logo
The truth about stress: from the benefits of the ‘good kind' to the exercise that only makes it worse

The truth about stress: from the benefits of the ‘good kind' to the exercise that only makes it worse

The Guardian18-04-2025

True (up to a point)The way stress manifests is very much bodily, centred around hormones such as cortisol and their effect on us. But this process is triggered by the brain (notably the amygdala and the hypothalamus) and the way our brains react to stress is often set in early childhood, even in the womb. Pregnant women who experience extreme stress can give birth to infants who react more strongly to stress hormones – with increasing evidence suggesting that this causes modifications to the baby's DNA. Self-actualising your way out of stress is difficult – not least because the causes might be serious and inescapable – but not always impossible. Some studies have shown that if you tell people they are the sort of person who doesn't feel stress, they experience fewer symptoms. One US study found that teenagers growing up with worries about violent crime in a deprived part of Chicago tended to fare better if they simply tried to not think about it.
FalseStress is central to the human existence, and its most obvious and visceral manifestation – our fight-or-flight response to immediate threat – has evolved to protect us from danger. There is also evidence that it can help us concentrate. A study of video game players taking part in a tournament found that those who showed barely any rise in cortisol levels fared the worst, and those with the highest increase performed moderately. Winners tended to have some extra cortisol, but not too much. This hormonal and psychological balancing act is different for everyone, so gauging the 'right' amount of stress is difficult. But as a broad guide, stress is less likely to be harmful if it is predictable, and particularly if it is voluntary. Studies have shown that conducting an orchestra makes the body show multiple signs of apparent stress. But this is the stress of exhilaration, which is less likely to cause ill effects.
FalseFor decades the study of stress was based entirely around men, and often centred on the better-off. The breakthrough came with a pioneering Swedish study which found that people who had high demands on their time but little control over their lives tended to be the most stressed. Subsequent research has shown how unavoidable demands, whether through caring responsibilities or having multiple jobs, are especially stressful. These findings are central to much of the understanding about modern stress, particularly that connected to work. Sir Michael Marmot, the pioneering researcher into health inequalities, has argued that jobs like those in an Amazon-type warehouse, where the pace is relentless and every movement is tracked, are 'as if we took everything we knew about psychosocial work hazards, put it in a syringe and injected people with it'.
FalseMuch of our modern understanding of stress is based on experiments with laboratory rats carried out in the 1930s by Hans Selye, an Austrian–Hungarian doctor and researcher who discovered that repeated and chronic triggering of the body's hormonal alarm system can harm health. But even the Victorians worried that innovations like rail travel and the telegraph were too much for humans to deal with. George Miller Beard, the highly creative populariser of the disorder he called neurasthenia, used his evocatively titled 1881 book, American Nervousness, to blame stress on everything from science to civil liberties and 'the phenomenal beauty of the American girl of the highest type'. Is modern stress any worse? It is certainly different. Compared to a Victorian, a 21st-century Briton has a state-provided safety net, decades' more life expectancy and a child mortality rate about 60 times lower. There is, however, much focus on whether information overload from things like phones is a new type of stress. It is a reasonable concern, particularly for children – but it's far from new. The term 'information overload' was coined by Alvin Toffler, a US author whose bestselling book Future Shock argued that the pace of change in society caused by things like modern technology was simply too much for people's brains – in 1970.
Mainly falseIn his 1972 poem The Shoelace, Charles Bukowski noted that while humans can generally cope with major upheavals, what eventually proves too much is the 'continuing series of small tragedies' – everything from the 'shoelace that snaps with no time left' to an unexpected bill. He was right; repeated studies have shown that stress tends to affect people most when it is chronic. But it's also important to note that the scale of a worry is relative. What qualifies as a 'minor' stress is entirely personal and subjective, and dependent on everything from personal circumstances and background to income – a single larger-than-expected bill can be catastrophic if you're poor. There are some ways that stress, or at least its effects, can be mitigated. But don't let anyone tell you that a particular cause of stress is minor. That is entirely a matter for you and your body.
FalseThere are endless studies showing that physical activity can alleviate stress symptoms. But other research has shown that very high-intensity exercise can worsen matters. One study put volunteers through either a gruelling mock job interview process or a physical test using a stationary bike. While post-test questionnaires showed those in the latter group perceived themselves to be less stressed, their cortisol levels were higher, and stayed so for hours after. Cortisol itself is not a problem for the body. It plays a central role in maintaining things like blood glucose levels, and also acts as a hormonal alarm clock, rising gradually during the night to a morning peak to help get us out of bed. The problem comes with the chronic triggering of the body's stress response. So, how to avoid this with exercise? One tip is to make sure it doesn't feel like a chore – research has shown this can be particularly stressful. Another is to see if less intensive exercise, perhaps even something like yoga, helps. But as ever, there are no firm rules. Everyone is different.
True and falseSome people lose weight under chronic stress. But around two-thirds of people are more likely to put it on. There are two different factors at work, and one is hormonal. Studies have linked consistently high levels of hormones like cortisol with a propensity to store fat around the stomach. Also, research has consistently shown that stress tends to push people towards less healthy eating choices. There is an entire sub-genre of studies in which volunteers are placed under artificial stress, presented with a table of various foods, and told to snack as they please. Each time, those exposed to stress gravitate towards fatty, sweet or salty choices, and eat more overall than the control group who were not stressed.
True
The same fight-or-flight hormonal alarm system exists in mammals, birds, fish, amphibians and reptiles. And this is not just about existential threats. Studies of baboons have shown that lower‑ranked animals in a troop display higher levels of stress hormones. But what is unique about humans is the idea of chronic anticipatory stress. As Robert Sapolsky, a US biologist who spent two decades studying Kenyan baboons, once joked: 'It is startling to realise that a vast length of time ago, while evading a predator or pursuing a prey, a dinosaur secreted glucocorticoids … [But] no dinosaur ever worried itself sick from perseverating on the absurd idea that an asteroid might strike Earth.' For humans, anticipatory stress serves a purpose. For example, if you were blithely unworried about taking an exam, your study regime might be a bit relaxed. Simply telling people not to worry about future events is pointless, and you should never feel guilty about worrying.
Very, very falseThere are two immediate and very obvious reasons why this is wrong. Stress is often imposed by inescapable external factors, and people's bodily response to it can often be exacerbated by their backgrounds, notably their childhood and infancy. But there is more to it: stress acts in such a way as to make it even harder to escape the circumstances which cause it, like poverty. One US study found that when poorer people were asked to think about an entirely hypothetical car repair bill, they performed less well in a subsequent cognitive test. Other studies have quantified this effect variously as being about the same as losing an entire night of sleep or shedding close to 15 IQ points. This is not a minor impact.
True (and yet not)This is correct in the sense that stress can often be imposed by your life circumstances and the preset way your body reacts. But the physical manifestations of stress are more possible to address. For example, while chronic stress can make you more likely to develop metabolic ailments such as type 2 diabetes, being more physically active can reduce this risk again. Some diets can have a similar effect, with studies showing that ones including a lot of green vegetables and foods rich in polyphenols, known for their anti-inflammatory properties, can reduce cortisol levels. Psychotherapy can also help with our in-built responses to stress. And research has shown the stress-reducing benefits of everything from more sleep and better-quality social relations to certain music, aromas and, at least in the short term, simple human touch. What works for one person might not for another, but one of the curiosities of stress is that its very slipperiness, the way it presents such a broad front in its impact on humans, also gives lots of ingress points when fighting back.
Stress Tested: How the New Science of Stress Hormones Can Transform Your Health by Dr Richard Mackenzie and Peter Walker is published on 24 April (Bluebird, £22). To support the Guardian and Observer, order your copy at guardianbookshop.com. Delivery charges may apply.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

I tried a 11p Amazon buy that promises you'll never sweat out of your armpits again
I tried a 11p Amazon buy that promises you'll never sweat out of your armpits again

The Sun

time10 hours ago

  • The Sun

I tried a 11p Amazon buy that promises you'll never sweat out of your armpits again

NOW that the temperatures in the UK are finally rising, there's one thing many of us dread: sweat patches. They are those uncontrollable annoying damp circles under the arms - that no matter how much deodorant you put on, can not be avoided. 5 5 Whether it's a casual coffee with friends, a day out in the sunshine, or a high-stakes work meeting, visible sweat marks can leave you feeling self-conscious and desperate to cover up. I've tried everything in the past to combat this - from strong antiperspirants to breathable fabrics - but nothing seemed to truly solve the problem, especially on those warmer days when sweat patches seem inevitable. So, I decided to do a little research, convinced there must be a hack out there to help tackle this frustrating issue. After all, we live in the 21st century, where there are brilliant inventions like portable washing machines and self-cleaning gadgets. Naturally, my first stop was TikTok, where I stumbled across the trending hashtag #sweatpatches. That's when I discovered a solution that's surprisingly simple yet completely effective: Armpit Sweat Pads from Amazon, priced at just £4.59 for a pack of 40. This works out to be around 11p per pad. These pads are designed for everyone - men, women, and even children - and are perfect for a variety of situations, from commuting on the tube to exercising, giving speeches, or just enjoying a hot summer's day. They promise to absorb sweat, lock in moisture, and keep your underarms dry for up to six to eight hours. On top of that, they help prevent those dreaded yellow stains on your favourite tops, which, as we all know, are nearly impossible to get out. My feet always get freezing during the winter - my £1 hack will keep them toasty, with no need to put the heating on Using them is easy: you simply peel off the plastic backing and stick the adhesive side onto the armpit area of your top, leaving the padded side to absorb the sweat. At first, I was sceptical, but desperate enough to give them a try - and to my pleasant surprise, they actually worked. Despite a particularly sweaty day, my top stayed completely dry, and the pads themselves felt so comfortable that I forgot I was even wearing them. I kept checking throughout the day, expecting them to fail, but they didn't. The pad itself even stayed dry to the touch. Discreet padding What really impressed me was how discreet they were. They didn't leave any marks on my clothes or arms, and at the end of the day, I barely noticed they were still there - a testament to how lightweight and comfortable they are. I could stretch my arms, dance, socialise, and go about my day without worrying about embarrassing sweat patches. The only minor challenge is getting the positioning right when you first apply them, but after a couple of tries, it becomes second nature. 5 5 For just £4.59, these disposable sweat pads are an absolute game-changer. They're ultra-thin, incredibly effective, and suitable for both sports and daily wear. If you, like me, have been battling the dreaded sweat patches and pit stains, I can't recommend these enough. They've quickly become a staple in my summer survival kit, and I'll definitely be stocking up for the warmer months ahead. How to dress in a heatwave SUMMER is finally here with temperatures soaring this weekend, but it has been so long since we dressed for the warmer weather - what should we wear?The Sun's fashion team is here to help with a cut-out-and-keep guide to heatwave attire. Clemmie Fieldsend and Abby McHale reveal the ultimate dos and don'ts so that you never suffer from unsightly tan lines, sweaty patches or wardrobe malfunctions again. Cover up While you might be tempted to put on your skimpiest outfit when the mercury rises above 25C, it has actually been proven that staying covered up can keep you cooler. We're not saying wear your winter coat and wrap up. You should wear a light breathable fabric such as cotton - look for flowy midi skirts, dresses or wide leg trousers which will billow and create a nice cool breeze for you as you walk. Prepare for extremes With our unpredictable weather, it's not uncommon to see either someone in hotpants with goose-pimpled legs after an unexpected downpour, or at the other end of the spectrum, someone still wearing their winter tights in 30C heat. When you're on the fence, opt for a loose co-ord that will keep you cool but not expose you to the elements if it rains. Wear shorts Yes, you can wear shorts - and at any age. The key is getting the length just right and longer shorts are all the rage this year. Short shorts are of course allowed but they won't make you any cooler. If anything, micro-shorts can make you feel hotter. Plus, they are wedgie inducing, often too tight and often show off rather too much bum cheek. Wear white White is not the easiest to keep clean but it is the best shade for a heatwave, and looks effortlessly chic. It doesn't absorb light like black but instead, reflects it. It's also a shade that never goes out of style. If you do get the odd suncream smear on your whites, quickly dab with hand soap and water, rub in with a brush and then wash as normal. Don't show bra straps Whilst everyone wants to wear strappy clothing in the summer, there really is nothing classy about your bra straps being on show - especially when they're the opposite colour to your top. Instead, if you are plumping for a strappy top, stick a strapless bra underneath. Don't attempt a boob tube The boob tube has got to be one of the most faffy and unflattering pieces of clothing you can own. Yes, you will avoid shoulder strap tan lines, but you will spend the whole day pulling your top up and trying to keep your boobs in place. Come evening, you will have grubby fingerprints all over and will have no doubt experienced the odd nip slip. Don't choose espadrilles Espadrille wedges were once Kate Middleton's go-to summer shoe but they have well and truly fallen off the fashion wagon. While noughties ballet flats are back, the espadrille is yet to have its revival. It's one of those fashion items that Gen Z won't be seen dead in, and have even dubbed 'the granny sandal'. For now, opt for a ballet flat or a sandal. Don't wear crochet The crochet trend is nice enough and while it looks great on the likes of Love Island presenter Maya Jama, it's simply not practical. If the sun is out, chances are, you'll end up with tragic tan lines like a mosaic. Plus, it's essentially knitwear - hot and itchy. For men, knitted polos have also crept into the fashion fold, masquerading as summer wear but they are made from synthetic materials and induce swear. Wear at your own risk.

Stacey Solomon-loved brand has one product that lets you tan without orange skin
Stacey Solomon-loved brand has one product that lets you tan without orange skin

Daily Mirror

time12 hours ago

  • Daily Mirror

Stacey Solomon-loved brand has one product that lets you tan without orange skin

Say goodbye to fake tan transfer and orange skin while you wait for it to develop with this innovative tanner that comes from a brand with Stacey Solomon's seal of approval The worst part of fake tanning from home has to be the stains left on bedding and clothes, or the dark orange shade of skin while you wait for the tan to take effect. That's where this brand's innovative product may be your new best friend. Waving goodbye to the transfer and orange skin, this Gradual Clear Self Tan Water Mousse is completely see-through while it works to give you that golden glow. From a brand adored by Stacey Solomon, Sienna X, this innovative tanner lets you discreetly get that sunkissed skin, so you can go out and about without worrying about stains on your clothes or looking vibrantly orange. Tan before work, lunch dates, running errands or overnight, and enjoy your summer tan without the stress. This Clear Self Tan Mousse, retailing for an affordable £19.99 on Amazon, is the new-gen way to tan on the downlow. With continued use over a few days, it builds up to a light-medium everyday glow. Promising all the benefits of a natural-looking tan, this offers a fuss-free way to achieve a healthy, radiant complexion without getting residue onto clothes, towels, or bed sheets. Boasting a vegan formula that's suitable for all skin types, this is an easy-to-apply, lightweight, water-based mousse that contains no guide colour, meaning no development stain transfer. This tan takes 8 hours to develop, so you can enjoy going about your daily tasks without worrying about the orange hue. Perfect for use at any time, anywhere, this tan leaves a light, clear sheen upon application that helps you see where you've already applied it without an orange colour guide. Ideal for first-time tanners or those looking to top up an existing tan, this mousse doesn't just create a dazzling tan. It also comes armed with skin-loving ingredients, including Hyaluronic Acid, which holds up to 1000x its own weight in water to deeply hydrate the skin, and aloe vera, which soothes and moisturises upon application. Shoppers who have tried this Clear Tanning Mousse have been singing its praises. One 5-star reviewer writes: "This tanning water is superb for at-home tanning, and I'm really pleased with how easy it is to use. I like that it's easy to dispense and there's not much wastage of product. It applies really well to my skin and smells nice too. I like the final results as it's a natural-looking tan, and my skin is glowing after using it. It doesn't leave any residue behind after application, either, which is a godsend for my sheets! It's easy for me to see where I've applied it too, as it's got a helpful and handy light sheen. It feels nice on my skin and isn't greasy. It's a high-quality premium tanning solution, so I feel the value for money is very good, and I do recommend it. I've not had any issues with it at all." Further accolades come from this buyer who beams: "I was really sceptical about this, as I am with most gradual/fake tanners. But I was pleasantly surprised. The colour is perfect. I've only used it for 3 days and my skin has a really healthy glow and colour, it looks like a really natural sun tan. I find the consistency is light, and using a mitt, it goes on easily, and I'm able to spread it out, so a little goes a long way. Plus, I don't get any streaks." And a third notes: "First time I've ever used tanning water. It is so easy to apply. I exfoliated first, then put moisturiser on elbows, knees, knuckles and toes. I used a mitt to apply the foam. The colour is really natural, lasts longer than I thought it would and there's very little transfer onto clothes. Will keep buying this product."

Samsung Galaxy watch with 'accurate step count' now £41 in limited-time Amazon deal
Samsung Galaxy watch with 'accurate step count' now £41 in limited-time Amazon deal

Wales Online

timea day ago

  • Wales Online

Samsung Galaxy watch with 'accurate step count' now £41 in limited-time Amazon deal

Samsung Galaxy watch with 'accurate step count' now £41 in limited-time Amazon deal The Samsung Galaxy Fit3 Smart Watch is currently on sale at Amazon The Samsung Galaxy Fit3 is on sale at Amazon (Image: (Image: Amazon) ) Smart watches are incredibly useful devices for tracking fitness objectives and monitoring health. Amazon is currently offering a 31% discount on the Samsung Galaxy Fit3 Smart Watch, reducing the price from £59 to £41. The stylish grey watch features a large rectangular face that clearly displays selected data, including date, time, step count and heart rate. The Samsung smart watch boasts up to 13 days of battery life from a single charge and can reach 65% in just 30 minutes. The device tracks over 100 workouts, such as running, cycling and walking, and provides valuable insights into sleep patterns, oxygen levels and more. READ MORE: Dunelm cuts 30% off 'comfortable' £55 sun lounger in flash sale LATEST: 'Soft and breathable' striped bedding set reduced from £90 to £36 If desired, the watch can also receive notifications and messages. For shoppers looking to explore more smart watch options, Argos is currently offering the Garmin Forerunner 165 GPS Running Smart Watch on sale for £199.99, down from £249.99. This device is compatible with both iOS and Android phones and offers up to 11 days of battery life in smart watch mode and up to 19 hours in GPS mode, reports the Express. Boots is offering the Fitbit Inspire 3 Health and Fitness Tracker at a discounted price of £68.99 (RRP £84.99). This smart watch can track stress, fitness and sleep, and provides up to 10 days of battery life. From superstar gigs to cosy pubs, find out What's On in Wales by signing up to our newsletter here . The Samsung Galaxy Fit3 Smart Watch is an Amazon's Choice product; a highly rated, well-priced item that's available for immediate shipping. To date, over 400 customers have reviewed the gadget, awarding it an overall rating of 4.3 out of five. One thrilled customer remarked: "I bought this to replace my Garmin tracker. The watch face is a good size with a coloured screen. "It is very easy to read, and that is coming from someone whose eyesight is increasingly poor (blame the old age). "The watch was very easy to set up via the Samsung Galaxy Wearable app and is very easy to use. "It has a number of different functions, far more than I will ever need to use, but useful nonetheless. "The recording of the number of steps appears to be accurate and the vibrating alarm is very easy to set up and use." They went on to say: "Another feature I like is the ability to change the watch face via the app so that it shows the most useful data according to the individual user. "There are so many to choose from I have not even bothered to count how many are available. "Another useful feature is the magnetic charging cable which attaches to the watch incredibly easily (unlike my previous watch). The device tracks over 100 workouts, such as running, cycling and walking, and provides valuable insights into sleep patterns, oxygen levels and more (Image: (Image: Amazon) ) "I don't know how long it takes to charge, as I have only had it a week and it is still on its first charge, so no complaints there. "Overall, this was a great purchase and I would recommend it to anyone who wants a tracker with an easy to read screen." One shopper felt let down after finding out that the Samsung Galaxy Fit3 only works with Android devices, expressing their frustration: "Bought this for my son's 8th birthday. "Spent about 15 minutes trying to work out which Galaxy app I needed before realising that the watch is incompatible with Apple iOS iPhone, iPad etc. "It requires a Samsung or Android device to pair and monitor, so it's useless to me." Conversely, another customer was delighted with their purchase of the smartwatch, sharing their positive feedback: "Bought for my husband to replace an old Fitbit. "Connects easily to Samsung Galaxy phone, I love that you can change the clock face. Does way more than he needs. "Looks good, well made, the strap fits well. Appears to be very accurate with tracking steps. Article continues below "Lightweight and comfortable on the wrist, you can sync with phone and have notifications on or off."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store