London AI firm says Getty copyright case poses ‘overt threat' to industry
A London-based artificial intelligence company, Stability AI, has claimed that a copyright case brought by the global photography agency Getty Images represents an 'overt threat' to the generative AI industry.
Getty's case against Stability AI for copyright and trademark infringement relating to its vast photography archives reached the high court in London on Monday.
Stability allows users to generate images using text prompts, and its directors include James Cameron, the Oscar-winning film director of Avatar and Titanic. But Getty called the people who were training the AI system 'a bunch of tech geeks' and claimed they were indifferent to the problems their innovation might create.
Stability countered by alleging that Getty was using 'fanciful' legal routes and spending approximately £10m to fight a technology it feared was 'an existential threat' to its business.
Related: The 'death of creativity'? AI job fears stalk advertising industry
Getty represents the work of almost 600,000 content creators globally. It alleges Stability trained its image generation model on its vast database of copyrighted photographs. As a result the program, called Stability Diffusion, outputs images with Getty Images watermarks still on them. Getty alleges that Stability was 'completely indifferent to what they fed into the training data'. It told the court the system amounted to 'sticking our trademark on pornography' and 'AI rubbish'.
Lawyers for Getty said the dispute over the unlicensed use of thousands of its photographs, including images of celebrities, politicians and news events, 'is not a battle between creatives and technology, where a win for Getty Images means the end of AI'.
They added: 'The problem is when AI companies such as Stability want to use those works without payment.'
Lindsay Lane KC, representing Getty Images, said: 'This was a bunch of tech geeks who were so excited by AI that they were indifferent to any of the dangers or problems it presents.'
In submissions to the court on Monday Getty claimed Stability had trained its image generation model on databases that contained child sexual abuse material.
Stability is fighting the overall Getty claim and its lawyer said the allegations relating to child sexual abuse material were 'repugnant'.
A spokesperson for Stability AI said it was committed to preventing misuse of its technology, 'particularly in the creation and dissemination of harmful content, including CSAM [child sexual abuse material]'. It said it had robust safeguards 'to enhance our safety standards to protect against bad actors'.
The case comes amid a wider campaign from artists, writers and musicians, including Elton John and Dua Lipa, to protect their copyright from alleged theft by generative AI companies, which then use it to allow their customers to create new pictures, music or text.
The UK parliament is locked in a similar dispute after the government proposed that copyright holders would have to opt out of their material being used to train algorithms and produce AI-generated content, otherwise it would be free to use by tech companies.
'Getty Images, of course, recognises that the AI industry overall may be a force for good, but that doesn't justify allowing those developing AI models to ride roughshod over intellectual property rights,' said Lane.
The trial, which is scheduled to run for several weeks, will focus in part on the use of images by celebrated photographers, including photos of the former Liverpool football coach Jürgen Klopp taken by the award-winning British sports photographer Andrew Livesey; a picture of the Chicago Cubs baseball team by Gregory Shamus, an American sports photographer; a photo of the actor and musician Donald Glover by Alberto Rodriguez; and photos of the actor Eric Dane and film director Christopher Nolan by Andreas Rentz.
Seventy-eight thousand pages of evidence have been disclosed in the case and AI experts are being called to give evidence from the University of California, Berkeley and the University of Freiberg in Germany.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
40 minutes ago
- Forbes
From Cognitive Debt To Cognitive Dividend: 4 Factors
Benjamin Franklin portrait and light bulbs idea concept on white background When an eye-catching (not yet peer reviewed) MIT Media Lab paper — Your Brain on ChatGPT — landed this month, the headline sounded almost playful. The data are anything but. Over four months, students who leaned on a large-language model to draft SAT-style essays showed the weakest neural connectivity, lowest memory recall, and flattest writing style of three comparison groups. The authors dub this hidden cost cognitive debt: each time we let a machine think for us, natural intelligence quietly pays interest. Is it time to quit the AI train while we still can, or this the moment to adopt a more thoughtful yet pragmatic alternative to blind offloading? We can deliberately offset cognitive debt with intentional mental effort, switching between solo thinking and AI-assisted modes to stretch neural networks rather than letting them atrophy. Drawing from insights into physiology, this might be the moment to adopt a cognitive high-intensity interval training. To get started think in terms of four sequential guardrails, the 4 A-Factors — that convert short-term convenience into the long-term dividend of hybrid Intelligence:. Attitude: Set The Motive Before You Type (Or Vibe Code) Mindset shapes outcome. In a company memo published on 17 June 2025, Amazon chief executive Andy Jassy urged employees to 'be curious about AI, educate yourself, attend workshops, and experiment whenever you can'. Curiosity can frame the system as a colleague rather than a cognitive crutch. Before opening a prompt window, write one sentence that explains why you are calling on the model, for example, 'I am using the chatbot to prototype ideas that I will refine myself.' The pause anchors ownership. Managers can reinforce that habit by rewriting briefs: swap verbs such as generate or replace for verbs that imply collaboration like co-design or stress-test. Meetings that begin with a shared intention end with fewer rewrites and stronger ideas. Approach: Align Aspirations, Actions And Algorithms Technology always follows incentives. If we measure only speed or click-through, that is what machines will maximize, often at the expense of originality or empathy. It does not have to be an either-or equation. MIT Sloan research on complementary capabilities highlights that pattern recognition is silicon's strength while judgment and ethics remain ours. Teams therefore need a habit of alignment. First, trace how a desired human outcome, i.e. say, customer trust, translates into day-to-day actions such as transparent messaging. Then confirm that the optimization targets inside the model rewards those very actions, not merely throughput. When aspirations, actions, and algorithms pull in one direction, humans stay in the loop where values matter and machines are tailored with a prosocial intention to accelerate what we value. Ability: Build Double Literacy Tools do not level the playing field; they raise the ceiling for those who can question them. An EY Responsible AI Pulse survey released in June 2025 reported that fewer than one-third of C-suite leaders feel highly confident that their governance frameworks can spot hidden model errors. Meanwhile an Accenture study shows that ninety-two per cent of leaders consider generative AI essential to business reinvention. The gap is interesting. Closing it requires double literacy: fluency in interpersonal, human interplays and machine logic. On the technical side, managers should know how to read a model card, notice spurious correlations, and ask for confidence intervals. On the human side, they must predict how a redesigned workflow changes trust, autonomy, or diversity of thought. Promotions and pay should reward people who speak both languages, because the future belongs to translators, not spectators. Ambition: Scale Humans Up, Not Out The goal is not to squeeze people out but to stretch what people can do. MIT Sloan's Ideas Made to Matter recently profiled emerging 'hybrid intelligence' systems that amplify and augment human capability rather than replace it.. Ambition reframes metrics. Instead of chasing ten-per-cent efficiencies, design for ten-fold creativity. Include indicators such as learning velocity, cross-domain experimentation, and employee agency alongside traditional return on investment. When a firm treats AI as a catalyst for human ingenuity, the dividend compounds: faster product cycles, richer talent pipelines, and reputational lift. 4 Quick Takeaways Attitude → Write the 'why' before the prompt; the pause keeps you in charge. Approach → Harmonize values and tools; adjust the tool when it drifts away from the values you believe in, as a human, offline. Not the other way → Learn to challenge numbers and narratives; double literacy begins with you. Ambition → Audit metrics quarterly to be sure they elevate human potential. Cognitive Debt Is Not Destiny Attitude steers intention, approach ties goals to code, ability equips people to question what the code does, and ambition keeps the whole endeavor pointed at humane progress. Run every digital engagement through the 4 A factor grid and yesterday's mental mortgage turns into tomorrow's dividend in creativity, compassion and shared humanistic value for all stakeholders.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
How much passive income could a £20,000 ISA provide in a year?
The London Stock Exchange — and more specifically, the FTSE 100 — is a popular place for investors to hunt for passive income. The UK is famed for its culture of paying large and consistent dividends. And the Footsie is packed with shares whose strong balance sheets, market leading positions, and diversified revenue streams provide companies the firepower to deliver decent dividends over time. Yet the exact amount of dividend income an investor makes can vary significantly from stock to stock. And with hundreds of dividend-paying stocks to choose from, the amount one individual makes could look very different to someone else's. Still with a £20,000 Stocks and Shares ISA allowance, I'm confident that investors can make a tasty four-figure dividend income each year. As I say, the dividends paid by UK shares are impressive by global standards. But shareholder payouts are never, ever guaranteed, and past performance isn't always a reliable guide to future returns. Take Shell, for instance, which hadn't cut annual dividends since World War II until the global pandemic came along in 2020. Looking ahead, speculation is mounting that Diageo's about to cut dividends as weak sales and the impact of US tariffs weigh. Payouts here have risen at reported currencies every year since the late 1990s. ISA investors can, however, substantially reduce (if not totally eliminate) the risk of such events on their income through diversification. Owning a basket of dividend-paying stocks can substantially limit the impact on an individual's total passive income. Here's a portfolio of 10 separate dividend stocks that could deliver a large and reliable income over time. With high dividend yields averaging 5.8% — above the FTSE 100 average of 3.4% — they could provide a second income of £1,160 over the next 12 months alone, based on a £20,000 ISA investment spread equally among them. Dividend share Sector Forward dividend yield Legal & General Financial services 8.6% Severn Trent Utilities 4.6% Aviva (LSE:AV.) Financial services 6.2% Mondi Manufacturing 5.1% Unite Real estate investment trust (REIT) 4.5% HSBC Banking 5.7% Rio Tinto Mining 6.4% Vodafone Telecommunications 5.5% WPP Media 7% GSK Pharmaceuticals 4.5% As I say, this portfolio (like any) doesn't come without peril. Both Vodafone and Rio Tinto have cut dividends in recent times in response to tough trading conditions and/or balance sheet worries. But this collection of quality FTSE 100 shares combines high yields with diversification across sectors, reducing risk while maintaining strong overall income potential. I hold four of these dividend shares in my own portfolio. Aviva is actually my fifth largest single holding today. Following heavy restructuring, it has substantial balance sheet strength it can use to pay large dividends and invest for growth. As of December, its Solvency II capital ratio was 201%. With its robust financial foundations, it can continue building and acquiring capital-light businesses to grow long-term earnings (and by extension) dividends. Its planned £3.7m acquisition of Direct Line is a prime example of how it's using its cash reserves to good effect. Dividends could come under threat when economic downturns dampen financial services spending. But over a longer horizon, I think it will remain a top-paying dividend stock. The post How much passive income could a £20,000 ISA provide in a year? appeared first on The Motley Fool UK. More reading 5 Stocks For Trying To Build Wealth After 50 One Top Growth Stock from the Motley Fool HSBC Holdings is an advertising partner of Motley Fool Money. Royston Wild has positions in Aviva Plc, Diageo Plc, HSBC Holdings, Legal & General Group Plc, and Rio Tinto Group. The Motley Fool UK has recommended Diageo Plc, GSK, HSBC Holdings, and Vodafone Group Public. Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. Motley Fool UK 2025
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
The Rolls-Royce share price is close to an all-time record. Could it still be a bargain?
At first glance, even the idea of Rolls-Royce (LSE: RR) offering a stock market bargain right now may seem laughable. After all, the Rolls-Royce share price is already up 52% so far this year and has been trading close to record levels. Over five years, it has risen a staggering 677%. But could it still be a smart buy for my portfolio even at its current level? An important thing to understand about this situation is that the Rolls-Royce share price has not been moving like that for no reason. Five years ago, the business was on its knees. Civil aviation demand had slumped, the company was bleeding cash and it diluted existing shareholders by selling more shares to raise cash. Part of the reason the Rolls-Royce share price has recovered sharply is that the civil aviation demand picture has since been transformed. With people flying again in large numbers, airlines have been servicing existing engines regularly as well as buying new ones. But that is not the only reason Rolls shares have soared. Defence spending has increased markedly, lifting defence shares including this one. The company's power systems division has also been doing well, something that looks set to last. Meanwhile, the company has made moves of its own that help explain the share price growth. One is aggressive cost-cutting. Another has been setting aggressive medium-term goals for financial performance. If reached, this could help justify a premium valuation for the company. The better Rolls has been doing, the healthier it has looked financially – paving the way for more success in future. On that basis, I reckon that even now, Rolls-Royce shares could be a bargain. This month, a non-executive director bought 2,837 of them with her own money. Should I do the same? Having hit some goals early, the company has raised them. That could create more value. It is benefiting from elevated demand in all three of its business areas. A price-to-earnings ratio of 30 looks expensive to me. But by 2028 the company is targeting £3.6bn-£3.9bn of underlying operating profits annually. That is not the same as profit (as there are non-operating elements to consider, like financing and investing) but the current market capitalisation is around 19 times that number (at the top end of the estimate). So if Rolls-Royce delivers, the current share price does not look wildly expensive to me. If it can deliver on those targets, it may set higher ones, making the current price look even more attractive to a long-term investor. Still, there is a lot that remains to be proven. Setting a goal is one thing, achieving it is another. Civil aviation demand is occasionally thrown into a slump by anything from war or terrorism to a recession or pandemic. That risk remains high in my view and I do not think the current Rolls-Royce share price offers me enough margin of safety to account for it. Therefore, although I reckon the price could move up even from here, I will not be buying. The post The Rolls-Royce share price is close to an all-time record. Could it still be a bargain? appeared first on The Motley Fool UK. More reading 5 Stocks For Trying To Build Wealth After 50 One Top Growth Stock from the Motley Fool C Ruane has no position in any of the shares mentioned. The Motley Fool UK has recommended Rolls-Royce Plc. Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. Motley Fool UK 2025 Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
