Gary Payton Questions Luka Doncic's Willingness To Become A Defensive Player
Gary Payton Questions Luka Doncic's Willingness To Become A Defensive Player originally appeared on Fadeaway World.
Hall of Famer and 1996 Defensive Player of the Year Gary Payton has weighed in on the lingering question that continues to follow Luka Doncic: Will he ever become a competent defender?
Advertisement
During a candid conversation at the BUDX NBA House event in Mumbai, Payton, renowned for his elite perimeter defense and relentless tenacity, didn't mince words. He didn't question Doncic's talent, he questioned his will.
"Like I said, basketball is different than when I played because I could put my hands on them and I could hand check. We'll talk about Luka. You have to be dedicated to play defense. You have to be dedicated. Maybe that's not for him."
"He's a scorer. He can do it. Now, if he gets his mind to it, I tell every kid that I go and do camps with, I say there's a mindset to play defense. Not just say you want to play defense. You can't do that unless you have a mindset to do that."
"You have to have great hands and feet to do that. You have to be able to move. You have to be willing to take sacrifices to do things. And that's just the way it goes. I don't think Luka is a defensive player. I think he's a scorer. He's not one of that. But now, if he wants to, yes, he can get his mind to it to do it. But does he want to do it?"
Advertisement
"That's left up to him. That's not left up to us. He's an athlete. He's got great ability. Now, if he wants to go and change it and prove people wrong that he can't play defense, if that was me, I would change it."
"I would say, yeah, I'm going to go out there and I'm going to try to defend somebody. And I'm going to get in shape. I'm going to do the things that I need to do. And I'm going to do that."
This statement cuts to the heart of one of the biggest critiques of Luka Doncic. Offensively, there's no doubt he's a generational savant, a wizard with the ball, capable of scoring and facilitating at historic levels. But defensively, he's often compared to a traffic cone.
In the 2025 Western Conference first-round matchup against the Minnesota Timberwolves, Doncic was repeatedly exposed in one-on-one matchups. Anthony Edwards and Mike Conley blew past him with ease, and clips of Luka conceding straight-line drives went viral.
Advertisement
Paul Pierce openly criticized Doncic on national television after the series, declaring that he has to learn how to play defense. Kendrick Perkins was even more direct, calling Doncic 'the worst defensive star in modern basketball.'
And those criticisms had real-world consequences, they played a role in the Dallas Mavericks' shocking trade that sent Doncic to the Los Angeles Lakers in exchange for Anthony Davis.
Mavs GM Nico Harrison defended the move by saying, 'Defense wins championships,' subtly implying that Doncic's limitations on that end were incompatible with their championship goals. Harrison believed Davis, despite being older and more injury-prone, gave Dallas the elite defensive anchor they lacked with Luka.
The Boston Celtics also schemed Doncic into oblivion during the 2024 NBA Finals, targeting him relentlessly in pick-and-roll actions. The results were brutal: open looks, exposed rotations, and layups, all courtesy of Luka's sluggish foot speed and delayed reactions.
Advertisement
However, there are signs that Doncic is finally taking the criticism seriously. This offseason, photos surfaced of a slimmed-down Luka, reportedly after undergoing a modified diet and focused indoor training regimen.
Now with the Lakers, he seems more determined than ever to shed the perception that he's a one-way player. Sources close to the team say his conditioning has vastly improved, and his attention to detail during film sessions has been sharper than in years past.
Whether that transformation translates to better defensive results on the court remains to be seen. But as Gary Payton emphasized, defense isn't about talent, it's about choice.
Doncic has all the tools to become a passable, even respectable defender. But only time will tell if the new-look Lakers star finally develops the mindset required to back it up.
Advertisement
Related: Luka Doncic Predicted To Take $63 Million Hit On Lakers' Contract Following $100 Million+ Loss In Mavericks Trade
This story was originally reported by Fadeaway World on Jun 5, 2025, where it first appeared.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox Sports
18 minutes ago
- Fox Sports
Connecticut faces Golden State on 5-game slide
Associated Press Connecticut Sun (2-11, 2-6 Eastern Conference) at Golden State Valkyries (6-6, 4-4 Western Conference) San Francisco; Sunday, 8:30 p.m. EDT BOTTOM LINE: Connecticut Sun heads into the matchup with Golden State Valkyries as losers of five in a row. The Valkyries have gone 4-2 in home games. Golden State has a 2-3 record in games decided by 10 points or more. The Sun are 1-5 in road games. Connecticut is sixth in the Eastern Conference allowing 87.6 points while holding opponents to 46.5% shooting. Golden State averages 78.3 points per game, 9.3 fewer points than the 87.6 Connecticut allows. Connecticut averages 6.1 made 3-pointers per game this season, 2.8 fewer made shots on average than the 8.9 per game Golden State gives up. The teams meet Sunday for the first time this season. TOP PERFORMERS: Veronica Burton is averaging 11.2 points, 5.2 assists and 1.6 steals for the Valkyries. Kayla Thornton is averaging 15.3 points over the last 10 games. Tina Charles is averaging 16.6 points and 5.3 rebounds for the Sun. Marina Mabrey is averaging 15.8 points over the last 10 games. LAST 10 GAMES: Valkyries: 5-5, averaging 79.7 points, 36.0 rebounds, 18.8 assists, 8.5 steals and 3.7 blocks per game while shooting 41.4% from the field. Their opponents have averaged 79.8 points per game. Sun: 2-8, averaging 72.5 points, 28.6 rebounds, 16.7 assists, 7.9 steals and 3.1 blocks per game while shooting 40.5% from the field. Their opponents have averaged 88.6 points. INJURIES: Valkyries: None listed. Sun: None listed. ___ The Associated Press created this story using technology provided by Data Skrive and data from Sportradar. recommended
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
"Those three guys are not gonna win anything" - Shannon Sharpe urges the Lakers to trade Austin Reaves and improve their team
"Those three guys are not gonna win anything" - Shannon Sharpe urges the Lakers to trade Austin Reaves and improve their team originally appeared on Basketball Network. Time is ticking for the Los Angeles Lakers if they want to maximize their championship prowess with the tandem of Luka Doncic and LeBron James. With "The King" turning 41 next season, the window to chase a championship with him is narrow at best. Advertisement That is why Shannon Sharpe feels the Purple and Gold need to act strategically, and that includes considering a tough decision — trading their most valuable trade chip, Austin Reaves, to pursue a traditional center that can help elevate the game of both James and Doncic. Reaves is the only asset that the Lakers have After averaging 15.9 points and 5.5 assists during the 2023-24 campaign, AR proved himself to be one of the most reliable no. 3 options in the league. As a result, the franchise rewarded him with a four-year, $53 million contract before the start of this season. And "Hillbilly Kobe" didn't disappoint, averaging 20.2 points in the 2024-25 season, asserting himself as one of the most valuable pieces in their core. During the 2025 trade deadline, the Lakers seemed determined not to entertain any trade offers for Reaves. However, as the legendary NFL tight end said, now is the time to consider. With the 6'5" shooting guard now reaching his borderline All-Star level, more and more teams will be interested in offering him a lucrative contract worthy of his growth and talent. Advertisement On his podcast, Sharpe argued that from a team perspective, the Lakers need to offer their most valuable piece to acquire a battle-tested rim protector and pick-and-lob threat who can dominate the paint alongside the marquee duo. "The Lakers can only pay him so much. You're gonna go somewhere and get a big payday anyway. You ain't trying to stay with the Lakers when you get $200 million, and they can't give you that," Sharpe said. "Yeah, he has improved every single year; he's a hell of a player." "But those three guys are not gonna win anything. Now, I'm not saying you gotta package him, but they need a (traditional) big. He's the only valuable piece that they have," he added. Related: "He's Mr. Discipline, Mr. Straight, Mr. Conservative" - Dennis Rodman admits Gregg Popovich was "the big problem" in San Antonio The Lakers should never trade AR As tempting as it is to see Reaves' name used as trade bait, the truth is that the Lakers should not let go of him so easily. The 26-year-old is not an ordinary rising star but a homegrown fan favorite. Suppose the organization has put its faith in him. In that case, he has rewarded that trust by improving each season, regardless of the coaching changes or shifting roles. Advertisement Whether Bron or Luka was out of the lineup, AR stepped up and delivered, proving that he's more than capable of handling pressure on the big stage. And that is exactly the type of selfless, gritty player who can help build long-term success. He might not have individual accolades to his name. Still, with how Reaves has performed in the 2024-25 season, he was better as a third option than the second option of some teams and, in a handful of cases, more impactful than the production of the team's best player. Thus, the Lakers should definitely have plans for the future now that the Doncic era has begun. Still, trading proven youngsters like Reaves would only be a lose-lose move, as they would be giving up on a selfless, team-oriented player only to add another experiment to their roster. Related: "With Jordan, they don't talk about the the playoff losses" - Michael Beasley says LeBron is '100%' the GOAT over MJ This story was originally reported by Basketball Network on May 28, 2025, where it first appeared.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
"The Lakers need to get him into that contract" - Windhorst shares the ownership change in the Lakers means they must sign Doncic to a long-term deal
"The Lakers need to get him into that contract" - Windhorst shares the ownership change in the Lakers means they must sign Doncic to a long-term deal originally appeared on Basketball Network. The Los Angeles Lakers' majority ownership officially changed hands following the franchise's record $10 billion sale to Mark Walter's TWG Global. While the deal was widely praised, Brian Windhorst believes the new regime has a clear Luka Doncic matter to address first. Advertisement "I'm big on actions over words, and this is where Luka can absolutely do that," Windhorst said on ESPN's "Get Up." "So, I would argue one of the most important things that is on the table for the entire NBA this summer is whether Luka signs a contract extension with the Lakers, which he can do on or after August 2nd… The Lakers need to get him into that contract." Windhorst believes Los Angeles gives Doncic the best runway, primarily because of Walter's deep pockets. The new group could invest in a stronger staff or spend more aggressively to build a contender — something the Buss family had grown hesitant to do in recent years. Still, none of that matters if Luka doesn't sign on the dotted line and make it official. Doncic is showing plenty of interest Immediately after the sale was announced, the Slovenian superstar had already hinted at his next move. Luka expressed excitement about the team's direction and seemed pleased that Jeanie Buss would remain as team governor. Advertisement "The Lakers are an amazing organization. I'm looking forward to meeting Mark and excited about the future. I am also grateful to Jeanie and the Buss family for welcoming me to L.A., and I'm happy that Jeanie will continue to be involved. I look forward to working with both of them to win championships!" he wrote on his official "X" account. However, as Windy indicated, nothing is set until everything is official. If the Lakers fumble the ball and allow October 20 to pass (the last day of signing the Designated Veteran Extension), anything can happen. Doncic is still under contract for next year and has a player option for the 2026-27 season. Without an extension, the Lakers can't plan long-term or build the roster stability they need. The longer he remains uncommitted, the more leverage Luka holds — and the louder the noise from other franchises gets. If that happens, everything is up in the air. Related: "They are going to have to start to paying guys" - Doc Rivers breaks down why OKC won't be able to keep this team together Retooling the roster Even if Luka stays, that's only half the battle. The Lakers still have to retool the roster around him. With that in mind, Markieff Morris believes they don't need to turn the house upside-down to make some noise. Advertisement "Ultimately, I think he (Luka) will be there," Kieff told host Mike Greenberg. "What I think they need to make happen to the roster is minor tweaks. You are in a position where LeBron maybe has two years left, and he's trying to win right now, so I don't think bringing in a ton of new pieces and kind of revamping the team makes a lot of sense." For Morris, who was traded to L.A. from Dallas with Doncic, trading a core player just to fill a hole upfront feels like an overreaction. Chasing size might come at the expense of stability and cohesion. Over the past few weeks, Austin Reaves' name has been mentioned as the most likely core piece to be dealt with if it meant acquiring a starting-level big in return. He is still the most valuable asset the team has, given his contract length and the money he is owed. As productive as AR is, L.A. can't afford to skip the homework, even if it means putting his name on the table. Whatever the case may be, the uncertainty only adds to the stakes of what comes next. The ownership change may signal a fresh start, but it also comes with immediate pressure. Securing Luka's future is only part of the equation. Now, the Lakers have to prove they can build around him, too. Advertisement Related: "Best caretaker of the Laker brand" - Magic Johnson says the L.A. Lakers are in good hands with Mark Walter This story was originally reported by Basketball Network on Jun 20, 2025, where it first appeared.
