What happens when PM gets recommended names for judges? Ex-JAC members share experiences

Published on: Saturday, May 10, 2025
Published on: Sat, May 10, 2025
By: Ida Lim, MM Text Size: Holder of the Tunku Abdul Rahman Chair, Universiti Malaya Emeritus Prof Datuk Shad Saleem Faruqi address the floor during the Judicial Independence in Malaysia Forum held at Raja Aziz Addruse Auditorium, Wisma Badan Peguam Malaysia. — Picture by Sayuti Zainudin Kuala Lumpur: When the Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) recommend names to be appointed as judges, does the prime minister of Malaysia accept all these recommendations? During a forum by the Malaysian Bar here, two former JAC members today confirmed that 'the answer is no', including Former Malaysian Bar president Datuk Mah Weng Kwai. 'When it goes to the PM's Office, everything is done so diplomatically, you will never get an answer from the PM's Office to say so and so not to be appointed. What we will hear is, can we have other names please,' said Mah, who is also a retired Court of Appeal judge. Emeritus Prof Datuk Shad Saleem Faruqi, holder of Universiti Malaya's Tunku Abdul Rahman chair, replied: 'Same here, the answer is no. In some cases, we rejected candidates and we found their name on the list.' The duo were panelists in the first session titled 'Safeguarding the Bench: Judicial Independence in Malaysia' at the Malaysian Bar's two-hour-plus forum 'Judicial Independence in Malaysia: Past Lessons, Current Challenges'. They were replying to the forum session's moderator and Malaysian Bar vice president Anand Raj, who had asked them for if 'all recommendations of JAC were accepted by the executive' while both of them were in the JAC. In Malaysia, the JAC vets through potential candidates to be appointed or promoted as judges by checking if they are qualified and fulfil the criteria under the law. The JAC then votes on these candidates before forwarding the names as recommendations to the prime minister, before the prime minister gives advice to the Yang di-Pertuan Agong for the judges to be appointed. But under the existing laws under the Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) Act 2009, the prime minister can choose not to accept the names recommended by the JAC, and instead ask the JAC to give additional names or other candidates. Datuk Seri M Ramachelvam, fellow panellist at the same forum session and co-chair of the Bar Council's Civil Law and Law Reform Committee, said the JAC has brought about a 'much better process' and 'brought much improvement to the appointment of judges from what it was'. But Ramachelvam said Malaysia should head towards the direction of making JAC's recommendations 'binding' on the prime minister, and said this would require amending the Federal Constitution to mandate the prime minister to follow the JAC's recommendations. * Follow us on Instagram and join our Telegram and/or WhatsApp channel(s) for the latest news you don't want to miss. * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available.
Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

New Straits Times

3 hours ago

• New Straits Times

[UPDATED] Mohd Khalid appointed IGP on contract, effective June 23

KUALA LUMPUR: The Yang di-Pertuan Agong has consented to the appointment of Datuk Seri Mohd Khalid Ismail as the new Inspector-General of Police on a two-year contract, beginning June 23, 2025, until June 22, 2027. Home Minister Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail announced the appointment today, stating that it was made in accordance with Clauses 4 and 5 of Article 140 of the Federal Constitution, with the advice of the Prime Minister and the recommendation of the Police Force Commission. "Khalid brings with him vast experience and leadership qualities in policing and national security. "His appointment ensures continuity in leading the police (force)," Saifuddin said in a statement today. Born on April 8, 1965, in Manong, Perak, Khalid holds a Master's Degree in Comparative Laws from the International Islamic University Malaysia (IIUM). He began his career in the police force on April 5, 1987, joining the Special Branch at federal police shortly after completing his basic police training. Throughout his career, he served in various key roles both domestically and abroad, including as deputy director of Special Branch I at federal police and as Security Liaison Officer (SLO) in London, United Kingdom. "He was promoted to director of Special Branch on April 10, 2023, and retired on April 8, 2025. However, his service was extended on a contract basis from April 8, 2025, and now continues with his new appointment as IGP. "On behalf of the Madani government, I also express appreciation to the outgoing IGP, Tan Sri Razarudin Husain, for his service since June 23, 2023. "We extend our deepest gratitude to Razarudin for his dedication and contributions throughout his tenure," he said, adding that the government also congratulated Khalid on his appointment and wished him every success in leading the police force. In his speech during the Handing Over of Duties Ceremony at the Police Training Centre, Saifuddin said the appointment of Khalid is a trust and a responsibility to ensure the nation's safety and security. Saifuddin said the position of IGP is not a privilege, but a solemn duty that carries immense accountability. "The role of a leader is to bring prosperity, and that must come with responsibility and accountability. "This appointment is not a reward. It is a trust and a duty placed upon Khalid as the new Inspector-General of Police to lead this respected force," he said, highlighting the expectations that come with leading the police force as the country navigates increasingly complex security challenges both domestically and abroad.

Daily Express

3 hours ago

• Daily Express

Mohd Khalid Ismail appointed new IGP

Published on: Friday, June 20, 2025 Published on: Fri, Jun 20, 2025 By: Bernama Text Size: KUALA LUMPUR: Bukit Aman Special Branch director Datuk Mohd Khalid Ismail ( pic ) has been appointed as the new Inspector-General of Police (IGP), replacing Tan Sri Razarudin Husain, effective today. The handover-of-duties ceremony took place at the Kuala Lumpur Police Training Centre (Pulapol), witnessed by the Home Minister Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail and attended by the Communications Minister Datuk Fahmi Fadzil as well as senior officers of the Royal Malaysia Police (PDRM). Advertisement Mohd Khalid, 60, has held various important positions in the PDRM Special Branch, including Chief of the Pahang Special Branch from May 25, 2018, before being appointed as the Bukit Aman Special Branch chief assistant director on Sept 6, 2021. Saifuddin Nasution in a statement today said Mohd Khalid's appointment received the consent of His Majesty Sultan Ibrahim, King of Malaysia in accordance with Clauses (4) and (5) Article 140 of the Federal Constitution, upon the advice of the Prime Minister and the recommendation of the Police Force Commission. According to him, the contract appointment is for two years, starting from June 23 this year until June 22, 2027. He said Mohd Khalid was a highly experienced officer in the field of intelligence and security since he began serving in the force on April 5, 1987, when he was assigned to the Special Branch at the Bukit Aman police headquarters, after completing the General Police Training in the same year. Advertisement "Mohd Khalid also has experience serving at the Bukit Aman police headquarters, contingents and overseas, and has held key positions such as Deputy Director of Special Branch I, Bukit Aman police headquarters, and Security Liaison Officer (SLO) London, United Kingdom. "He was promoted to the position of Special Branch director on April 10, 2023, before mandatory retirement on April 8, 2025, and his service as Special Branch director continued after retirement and he was appointed on a contract basis starting from April 8, 2025, until now," he said. Saifuddin Nasution said that based on his extensive experience in the field of policing, Mohd Khalid possesses high competence and leadership qualities to carry on the continuity and responsibility of leading the team. Mohd Khalid, who was born in Manong, Perak on April 8, 1965, holds a Master's Degree in Comparative Laws and a Bachelor's Degree in Law (Honours) from the International Islamic University Malaysia, as well as a Diploma in Public Administration from Universiti Teknologi Mara. Saifuddin Nasution also expressed appreciation to Tan Sri Razarudin Husain for his dedicated service and contributions during his tenure as IGP since June 23, 2023. "The Madani government congratulates and extends its best wishes to Mohd Khalid on his appointment," he added. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available. Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia

Malaysian Reserve

3 hours ago

• Malaysian Reserve

Mohd Khalid Ismail appointed new IGP

KUALA LUMPUR — Bukit Aman Special Branch director Datuk Mohd Khalid Ismail has been appointed as the new Inspector-General of Police (IGP), replacing Tan Sri Razarudin Husain, effective today. The handover-of-duties ceremony took place at the Kuala Lumpur Police Training Centre (Pulapol), witnessed by the Home Minister Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail and attended by the Communications Minister Datuk Fahmi Fadzil as well as senior officers of the Royal Malaysia Police (PDRM). Mohd Khalid, 60, has held various important positions in the PDRM Special Branch, including Chief of the Pahang Special Branch from May 25, 2018, before being appointed as the Bukit Aman Special Branch chief assistant director on Sept 6, 2021. Saifuddin Nasution in a statement today said Mohd Khalid's appointment received the consent of His Majesty Sultan Ibrahim, King of Malaysia in accordance with Clauses (4) and (5) Article 140 of the Federal Constitution, upon the advice of the Prime Minister and the recommendation of the Police Force Commission. According to him, the contract appointment is for two years, starting from June 23 this year until June 22, 2027. He said Mohd Khalid was a highly experienced officer in the field of intelligence and security since he began serving in the force on April 5, 1987, when he was assigned to the Special Branch at the Bukit Aman police headquarters, after completing the General Police Training in the same year. 'Mohd Khalid also has experience serving at the Bukit Aman police headquarters, contingents and overseas, and has held key positions such as Deputy Director of Special Branch I, Bukit Aman police headquarters, and Security Liaison Officer (SLO) London, United Kingdom. 'He was promoted to the position of Special Branch director on April 10, 2023, before mandatory retirement on April 8, 2025, and his service as Special Branch director continued after retirement and he was appointed on a contract basis starting from April 8, 2025, until now,' he said. Saifuddin Nasution said that based on his extensive experience in the field of policing, Mohd Khalid possesses high competence and leadership qualities to carry on the continuity and responsibility of leading the team. Mohd Khalid, who was born in Manong, Perak on April 8, 1965, holds a Master's Degree in Comparative Laws and a Bachelor's Degree in Law (Honours) from the International Islamic University Malaysia, as well as a Diploma in Public Administration from Universiti Teknologi Mara. Saifuddin Nasution also expressed appreciation to Tan Sri Razarudin Husain for his dedicated service and contributions during his tenure as IGP since June 23, 2023. 'The MADANI government congratulates and extends its best wishes to Mohd Khalid on his appointment,' he added. — BERNAM