Range over performance: Is Indian auto industry selling EVs all wrong?
Indian auto industry has been devising its marketing strategies for electric vehicles on the range per charging cycle, but not the performance, which is quite the opposite of the marketing plan for ICE vehicles. Check Offers
One word that is gradually becoming the driving force of the Indian passenger auto industry is EV. The electric vehicles have been finding an increasing footprint in the Indian automobile industry, owing to the growing demand and continuous government push for environmental concerns. Other peripheral issues that have been fuelling the growth of electric vehicles in India include sky-high prices of petrol and diesel, uncertainty over the regulations regarding fossil fuel vehicles, and perception of lower operational cost compared to ICE vehicles, etc.
Owing to the rising demand for battery electric vehicles, the automakers too are increasingly focusing on bringing more EVs to the Indian market, to encash the trend and ramp up their revenue. If we keep an eye on the electric vehicle manufacturers' EV marketing trend, one thing becomes clear. All the automakers focus on highlighting how much range their respective electric vehicles offer, how the charging cost is lower than other competitors, and how the overall ownership cost is lower than ICE vehicles or other competing EVs. In comparison to that, when automakers market petrol or diesel or even CNG vehicles, one of the key focus areas remains the performance. But, in the case of EVs, better performance over ICE vehicles is often not mentioned as a key highlight.
Also Read : Upcoming cars in India
While the industry experts debate range anxiety and charging costs when discussing electric mobility, the pure instant performance is often missed, which in fact should be the biggest selling point of EVs. For example, Hyundai Creta Electric, the pure electric iteration of Hyundai Creta, delivers maximum power from zero rpm. On the other hand, the fossil fuel powered iteration of Creta needs 3,000 rpm to churn out the peak torque.
The MG Windsor EV, which has been increasingly becoming popular among the Indian consumers, is not only popular because it offers a plethora of premium features but also because of the performance. While JSW MG Motor dubs the Windsor EV as low maintenance electric car and intelligent CUV, one of the key highlights of it is the 200 Nm torque pumped out straight from zero rpm.While any similarly priced SUV with a fossil fuel engine struggles through the dense city traffic, the electric vehicles feel no extra effort in generating the performance. Fuel efficiency question still looms large
One of the fundamental factors driving the Indian automobile buyers' purchase decision for decades has been the fuel efficiency. The age-old question, 'Kitna deti hai?" (How much fuel efficiency it offers?), continues to shape the commercial success of most vehicles in India across segments. The automobile companies too device their marketing strategy themed around that.
Speaking about this, Puneet Gupta, Director, Indian Automotive Market, S&P Global Mobility, said that the auto companies' marketing strategy typically reflects the priority factors of the Indian consumers. 'Indian car buyers have traditionally prioritized fuel efficiency, technology, and brand value when making purchase decisions. While performance does factor in, it typically ranks lower in importance compared to markets in developed economies. Automakers have aligned their strategies accordingly, tailoring powertrains and features to suit the needs of a value-conscious and price-sensitive market," he said. Maketing electric vehicles: What goes wrong?
Electric vehicles handle the stop-go traffic in congested cities excellently, as compared to their ICE peers. Climbling the hilly slopes becomes easier for the electric cars owing to the instant torque delivery they offer. On highways, in case of a quick overtake manoeuvre, an electric vehicle can easily allow the driver to perform the move with immediate acceleration and without him or her hunting for the right gear. These advantages of the electric vehicles are not marketed by the EV manufacturers in India.
While marketing the electric vehicles, many auto manufacturers selling EVs in India portray the vehicles in a manner to alleviate the consumers' range anxiety concerns by highlighting the range figures per charging cycle. This somehow puts the electric vehicle purchase as a compromising decisions, but in many cases, they are actually upgrading to a new and cleaner technology. While the automakers try to sell their story as sustainable ones, the story of performance remain untold. But for many consumers, the story of performance is the story that sells.
Speaking on this, Gupta said that the battery electric vehicle narrative is evolving. He believes the Indian auto manufacturers present in the EV market, are gradually changing their marketing strategies. 'In its initial phase, it is increasingly attracting an aspirational set of consumers seeking tech-laden, high-performance electric vehicles. Models like the Mahindra BE 6 electric SUV are designed for the technology-driven customer, whereas offerings like the Tata Harrier EV appeal to the emerging cohort that prioritizes performance," he added.
Check out Upcoming EV Cars in India, Upcoming EV Bikes in India.
First Published Date: 18 Jun 2025, 13:05 PM IST
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
29 minutes ago
- Hans India
Strong demand, stable activity in economy
India's economic indicators are becoming more supportive of growth, according to the report released by Motilal Oswal Private Wealth (MOPW) on Friday. The report highlights that several positive trends are emerging on the domestic front, including higher GDP growth, easing inflation, and strong tax GDP grew by 7.4 per cent in the fourth quarter of FY25, which is the highest reading in the last four has remained below 4 per cent for four consecutive months, and GST collections have been rising steadily. These signs indicate strong demand and stable activity in the formal sector of the report also notes that India's policy environment is now moving in a unified direction. Fiscal, monetary, and regulatory policies are all aimed at maintaining growth increased tax exemption limits that came into effect from April 2025 are expected to improve disposable incomes and boost the same time, the government's capital expenditure continues to rise, supporting the investment the global front, the environment remains mixed. In April and May, markets faced worries over tariffs and geopolitical tensions. However, the situation improved with a delay in global tariff implementation and a ceasefire announcement between India and Pakistan. This improved global sentiment has helped global equity markets, with the MSCI World Index reaching record highs. Meanwhile, rising bond yields in Japan and China's shift towards gold show that global investors are moving away from US could become a concern as the US faces refinancing of $9 trillion in debt this a weaker Dollar Index could help emerging markets like India by attracting more foreign investments. In the Indian stock market, valuations have increased as earnings have not grown at the same Nifty-50's one-year forward valuation has risen above its long-term average, and mid and small-cap stocks continue to trade at a premium. This makes careful stock selection and active management more important for investors looking to generate higher returns, the report stated.
Hans India
an hour ago
- Hans India
Middle East conflict no major worry: Crisil
The impact of the Middle East tensions on most Indian companies is expected to be limited in the near-term, with low capex intensity and balance sheet strength of firms offering a cushion from potential vulnerabilities, according to a Crisil report released on Friday. However, a prolonged escalation could aggravate the impact mainly due to a rise in oil prices and disruption in supply chains which could stoke inflation, the report added. 'So far, the ongoing uncertainties in the Middle East have not had any significant impact on India Inc's global trade. However, if the situation deteriorates, some sectors such as basmati rice could see a heightened impact and will require monitoring, while others like fertilisers and diamonds — both cut and polished — may also see some impact,' the report stated. Also, prolonged and increasing uncertainties can result in a rise in air/sea freight cost and insurance premiums for export/import-based sectors, the report states. India's direct trade with Israel and Iran is minuscule at less than 1 per cent of the total trade. While India's major export to Iran is basmati rice, trade with Israel is more diversified, and includes fertilisers, diamonds and electrical and Israel accounted for around 14 per cent of India's basmati rice exports in fiscal 2025. But because basmati rice is a staple, the impact on demand due to the ongoing tensions is likely to be limited, according to the Crisil report. Additionally, India's ability to export to other countries in the Middle East, the US and Europe reduces demand risk. But a prolonged crisis can lead to possible delays in payment from counterparties in these regions, elongating the working capital cycle, the report domestic diamond polishers, Israel is mainly a trading hub, accounting for about 4 per cent of the total diamond exports last fiscal. Additionally, around 2 per cent of all rough diamonds imported are from Israel. Polishers also have alternative trading hubs such as Belgium and the United Arab Emirates, with ultimate buyers based in the US and Europe, which will help them to manage any adverse impact on the sector, the report states. Repercussions of any further significant increase in the crude oil prices from the current levels would vary across oil prices will benefit upstream oil companies because it translates to more revenue, while their costs are downstream oil refiners, operating margins could get squeezed due to higher input cost as they may have limited ability to fully pass on the same through increase in retail fuel aviation companies, fuel accounts for about 35-40 per cent of operating cost. Further, the operators will also witness higher fuel cost due to increased travel time on account of airspace closures/diversions.
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Kashmir's industries run on migrant labour. When they leave, everything stops.
Srinagar: Shahid Kamili still remembers the silence. On the morning of 5 August 2019, his steel plant in Srinagar's Rangreth industrial estate stood eerily still. The hot strip mills sat idle, the reheating furnace cold. Nearly 350 of his 500 workers, mostly migrant labourers, had vanished overnight. Just a day earlier, on 4 August, authorities had issued an urgent directive asking all non-local workers to leave the Kashmir Valley, ahead of the central government's move to revoke Article 370, stripping Jammu and Kashmir of its special constitutional status. By dawn, Kamili's Himalayan Rolling Steel Industries Pvt. Ltd, a ₹120-crore industrial unit, had come to a grinding halt. 'When 350 migrant workers left my steel factory in one go, I lost furnace technicians, mill fitters, and crane operators, the specialized labour needed to keep molten steel moving through the production line. No steel slabs were cast, no billets rolled, production stopped mid-cycle, and losses quickly piled up," recalls Kamili. In the months that followed, without skilled manpower to restart full-scale operations, Kamili's company slipped into financial distress. Like hundreds of other industrial units in the region, it was eventually classified as a non-performing asset. His experience underscores a vulnerability Kashmir's industries have lived with for decades: an overwhelming dependence on migrant workers from other Indian states to power its manufacturing, construction and horticulture sectors — and a recurring risk that political instability, violence or sudden government orders could drive them away, crippling production overnight. The migrant backbone of Kashmir's industries Industries in the Kashmir Valley have long battled political unrest, but one constant has been their reliance on migrant workers from Bihar, West Bengal, Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Haryana, and Punjab. From cement plants and steel factories to cold storage units and oxygen plants, these workers fill a labour gap locals are often unwilling to close. For Malik Wajid Mushtaq, a 31-year-old entrepreneur, migrant labour keeps his ₹70-crore cold storage unit, Alpine Agro Fresh Pvt Ltd, running. At his facility in Lassipora, Pulwama — Kashmir's major manufacturing hub — 230 of his 300 workers are migrants handling apple grading, packing, and general labour, earning around ₹18,000 per month. 'Non-local workers are punctual and dedicated. We have tried hiring local labourers multiple times, but they often lack the same level of commitment. For instance, even a slight change in weather keeps them away. In contrast, migrant workers come here with a passion to work, to earn, and to succeed," says Mushtaq, an engineering graduate. At the Industrial Growth Centre (IGC) Lassipora, home to around 350 business units, nearly 15,000 non-local labourers are employed. Aircraft engineer-turned-entrepreneur Sarwar Hussain Malik, who runs a packaged mineral water unit there, calls migrant workers the 'lifeline of Kashmir's industrial sector." 'Kashmir mostly has small-scale industrial units, but we still lack sufficient skilled manpower to fill even those needs. From operating machines to managing production and repairing faults, it is the migrant workers who handle most of the critical tasks," says Malik. Read this | A fire, a mushroom, and Kashmir's vanishing spring According to the 2011 census, migrant labourers account for 80% of Kashmir's construction workforce, with an estimated 400,000-500,000 migrant workers currently employed across the region. Why locals stay away Despite steady industrial growth, convincing Kashmiri youth to join private-sector jobs remains difficult. Kamili, who also serves as president of the Federation Chamber of Industries Kashmir (FCIK), explains the dilemma. 'Such is the obsession with government jobs in the Valley that local youth prefer to work as daily wagers in government departments for a paltry salary of ₹6,000 to 8,000 per month, rather than earn ₹25,000 to 30,000 as labourers in the private sector." Shakeel Qalandar, a prominent industrialist, argues that to boost local participation, vocational training and skill development need urgent attention. 'Our educational centres need better infrastructure and updated technical courses that align with the needs of today's industries. Without this, the gap between job seekers and available industrial roles will only widen." Srinagar-based economist Ejaz Ayoub points to larger economic disparities driving this dynamic. 'Most of the workers who come here take up menial jobs that locals often avoid. They come from extremely poor backgrounds, and for them, even the low-end labour opportunities in Kashmir are worth the long travel and effort. In contrast, our local youth, especially in the construction sector, shows minimal participation." The underlying economics are stark. 'India has nearly 21% of its population below the poverty line, while J&K has only around 10.2%. That difference matters. In Kashmir, you do not see people sleeping on the footpaths or scrambling for daily bread. Most fall between the lower and middle-income groups. We are not very poor, and we are not very rich either, which is why many locals shy away from physically demanding or low-paying jobs. Every year, around 500,000-700,000 migrant workers arrive in J&K Union Territory to fill that gap and the local economy quietly relies on them," says Ayoub. Seasonal cycle of hardship Every spring, tens of thousands of workers descend on Kashmir for the brief construction season, taking up hard labour in masonry, carpentry, welding, and farming. As winter sets in, they return home. Mohammad Majeed, a mason from Bihar's Purnia district who has been working in Kashmir since 2020, says the Valley offers better conditions compared to other cities. 'The weather here is ideal. I have worked in Bengaluru and Delhi, but I prefer Kashmir. The wages are also higher. We earn around ₹1,200 a day here, while it is only ₹800 outside." For Majeed, who supports a dozen family members, discipline is key. 'I have never hired locals for the kind of work we do. They do not show up on time and can not work overtime when needed. For us, the focus is simply to work with dedication and efficiency to earn as much as possible." In Sangam, Kashmir's bat manufacturing industrial zone, Tara Singh, a craftsman from Meerut, Uttar Pradesh, who has been making cricket bats for eight years, highlights another reason for choosing Kashmir. 'We are respected and treated as any other dignified human being. Even in disturbed times I work without any hesitation and I am treated by people like their family members." The pattern repeats across sectors. At the brick kilns, Muzaffar Ahmad, a young entrepreneur, watches lorries packed with freshly made bricks roll out. 'The bricks that build Kashmir's houses are made by labourers from Bihar and Uttar Pradesh. Working inside those kilns is not easy. It takes blood and sweat. The heat, the soot — it is work most locals simply avoid." Beyond construction, migrant workers are vital to Kashmir's orchards, paddy fields, and horticulture — the Valley's largest industry. The apple sector alone supports 3.5 million people and anchors the ₹8,000-crore horticultural economy. During harvest, migrants handle the plucking, grading, and packing of apples bound for national and international markets. Their labour fuels the journey of Kashmir's famous apples year after year. Fragile industries in a volatile region This reliance, however, comes at a cost. Periodic unrest and violence repeatedly disrupt the fragile system. According to data available with Mint, a total of 36 migrant workers were killed in Kashmir between 2019 and 2024. In one of the deadliest recent attacks, terrorists opened fire near a tunnel construction site in Ganderbal last October, killing six migrant workers and a local doctor. 'When the workers leave, industries are unable to resume production for months. During that time, losses accumulate, bank interest on loans continues to grow, and electricity demand charges also keep adding up. The fixed costs do not stop, even when operations do. For many units, it becomes unsustainable. Shutdowns follow, and industrialists are left buried in debt," says Kamili. The Valley's main industrial estates — Khunmoh, Rangreth, and Lassipora — are dotted with sick units where machinery lies idle and production lines have stalled for years. Some decades-old units, once run by migrant industrialists, remain abandoned since the 1990s insurgency forced owners to flee. Their rusting machinery and overgrown campuses stand as stark reminders of industrial decay. Also read | Death overs: After a century, Kashmir's batmakers could be run out Even today, Kashmir's Labour Commission estimates that around 400,000 non-local workers are employed across the region. But as one official admits, 'Despite their large numbers, the sector remains entirely unorganised, with no formal mechanisms for registration or oversight. The informal nature of this workforce makes it difficult to track their exact numbers or monitor their working conditions."
