Derek Finkle: Pro-drug injection site activists were dangerously wrong on closures
'A lot more people are going to die.'
Article content
This was the dire prediction oft-repeated back in March by a busload of lawyers who supported a legal challenge filed by an injection site in Toronto that claimed recent Ontario legislation forcing the closure of sites within 200 metres of schools and daycare facilities violates the Charter rights of drug users.
Article content
The two expert witnesses for that site, in the Kensington neighbourhood of Toronto, are employed by the MAP Centre for Urban Health Solutions, a hospital-run research centre. MAP had played a key role in the establishment of the city's first injection sites in 2017. Dr. Ahmed Bayoumi and Dr. Dan Werb both submitted evidence that overdose deaths in Toronto would increase sharply if half of the city's ten injection sites closed at the end of March because of the legislation.
Article content
Fred Fischer, a lawyer representing Toronto's Board of Health, one of the intervenor groups in the case, also told Justice John Callaghan of the Ontario Superior Court that reducing harm reduction services in Toronto during the ongoing opioid crisis would have severe consequences — more people will overdose and die.
Article content
Article content
A lawyer for another intervenor, a harm reduction coalition, put an even finer point on it. He said that one of the Toronto injection sites not affected by the legislation was anticipating such an immediate and overwhelming increase in overdose deaths in April, after the closures, that the site was in the process of hiring grief counsellors for its staff.
Article content
More than two months have passed since then, and now that we're in June, you might be wondering: How many more people ended up dying because of the closure of these sites?
Article content
According to data that's compiled by Toronto Paramedic Services and Toronto Public Health, the answer, so far, is none. In fact, the number of overdoses in Toronto for the month of April, the first month after the sites had closed, dropped notably.
Article content
Article content
Toronto had 13 fatal overdose calls in April, one less than in March, when the now-closed injection sites were still open. Thirteen is less than half the number of fatal overdoses across the city in April of last year, and significantly below the monthly average for all of 2024 (19).
Article content
Article content
Thirteen fatal overdoses are far lower than the average monthly number during the period of Covid-19 emergency between April 2020 and May 2023 (25). The last time 13 was the norm for monthly fatal overdoses was prior to the pandemic.
Article content
The number of calls for non-fatal overdoses in April was 161. This may sound like a lot but it's the lowest monthly total so far this year in Toronto. And 161 non-fatal overdoses are 55 per cent less than the 359 that occurred in April of 2024.
Article content
Remarkably, in the third week of April, there were zero fatal overdose calls, something that hasn't happened in Toronto in months.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
15K Rotarians from 140 countries celebrate community at Calgary convention
Mark Starratt is the co-chair of the host organizing committee of 2025 Rotary International Conventional, which has 15,000 people from 140 different countries attending. Last week, Alberta hosted the G7, which featured global leaders from around the world gathering together in Kananaskis Country to try to solve a few of the world's problems. This week, Calgary is hosting the 2025 Rotary International Convention, which features 15,000 ordinary folks from 140 countries around the world gathering together at BMO Centre in Stampede Park to try to solve a few of the world's problems. "I don't think we have enough time to talk about the variety of things that are being talked about, but it's everything from peace and conflict resolution to polio eradication to literacy, maternal health, and community engagement,' said Mark Starratt, the co-chair of the host organizing committee. 'There's just so many things going on at this convention. It's hard to put a pulse on just one thing." Starratt said there are 13 Rotary Clubs in Calgary and more than 45 in southern Alberta and Saskatchewan, who represent a sliver of the organization's 1.2 million people from 46,000 different clubs. When you put that kind of people to work trying to solve a problem, you can get a lot done, said Rotary International General Secretary and CEO John Hewko. 'Rotary, really, back in 1985, had the the audacity to say we are going to eradicate a disease from the face of the earth,' Hewko said. 'Smallpox have just been eradicated, and we -- to celebrate our 75th anniversary -- said we're going to tackle eradicating polio. John Hewko, Rotary International CEO John Hewko, Rotary International president and CEO (Tyler Barrow, CTV Calgary) 'We were joined by the WHO, UNICEF, CDC, and, more recently, the Gates Foundation and GAVI to create the Global Polio Eradication Initiative. 'We started with 125 countries that had polio back then,' Hewko said. 'We're now down to just two: Afghanistan and Pakistan, where the virus is still circling. So we're on the verge of eradicating polio and leaving a legacy for as long as mankind inhabits the earth.' Hewko said Rotarians around the world have contributed US $2.9 billion to the effort over 40 years, and recently Gates announced he would chip in two dollars for every dollar raised by Rotarians. Not bad for a gathering of not-so-ordinary folks. 'What the polio eradication effort demonstrates is the power of the individual, the power of grassroots organizations to unite together around the cross to drive change and to really make a difference in the world,' Hewko said. Locally, two Calgary Rotary Clubs joined with the Flames Foundation Friday to announce a $3 million donation to build four sports zones in different communities across the city. The convention is believed to be one of the largest Calgary has ever hosted and if there's a problem to be solved in Calgary this week, it might be finding a vacant hotel room or a dinner reservation at a restaurant. All those visitors are expected to book 30,000 hotel room nights and drop around $81 million into the local economy. 'We're delighted to be here in in Calgary,' Hewko said. 'And of course, we're going to be taking advantage of the incredible hospitality of the of the people of Calgary and the City of Calgary.' Rotary International Convention 2025 continues through May 25.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
How a Canadian startup is helping kids defy the odds one robotic step at a time
When Marc Robert's son Mitchell was just two years old, doctors delivered a diagnosis no parent is ever prepared for: a rare genetic disorder, epilepsy, and the prognosis that he may never walk. But years later, Mitchell walked nearly a kilometre and a half with his dad at his side, holding back tears. The reason? A pediatric robotic exoskeleton called the Trexo. 'We had one of these devices delivered to him just before COVID closed the world out,' said Robert. 'And I had a background previously in working with guys with acquired brain injuries, so I was able to use my background and then take this tool and start to effect change in him in the way that I was hoping to do.' Trexo Robotics, a Canadian-based company, has created a robotic mobility device specifically engineered for children who can't walk due to conditions like cerebral palsy, muscular dystrophy, or spinal cord injuries. It's designed from the ground up for growing bodies, adapting to their pace and needs. 'The machine itself has motors on the hips and motors on the knees,' explained Robert. 'The way it works is you put a person in there and they move their leg through the range that they're able to do, it measures what they're able to do. Then, through that, we can use the angles that they're able to do and then adjust the motor strengths on the hips and knees to decide how much support it's going to offer.' A Trexo device A Trexo exoskeleton device was photographed on June 22, 2025. (Hannah Schmidt/CTV News) For Robert, and hundreds of families like his, it's been nothing short of transformational. 'It's been a complete game changer for him,' said Robert. 'He's so much stronger and different. He's a different kid than he was five, six years ago. And I know you say that about everybody, but he could barely hold his hand up and now he is a different beast. He can stand up in the shower with me, he can do lots of things because he's strong enough to do it. He's in Grade 5 now. He's probably done 2.7 million steps on the device.' A child uses a Trexo exoskeleton device A child uses a Trexo exoskeleton device in this undated image. Where it all began Trexo's story begins back in 2011 when Manmeet Maggu learned that his nephew, Praneit, was diagnosed with cerebral palsy. Maggu, along with his family, worked tirelessly to find solutions that would allow his nephew to walk. He recruited his friend Rahul Udasi to help him. They both studied robotics at the University of Waterloo and decided on building a robot to help Praneit. That's when the Trexo was born. 'The goal was to build something for him, help him take a few steps, his first few steps,' said Udasi. 'And then after that, it just organically grew. And now we have a lot of families in Canada using the device.' Trexo supports hip and knee movement using motorized joints controlled through a tablet. Over 450 units are now in use across 40 countries in homes and hospitals. In total, Trexo kids have taken more than 125 million steps. 'We take it for granted,' said Udasi. 'We can walk from one place to another. It's not even something we think about. But for a lot of these kids, that's a very difficult problem. It's very rewarding to start helping them move around.' Marc Robert and Mitchell Trexo Marc Robert and his son Mitchell walked side-by-by as Mitchell used a Trexo device on June 22, 2025. (Hannah Schmidt/CTV News) 'It's a game changer' Sara Valenzuela, a mom based in the U.S., first heard about Trexo at a Canadian clinic she brought her son Kenny to. She says she was unsure her son would ever be able to walk. 'My son was born as a micro preemie, born at 25 weeks, one pound ten ounces,' she said. Now, Kenny can stand up and walk around at home and out during excursions. 'Every day we use Trexo,' she said. 'I say it's a game changer for our family, the best equipment that we have. Even with an able-bodied child, just getting to watch a child walk for the first time is a milestone. It's just that moment that you'll always remember. And it's so surreal.' Sara Valenzuela and Kenny Trexo Sara Valenzuela and her son Kenny prepared for an excursion on June 22, 2025. (Hannah Schmidt/CTV News) Next steps Robert and Valenzuela, who now both work directly with Trexo, help families navigate everything from fundraising to insurance paperwork. They know firsthand how intimidating it all can feel. '[The Trexo devices] range between $35,000 and $40,000,' said Robert. 'We did a GoFundMe campaign to be able to offset the cost of it, we also have an arm of our company that helps families do fundraising.' 'We're looking at funding sources through the Ontario government,' said Udasi. 'There's the ADP [Assistive Devices Program]. We're trying to apply to that and see if they can cover the full cost or at least some cost of the device for families." Rahul also said Trexo Robotics won't be slowing down any time soon. 'We're going to make it better, trying to make it work with more types of kids with different conditions.' And kids like Mitchell and Kenny are leading the way — step by step. 'I bawled my eyes the first time I saw him walk with Trexo,' said an emotional Robert. 'I've had the opportunity to put lots of different kids in the machine and watch the parents do exactly what I did and it's probably the most rewarding thing that I've ever got to experience.'
CTV News
2 hours ago
- CTV News
Heat warning issued as Quebec swelters under prolonged hot and humid conditions
Environment Canada has issued a heat warning for Quebec, with hot and humid conditions expected to last through Wednesday, pushing residents to find ways to stay cool and safe. If you can't take the heat, you're out of luck. Environment Canada issued a heat warning on Sunday. A warm and humid air mass could loom over Quebec until Wednesday. Daytime temperatures could exceed 30 degrees and remain above 20 degrees at night. 'We saw that the humidity is going to be like 40 or 45,' said one Montreal father. 'It's hard to be out with these small kids. So we decided to come earlier to the park so they can enjoy a bit of time off and then they can get back home,' he said. Parents and children aren't the only ones affected. Equally vulnerable are their furry family members. 'I try not to put him too much in the heat. [...] I walk with him later in the evening,' one dog owner said. With 98 per cent of lakes and rivers inaccessible to the public in southern Quebec, the heat is on to stay cool. Emergency health specialist Dr. Mitch Shulman says overheating can have serious consequences. 'If you suddenly notice that sweat is pooling on your body rather than evaporating, that's a tip off. If you're feeling nauseated, lightheaded, unwell, feel like you're going to faint, feel your heart beating in your chest, or you're breathing faster. Those are all tip offs that your body is no longer able to cope,' he says. These can all be symptoms of heat exhaustion - or worse, heat stroke. 'Avoid the parts of the day that are the hottest. If you can, make sure that you're well hydrated. You need a variety of liquids. So if you're going to use Gatorade or Powerade [...] cut it in half and half with water because you want the minerals and the electrolytes,' Dr. Shulman told CTV News. In the heat of the moment, City of Montreal spokesperson Philippe Sabourin says there are places you can go. 'We have 56 outdoor pools open already for Montrealers. There's also four beaches in Montreal. The one in Cap-Saint-Jacques [...] and there is the beach at Verdun. For the little kids, the splash pads are open,' he says. Sabourin adds shopping malls and libraries are also good options for those in need of air conditioning over the next few hot days.
