

Watch: Priyanka Chopra Jonas calls daughter Malti 'a light of our lives'

June 20 (UPI) -- Priyanka Chopra Jonas says her daughter Malti is "a light of our lives." The actress, 42, discussed Malti, her 3-year-old daughter with her husband, singer Nick Jonas, when she stopped by The Tonight Show starring Jimmy Fallon Thursday to discuss her new movie Heads of State. "She's precocious. She is funny. She's a little comedian and she knows she's funny, so that's even better," Chopra Jonas said. "But, yeah, she's just such a light of our lives right now. This is an amazing season for us." Malti was born in 2022 via surrogate. Chopra Jonas and Nick Jonas, 32, married in 2018. "It's lovely not to have found your person," Chopra Jonas previously said on the Jennifer Hudson Show. Chopra Jonas also shared on Tonight that she "had a great time" filming Heads of State opposite Idris Elba and John Cena. In the film, Elba plays British prime minister Sam Clarke, while Cena portrays Will Derringer, an actor and the U.S. president. Chopra stars as Noel Bisset, the M16 agent who rescues the pair after their plane is attacked. "I have to bring them to safety, and we have a lot of fun stuff -- explosions and fun things that happen while we're doing it," she told Fallon. Heads of State begins streaming on Prime Video July 2. Nick Jonas turns 30: a look back

Elle

23 minutes ago

• Elle

18 TV Shows You Absolutely Can't Miss This Summer

Sometimes the best getaways are the ones where you don't have to leave your couch—all you have to do is press play. Maybe the destination is a high-pressure kitchen in Chicago, or the upper crust of England in the 1870s, or—for the more gothically inclined—the spooky halls of Nevermore Academy. No matter where you're headed, rest assured there are no lines or bumpy airplane rides involved. There's a lot to watch this summer, both on the big and small screen. If the latter is more up your alley, you just might find your next watch among our recommended titles below. And if you're still catching up on this year's TV offerings, check out our picks for the best TV shows of 2025 so far. And Just Like That...'s third season picked up after the emotional season 2 finale, where Carrie hosted a farewell party for her apartment and Aidan announced he wanted to take a five-year break, for family reasons. Showrunner Michael Patrick King promised in Entertainment Weekly to deliver 'new loves, fresh challenges, and surprising reunions,' plus an exciting twist: the return of Carrie's iconic voiceover as she writes a new book. Follow along as she works on her draft—and her romance with Aidan. New episodes arrive weekly on Thursdays on HBO Max through August 14. Watch Now on HBO Max Based on Edith Wharton's (unfinished) novel of the same name, The Buccaneers follows five young American women in the 1870s who set off across the pond to marry into high society Britain. Kristine Frøseth, Alisha Boe, Aubri Ibrag, Josie Totah, Imogen Waterhouse, Mia Threapleton, and Christina Hendricks star. This season, they are joined by Leighton Meester, in a guest role. Another bonus: Season 2's soundtrack includes Chappell Roan, Taylor Swift, Lady Gaga, Sabrina Carpenter, and more. New episodes arrive weekly on Wednesdays on Apple TV+ through August 6. Watch Now on Apple TV+ Sometimes, a teen drama summer drama just does the trick. We Were Liars, based on E. Lockhart's 2014 bestseller, follows a group of elite teenagers who call themselves 'the Liars.' They're the kind of kids who vacation on a friend's private island in New England every summer. But when their ringleader, Cadence Sinclair Eastman, experiences a mysterious accident, everyone's secrets come to the surface. Watch Now on Prime Video After the first season made a splash on Netflix, season 2 of America's Sweethearts once again takes us behind the curtain of the Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders franchise, this time focused on tryouts for the 2024-25 season. Meet new stars as they vie for a spot on the iconic squad, dive into the members' personal lives, and follow along as they negotiate for equitable pay. Watch Now on Netflix HBO's The Gilded Age returns for a third season full of even more drama and social intrigue among the elites in 1880s New York. Deadline reports Manhattan's 'society will change drastically' in this installment, and there will be new cast members, including Phylicia Rashad, Brian Stokes Mitchell, Victoria Clark, Dylan Baker, Kate Baldwin, Michael Cumpsty, John Ellison Conlee, Bobby Steggert, and Hannah Shealy. On HBO June 22. After making her debut as Riri Williams in Black Panther: Wakanda Forever, Dominique Thorne returns in Ironheart as the young tech genius, who engineers a super suit that could rival Iron Man's. The series is set in Chicago following the events of the film, and finds Riri and her inventions clashing with Parker Robbins, a.k.a. The Hood (Anthony Ramos). On Disney+ June 24. Attention, chefs! Season 4 of FX's The Bear is set to return this year. It will likely tie up loose ends from the season 3 finale, including Sydney's major career decision, and the restaurant's struggle to earn a Michelin star while balancing Carmy's exacting standards. Fans are also expecting to see the outcome of Carmy's unresolved tension with his staff members, the results of The Chicago Tribune's review, and more on Richie's personal growth, Marcus's dessert innovations, and the future of the partnership with Cicero. On FX and Hulu June 25. The final season of Squid Game promises a face-off between Seong Gi-hun (Lee Jung-jae) and the enigmatic Front Man (Lee Byung-hun), concluding the high-stakes cliffhangers introduced in season 2. Series creator Hwang Dong-hyuk confirmed the news in a letter per Netflix's Tudum, stating, 'The fierce clash between their two worlds will continue into the series finale.' On Netflix June 27. What if you had to choose your bandmates without ever seeing them? That's the premise of Building the Band, Netflix's new reality competition where connection and chemistry are judged purely by sound—until the big reveal. Hosted by AJ McLean, with Nicole Scherzinger mentoring, and Kelly Rowland and the late Liam Payne joining as guest judges, the show brings together aspiring artists to form the next great pop group. On Netflix July 9. Eight years after the finale of Girls, Lena Dunham is back. Her new series Too Much, stars Meg Stalter (the gem of Hacks) as Jessica, a 30-something New Yorker who just underwent a terrible breakup. She decides to turn the page with a new job in London, where she meets Felix (Will Sharpe), who's equal parts attractive and complicated. The cast also includes Michael Zegan, Janicza Bravo, Richard E. Grant, Adele Exarchopoulos, Rita Wilson, Naomi Watts, Andrew Rannells, Emily Ratajkowski, and more. On Netflix July 10. This adaptation of the third book in Jenny Han's The Summer I Turned Pretty series will see Belly's love triangle with Conrad and Jeremiah finally come to a close as she sorts out her feelings about the brothers and makes her choice. 'I know Jenny is really just strong on staying as true to the books as possible and hitting the main points,' Gavin Casalegno (Jeremiah) told People. Kyra Sedgwick, who played Aunt Julia, won't return, but fans can look forward to new twists inspired by Han's novel. On Prime Video on July 16. We've been blessed with another Sterling K. Brown show. The Paradise and This Is Us star leads this new Hulu series as the titular protagonist, an enslaved boy on a sugar plantation in Barbados, who also happens to be a scientific genius. When a traumatic event sends him on the run, his escape turns into a series of travels around the world. This decades-spanning saga is based on the 2018 book of the same name by Esi Edugyan. On Hulu July 23. Fashion gets competitive again this summer as Project Runway kicks off its 21st season with a fresh cast and some familiar faces. Judges Nina Garcia, Law Roach, and Heidi Klum return to the panel, with Christian Siriano back as a mentor. With sharp critiques, high-stakes challenges, and the kind of runway drama that never goes out of style, this season promises to give us plenty to talk about both on and off the catwalk. On Freeform, Hulu, and Disney+ July 31. If you're waiting to see more Seth Rogen on your screen after The Studio, check out his other Apple TV+ comedy, Platonic, co-starring Rose Byrne. The duo play a pair of best friends who 'contend with new mid-life hurdles including work, weddings and partners in crises' in season 2, according to the streamer. Saturday Night Live alums Aidy Bryant, Kyle Mooney, and Beck Bennett are set to guest-star. On Apple TV+ August 6. Season 2 of Wednesday introduces new characters as Jenna Ortega's titular Addams Family character faces darker challenges at Nevermore. The new cast members include Steve Buscemi, Evie Templeton, Owen Painter, Noah Taylor, and Billie Piper, according to Netflix's Tudum. Showrunners Al Gough and Miles Millar told the site they aimed to 'discover some fresh faces as well as invite some acting legends we've always admired to join Jenna and the gang at Nevermore.' And they did exactly that: 'Mission accomplished,' the duo added. Part 1 on Netflix August 6; part 2 on Netflix September 3. Outlander might be nearing its eighth and final season, but Jamie and Claire's universe only continues to grow. This prequel series dives into the equally romantic love stories of their parents, set in the Scottish Highlands in the 18th century and Britain amid World War I. Prepare to see new faces behind familiar names—hello, young Dougal MacKenzie and Murtagh Fraser. On Starz August 8. Noah Hawley, creator of the Fargo series and Legion, is behind this new chapter of the Alien franchise. It's set in the future—the year 2120, to be exact—when a space research vessel crash-lands onto Earth. Wendy, a 'humanoid robot infused with human consciousness,' according to FX, encounters the crash and finds a grave threat to the planet. On FX and Hulu August 12. Grace Van Patten steps into the role of Amanda Knox in this limited series based on Knox's years-long fight to clear her name. Created by This Is Us writer KJ Steinberg and executive produced in part by Monica Lewinsky and Knox herself, The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox dramatizes the infamous case that began with a study-abroad semester in Italy and spiraled into a global media storm. The result is a psychological drama about protecting one's identity, the search for justice, and who gets to control the narrative. On Hulu August 20.

Forbes

34 minutes ago

• Forbes

‘Borderlands 4' Adds A Hugely Requested Feature Months Before Launch

Borderlands 4 Gearbox Borderlands 4 has officially become my most-anticipated game of the year, between how good its previews have looked and the glowing hands-on reviews that have just hit the internet this past week. Now, I am deeply impressed by what Gearbox has just announced. Due to a load of fan feedback and debates about the issue, they have added a feature to the game that will launch with it in September, a demonstration of both listening to the playerbase and nimble development. The debate was whether or not the Borderlands 4 'compass' system of locating objectives and enemies was better than a 'minimap' system that did the same thing but in a different format. Gearbox adamantly defended the compass decision, but the conversation was so pervasive that it has just been announced that Borderlands 4 will indeed launch with a combat minimap option. Here's Gearbox CEO Randy Pitchford showing off the system during a 32-tweet thread covering the issue: Randy credits the community for helping to reinforce how important this issue is and that it needed to be addressed: 'This happened because of the best elements of our community. I'm talking about the real fans who sincerely want the best for the game and gave constructive notes and made reasonable arguments. You know who you are and you rock! You made this happen!' I'm not exactly sure which side of this I come down on. I think perhaps the compass, as it seems less intrusive in the UI, but I'll try both out to be sure. Regardless, it's great that there's an option, and you really do not see this sort of thing happen this quickly and way ahead of launch, rather than a 'yeah, we'll look into that for the future' sort of thing. It seems like it's all green lights for Borderlands 4 so far. The only negative things I've heard about it are not about the game itself, but people saying they didn't like Borderlands 3 , so they're not excited about 4. But a lot of the praise about Borderlands 4 is that it's fixing many of the issues of 3, from combat movement to looting to even the tone of its writing. That, combined with what appears to be a very reactive dev team on top of their game, I think this is going to be a big fall launch, particularly with a number of other games moving out of its way. Can't wait to play. Follow me on Twitter , YouTube , Bluesky and Instagram . Pick up my sci-fi novels the Herokiller series and The Earthborn Trilogy .