Study paints grim picture of worsening wait times in northern Ont. ERs
The median patient spent about five and half hours at the ER before they were discharged from HSN.
A new study by the Canadian think tank MEI says new approaches are needed to deal with growing wait times at hospital emergency departments across Canada.
In particular, it suggests adopting a model used in France, where separate clinics are set up to deal with emergency cases that are not life and death, such as bone fractures, sprains and serious flu cases.
The study looked at the median times it takes patients to be assessed by a physician, as well as how long people spend in the ER, from the time they arrive until they are discharged.
Timmins hospital to benefit from new lottery
Included was data from hospitals in northeastern Ontario, where Health Sciences North in Greater Sudbury reported the longest waits.
The median patient spent about 5 ½ hours at the ER before they were discharged from HSN. Results from other major hospitals in the northeast include three hours, 45 minutes at Timmins & District Hospital; four hours, 40 minutes at Sault Area Hospital; and, four hours, 56 minutes at North Bay Regional Health Centre.
The study also looked at the length of time it took to get an initial assessment from a doctor in the ER. Timmins again had the shortest time – one hour, 43 minutes – followed by the Sault (one hour, 56 minutes), North Bay (two hours, 16 minutes) and Sudbury (two hours, 23 minutes).
Results for all hospitals in northern Ontario – and Canada – can be found here.
Krystle Wittevrongel, MEI's director of research, said in an interview that Canada's system of funneling all emergency cases to the same community emergency departments is partly to blame for the ER bottlenecks plaguing the system.
Krystle Wittevrongel
Krystle Wittevrongel, MEI's director of research, said Canada's system of funneling all emergency cases to the same community emergency departments is partly to blame for the ER bottlenecks plaguing the system.
(Photo from video)
While we do a good job of addressing critical cases as they come in, people with non-life-threatening but emergency cases are often left to wait several hours for care.
One option would be to adopt a model used in France where separate, middle-emergency clinics are set up to handle serious but not life-threatening cases.
The clinics are a midway point between walk-in clinics that can't handle emergency cases and the overwhelmed emergency departments at hospitals.
'We tend to see a lot of patients going to the emergency room for care that might not need to be there,' Wittevrongel said.
'They might have a more minor injury like a sprain or a strain that isn't necessarily emergency care but is a little bit much for primary care (physicians).'
Middle emergency clinics
She said France has had great success with this model, which is a better allocation of existing resources.
Similar to walk-in clinics, the middle care centres would be publicly funded but independently run by doctors and nurses.
'Rather than being the same as an urgent care centre like the Province of Ontario currently has, it's more community-focused and so there's also more localized decision-making, (offering) more flexibility for those doctors and nurses.'
She said the median length of stay in northeastern Ont. ERs is four hours, 14 minutes, which shows the differences in factors such as the number of hospital beds and staffing levels.
By creating a system of middle-emergency care centres, hospitals in the north could potentially ease the demand on existing staff, making it easier to retain people.
Read more on MEI's study here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Post
33 minutes ago
- National Post
Opinion: Canada has put up with Khalistani terrorists for long enough
By Ujjal Dosanjh and Joe Adam George Monday, June 23, marks the 40th anniversary of the bombing of Air India Flight 182 — the deadliest terrorist attack in Canadian history, and the most lethal act of aviation terrorism in the world prior to 9/11. The bombing left 329 people dead, including 268 Canadians. The investigation into the attack is still ' active and ongoing,' and is considered 'one of the most complex domestic terrorism investigations' undertaken by the RCMP. Article content Despite two separate inquiries finding that Khalistani terrorists in Canada had masterminded the attack, the perpetrators managed to walk away largely unscathed, much to the despair of the victims' families and the frustration of India. To this day, they are venerated as heroes by their fellow extremist ideologues. Article content Article content The Khalistanis form part of a Sikh extremist separatist movement that aims to establish an independent state of Khalistan carved out of India. Although it continues to rally a small but outspoken minority of Sikhs, the movement holds virtually no appeal among Sikhs in India or the majority of Canada's Sikh community. Article content The U.K. government-commissioned Bloom Review, which was released in 2023, revealed that Khalistani activists had exploited government ignorance, threatened and intimidated Sikhs, indoctrinated and recruited young people and solicited funds from Sikh temples to advance their agenda. Article content The review warned the British government that, 'The subversive, aggressive and sectarian actions of some pro-Khalistan activists and the subsequent negative effect on wider Sikh communities should not be tolerated.' Article content Yet Canada's political class choose to disregard those warnings. Politicians of all stripes continue to commit the cardinal sin of ignoring India's concerns and legitimizing Khalistanis by conflating them with the broader Sikh community. They repeatedly indulge them, hoping to boost their electoral fortunes, given the substantial sway the Sikh vote holds in many ridings throughout the country. Article content Article content For decades, Canadian Khalistanis have been an enduring national security and diplomatic liability to New Delhi, which accuses them of engaging in organized crime and acts of terrorism, both in India and abroad, under the guise of a religious political movement. Article content During a public hearing of the foreign interference inquiry last year, CSIS members testified that Khalistani elements in Canada — with covert backing from Pakistan's spy agency, Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) — were attempting to undermine Indian interests in the country, confirming a longstanding allegation by New Delhi.
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Measles 'out of control,' experts warn, as Alberta case counts surpass 1,000
Alberta's measles outbreaks have now eclipsed the 1,000-case mark and infectious disease specialists are warning the virus is "impossible to contain," given the current level of transmission. The province reported another 24 cases on Friday, including 14 in the north zone, nine in the south and one in the Edmonton zone. This brings the total confirmed cases since the outbreaks began in March to 1,020. "It is a very grim milestone," said Dr. Karina Top, a pediatric infectious disease physician at the Stollery Children's Hospital in Edmonton, which has been treating children with measles. "I'm very worried we're going to see more hospitalizations and some deaths soon because we know the death rate is about one to two per thousand. So it's likely that we're going to see that and that will be a very tragic day." Measles is highly contagious and can lead to serious complications including pneumonia, brain inflammation — which can trigger seizures, deafness and brain damage — as well as premature delivery. A premature baby who was born with measles died in Ontario recently. And another young child died of measles in that province last year. Doctors warn there are severe long-term consequences as well, including immune system impacts and a degenerative neurological condition that occurs seven to ten years after an initial measles infection. It is rare but nearly always fatal. 'Out of control' Alberta's case count has more than doubled in the last month. On May 20, a total of 486 cases had been confirmed. "This is out of control," said Top. The hardest hit areas are the south, central and north zones, where there are some very low vaccination rates among young children. Case counts have been rising quickly in the north zone, which has now topped 200 cases. The south zone has confirmed 681 cases and the central zone has 105. And health officials are warning the virus is more widespread in those areas than case counts reflect. "Due to the number of people in these areas who may not be immune to measles, it's likely that some cases are going undetected or unreported," the Alberta government's measles web page states. "I think we really need to be doing everything we can to engage with those communities that are affected and community leaders to see how best we can work with them to try to get people vaccinated to help contain this infection," said Top. "And [we need to] get everyone else up to date so that if there are other cases introduced in Edmonton, Calgary or elsewhere in the province, it can be contained more quickly." University of Calgary infectious disease physician Dr. Dan Gregson is also worried about Alberta's surging measles cases. "This transmission is just out of the box. It's impossible to contain at the present time," he said. "The risk, right now, of your child getting measles in Alberta if they're not immunized is pretty high." Gregson is urging parents who have opted not to immunize their children to rethink that decision. "If you had made a decision not to vaccinate because measles was not circulating, that's no longer true. We don't have herd immunity. There's measles circulating in the community. And the best way to prevent your child from having a complication would be to get them vaccinated," he said. The vast majority of Alberta's measles cases are among the unimmunized. The most recent data shows 85 Albertans have been hospitalized due to this year's outbreaks, including 14 who have ended up in intensive care. "Most of these hospitalizations are due to patients having pneumonia — they're short of breath, they have to wear oxygen. Some of them are due to brain inflammation. [It's] not a pleasant thing for the parents or the child to have to go through," said Gregson. In Edmonton, where the Stollery Children's Hospital is treating the sickest patients from northern Alberta, Top said the outbreaks are taking a toll. "It is distressing as a pediatrician to see children that are sick from a disease that is completely vaccine preventable."
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Big grocery wants Ontario to lift ban on 'private label' wine, beer
Social Sharing Premier Doug Ford's next move to reform alcohol retail in Ontario could be allowing supermarket chains to sell their own private-label wine and beer, such as Costco's Kirkland Signature brand. The government recently began consulting with the industry about making further changes to Ontario's rules on booze sales. As part of the consultations, big grocery is lobbying for Ontario to end its ban on supermarkets selling their own-brand alcohol products, CBC News has learned. Current provincial regulations prohibit grocery stores from selling any brands of beer or wine in which they have "a direct or indirect financial interest." Small wineries in the province fear the consequences of lifting that ban. "Allowing private label wine in grocery, big box and convenience stores would be a severe blow to Ontario's wine industry," said Michelle Wasylyshen, president and CEO of Ontario Craft Wineries, which represents more than 100 wine producers. WATCH | How the LCBO makes money for the Ontario government: Here's how the LCBO brings in $2.5 billion for Ontario annually 11 months ago Duration 3:40 The LCBO earns nearly 80 per cent of its revenue from its retail outlets, all currently closed by strike, the corporation's latest annual report shows. CBC's Mike Crawley breaks down how the LCBO currently turns a profit and how things are expected to change with the Ford government's reforms — including the premier's plan to sell select alcohol in Ontario convenience and grocery stores. Wasylyshen says while craft wineries deeply value their working relationship with the grocery stores, Ontario's private-label ban needs to stay in place so that locally-produced wines are not pushed out by the big supermarket chains. "This is a black and white issue for us, backed by data and previous experience. There is no grey zone," she said in an email to CBC News. B.C. also bans private-label sales Canada's other major wine-producing province, British Columbia – where it's a $3.75 billion-a-year industry – also bans supermarkets from selling their own brands. The Retail Council of Canada, which represents all the large supermarket and big-box chains including Costco, Loblaws, Walmart and Sobeys, says its members in Ontario are interested in selling their own brands of alcohol. "Private label increases competition, lowering prices for customers, because brewers and vineyards need to indirectly compete with the lower retail prices of private label brands," said Sebastian Prins, the Retail Council's director of government relations for Ontario, in an email to CBC News. Prins says the province's wine industry would remain protected by provincial regulations requiring supermarkets to allocate certain portions of shelf-space to Ontario-made products. He also says private-label sales could benefit grape growers in Ontario because the retailers would be looking for new sources for their wine. But with cross-border trade tensions remaining high, and the LCBO currently not stocking U.S. products, a spokesperson for Ford says private-label sales are not currently planned as part of the government's modernization of alcohol retailing. 'Supporting Ontario growers' is Ford's priority "Our priority right now is supporting Ontario growers and supporting Ontario-made products," said Ford's director of media relations, Grace Lee. The push on private-label sales comes less than a year after Ford sped up the timeline for allowing convenience stores to sell beer, wine and ready-to-drink cocktails. That move is costing taxpayers at least $612 million, including $225 million of compensation paid to the mega-breweries that own The Beer Store for the expanded retail competition. In April, Ford announced a shift in pricing rules so that convenience stores now get their products supplied at a 15 per cent discount from the LCBO's retail price, giving them a potentially higher margin on wine and beer than grocery stores, whose discount remains at 10 per cent. The Retail Council and the Canadian Federation of Independent Grocers wrote a joint letter to Ford last month asking for a number of changes to the province's booze marketplace, including the ability to sell private-label alcohol. The chain and independent supermarkets also raised concerns about the mandate that all grocery stores selling beer and wine must start accepting returns of empty cans and bottles in 2026, a requirement not imposed on convenience stores.
