Getting set to tackle water services myths
One councillor is hoping consultation on how water services are provided across Central Otago will deal to the many "myths" circulating in the community, while another has suggested the outcome of the consultation is already a "fait accompli".
The Central Otago District Council is considering teaming up with three other local authorities to deliver and maintain Three Waters infrastructure.
The council now wants to hear the view of residents and ratepayers. In a virtual meeting last Thursday, elected members signed off on a consultation document.
Cr Cheryl Laws said it was a matter of "how we get our message out now to the public and avoid all of these myths that are out there".
Branded as "Southern Water Done Well", the topic was canvassed in the just-closed long-term plan consultation. Collaboration with neighbouring councils and the status quo were among options mooted.
Council Three Waters head Julie Muir told elected members at Thursday's meeting initial analysis of submissions received in response to the long-term plan showed close to a 50:50 split in sentiment regarding the creation of a new water entity versus retaining the status quo.
However, much of the discussion at last week's meeting centred on the status quo being a red herring.
"The word status quo implies that we can continue as we are, with the same costs, and we know legally that's not achievable," Ms Muir said.
"There's no such things as status quo — it's 'status quo' that we continue to deliver in-house, but it's at a higher cost and higher level of service."
Cr Sarah Browne said people she talked to were confused as to why any change was needed when, on the whole, the district was already delivering water services well.
"I'd say the public feedback at this stage is that we absolutely should just be doing the status quo, keep it in house," Cr Browne said.
"That's the crux of the conversation I've had with everybody that's interested in it."
However, it was not that the council did not want to maintain the status quo; rather, it "can't do it".
"I think that's the key issue ... the status quo isn't an option; it isn't sustainable."
Mayor Tamah Alley said people needed to "wrap their heads around" the proposal.
"There are challenges coming in this [Three Waters] space that we are aware of, but perhaps the general public aren't quite across," she told councillors.
Cr Martin McPherson called the paper in front of elected members an "educational document" rather than a "consultation document".
However, there was silence when he went as far as saying: "We're not really seeking any feedback, because this is a fait accompli. We're going ahead with this come hell or high water because we don't have a choice."
Ms Muir said the latest consultation, zeroing in on water, would move the discussion on. She said the consultation document was "well put together" and "easy to read".
"I think this gives people a greater depth of knowledge and understanding of what's proposed."
Council chief executive Peter Kelly said the other three councils — the Clutha, Gore and Waitaki District Councils — signed off on similar consultation documents last week, with only minor amendments.
According to the Central Otago document, combined debt for the four councils is projected to rise from $236million to $598m by 2034, with $760m invested in water services over the coming decade to ensure compliance with national expectations.
The month-long consultation started late last week and will conclude on June 6. Public information sessions are planned.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
5 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
SDC votes to keep water services in-house
A Southern council has opted to keep its water services in-house following strong community feedback. Southland district councillors last week voted unanimously to run with an "adjusted status quo model" for Three Waters services which allows it to retain responsibility while meeting new requirements. It comes at a time when councils all over the country are responding to government reform on how they want to deliver drinking water, wastewater and stormwater. More than 97% of Southland respondents preferred an adjusted status quo option instead of a standalone council-controlled organisation (CCO). Reasons for the overwhelming vote included local control, accountability, affordability, cost efficiency and a feeling of "reform fatigue". If the council had opted to go down the CCO route, estimated costs of $750,000 would have been required for setup in addition to about $625,000 a year for operating. Mayor Rob Scott attended several meetings during consultation. "It was really good engagement everywhere we went, even with the smaller numbers," he said. The adjusted status quo model will form part of the council's water services delivery plan, as required under legislation. That plan needs to show how the council will be compliant in delivering a satisfactory and financially sustainable service by mid-2028, and must be submitted to the Department of Internal Affairs (DIA) by September 3. The council was also involved in a DIA case study looking at how new standards would impact rural councils. Results from the study were received last week, but the staff report had already been prepared for the meeting. Community consultation in Southland ran from April 3 to May 21. In May, the Invercargill City Council also voted to keep its delivery in-house. Consultation has just ended on a proposal in which Gore would join forces with Clutha, Central Otago and Waitaki. • LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
Otago Daily Times
5 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Big opposition to joint water CCO
A sample of submissions for a joint local government water initiative suggests officials may have a fight on their hands. The Clutha District Council meets in Balclutha today for hearings on its Southern Water Done Well proposals. Thirty-three groups and individuals are scheduled to speak to their submissions regarding the proposals, under which Clutha would join forces with the Waitaki, Central Otago and Gore District Councils to manage water services infrastructure and delivery. The council received 393 submissions during consultation, of which only the 33 from those speaking to their submissions have been made public. Of those, 29 (88%) opposed Clutha forming a jointly council-controlled organisation (CCO), the preferred option put forward by all four councils in the group. Only four favoured a joint or stand-alone CCO model, some with modifications. During consultation, Clutha District Mayor Bryan Cadogan described the joint CCO as the "least bad" solution to the latest central government push for water reform. Documents showed the four councils collectively accruing $598 million of water infrastructure debt by 2034, as they expected to spend $760m on providing improved water services in line with more stringent regulations. At the time, Mr Cadogan said the joint CCO could lead to modest efficiencies and savings for ratepayers. Other options included formation of a stand-alone CCO, or an in-house business unit. Mr Cadogan warned these options could consign Clutha to insolvency during the next decade, due to mounting infrastructure debt. Submissions against the joint council-controlled organisation cited "loss of local control" and "lack of transparency" as concerns. Submitter Alex de Boer, of Owaka, said centralisation had been demonstrated not to work. "The sums show very little advantage in rating by 2033-34. "Combining with other areas will cause loss of focus on our unique issues. "Centralisation did not work for the polytechs, hospital boards or the Auckland 'Super City'. Rates rose a lot." Council deputy chief executive Jules Witt said yesterday the council could not comment on the overall split of submissions until the hearings had been completed. "Council is still in the process of collating and analysing the submissions received. The submissions are part of the overall decision-making process of council," he said. The Waitaki, Central Otago and Gore District Councils are also seeking feedback on the proposals at present. The government will assess the council's resulting water services delivery plan and provide feedback from December. If approved, a jointly owned CCO would begin operation in July 2027.
Otago Daily Times
11-06-2025
- Otago Daily Times
SDC votes unanimously to keep water services in-house
Southlanders have made their voices heard on how they want the district council to deal with its water assets. PHOTO: SUPPLIED A southern council has opted to keep its water services in-house following strong community feedback. Southland district councillors yesterday voted unanimously to run with an "adjusted status quo model" for Three Waters services which allows it to retain responsibility while meeting new requirements. It comes at a time when councils all over the country are responding to government reform on how they want to deliver drinking water, wastewater and stormwater. More than 97% of Southland respondents preferred an adjusted status quo option instead of a standalone council-controlled organisation (CCO). Reasons for the overwhelming vote included local control, accountability, affordability, cost efficiency and a feeling of "reform fatigue". If the council had opted to go down the CCO route, estimated costs of $750,000 would have been required for setup in addition to about $625,000 a year for operating. Mayor Rob Scott attended several meetings during consultation. "It was really good engagement everywhere we went, even with the smaller numbers," he said. The adjusted status quo model will form part of the council's water services delivery plan, as required under legislation. That plan needs to show how the council will be compliant in delivering a satisfactory and financially sustainable service by mid-2028, and must be submitted to the Department of Internal Affairs (DIA) by September 3. The council was also involved in a DIA case study looking at how new standards would impact rural councils. Results from the study were received yesterday, but the staff report had already been prepared for the meeting. Community consultation in Southland ran from April 3 to May 21. In May, the Invercargill City Council also voted to keep its delivery in-house. Consultation has just ended on a proposal in which Gore would join forces with Clutha, Central Otago and Waitaki. • LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
