Attacks on healthcare in war zones in 2024 reach ‘new levels of horror'
Last year saw more than 3,600 attacks on health workers, hospitals and clinics in conflict zones, a record figure reflecting 'new levels of horror', a new report has found.
The total is 15% higher than in 2023 and includes air, missile and drone strikes on hospitals and clinics, as well as the looting and takeover of facilities and arrest and detention of health workers.
More than a third of the attacks took place in Gaza and the West Bank, but there were also hundreds recorded in Ukraine, Lebanon, Myanmar and Sudan.
Leonard Rubenstein, the chair of the Safeguarding Health in Conflict Coalition (SHCC), which authored the report, warned that the rise comes at the same time as 'attempts by perpetrators to limit legal protections for healthcare and civilians in war'.
He cited sanctions imposed on international criminal court (ICC) staff by US president Donald Trump for having charged Israelis with war crimes, and a 2023 law passed by Russia's Duma that criminalised cooperation with the ICC.
Rubenstein said: 'On average, in 2024, healthcare came under attack 10 times a day across the world's war zones. Each of these assaults brings terror, trauma, and in too many cases, injury, destruction and death.
'Attacks on healthcare undermine the ability to care for people when it is needed most, in war.'
There were 3,623 recorded incidents in 2024, including 1,111 where health facilities were damaged or destroyed, 927 where health workers were killed, 473 where health workers were arrested and 140 where health workers were kidnapped. Most of the incidents – 81% – were attributed to state actors.
Related: 'No rules': Gaza's doctors say they were tortured, beaten and humiliated in Israeli detention
More than 55% of health worker arrests in 2024 were made by the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) in Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem. The SHCC points to reports of physical and sexual abuse inside detention facilities. Nearly half of the deaths were reported from Lebanon, and most were emergency medical responders killed during the IDF's Operation Northern Arrows.
Explosive weapons are used in an increasing proportion of attacks against healthcare, the report warned, up from 36% of incidents in 2023 to 48% last year. Much of the rise was accounted for by the increased use of drones.
The figures in the report are probably an undercount, it said, due to the difficulty of collecting accurate information during conflict.
Christina Wille, director of Insecurity Insight, who led the report's data collection, said: 'There has been a complete erosion in the respect for international humanitarian law and the responsibility to protect healthcare in conflict.'
She called for a 'decisive response', adding: 'Justice must be pursued and accountability enforced.'
The report calls on UN member states to 'collectively reject efforts to reinterpret international humanitarian law that undermine their purpose of protecting healthcare in armed conflict' and 'end impunity by encouraging investigations, data sharing, prosecutions through the ICC and empowering monitoring bodies'.
It also calls for support for declarations and treaties that would strengthen protections for civilians in armed conflicts, and a review of military doctrines and protocols to put greater emphasis on safety for healthcare.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
2 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
In backdrop of shuttered MetroSouth hospital in Blue Island, south suburban officials warn Medicaid cuts could undermine health care
Blue Island's former MetroSouth hospital served as a warning Friday of what could happen if President Donald Trump's big bill aimed at slashing federal spending and extending tax cuts becomes law, elected officials and health care workers said Friday. 'We went through a hospital closure right down the street, and we know what that did to this community, but not just this community, the South Side of Chicago and the south suburbs,' state Rep. Bob Rita said at a news conference on the impact of Medicaid cuts. 'What these proposed cuts will do will just be devastating, not only for the communities I represent, but the entire state of Illinois,' he said. Rita and other local officials, including U.S. Rep. Robin Kelly, visited the Blue Island Health Center Friday to highlight how Medicaid cuts put not only uninsured people, but entire communities and hospital systems at risk. MetroSouth Medical Center was Blue Island's largest employer until it closed in 2019, with owner Quorum Health citing multimillion dollar losses. Plans are underway to convert the former hospital into a senior living facility. Dr. Kiran Joshi, practicing family medicine physician and chief operating officer of Cook County Health, said without Medicaid reimbursement, hospitals and clinics could be forced to cut services or close their doors completely. 'And don't forget that the costs to care for uninsured patients don't just go away,' Joshi said. 'They will increase everyone's health care costs, and that impacts access to care for everyone.' Jacquelyn Banks, a mental health clinician at the health center, said 60% of patients served by such community health centers are covered by Medicaid. Banks said she has already seen an uptick in symptoms in patients concerned about how potential Medicaid cuts would affect them as well as a decrease in medication compliance. 'They're afraid,' Banks said. 'They're hoarding medications should they need them in the future. They don't know what the future looks like, so they're willing to risk their stability at this time.' Trump and Republican lawmakers' One Big Beautiful Bill Act was written to find $880 billion in cuts from programs under the purview of the Energy and Commerce Committee, which includes jurisdiction over Medicaid. If the bill passed in its current form, an estimated 10.9 million people could lose access to health coverage, officials said. Supporters of the bill have said that rather than cut programs, they aim to remove people who are taking advantage of the system and protect it for those who need it most. But health care providers like Banks believe the result could bring widespread illness, higher insurance premiums and longer wait times for care. 'We as medical professionals know the risk. We know the science behind this,' Banks said. 'The very factor causing folks to improve their health should not be what causes them to become more ill.'
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
As death toll rises, Gazans make life-risking journeys to seek food
By Nidal al-Mughrabi GAZA/CAIRO (Reuters) -Like thousands of other Palestinians in Gaza, Hind Al-Nawajha takes a dangerous, miles-long journey every day to try to get some food for her family, hoping she makes it back alive. Accompanied by her sister, Mazouza, the mother-of-four had to duck down and hide behind a pile of rubble on the side of the road as gunshots echoed nearby. "You either come back carrying (food) for your children and they will be happy, or you come back in a shroud, or you go back upset (without food) and your children will cry," said Nawajha, 38, a resident of Beit Lahiya, in northern Gaza. "This is life, we are being slaughtered, we can't do it anymore." In the past two days, dozens of Palestinians have also been killed by Israeli fire as they tried to get food from aid trucks brought into the enclave by the United Nations and international relief agencies, Gaza medics said. On Thursday, medics said at least 51 people were killed by Israeli gunfire and military strikes, including 12 people who tried to approach a site operated by the U.S.-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation in the central Gaza Strip, the latest in near-daily reports of killings of people seeking food. The Israeli military said there were several attempts by "suspects" to approach forces in the area of Netzarim in the central Gaza Strip, in a manner that endangered them. It said forces fired warning shots to prevent suspects from approaching them, and it was currently unaware of injuries in the incident. In an email, GHF criticized Gazan health officials, accusing them of regularly releasing inaccurate information. GHF said that Palestinians do not access the nearby GHF site via the Netzarim corridor. It did not address questions about whether GHF was aware that such an incident had occurred. Thirty-nine people were killed, meanwhile, in separate Israeli airstrikes in the northern Gaza Strip, medics said. One of those strikes killed at least 19 people, including women and children, in a tent in Shati refugee camp in Gaza City, they added. Another strike killed at least 14 people and damaged several houses in Jabalia, in the north of the enclave, medics said. There was no immediate comment from the Israeli army on those attacks. In recent days, the Israeli military said its forces had opened fire and fired warning shots to disperse people who approached areas where troops were operating, posing a threat. It said it was reviewing reports of casualties among civilians. SLEEPING BY THE ROAD Israel has been channelling much of the aid it is now allowing into Gaza through a new U.S.- and Israeli-backed group, the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, which operates a handful of distribution sites in areas guarded by Israeli forces. The Gaza health ministry said hundreds of Palestinians have been killed trying to reach GHF sites since late May. The United Nations rejects the GHF delivery system as inadequate, dangerous and a violation of humanitarian impartiality rules. Israel says it is needed to prevent Hamas fighters from diverting aid, which Hamas denies. On Wednesday, the GHF said in a statement it had distributed 3 million meals across three of its aid sites without an incident. The Gaza war was triggered when Palestinian Hamas militants attacked Israel on October 7, 2023, killing 1,200 people and taking 251 hostages, according to Israeli tallies. Israel's subsequent military assault on Gaza has killed nearly 55,600 Palestinians, according to Gaza's health ministry, while displacing almost the entire population of more than 2 million and causing a hunger crisis. The Norwegian Refugee Council warned on Thursday that more than 1 million people were without adequate shelter, saying equipment such as tents and tarpaulins had been blocked by Israel from entering since March 1. Nawajha returned empty-handed on Wednesday from her journey to find food, flopping down exhausted on the dusty ground outside the tent in Gaza City, where she has been displaced and sheltering with her family. She and her sister have been camping by the road for the past 20 days. They say they try to force their way into the distribution site where trucks carrying aid arrive, but are often outmuscled by men, who sometimes fight over sacks of flour coming off U.N. trucks. "(When) there is no food, as you can see, children start crying and getting angry," said Nawajha. "When we are for three, four kilometres or more on our legs... Oh my... our feet are bruised and our shoes are torn off."
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Outpouring of grief in Gaza as Israel's military campaign intensifies
The Palestinian Ministry of Health says more than 70 people, including multiple children, were killed Thursday by Israeli strikes, with the Al-Shati refugee camp west of Gaza City among the targets. CNN's Paula Hancocks reports on the trauma faced by Palestinians in Gaza, where a 12-year-old boy offered a gripping account of the suffering.
