Wales is UK worst for surgical abortions, says charity
Wales is the worst part of the UK for providing surgical abortions with many women treated in England, according to a leading healthcare charity.
The British Pregnancy Advisory Service (BPAS) said it was "astonishing" Wales was behind Northern Ireland, where abortion was only decriminalised in 2019.
One south Wales woman said she felt extra trauma and guilt at the thought of being sent away for the procedure - which involves an operation to remove the pregnancy from the womb.
The Welsh government said it accepted improvements needed to be made for mid-trimester (13 to 27 weeks) abortion services, and women should be able to access essential healthcare services closer to home.
Women from Wales have to travel to England for abortions
Abortion laws are Victorian era, says grieving mum
In Wales, England and Scotland abortion is allowed up to 24 weeks of pregnancy with the approval of two doctors.
Abortion was decriminalised in Northern Ireland in 2019, and prior to that it was only allowed in very specific circumstances.
Abortion care provider BPAS told BBC Wales that Northern Ireland now offered second trimester surgical abortions beyond 20 weeks, with Scotland offering services up to 20 weeks.
However, in Wales there was "very limited provision after 14 weeks" it said, partly because of a "skills gap" and few doctors.
Sarah, not her real name, found herself unexpectedly pregnant about two years ago.
She was already a mum, and because she had experienced serious post-natal depression in the past, could not face going through with the pregnancy.
Sarah, who is her late 30s, said she did not want a medical abortion because of an earlier miscarriage, but was told she could not have a surgical abortion locally because of an existing medical condition that meant she needed general anaesthetic.
When she was around 16 weeks pregnant, she was offered the procedure in London with her travel and accommodation paid for for two nights.
But she found the whole experience "really stressful".
"There was a bigger sense of guilt, because I was being sent away," Sarah added.
"I was imagining people with placards waving and shouting, I didn't know what hospital it would be.
"Having to leave my two children – who I hadn't left for more than one night – what would we tell them, what would we do? It added a lot of extra stress and trauma."
Sarah decided to continue with the pregnancy, describing it as a "really difficult time" until she was around 28 weeks.
"Emotionally, it was the worst summer of my life," she said.
What is surgical abortion?
Surgical abortion involves an operation to remove the pregnancy from the womb
It may be done with local anaesthetic, conscious sedation or general anaesthetic and, according to the NHS, the surgical method can be performed by vacuum or suction aspiration or by dilation and evacuation
Medical abortions, which involve the use of drugs, accounted for 86% of abortions in Wales and England in 2022
Rachael Clarke from BPAS said each year about 175 women travel from Wales to England for care.
"Many of these women don't want to speak out about what they experienced, they don't want to revisit it, and it makes it very easy for people to ignore the quite harrowing experiences," she said.
The head of advocacy added it was often seen as the "easy option" to send women to a different service or country instead of accessing care closer to home.
"A lot of that is down to clinical availability, but also premises," she said.
"If you don't have space in a hospital, if you don't have a theatre, if you don't have a ward where women can go before and after that limits what you're able to provide."
She added that there was a dangerous skills gap with a lack of doctors routinely performing surgical abortions, or procedures also used in mid-trimester miscarriage.
The first women's health plan for Wales, published in December last year, lists abortion as a "fundamental aspect" of women's reproductive healthcare, stating it should be available "locally and without delay for all women" to reduce "complications, distress and cost".
Funding and delivering services for mid-trimester abortion care is listed as a long-term goal, with a timescale of approximately six to 10 years.
Ms Clarke described that timeline as "a kick in the guts".
MS Sioned Williams said the women's health cross-party group had been asking the Welsh government to act since 2018.
"It's important to me that when we say something is a health right, as it states in the new women's health plan, that there's action behind that to make it so, and that people are able to access abortions in a timely way," she said.
The Plaid Cymru MS for South Wales West added she thought this could be easily changed because of the relatively small number of women who require this care.
A spokesperson for the Welsh government accepted that improvements in mid-trimester abortion services need to be made, adding it fully acknowledges that women should be able to access essential healthcare services closer to home.
"We are working with NHS Wales to identify and address the specific barriers to providing surgical abortion services locally and we are exploring what short-term improvements we can make while developing a robust, sustainable service for the future", they added.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
British lawmakers vote to decriminalize abortion for pregnant women while America cracks down
British lawmakers voted Tuesday to decriminalize abortion for the pregnant woman – in striking contrast to the crackdown on reproductive rights in the United States. Lawmakers voted by an overwhelming majority to invalidate Victorian-era legislation that makes it possible to prosecute a woman for ending her pregnancy in England and Wales, though medical professionals who help terminate a pregnancy beyond certain limits will still be breaking the law. Currently, abortion beyond the first 24 weeks of pregnancy is illegal in those two parts of the United Kingdom. Beyond that time limit, it is permitted in certain circumstances, such as when the mother's life is at risk. While abortions are common in England and Wales, women who terminate their pregnancy outside of existing restrictions face the threat of criminal investigation, arrest, prosecution and even imprisonment. Tuesday's vote – which amends a draft policing and crime law – seeks to remove those threats. The amended bill needs to pass through both chambers of the UK parliament before it can become law. The vast majority of Britons believe women should have the right to an abortion, according to YouGov surveys stretching back to 2019. The latest poll, conducted in April, showed that 88% of respondents supported that right. Britain's vote comes as its ally across the Atlantic has dramatically restricted abortion rights. Since the US Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in 2022 – which had enshrined abortion as a constitutional right – many US states have introduced severe restrictions or outright bans on the practice. The changes have completely upended the landscape of reproductive health and choice in America. Louise McCudden, UK head of external affairs at MSI Reproductive Choices, a charity providing abortions, thinks there is a connection between Tuesday's vote and a 'hostile climate' toward abortion rights in the UK driven by the changes in the US. McCudden told CNN there had been an 'increase in activity from anti-choice groups outside (MSI) clinics' that feel 'emboldened' by the crackdown on abortion rights across the pond. 'On the rare occasions when you do see women who are suspected of ending a pregnancy over 24 weeks, they are invariably in extremely vulnerable situations,' she also said, noting that the women who had been investigated in the UK included domestic abuse survivors, potential trafficking survivors and women who'd had miscarriages and stillbirths. However, the UK's Society for the Protection of Unborn Children strongly condemned Tuesday's vote. 'If this clause becomes law, a woman who aborts her baby at any point in pregnancy, even moments before birth, would not be committing a criminal offense,' Alithea Williams, the society's public policy manager, said in a statement Tuesday. 'Now, even the very limited protection afforded by the law is being stripped away,' she added. CNN's Kara Fox contributed reporting.
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
'I'm scared dad will die in hospital 140 miles away'
A son has said he is being robbed of precious time with his father after he was placed in a mental health hospital nearly 140 miles from home. Bernard Mendoza, 83, who has dementia, had to be moved from his Wrexham care home after he became aggressive towards staff and other residents, but the nearest suitable bed was in Northampton. His son Danny Mendoza has called the system "broken", and is worried about his father "passing away in there, and being so far from home". Betsi Cadwaladr health board said it was "extremely sorry," and wanted to bring him home as soon as possible. I love dad to bits - but being his carer has broken me 'I know I'm going to have early onset dementia' 'I do press ups every day so I can care for my son' Earlier this year, Danny, 54, from Gresford in Wrexham, told BBC Wales how he had been the sole unpaid carer for his father after he developed dementia three years ago. But the isolation of "living like a hermit" pushed Danny to "breaking point", and his father was eventually offered a place in a Wrexham care home. Bernard settled in well and Danny was able to visit daily. But in recent weeks his father's condition has worsened, and after several incidents of aggression towards staff and residents, Danny agreed he needed to go into a mental health hospital. Danny said his father had become so aggressive he was sectioned under the Mental Health Act, but was told the only suitable place available to care for him was a two hour and 40 minute drive away at St Andrew's Hospital in Northampton – a £40 trip Danny can only afford to make once or twice a week. He said: "It's appalling – not a single bed in north Wales, or the whole of Wales? "It's not going to help me, it's not helping dad, it's not going to help the staff who look after him to settle him. It's not right. "The time I've got left with my dad is precious. I don't know how long we've got left, and that's why I need him somewhere close to home, so I can spend time with him – what time he's got left. "It's just the fear of him passing away in there and being so far from home." Danny said it was upsetting seeing his dad so "badly confused" as he does not know where he is, staying in a "strange hospital". Danny said he felt "powerless" and racked with "guilt". "I just want to be there for dad," he said. "He needs love, he needs support. And having my dad placed in Northampton, it's just having a huge impact on me. It's just so upsetting that we can't do better in this day and age." Danny said he completely understood his father had become a risk to himself and others, and needed to be moved to a more specialised environment. But he fears other families could have loved ones being cared for hours away, and said funding for more suitable beds and treatment closer to home was urgently needed. "We've got an ageing population. Unless the funding keeps pace with demand, then the system is going to collapse." He said people deserved "more respect than that" when they age and become ill with dementia. Charity Carers Wales said Danny's situation was "quite a common occurrence". Rob Simkins, head of policy and public affairs, added: "I just think it's a really sorry state of affairs that in 2025, in one of the richest countries in the world, people are having to travel two-and-a-half hours to go and look after the people they provide care for, or go and visit them. "I think we can do better than that in Wales." Mr Simkins said it painted a picture where there was not enough infrastructure close to people and their families, putting "additional stresses and strains on carers trying to help and support the people they provide care for". "We need to get it sorted, and quickly," he added. Teresa Owen, an executive director at Betsi Cadwaldr health board, said: "I am extremely sorry for the situation Mr Mendoza and his son find themselves in. "Unfortunately, we work in an extremely pressured system and sometimes we do not have the capacity to admit to our own facilities in complex cases like these. "Sadly, there was no-one available to us to provide the type of care Mr Mendoza needed closer to his home, at the time he needed help. "We are focused on him receiving the best care and bringing him back home as quickly as possible." The health board's mental health and learning disability team's east division has four patients at St Andrew's. The number of patients has decreased in the past year, but there is "still more work to do," she added. "You can be assured this is a priority for us, as we want people to be closer to their homes and their families." The Welsh government said it provided £12.7m a year to support implementing its dementia action plan. It added: "Our mental health and wellbeing strategy aims to ensure when people need support, care or treatment, they will be able to access a range of services seamlessly and delivered as close to home as possible."
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
UK MPs vote to decriminalise abortion for women in all cases
UK MPs on Tuesday voted to end contentious prosecutions of women in England and Wales for terminating a pregnancy, paving the way for a huge overhaul of how the country's abortion laws are enforced. Currently, a woman can face criminal charges for choosing to end a pregnancy after 24 weeks or without the approval of two doctors, under laws which technically still carry a maximum sentence of life imprisonment. The issue has gained attention in the UK due to recent court cases. In one, a woman was cleared by a jury at trial, while another was released from prison on appeal. MPs voted by a majority of 242 on Tuesday in favour of an amendment put forward by Labour MP Tonia Antoniazzi, which would ensure that no woman would be criminally pursued for terminating her own pregnancy at any time -- even though the amendment leaves the underlying abortion laws unchanged. The full crime and policing bill must now be voted on by parliament and then pass the upper House of Lords before becoming law. "Women are currently being arrested from hospital bed to police cell and facing criminal investigations on suspicion of ending their own pregnancy," Antoniazzi told AFP. "My amendment would put a stop to this," she said, adding it was "the right amendment at the right time". Abortion in England and Wales is a criminal offence under the Offences Against the Person Act, passed in 1861 during the Victorian age and which theoretically carries a maximum sentence of life imprisonment. The Abortion Act 1967 made terminations legal in certain circumstances, including by permitting it up to 23 weeks and six days of gestation if done by an authorised provider. Abortions are allowed in limited circumstances after this time, such as if the mother's life is in danger or there is a "substantial risk" the child could be born with a serious disability. An update to the law introduced during the Covid-19 pandemic allows women to take abortion pills at home up to 10 weeks into a pregnancy. In May, Nicola Packer was acquitted after taking prescribed abortion medicine when she was around 26 weeks pregnant, beyond the 10-week legal limit. The 45-year-old told jurors during her trial, which came after a four-year police investigation, that she did not realise she had been pregnant for so long. "It was horrendous giving evidence, absolutely awful," she told The Guardian newspaper last month. The Society for the Protection of Unborn Children has however called the proposed amendment "the greatest threat to unborn babies in decades". - 'Optimistic' - Antoniazzi's amendment will not change any of the laws regarding the provision of abortion services, including the time limits. And anyone assisting a woman in getting an abortion outside the remits of the law, such as medical practitioners, will still be liable for prosecution. Some 50 organisations, including abortion providers, medical colleges, and women's rights groups, have backed the amendment. They say six women have appeared in court in England charged with ending or attempting to end their own pregnancy outside abortion law in the last three years. Carla Foster was jailed in 2023 for illegally obtaining abortion tablets to end her pregnancy when she was between 32 and 34 weeks pregnant. The Court of Appeal eventually suspended her sentence. Antoniazzi said police have investigated "more than 100 women for suspected illegal abortion in the last five years including women who've suffered natural miscarriages and stillbirths". "This is just wrong. It's a waste of taxpayers money, it's a waste of the judiciary's time, and it's not in the public interest," she told the BBC Tuesday. When asked about the vote, Prime Minister Keir Starmer said Tuesday that women have the right to a "safe and legal abortion". Northern Ireland decriminalised abortion for women in 2019. Scotland is currently reviewing its abortion laws. pdh/jwp/gv
