Plastic Surgeons Anonymously Reveal Procedures They'd Never Get—and Why
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
Plastic surgery is on the rise, with some procedures becoming so common and flawlessly handled among film stars and influencers that they are often undetectable—but is there a limit to what surgeries we should be pursuing?
A now-viral post to Reddit from May 13 brought this very question to public consciousness. "Plastic surgeons of Reddit, what body altering surgery would you never get and why?" the anonymous inquiry, shared by u/topgunner85, read. It has since racked up more than 9,400 upvotes and hundreds of comments from users claiming to be plastic surgeons.
The thread, which prompted vigorous discussion on surgical risks and aesthetics, became a rare moment where professionals publicly voiced what they would avoid in their own practice—or bodies. It resonated because of its candor: procedures that some patients chase, despite trending popularity, are ones these experts would not go near.
To assess whether the internet consensus aligned with medical reality, Newsweek spoke to four board-certified plastic surgeons, asking whether these procedures are worth it. From Brazilian butt lifts to buccal fat removal, their responses ranged from concern to outright dismissal.
Why Plastic Surgeons Are Wary of BBLs
The Brazilian butt lift (BBL), a procedure involving the transfer of fat to the buttocks to increase volume and shape, drew some of the strongest criticism in the Reddit thread. Among medical professionals, it is no less controversial.
Sam Fuller, a board-certified plastic surgeon in Indiana and host of the Fuller Butz podcast, told Newsweek he would never get a BBL.
"It has some of the highest complication rates within plastic surgery, including bleeding, deformity, pain, blood clots, fat embolism, and death," Fuller said.
While the surgeon performs fat transfers to the hips and butt, he draws a sharp distinction between these smaller-volume procedures and the high-risk BBLs many patients request.
"The recovery of a BBL includes lying on your stomach for several weeks … This painstaking recovery overwhelms my interest in the goals of the surgery," Fuller said.
He added that reversing the effects of a BBL is extremely difficult if complications arise or beauty standards change.
Andrew Kwak, a cosmetic surgeon and founder of The Lumen Center in Philadelphia, acknowledged the risk but struck a more-nuanced note.
"A BBL can be dangerous if done improperly," Kwak told Newsweek, pointing to pulmonary embolism as a serious risk.
Still, he considers the procedure safe when performed with "large blunt instruments and pristine shallow injection technique."
Brandon Richland, who practices in California and Nevada, was more cautious. He told Newsweek that BBLs carry the "highest mortality of any cosmetic plastic surgery procedure," exacerbated when nonplastic surgeons attempt to perform the procedure in unregulated settings.
"Some providers are attempting to add too much volume," Richland said, "causing a significant increase in complications and fatalities."
The Trouble With Liquid Rhinoplasty
Another procedure Reddit users flagged was "liquid rhinoplasty," a nonsurgical nose reshaping using dermal fillers. Kwak echoed these concerns.
"The nose and area between the eyes carry fine arteries that can cause severe skin damage if they are inadvertently injected with a filler," he told Newsweek.
He advocates for blunt cannulas over needles and insists on "light injection in small amounts" to reduce the risk of complications.
Stock image: A plastic surgeon marks out a prospective face-lift on a woman's face.
Stock image: A plastic surgeon marks out a prospective face-lift on a woman's face.
Getty Images
Richland also noted the danger of this increasingly popular technique.
"When done unsafely, by untrained providers, it carries significant risks of skin necrosis, and even risk of blindness," he said.
Still, like Kwak, he noted that with proper training and patient selection, liquid rhinoplasty "can produce dramatic improvement."
The Risk of Overdoing Buccal Fat Removal
Once a niche procedure, buccal fat removal gained mainstream attention for creating more sculpted cheekbones. But it too featured heavily in the Reddit thread as a procedure to avoid.
Richland said: "This procedure, when performed conservatively on the right patient, can lead to a significant improvement in facial harmony. However, when performed too aggressively … it can lead to severe deformity and a 'skeleton' appearance."
His warning underscores a broader concern among surgeons: the risk of irreversible outcomes when aesthetic trends push the limits of anatomy.
The 'Fox Eye' Trend and Thread Lifts
Robert Schwarcz, a double board-certified oculofacial plastic surgeon in New York, expressed strong disapproval of the so-called "Fox eye" procedure.
"I wouldn't get the Fox eye procedure," Schwarcz told Newsweek, calling it "abused" and "destructive to the eye area."
The procedure, popularized by celebrities and influencers, attempts to recreate an almond-shaped eye via surgical or nonsurgical means. Schwarcz detailed the complex nature of the surgery, which often combines temporal lifts, canthoplasty or canthopexy, and sometimes thread lifting.
"The concern," Schwarcz said, "is for cosmetic deformity, damage to the zygomatic branch of the facial nerve, scarring and alopecia, eyelid malposition such as ectropion or entropion, and dry eye syndrome."
Nonsurgical options, such as thread lifts, are not better.
"Thread lifting can cause thread extrusion, palpable nodules or bumps, puckering or dimples," Schwarcz said, calling it a procedure he would never undergo.
"I think and hope this trend will be gone by next year," Schwarcz added. "Thankfully, recent beauty trends favor softer, more natural features."
The Consensus: Caution Over Hype
The rapid increase in cosmetic procedures among young people, particularly young women, has been well documented.
Lip fillers have become a routine beauty maintenance step for many, and there has been a significant rise in patients under the age of 30 seeking cosmetic surgeries and injectable treatments. For instance, the American Society of Plastic Surgeons found that the number of Botox procedures among patients aged 20 to 29 have risen sharply over the past decade.
A 2024 study by vitamin and supplement company Thorne found that some U.S. teenagers are already planning to go under the knife, despite their youth. Thorne found that 1 in 4 of the surveyed group of 13- to 17-year-olds plan to get cosmetic surgery to combat signs of aging, with "Baby Botox" frequently trending on platforms such as TikTok and Instagram.
Between the four plastic surgeons' opinions, one theme stood out: risk does not always stem from the procedure alone, but from the environment in which it is done—and who is doing it.
"All of these procedures can be done safely by a board-certified plastic surgeon who is trained in these procedures," Richland said. "But no procedure is completely risk-free."
He added that patients should avoid being swayed by social-media trends, noting that surgeries popularized online are sometimes performed by unqualified providers in unsafe facilities.
The viral Reddit post may have struck a chord precisely because it confronted this disconnect. Behind the gloss of aspirational social-media content are complex surgeries with real consequences.
For the surgeons who perform them, the decision to abstain is not about fear—it is about trust, standards, and the enduring gap between trend and medical judgment.
"It simply does not move the needle on my wish list," Fuller said of the BBL, summing up a broader industry view. "It is a hard pass on BBLs for me at this time."
Newsweek reached out to u/topgunner85 for more information via Reddit.
Is there a health issue that's worrying you? Let us know via health@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice, and your story could be featured on Newsweek.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Miami Herald
5 hours ago
- Miami Herald
Retransmission - Dr. Meegan Gruber Shares Insight on Plastic Surgery Transparency: How Younger Generations Are Shaping a New Era of Body Authenticity
A culture change is affecting how people talk about cosmetic surgery, from popular TikToks to BBL reversals. Dr. Meegan Gruber shows why choices made with knowledge and power are becoming more critical. TAMPA, FLORIDA / ACCESS Newswire / June 20, 2025 / Younger people are driving a new wave of openness in the world of cosmetic surgery. They are not only accepting procedures but also expecting complete transparency about them. The way people talk about plastic surgery is changing. Body-positive creators are sharing their stories online, and an increasing number of influencers are discussing their personal transformations and life changes. Gruber Plastic Surgery is at the forefront of this culture change. Board-certified plastic surgeon and founder of Gruber Plastic Surgery, Dr. Meegan Gruber MD PhD, notes that more patients are coming in with greater knowledge, asking more in-depth questions, and selecting procedures that align with a growing movement toward natural beauty and authenticity. "People don't feel like they have to hide their procedures anymore," says Dr. Gruber. "Patients want to be real, and not just in how they look. They also want to know that their choices are respected and supported." "They want to know if the changes can be undone, if the results will still work in the future, and how their bodies will change." This change has also led to the so-called BBL Reversal Era, in which many people are seeking more natural, proportional results after years of trying to achieve curves that were too large. Instead of making surgery look cool, today's patients are pushing for adults to make decisions based on self-awareness and sustainability. This is reflected in the popularity of awake procedures, such as awake liposuction, at Gruber Plastic Surgery. During these procedures, patients remain awake and aware throughout, and they are actively involved in the conversation during the surgery. This method not only speeds up recovery but also fosters trust and openness, which are traits that today's patients consider essential. Dr. Gruber says, "Education is a form of empowerment." "Whether someone is thinking about a first procedure or a revision, we want to take the mystery out of every step." There is no such thing as a small question. We don't see radical openness as a trend; it's our way of life. It's less of a secret to have cosmetic surgery now that TikTok, Reddit forums, and wellness shows talk about everything from how to care for scars to the different kinds of implants. As a result? A public that knows more has fewer unrealistic demands and cares more about safety and ethics. Suppose you're thinking about getting surgery, like a breast revision, liposuction, or a BBL reversal. In that case, Dr. Gruber advises that you should undergo a comprehensive evaluation and prioritize your own goals over what others think is cool. About Gruber Plastic Surgery Gruber Plastic Surgery, located in Tampa, FL, is led by Dr. Meegan Gruber, MD Ph.D., a board-certified plastic surgeon renowned for her pioneering work in awake surgery. Dr. Gruber, also the star of "Awake Surgery," which you can stream today on TLC GO, HBO MAX, Hulu, Discovery+, and other streaming platforms, integrates advanced techniques and cutting-edge technology to deliver safe, comfortable, and natural-looking results with minimized recovery time. Specializing in awake surgeries, the clinic offers a range of state-of-the-art procedures. Dr. Gruber is committed to innovation and education, ensuring precision and safety in every treatment, while enhancing patient confidence through individualized care and surgical expertise. Contact Information Madeleine Moench madeleinem@ Related Images
Boston Globe
6 hours ago
- Boston Globe
‘I was terrified I was going to die.' Rape victims in Brazil struggle to access legal abortions
The Associated Press does not identify people without their permission if they say they have been sexually assaulted. In Brazil, abortion is legally restricted to cases of rape, life-threatening risks to the pregnant woman, or if the fetus has no functioning brain. Theoretically, when a pregnancy results from sexual violence, the victim's word should suffice for access to the procedure. 'The law doesn't require judicial authorization or anything like that,' explained Ivanilda Figueiredo, a professor of law at the State University of Rio de Janeiro. 'A woman seeking an abortion recounts the situation to a multi-disciplinary team at the healthcare clinic and, in theory, that should be enough.' Advertisement In practice, however, advocates, activists, and health experts say women encounter significant barriers to ending a pregnancy even under the limited conditions provided for by the law. This is due to factors including lack of facilities, disparities between clinic protocols, and even resistance from medical personnel. 'Healthcare professionals, citing religious or moral convictions, often refuse to provide legal abortions, even when working in clinics authorized to perform them,' said Carla de Castro Gomes, a sociologist who studies abortion and associate researcher at the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro. Advertisement Women in Brazil also face geographical barriers to legal abortions. Only 290 facilities in a mere 3.6 percent of municipalities around the country of approximately 213 million people provide the service, according to a 2021 study from scientific journal Reports in Public Health. In June 2022, four nonprofits filed a legal challenge with the Supreme Court, arguing that restrictions on abortion access violate women's constitutional rights. The case is currently under review. A 35-year-old cashier from a small city in the interior of Rio de Janeiro state also said she became pregnant as a result of a rape. But, unlike the woman in Brasilia, she chose to pursue an abortion through legal means, fearing the risks that come with a clandestine procedure. Although Brazil's Health Ministry mandates that, in the case of a pregnancy resulting from rape, healthcare professionals must present women with their rights and support them in their decision, the woman said a hospital committee refused to terminate the pregnancy. They claimed she was too far along, despite Brazilian law not stipulating a time limit for such procedures. She eventually found help through the Sao Paulo-based Women Alive Project, a nonprofit specializing in helping victims of sexual violence access legal abortions. The organization helped her locate a hospital in another state, an 18-hour drive, willing to carry out the procedure. Thanks to a fundraising campaign, the woman was able to travel and undergo the operation at 30 weeks of pregnancy in late April. Advertisement 'We are already victims of violence and are forced to suffer even more,' she said in a phone interview. 'It's a right guaranteed by law, but unfortunately still seen as taboo.' Brazil's abortion laws are among the most constrictive in Latin America, where several countries — including Mexico, Argentina, and Colombia — have enacted sweeping reforms to legalize or broadly decriminalize abortion. This legislative environment is exacerbated by a political landscape in which far-right politicians, supported by Catholic and Evangelical voters who make up a majority in the country, regularly seek to further restrict the limited provisions within the country's penal code. In 2020, the government of far-right former President Jair Bolsonaro issued an ordinance requiring doctors to report rape victims seeking abortions to the police. Current President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva revoked the measure in his first month in office in 2023. But the measure left lasting effects. 'These changes end up generating a lot of legal uncertainty among health professionals, who fear prosecution for performing legal abortions,' Castro Gomes said. Last year, conservative lawmaker Sóstenes Cavalcante proposed a bill to equate the termination of a pregnancy after 22 weeks with homicide, sparking widespread protests by feminist groups across Brazil. The protests ultimately led to the proposal being shelved. But in November, a committee of the Chamber of Deputies approved a proposed constitutional amendment that would effectively outlaw all abortions by determining the 'inviolability of the right to life from conception.' The bill is currently on hold, awaiting the formation of a commission. Earlier this month, Rio Mayor Eduardo Paes, a Lula ally, came under fire after sanctioning a bill mandating anti-abortion messages on posters in municipal hospitals and other health establishments. Advertisement Advocates say access to abortion highlights significant disparities: women with financial means dodge legal restrictions by traveling abroad for the procedure, while children, poor women, and Black women face greater obstacles. According to the Brazilian Forum on Public Safety, 61.6 percent of the 83,988 rape victims in 2023 were under the age of 14. A statistical analysis that year by investigative outlet The Intercept estimated less than 4 percent of girls aged 10 to 14 who became pregnant as a result of rape accessed a legal abortion between 2015 and 2020. Feminist groups in Brazil are campaigning at a federal level for enhanced access to legal abortion services. Last year, 'A Child Is Not a Mother,' a campaign by feminist groups, successfully advocated for the National Council for the Rights of Children and Adolescents to adopt a resolution detailing how to handle cases of pregnant child rape victims. The body, jointly made up of government ministries and civil society organizations, approved the resolution by a slim majority in December.
Newsweek
6 hours ago
- Newsweek
Transgender Veterans Barred From Fertility Treatment Under New Rules
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Transgender veterans eligible for Department of Veteran Affairs (VA) health benefits will no longer receive financial coverage for egg- and sperm-freezing fertility treatments, new guidance shows. According to a leaked email from a person at the VA's Women Veterans Health Care department, transgender veterans preparing for gender dysphoria treatment and seeking cryopreservation—the process in which eggs or sperm (gametes) are frozen and stored to be thawed for later use—will no longer see the costs of this process covered by the department. Treatment for gender dysphoria or gender identity disorder can affect an individual's ovaries or testes and thus fertility. Individuals sometimes freeze their eggs to mitigate against this prior to treatment. The email indicates a shift from previous policy. As it stands, everyone eligible for VA health care benefits (i.e. those who previously served in the military, navy or air service) can access these fertility preservation treatments, including transgender veterans, according to a Women Veterans Health Care document, published in October 2023. There are more than 134,000 transgender veterans in the U.S., according to the Williams Institute, a research center at UCLA School of Law that focuses on sexual orientation and gender identity. Newsweek contacted the VA by email to comment. A laboratory assistant shows a sperm sample in a cryopreservation container at minus-170 degrees Celsius at the Centre for Reproductive Medicine in Muenster, Germany, on February 6, 2013. A laboratory assistant shows a sperm sample in a cryopreservation container at minus-170 degrees Celsius at the Centre for Reproductive Medicine in Muenster, Germany, on February 6, 2013. Photo by: Friso Gentsch/picture-alliance/dpa/AP Images Since taking office for the second time, President Donald Trump has made a plethora of actions regarding transgender people, including signing an executive order stating that there are only two unchangeable sexes and another attempting to ban transgender women from competing in women's sports. He also signed an order aimed at restricting access to puberty blockers and other gender care for people under age 19. Some of the actions have sparked ongoing legal challenges. On February 18, he also signed an executive order expanding access to in vitro fertilization (IVF) and making it more affordable for patients. While IVF does not always require cryopreservation, it is often used to store excess embryos or to enable people to delay embryo transfer until a time of their choosing. The White House directed Newsweek to the VA after a request for comment. In the VA specifically, in March it was announced that the department was phasing out treatment for gender dysphoria in response to Trump's executive order recognizing two sexes. The VA said trans veterans would still continue to receive VA health care. The VA email, viewed by Newsweek said: "On yesterday's (6/16/2025) National Fertility Interdisciplinary Teams Office Hours call, it was announced that VA will no longer pay for cryopreservation of gametes for a medical indication if it involves transgender veterans seeking cryopreservation in preparation for treatment of Gender Dysphoria or Gender Identity Disorder. This will reportedly affect new authorizations and will not disrupt cryopreservation that has already been initiated." It added that according to another senior official in the Veterans Health Administration "the change is reportedly already in effect and an official announcement will be forthcoming" and advised the department to "hold on authorizing any new cryopreservation for medical indications related to gender dysphoria/gender identity disorder" while waiting for further guidance. "We want to avoid a situation where veterans could be told they are approved for cryo, only to find out after the fact that VA cannot pay for care they received," the email read. Newsweek chose not to name the person who sent the email as well as the senior official named in the correspondence to protect their privacy. According to the October 2023 Women Veterans Health Care document, fertility preservation of eggs and sperm, but not embryos, is covered by the VA for medical reasons. "If your VA health care provider determines there is a medical indication, VA can cover the cost of retrieving and freezing your eggs or sperm to preserve your fertility preservation," it said. It listed examples of medical indications that would be covered, including "veterans who are undergoing gender-affirming care that can affect their ovaries or testes." Roz Keith, the founder and executive director of the Michigan-based transgender charity Stand With Trans, said the policy was "discrimination." "Clearly, the rights of the trans community are the target of attack," she told Newsweek. "It doesn't matter whether someone is an adult, a minor, a veteran, a professional, or other, if one is trans identified, they are seeing rights being taken away one by one. It is deplorable. If one class of people can receive treatment paid for with their benefits, then other classes of people should receive the same. This is why we have the equal protection clause in our Constitution. "No one should be excluded from a particular treatment because they are transgender. This is the very definition of discrimination."
