Tory leader accused of demonising young people with push for school exclusions
Scotland's First Minister has accused the leader of the Tories of a 'demonisation of young people' after he pushed for more exclusions to tackle disruption in schools.
The Government this week released long-awaited guidance which attempts to deal with the issue, which has been worsening since the pandemic, telling teachers excluding pupils should be a 'last resort'.
Speaking at First Minister's Questions, Conservative leader Russell Findlay branded the 49-page document 'nonsense' as he urged John Swinney to 'end the barrage of guidance and please empower teachers to take a stricter approach'.
But Mr Swinney pointed to a summit he recently hosted in an attempt to limit school violence, where he said none of the attendees pushed for greater exclusions.
'A whole variety of different people involved, in violence reduction… all those organisations who are doing really good work to avoid violence in our society and to de-escalate, exactly what I'm talking about,' he said.
'Not one of them said to me that I should increase the level of exclusion from schools.
'So what we are getting from Russell Findlay today is a demonisation of young people and a failure to address the mechanisms and the interventions required to solve a difficult issue in our society.
'It is simplistic nonsense, and Parliament should ignore it.'
Earlier in the session, Mr Findlay attacked the guidance, saying: 'Really, it's exactly what you might expect from this ineffective Government.
'Forty-nine pages of tedious, hand-wringing nonsense, complicated and confusing. When John Swinney was education secretary, teachers said he issued too much guidance, which made their jobs even harder.'
Mr Findlay mocked some of the suggested measures in the guidance, including giving 'violent pupils laminated bullet points, telling them to think about their behaviour', and tackling dangerous behaviour by having 'a conversation to jointly problem solve with the child'.
Responding, the First Minister said: 'I don't think for a moment that Mr Findlay's presentation of the guidance is in any way, shape or form representative of what is actually there.
'What the guidance is designed to do is to de-escalate situations in our schools to ensure that young people can participate in their education.
'Because if young people are unable to participate in their education, they are unlikely to go into good outcomes in our society, and we will simply repeat the difficulties that we have seen for many years of young people who do not go on to positive destinations.'
The First Minister also told MSPs that, if excluded, pupils are no longer in the 'safe environment of school', adding: 'They are therefore likely to be out on the streets and therefore potentially able to become involved in some of the criminal activity that Mr Findlay himself has put to me with the last fortnight at First Minister's Questions as being a risk to which young people are exposed.'
Mr Findlay – a former crime journalist – has repeatedly raised the issue of organised crime, particularly around the ongoing feud which has sparked violence across Scotland's central belt.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
The assisted dying debate has been politics – but not as we know it
The House of Commons is a place defined by confrontation where political battles play out and engage more actively with their constituents. But the atmosphere could not have been more different on Friday, as those on both sides of the assisted dying debate listened respectfully, almost solemnly, to one another in the final hours before . As MPs headed for the division lobbies, the bill's supporters seemed confident but nervous. Read more: When the voting was completed and the result imminent, a long and profound silence fell over the House. From the press gallery, it seemed that the entire Commons was holding its breath together, collectively aware of the historic moment we were all about to witness, whatever the outcome. The woman at the centre of this seismic moment, the bill's sponsor Kim Leadbeater, braced herself as the result came in. Many months of pressure and responsibility appeared to be lifted from her shoulders as the win was announced and colleagues gathered to commend her efforts. Throughout the process this been politics but not as we know it, with party divisions put aside and MPs asked to search their own consciences and come to their own conclusions. It has created a more collaborative atmosphere in parliament and encouraged MPs to engage more actively with their constituents. In the end there was still anger, frustration and disappointment among those who were against the law change, either on principle or because they believed the legislation was flawed. And of course, politics will go back to being combative and voices in the Commons will be raised once again. But for a brief period, historic change was calmly ushered in. The challenge for the proponents now is to take the legislation through the next phases and deliver it with the same smoothness and determination.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Government Contractors Recruit Fewer Prospects
Thousands of private government consultants laid off during the Trump administration's cost-cutting crusade are increasingly flooding a shrinking labor market. Bloomberg's Rachel Phua has more on the story.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Find Big Beautiful Profits in Trump's Budget Bill
There's a new sheriff in town, or at least that's what the budget bill Trump is back in the saddle, and he's riding in with a 'Big, Beautiful Bill' that aims to reshape the fiscal landscape of America. Whether you love it or loathe it, one thing's certain: there's money to be isn't about political ideology. This is about dollars and cents. And if you're the kind of investor who likes to get ahead of the curve, now's the time to pay I'm breaking down exactly how Trump's latest budget proposal can translate into a market-moving opportunity. We're going to zero in on the sectors that are poised to benefit and understand why policy creates get into the Budget BoomTrump's budget isn't a 'skinny bill' or some placeholder draft. It's a fireworks show of federal spending. This is fiscal stimulus with a red hat and a bullhorn. Infrastructure, defense, border security, energy independence, you name it, there's a line item for are forward-looking machines, and as the bill takes shape, capital is already shifting. Institutional money doesn't wait until the ribbon-cutting ceremony; it loads up when the ink hits the page. That's why understanding the thematic shifts before they materialize in quarterly earnings is key to Government, Big Gains It may seem counterintuitive, but historically, markets have been fond of spending. It doesn't matter if the budget is balanced or busted; the important thing is where the money is going. And Trump's Big, Beautiful Bill tells us that loud and clear. Follow the money for take a look at the big-ticket themes in this budget that are likely to push equity valuations Spending ExplosionThis one is self-explanatory right now. If there's one part of the federal budget Trump never skimps on, it's defense. With ongoing geopolitical tensions and a hawkish stance on global military presence, the defense budget is poised to increase planes, tanks, missiles, cybersecurity, satellites, and advanced warfare tech. The contractors that feed the Pentagon machine are going to be very busy. Of course, Aerospace and Defense stocks immediately come to mind. But don't let yourself get caught up in 20th-century thinking on this one. The future of warfare is all about escalation in the Middle East is very unnerving. The threat of this conflict spilling over to other nations is Hat Capitalism: Infrastructure Gets the Green Light Trump is back to preaching 'America First,' and that includes putting steel to pavement. Roads, bridges, tunnels, ports, and broadband infrastructure are all getting a stocks, raw materials, engineering firms, and specialized machinery manufacturers are among the first to receive contracts and for US-based stocks in these industries to fare the best, of course. This is a clear case of 'The rich get richer,' as stocks that benefited from Trump's spending last time around are likely to benefit again. Don't be afraid to revisit what worked four years . . .------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------The Best $1 Investment You Can MakeThis unique Zacks Ultimate arrangement grants you 30-day access to all our private portfolios for only $1 without a cent of additional portfolios have closed 99 double and triple-digit gains so far this year. While not all our picks are winners, members saw gains of +220.3%, +298.3%, +627.5%, and even +1,340.0%.¹Start Zacks Ultimate Access Now >>------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------The Wall, Border Tech, and SecurityYes, the wall is back. But this time, it's more about tech than brick. Firewalls have replaced actual walls. We're talking surveillance, drones, biometric scanners, smart fencing, and AI-powered tracking involved in security hardware, software, and border protection will be bidding for billion-dollar contracts. As the world evolves and shifts increasingly to the digital realm, cybersecurity becomes and Mineral Independence Energy policy under Trump has always been built on independence and dominance. This budget loosens the reins on domestic drilling, pipelines, and nuclear energy—all under the banner of 'unleashing American energy.'Coal is politically symbolic, but the real money is in LNG, shale, and infrastructure upgrades. Energy services, fracking equipment, and even uranium players stand to more than just energy this time around. The bill was introduced to Congress around the same time as several Executive Orders aimed at achieving mineral independence for the US. That means that the US does not want to rely on imports for the critical minerals it needs to manufacture critically essential Reindustrialization & Anti-China SentimentThis bill has echoes of Trump's earlier 'Bring Jobs Home' campaign. This means reshoring chip production, subsidizing critical industries, and boosting American-made manufacturing, particularly in strategic sectors such as semiconductors, robotics, and that with anti-China tech policies and you've got a recipe for selective decoupling. Expect friendly tax treatment for U.S.-based manufacturers and aggressive tariffs or bans on Chinese you've been following along the NVIDIA saga at all, you've already seen this. One day, NVIDIA can sell lower-end chips to China, and the next day, it can't. If you're reading between the lines, it's best to bet on US chip manufacturers that don't deal with the Far and Rural Healthcare Expansion Bipartisan support for improved care for veterans and underserved rural populations means healthcare stocks, particularly those focused on logistics, telehealth, and clinic expansion, could receive a significant Federal ContractorsThe big companies, such as Lockheed and Raytheon, will get the headlines. However, the real alpha is hidden in the small- to mid-cap firms that secure subcontractor work. These companies often fly under Wall Street's radar, and their earnings are disproportionately affected by a single large contract.I'm referring to niche suppliers of military-grade connectors, battlefield software, rural broadband specialists, or regional construction companies with existing government ties. These smaller companies are the ones that could potentially surge 10x in a portfolio, versus some of the behemoths, where a billion-dollar contract doesn't even move the Line The One Big, Beautiful Bill is making its way through Congress. There have already been some significant winners and substantial losers as a result. These themes are not going to fall by the wayside overnight. Following the money in that bill could lead to substantial gains for investors over the next three Best Way to Find Zacks' Top Picks Today, I'm pleased to offer you full, 30-day, real-time access to every stock and ETF we recommend as part of our celebrated Zacks Ultimate expert-led recommendation services are designed to highlight the most promising stocks on the market, including the hottest AI firms, insider trades (the legal kind), home run moves, stocks under $10, earnings surprise stocks, and much total cost is only $1, and there's no obligation to spend a cent includes the real-time buy and sell recommendations, along with expert market insights from ALL of Zacks' private portfolio future success isn't guaranteed, Zacks Ultimate members recently had opportunities to close gains of +220.3%, +298.3%, +627.5%, and an incredible +1,340.0%.¹Free Bonus Report: You'll also receive our Special Report, The Semiconductor Surge: A Single Stock to Watch. As demand and revenue for semiconductor stocks continue to boom, this little-known chipmaker looks to rival NVIDIA's explosive growth moving wait – this opportunity ends at midnight Sunday, June Access and Our Bonus Report Right Now for Just $1 >>All the best,DaveDavid BartosiakStock StrategistDave Bartosiak is Zacks' resident earnings surprise expert and the manager of Zacks's Blockchain Innovators. He selects stocks and delivers daily commentary for our Surprise Trader portfolio.¹ The results listed above are not (or may not be) representative of the performance of all selections made by Zacks Investment Research's newsletter editors and may represent the partial close of a position. Access grants you a comprehensive list of all open and closed trades. Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click to get this free report This article originally published on Zacks Investment Research ( Zacks Investment Research
