There is still time for amendments to be made to the assisted dying bill – but it deserves to pass
When the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill passed its first stage in the House of Commons in November, The Independent agreed with the majority of MPs. They voted at second reading to approve the draft law in principle, while many of them had reservations about the terms of the bill and expected it to be improved when it was subjected to detailed scrutiny.
In particular, we agreed with those who said that the safeguards against coercion needed to be strengthened, and that the requirement for a High Court judge to sign off on a decision to die was unworkable.
To her credit, Kim Leadbeater, the Labour backbencher who is the sponsor of this private member's bill, has taken those concerns seriously and sought to allay them. Since November, the bill has been improved, as was confirmed in the Commons on Friday.
The safeguards have been strengthened and the role of the High Court judge has been replaced by a panel including a lawyer, a social worker and a psychiatrist. This is a better and more workable arrangement, drawing on a range of relevant expertise, rather than a narrowly legal authority.
No doubt the bill could still be improved further. We are worried, for example, that the Royal College of Psychiatrists said earlier this week that it could not support the draft law in its current form because, among other things, 'there are not enough consultant psychiatrists to do what the bill asks'.
But this raises questions that are beyond the scope of the bill itself, and it would be wrong to block the bill on the grounds that it may not be possible for everyone who wants to use its provisions to do so. If assisted dying is right in principle, it is better that it is available to some rather than none.
Among the amendments Ms Leadbeater accepted on Friday was one to exclude anorexia explicitly from the definition of a terminal illness. This is another welcome change.
MPs also agreed amendments to ensure that there is no obligation on anyone, such as medical staff, to take part in a patient's decision to seek an assisted death; to prevent doctors from discussing the option of an assisted death with under 18s, unless the patient has raised it first: and to require the government to publish an assessment of the availability and quality of palliative and end-of-life care.
These are all further improvements to the bill. That is not to say that it has now achieved a state of legislative perfection. We remain concerned, in particular, about whether the protections for people with mental illness are sufficient. The Royal College of Psychiatrists says that 'mental health services simply do not have the resource required to meet a new range of demands'.
Ms Leadbeater should continue to try to meet the concerns expressed in good faith by the bill's critics. There is still time for further amendments to be made before MPs are asked to give their yes or no verdict on the bill next month – and it can then be amended further in the House of Lords.
However, one of the striking contributions to the debate on Friday was made by Marie Tidball, the Labour MP for Penistone and Stocksbridge. As an MP with a disability – she was born with shortened limbs and a single digit on each hand – she said she had voted for the bill in November on the understanding that it would be strengthened and improved, and that she was now satisfied that it had been.
Of course, the bill is not perfect, and never could be, because the subject is so difficult and the circumstances in each case will be different. Ms Leadbeater must continue to make it the best it can be, but those MPs who gave the bill a conditional vote of confidence in November can now safely send it on to its next stage in the upper house.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
33 minutes ago
- BBC News
Support group helps Bristol woman with endometriosis
A 21-year-old living with stage three endometriosis said a support group has helped her to feel less Harrison, who lives in Bristol, has suffered with the condition since she was 12-years-old. Every month, she is left with "all encompassing" pain affecting her legs, stomach, back and the years, Ms Harrison has undergone two surgeries and trialled different contraception methods, diets and exercise plans, but has found nothing to drastically ease her pain."It's not just painful periods, it's so much more than that. It controls every single aspect of my life, from my work, university, my friendships, relationships, my mental health," she said. Ms Harrison spent seven years trying to understand why she experienced more pain during her periods compared to any of her friends or family was dismissed by many doctors who told her that painful periods are normal, that she has a low pain tolerance and she was "too young" to have a condition like endometriosis."I started to feel like I was going crazy and I was making it up in my head," she said. Endometriosis causes cells similar to those in the lining of the womb to grow in other parts of the body, leading to severe is no cure for it. Ms Harrison said the condition is "really difficult" to live with and leaves her feeling anxious about making plans in case she has to cancel them at the last minute."It's really difficult to explain to people who have never gone through it."She hopes that talking about the condition and raising awareness of it will help others dealing with it and help to validate those who have not yet figured out the cause of their pain."I empathise with people that really struggle with the pain but don't know why."It's such a lonely place to be," she added.
BBC News
33 minutes ago
- BBC News
Wildfire action call made by MP as moorland burns in Peak District
A call was made for the risk of wildfires in places like the Peak District to be discussed in Parliament at the same time as a fire had broken Pearce raised the issue in the House of Commons on Thursday after a number of recent the High Peak MP was stood up in London to address the need for a debate, in his constituency eight fire crews from Derbyshire, South and West Yorkshire and Greater Manchester were descending on a wildfire at Black Ashop Moor near Snake Road, government said it would provide an update in due course. Labour MP Pearce said: "Although many of us are enjoying the hot, dry weather, it does increase the risk of wildfires - in the past month alone, firefighters have been called to 20 wildfires in the Peak District."These include a major incident in Goyt Valley which shut roads, destroyed 800 acres and took days to bring under Peak Borough Council has since approved an order for public areas of the Peak District within its borders, giving powers to police and council officers "to reduce the risk of wildfires".It has banned lighting fires, barbecues, fireworks and sky lanterns, and carrying items which officers think will be used to do so, with fines of up to £100. Pearce continued: "All too often, these fires are started by the irresponsible use of disposable barbecues."Locally, we are doing everything we can to prevent this. I have written to all local supermarkets asking them not to sell disposable barbecues."Will the Leader of the House hold a debate in Government time on how we reduce the risk of wildfires in our national parks?"In response, Leader of the House Lucy Powell MP said the "irresponsible use of disposable barbecues" leads to "devastating consequences", adding: "Local authorities have existing powers to apply controls to restrict or ban the use of such barbecues in certain areas, but I will ensure that he gets an update on how we can take this further".
BBC News
33 minutes ago
- BBC News
Glastonbury Festival get to experience nature through VR
Festival goers will be able to try virtual reality (VR) nature experiences that researchers say can help with mental health and pain Sam Hughes of the University of Exeter is to exhibit the benefits of nature though VR, art, sound and film at Glastonbury Festival later this director of Exeter Pain Lab said immersing people in nature can reduce the amount of pain they feel and VR made nature accessible to those with mobility Hughes said the festival was "a great way to showcase the ability to use VR to deliver nature and its benefits to people from the comfort of their own homes". 'Nature at home' He said the VR headsets would immerse festival goers in environments including forests, mountains and said: "Pain is inherently a psychological construct."If we can immerse people in nature what we've found is that this can actually reduce the amount of pain people experience."While "real nature is always going to be the gold standard", he added, VR can deliver "some of these beneficial therapeutic effects of nature at home".The immersive experience is part of Brainwaves and Birdsong, a public engagement initiative by a team of scientists, mural artists, music composers and wildlife documentary project is funded through the Chronic Pain Neurotechnology Festival is set to run from 25 to 29 June at Worthy Farm in Somerset.
