Real Health podcast: Pouring cold water on saunas' health claims with Dr Tadhg Crowley
Dr Tadhg Crowley, GP, chair of the IMO GP committee and associate professor at University College Dublin, joins me on this week's episode of the Real Health podcast.
The big thing I wanted to get out of this conversation was whether the health claims about saunas were backed up by medical research. The GP told me, 'In terms of some of the research that's out there, they've looked at it affecting mental health, affecting lung diseases, arthritis, and there are various studies. None of them big enough to say, we'd absolutely agree that it proves health benefits a hundred percent.'
Cold water plunges have also become popular in Ireland, so I wanted to check with the doctor what are his concerns about the practice. He said, 'I would have concerns in terms of immersing yourself. First of all, it can cause respiratory difficulties and if you are out your depth and you're doing that, obviously you can't do it on your own. You need to be with people. In terms of the electrophysiology of the heart going from a normal temperature deep into really cold temperatures you'd have to be concerned about that.'
You can listen to the full episode here or wherever you get your podcasts.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
2 days ago
- Irish Independent
Real Health: Weight loss drugs, obsessive eating and protein requirements with Sophie Pratt RD
Sophie Pratt, registered dietitian, joins me on this week's episode of the Real Health podcast. I started by asking the dietitian about obsessive eating patterns. The nutrition expert told me, 'We are seeing it a lot more these days. A hundred years ago we never weighed our food. I think it's actually got a little bit out of hand. We want to promote health, we want to eat well, but we're now having individuals who are getting out the scales at every meal. I even see people in restaurants using scales. I think the cons outweigh the pros in my opinion. Just in terms of the relationship with food. By weighing, we build a negative relationship with food.' Secondly, I asked Sophie about what she thought about weight loss drugs. She explained, 'From a dietetic perspective. I don't particularly like it. For most, it's not necessary. Yes, there are certain individuals who may require it, but for the most part we don't require it. We need to bring it back to basics, we're seeing a lot of individuals who may have been placed on it, and their habits have not changed. They're still not doing exercise. I have no problem with individuals taking it who have done everything in their power to achieve weight loss but haven't been successful.' You can listen to the full episode here or wherever you get your podcasts.
RTÉ News
3 days ago
- RTÉ News
Over 900 extra GPs needed over 15 years to meet demand
At least 940 additional general practitioners will be required to meet expected demand over the next 15 years, according to research from the Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI). It says a growing, and to a lesser extent, an ageing population, is behind the reasons for the projected increase in demand for GP services of between 23% and 30% by 2040. It is also expected that demand for general practice nurses will rise in that timeframe. GP Chair of the Irish Medical Organisation, and GP in Kilkenny, Tadhg Crowley, has said Covid-19 interrupted medical practice and made it busier, but things are returning to what is normal. Speaking on RTÉ's Morning Ireland, he said general practice is a "great career option" but has "not been seen in this way" in recent years. "It's a great job. Anyone who's considering medicine, I'd always say general practice is a fabulous job to be in. We're facing challenges and ... some of the challenges are age related," he said. Dr Crowley said the sector had a generation of GPs or prospective GPs, wiped out by the Financial Emergency Measures in Public Interests (FEMPI) cuts about 15 years ago, which put people off going into general practice. "So we're starting recovering from that. In terms of job satisfaction, it's still a fabulous job, but I suppose we are facing challenges," he added. He said that Ireland is facing the same problems that the UK faced about 20 years ago and "they got it wrong" and the NHS is failing at general practice level. Dr Crowley said the Government needs to carefully handle the situation to avoid that scenario. "We're facing the challenges that the UK faced 20 years ago, so it's going to be really important to have steady hands in the Department of Health and Government. The UK got it wrong. "The NHS has been destroyed in general practice. And it's really important at this stage that we look at A; the number of medical doctors we trained and B: the number of GPs that we train," he said. Dr Crowley stressed that 40% of GPs are aged over 60 and the country is at a stage in terms of the GP population "that we are facing a crisis and the number of people that will come through there". He said as a result, the number of GP training posts has increased to 350, however it is "not going to come close to the number of GPs that we need in the long term". He said GPs are "at a crossroads" and will have to increase the number of undergraduates trained. "If you don't train enough GPs, what you have is, and we've seen this in other countries, these pop-up medical clinics that have employed doctors that aren't actually GPs," he added. Dr Crowley said the long-term effect in the population is "quite poor". He added that it is a competitive market worldwide for GPs and it is incumbent on those working in the health service to make it an attractive option for graduates. "It is a competitive market worldwide for doctors and I suppose it's incumbent on those working within the health system here to make sure that it's an attractive area for GPs to come back to. "And one of the areas, it's very difficult to set up and practice as a young GP and it's something that I think the Government really need to focus down on," he said. "It's the canary in the mine in terms of general practice, the number of GP lists that are being unfilled at the moment is something that will need to be looked at."
RTÉ News
3 days ago
- RTÉ News
Almost 1,000 extra GP's required to meet demand over next 15 years
Clip • 6 Mins • 18 JUN • Morning Ireland Tadhg Crowley, GP Chair of the Irish Medical Organisation, on new research outlining the projected demand for GP services over the next 15 years.
