‘A Tree Fell in the Woods' Review: Josh Gad and Alexandra Daddario in an Uneven, Occasionally Insightful Relationship Dramedy
If pop culture is to be believed, nothing good has ever come from a couple dashing off to a cute little cabin in the woods. This year alone, the sly sci-fi Companion, Netflix's drab dramedy The Four Seasons and the twisted Sundance rom-com Oh, Hi! have each taken turns considering the many, many different ways a weekend getaway might pressure-test a relationship, until fault lines become chasms big enough to swallow entire lives whole.
Adding to that collection now is Nora Kirkpatrick's debut feature, A Tree Fell in the Woods, premiering at Tribeca. In the canon of vacation-set marriage exposés, it's mid-tier, entertaining in parts but neither profound nor original enough to blaze any new trails. But in its epiphany that our most complicated relationships are the ones we have with ourselves, it delivers an intriguing if incomplete snapshot of Millennial anxiety.
More from The Hollywood Reporter
Jim Sheridan's 'Re-creation' Puts One of Ireland's Most Troubling Murder Cases Back on Trial
'Inside' Review: Guy Pearce Is a Lit Fuse of Internal Contradictions in Haunting Australian Prison Drama
'The Best You Can' Review: Kevin Bacon and Kyra Sedgwick Star in a Congenial but Unremarkable Dramedy About an Unlikely Friendship
The falling tree of the title turns out to be very literal: In the first act, best friends Debs (Alexandra Daddario) and Mitch (Josh Gad) are nearly flattened while exploring the forest around the home they've rented for their 'Christmas New Year's thingamajigy weekend.' Exhilarated by their near-death experience, they rush back to regale their spouses with the tale, only to spy through the window Josh (Daveed Diggs) and Melanie (Ashley Park) in flagrante delicto.
Mitch, dreading a future in which 'each one of us ends up depressed, angry, alone, masturbating on the couch,' prefers to say nothing. Debs, reluctantly, plays along through gritted teeth. Nevertheless, it's only a matter of time before a violent snowstorm traps the quartet inside, with nothing to do but wallow in their insecurities and trade furious invectives — well, that, and drown their sorrows in the ancient, mysterious, possibly slightly magical bottles of moonshine recovered from the basement, to mildly comic effect.
Kirkpatrick, whose credits include Prime Video's Daisy Jones & The Six, resists casting any of her four leads in roles as easy as victim or villain. As the couples separate to argue in private or individuals retreat to lick their wounds, the writer-director periodically cuts between them, so that their conversations or coping mechanisms become a single symphony of hurt and anger and misunderstanding. Sure, Melanie and Josh are in the wrong, and Mitch and Debs are right to be mad — but, the film makes clear, each has their part to play in everything that's gone wrong.
Which is not to say that the movie's understanding of all four is equally sharp, or equally sympathetic. Its most lucid and least likable portrayal is of Mitch, who feels taken advantage of by the women in his life (namely Melanie, but also Debs); Gad's exhaustingly showy performance adds to the sense that he's one of those stereotypical 'nice guys' who turns every act of kindness into a self-sacrificing spectacle.
On the flip side, Park delivers the film's most unexpectedly funny and oddly moving turn as a woman cracking under the dissatisfactions of a marriage built more around both parties' ideas of what they should want than what they actually do.
The script is less successful at dissecting Debs and Josh's relationship, favoring her indignation over his fury to the point that when he finally does open up about his anxieties late in the film, it feels like we're only now meeting him for the first time. Nor do Daddario and Diggs share the kind of chemistry that might let us understand what drew them together in the first place, though they do share a couple of eloquently written, tenderly acted exchanges in the back half.
But if A Tree Fell in the Woods is only fitfully persuasive in its excavations of the resentments that can build over a long-term relationship — and if the deployment of a vaguely magical potion to get there seems a tad too convenient — its shrewdest observation is that none of these grudges can be separated from the ones the characters hold against their own selves. No longer young but not quite middle-aged (the characters are in their 30s, though some of the actors are older), they find themselves suspended between fading promise and dull reality, between the futures they'd imagined and the ones they're settling into, between the people they hoped they might be and the ones they're actually becoming.
Debs, an author struggling to live up to the promise of her debut novel, is married to a photographer whose reputation outpaces his talent. Mitch is a successful banker who hates his job and the life it's bought him, with a wife who does not understand him. For all four, the idea that they might really be stuck with these lives is such a bitter pill to swallow that perhaps it's no wonder they're compelled to do something — anything — to put off the decades of disappointment and disillusionment they see looming before them.
At one point, Mitch even drunkenly floats the idea that the betrayal might turn out to be a blessing in disguise. 'We saw it,' he slurs, 'and it saved us from the rest of our lives.' Debs, understandably, isn't buying it. But sometimes, the only way out of a hellish weekend in the woods is through. And sometimes, the only way to cut to the truth is to knock down all the bullshit surrounding it first.
Best of The Hollywood Reporter
13 of Tom Cruise's Most Jaw-Dropping Stunts
Hollywood Stars Who Are One Award Away From an EGOT
'The Goonies' Cast, Then and Now
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
UPI
an hour ago
- UPI
Famous birthdays for June 23: KT Tunstall, Selma Blair
TV // 1 day ago Jake Weary: Playing charismatic Cane on 'Waterfront' is a game changer NEW YORK, June 21 (UPI) -- Jake Weary told UPI he wanted to star in "Waterfront" because the new Netflix drama gives him the chance to play a type of character he doesn't usually get offered.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Ashley Walters changed by Adolescence
Ashley Walters thinks Adolescence has changed his parenting. The 42-year-old star - who has Amaiya-Love, 10, and nine-year-old River with wife Danielle Isaie, is stepfather to her child, and also has adult kids Shayon, China, and Panera with former partner Natalie Williams, and Antonia and Ashley from another relationship - has become more present and engaged in doing things with his youngest son in particular since starring in the Netflix miniseries in order to encourage him away from the online world. He told the new issue of Men's Health UK magazine: '[As parents] we're really about uplifting and pushing the things that they love. He's an animator, so he has a lot of animation software on his iPad and spends his time doing that. "But sometimes, he's not animating when we think he is. We've been very conscious about that and drawing back on his screen time. Half the week, he can't even touch his device. "And then actually, it's about me stepping in as a dad and saying, 'Let's go fishing, let's do more stuff,' so he doesn't want to be on there as much as he is.' Ashley noted that parents often don't intervene with their children's screen time because they don't want their kids to feel left out, but believes Adolescence has empowered them to intervene more. He added: 'No one wants to be the ogre parent that comes in and goes, 'All right, that's it, everything off.' I don't want them to feel like they're not the same as their friends. You get caught up in all of that stuff as a parent, but I feel like around the world this show has allowed parents, to go, 'F*** that s***. Adolescence says this could happen. Now we're going to start having this conversation.' I think that's a good thing.' The former So Solid Crew rapper played DI Luke Bascombe in Adolescence and though he'd love to reprise the role for a second series, he thinks that's unlikely to happen. He said: 'I'd love to, but I strongly believe that it will be completely different characters with a completely different story. I think that the constant will be the one-take process.' The full interview with Ashley is available in the July/Aug issue of Men's Health UK, on sale from 24 June, or visit for more.
Tom's Guide
2 hours ago
- Tom's Guide
I watch Netflix for a living — here are the 5 new shows and movies I'd stream this week
Normally, there would be a deluge of new Netflix shows and movies to stream this week. But there are just five new arrivals to the streaming service between June 23 and June 29. There may be a good reason for this, though. "Squid Game" season 3 arrives on June 27, and it wouldn't be a shock if Netflix is clearing the decks for the final season of its most popular series ever. Of course, there are still other shows and movies worth checking out besides the series finale of Netflix's hit Korean drama. Chief among the best of the rest is "The Ultimatum: Queer Love" season 2, which adds yet another reality show to Netflix's already massive stable of popular reality TV. For more to watch, read on for my top picks, a full list of everything new on Netflix this week and the scoop on what's leaving Netflix this week. If you need more, check out our guide to everything new to Netflix in June or our review of Netflix's new soapy crime drama, which was the biggest new show last week. "Squid Game" takes place in a dystopian version of our world where a cabal of the wealthy and powerful pits the poor and desperate of South Korea against each other. If you win this series of children's games, you could take home a life-changing sum. Lose, and you lose more than just the game. Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips. In season 1, a down-on-his-luck divorced dad named Gi-hun (Lee Jung-jae) took home the top prize, and ever since, he's been looking to take the game down for good. Season 2 saw him in the game yet again, but his violent revolution ended in disaster. Now, he's the prisoner of The Front Man (Lee Byung-hun), but that doesn't mean the game is over. Tune in to the final season of Netflix's hit Korean-language thriller this week to see if Gi-hun can win once and for all. Watch on Netflix starting June 27 "The Ultimatum" has been a hit for Netflix. The premise is simple: several couples enter a reality dating show where one person in the relationship is given an ultimatum by the other — marry me or leave me. To determine if the couples are truly right for each other, though, they must first do the unthinkable. They will temporarily split up and enter into a trial marriage to see if married life is for them at all, or if maybe they're just with the wrong partner. Tune into "The Ultimatum: Queer Love" season 2 premiere this week and begin the eight-week journey to see which couples are right for each other and which are maybe better off with someone else. Watch on Netflix starting June 25 Some people like cruises. They're wrong, but people are entitled to their opinion. But what happens when a 4,000-passenger Carnival cruise ship loses power? That's the question "Trainwreck: Poop Cruise" looks to answer and — spoiler alert — everything goes to sh*t. If you love a story where the truth is stranger than fiction, do not miss this new Netflix documentary about the 2013 Carnival Triumph engine fire, which will forever live in infamy as the "poop cruise." Watch on Netflix starting June 24 A post shared by Steph Tolev (@stephtolev) A photo posted by on To call Steph Tolev's comedy raunchy might be an understatement. But the standup certainly has an ardent fanbase, including standup legend Bill Burr. Tolev has worked with Burr on multiple occassions, as well as appearing in "Hacks" as and "Tires" season 2. But in "Steph Tolev: Filth Queen," she's the main attraction of the show, dropping unfiltered confessions, dating stories and observations about life. Fair warning — when I say unfiltered, I mean it. Watch on Netflix starting June 24 Incredibly, the "Pokémon" anime has been ongoing for 27 seasons. Now titled, "Pokémon Horizons: The Search for Laqua," it probably looks unrecognizable to us who grew up with the original 150 Pokémon — it doesn't even feature Ash Ketchum — but if you need something for the kids this week, then this is the show for you. This latest batch of episodes picks up with Liko, Roy, and Dot reuniting with the Rising Volt Tacklers as they head to Kitakami and continue their Pokémon journey. Watch on Netflix starting June 27 JUNE 24 "Steph Tolev: Filth Queen" (Netflix comedy special) Bow down to the queen as fearlessly filthy Steph Tolev rules the stage with hilarious confessions, unfiltered dating stories and absurd observations. "Trainwreck: Poop Cruise" (GB) (Netflix documentary) An engine fire leaves 4,000 passengers stranded at sea without power and plumbing in this wild documentary about the infamous "poop cruise" of 2013. JUNE 25 "The Ultimatum: Queer Love" season 2 (Netflix series) Six couples put their love to the test by moving in with other partners. Are they ready for marriage — or is "the one" actually someone else? JUNE 27 "Pokémon Horizons: The Search for Laqua" season 2 part 3 (JP) (Netflix family) With their training complete, the three young adventurers embark on a new quest to learn more about Lucius and track down the rest of the Six Heroes. "Squid Game" season 3 (KR) (Netflix series) The third and final season of Squid Game follows Gi-hun (Lee Jung-jae) after losing his best friend in the game and being driven to utter despair by The Front Man (Lee Byung-hun), who was hiding his true identity to infiltrate the game. Gi-hun persists with his goal to put an end to the game, while the Front Man continues onto his next move and the surviving players' choices will lead to graver consequences with each round. The world eagerly awaits to see the grand finale written and directed by Director Hwang Dong-hyuk, who has vowed to bring the epic story to its deserved closure. Can we hope for humanity in the cruelest of realities? Fans all over the world are counting the days until the final answer is revealed. Leaving 6/26/25 "Ordinary People" Malcolm has been with Tom's Guide since 2022, and has been covering the latest in streaming shows and movies since 2023. He's not one to shy away from a hot take, including that "John Wick" is one of the four greatest films ever made. Here's what he's been watching lately:
