Shashi Tharoor On 3 Reasons Why Pak Can't Hide Its Link With Terror

New Delhi:
Shashi Tharoor has given three reasons why Pakistan can't deny its involvement in the Pahalgam terror attack that killed 26 tourists. Mr Tharoor was responding to a question during a discussion hosted by a US think tank when he gave the three points.
Here are the three key points Shashi Tharoor presented
"The first is that we have had a 37-year pattern of repeated terror attacks from Pakistan accompanied by repeated denials. I mean Americans haven't forgotten that Pakistan didn't know allegedly where Osama bin Laden was until he was found in a Pakistani safe house right next to an army camp in a cantonment city. That's Pakistan. Mumbai attacks, they denied having anything to do with it; one of the terrorists was captured alive, his name, his identity, his address in Pakistan, everything was revealed under interrogation. He told us where he was trained, what was done. The US intelligence as well as ours recorded the chilling voice of the Pakistani handler giving minute by minute instructions to the killers in Mumbai, telling them where to go and they were monitoring Indian TV and saying there are people hiding on the third floor of that hotel, go and shoot them there. This kind of thing is going on... So we know what Pakistan is all about. They will disperse terrorists, they will deny, they did so until they are actually caught red handed."
"Second point, the moment this [Pahalgam terror attack] happened, within 45 minutes or so a group called the Resistance Front claimed credit. Who is the Resistance Front? It is a well-known proxy front of the Lashkar-e-Taiba, a banned terror organisation listed by the United Nations, listed by the US State Department, which enjoys safe haven in the town of Muridke in Pakistan. The evidence about the Resistance Front and its doings was presented by India to the UN Committee on Terrorism in December 2023 and again in 24. But the problem was of course Pakistan too is a member of that committee. The Resistance Front was not listed by the UN, but its identity was known and publicised. These people then claimed credit within a time span. There were no media present when these killings took place. Most of the world hadn't even learned about this when they claimed credit. So that was itself a smoking gun. They repeated that claim 24 hours later. And having repeated that claim 24 hours later, their handlers must have woken up to the gravity of this, and told them to take it off their site. So they did. But the fact is the credit claim was on record and the world has seen it."
"Third, when the first strikes happened on the terrorist camps [in Pakistan and Pakistan-Occupied Kashmir], funerals were conducted, including for members of some of the key [terror] organisations, the Jaish-e-Mohammed in particular and the Lashkar-e-Taiba. The funerals were conducted and photographs emerged on social media showing Pakistani generals and police officers in uniform attending these funerals, being conducted by relatives of these terrorists. So we are looking at three concrete pieces of evidence as far as India is concerned. But finally I can add to the mix, we also have intelligence services. They have been studying these terrorist attacks very carefully. They have identified at least four of the five perpetrators and they know who they are. In fact, I'm told, and I don't have access to the direct intelligence information, but I have been reliably informed, they know that two of them are Pakistanis and the other two were locals who had exfiltrated, as the term, out to Pakistan for training 10 years ago and clearly were sent back for this mission."

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

United News of India

22 minutes ago

• United News of India

Afghan dry fruit traders concerned over continued closure of Attari-Wagah border

Kabul, June 21 (UNI) The closure of the Attari–Wagah border crossing, one of Afghanistan's key trade routes to India, has raised serious concerns among dried fruit exporters of Afghanistan. The Kabul Dry Fruit Exporters Union has warned that stopping freight truck movement on this route could severely disrupt both fresh and dried fruit exports, Tolo News reported. The union has urged Pakistani and Indian authorities to reopen the route permanently for Afghan cargo trucks. Khalid Rahmani, spokesperson for the union, told TOLOnews, 'We hope alternative links through Wagah and Chabahar ports will open soon. Given the current political and trade tensions between Pakistan and India, we predict a decline in exports to both countries.' After the Indian and Pakistani military tensions eased, the border reopened briefly on May 9, allowing about 162 trucks to pass, but it was shut again. At least 12 Afghan export trucks remain stuck at the crossing. With the fruit harvest season approaching, traders warn that continued closure could pose major challenges for Afghan exports. They are calling for diplomatic engagement to reopen this critical trade route. Omid Haidari, head of international relations at the Chamber of Agriculture and Livestock, said: 'We urge the leadership of the Islamic Emirate, especially the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, to strengthen contact with the Indian Foreign Ministry so that our major trade route can be reopened.' Merchant Mahboobullah Mohammadi, said, 'Our biggest export is dried fruit, especially pine nuts, which we mostly send to India via Wagah. But the decline in exports this year has brought significant losses. Our air corridors are still shut, and large amounts of pine nuts remain unsold in local markets.' The Wagah border was closed after tensions escalated between India and Pakistan following the terrorist attack in Pahalgam, India, on April 22. The closure of the land border check post continues to cast a shadow over Afghanistan's regional trade. UNI ANV RN

NDTV

an hour ago

• NDTV

"Will Never Be Restored": Amit Shah On Indus Waters Treaty With Pakistan

New Delhi: India will never restore the Indus Waters Treaty with Islamabad, and the water flowing to Pakistan will be diverted for internal use, Home Minister Amit Shah said in an interview with the Times of India on Saturday. India put into "abeyance" its participation in the 1960 treaty, which governs the usage of the Indus river system, after 26 civilians in Kashmir were killed in an act of terror. The treaty had guaranteed water access for 80% of Pakistan's farms through three rivers originating in India. Pakistan has denied involvement in the incident, but the accord remains dormant despite a ceasefire agreed upon by the two nuclear-armed neighbours last month following their worst fighting in decades. "No, it will never be restored," Mr Shah said. "We will take water that was flowing to Pakistan to Rajasthan by constructing a canal. Pakistan will be starved of water that it has been getting unjustifiably," Mr Shah said. The latest comments from Mr Shah have dimmed Islamabad's hopes for negotiations on the treaty in the near term. Last month, Reuters reported that India plans to dramatically increase the water it draws from a major river that feeds Pakistani farms downstream, as part of retaliatory action. Pakistan's foreign ministry did not immediately respond to Reuters' request for comments. But it has said in the past that the treaty has no provision for one side to unilaterally pull back and that any blocking of river water flowing to Pakistan will be considered "an act of war". Islamabad is also exploring a legal challenge to India's decision to hold the treaty in abeyance under international law.

Economic Times

an hour ago

• Economic Times

Doomsday Plane spotted in D.C. — what is it and who's behind the mysterious aircraft?

Agencies Doomsday Plane E-4B lands near D.C. as Trump weighs Iran strike. With rising Iran-Israel tensions, the powerful nuclear-ready aircraft's flight has sparked global concern. What does this unexpected movement mean for U.S. defense and global stability? Doomsday Plane lands near Washington as Trump weighs Iran strike amid rising Middle East tensions- A U.S. Air Force E-4B Nightwatch, widely known as the 'Doomsday Plane,' made an unusual flight from Louisiana to Joint Base Andrews near Washington, D.C., on Tuesday night, sparking growing speculation as tensions escalate between Iran and Israel. The aircraft, designed for use during nuclear war or national emergencies, took a winding and irregular path, adding to the concern among military analysts and aviation trackers. This development comes as President Donald Trump considers military action against Iran's nuclear sites, while regional instability intensifies. The rare flight of the E-4B — which serves as the National Airborne Operations Center (NAOC) — signals potential preparation for emergency scenarios. The E-4B Nightwatch, often referred to as the 'Doomsday Plane,' is one of four such aircraft operated by the U.S. Air Force. Its primary function is to serve as a mobile command center for the President, Secretary of Defense, and senior military leaders during catastrophic events, such as nuclear war. These planes are built to withstand nuclear blasts, cyberattacks, and electromagnetic pulses, and they can stay airborne for up to a week thanks to in-flight refueling capabilities. Each aircraft can carry up to 112 personnel and is equipped with 67 satellite dishes and antennas to ensure uninterrupted communication across the globe. While E-4Bs occasionally fly training missions, the timing, route, and destination of this flight — especially amid the current geopolitical crisis — have raised red flags. The E-4B took off from Barksdale Air Force Base in Shreveport, Louisiana, around Tuesday evening and arrived at Joint Base Andrews, Maryland, after about four hours, according to data from public flight trackers. Its erratic flight pattern deviated from standard military training routes, further fueling speculation about the nature of the mission. This flight coincided with growing fears of a regional war in the Middle East, where Israel is reportedly stepping up military operations against Iran, including the possibility of striking nuclear sites. The presence of this aircraft near Washington hints at heightened readiness in U.S. defense circles. This isn't just any airplane. The E-4B can stay in the air for over 35 hours without landing, and with mid-air refueling, it can fly for days at a time. It's packed with analog instruments to withstand digital warfare, and it can carry over 100 people — including military commanders, intelligence officers, and senior officials. Feature Details Crew Capacity Up to 112 personnel Endurance Over 35 hours (can extend with aerial refueling) Protection Shields from EMPs, nukes, and cyber attacks Communication Secure global communications & satellite links As of now, it's unclear whether President Donald Trump was on board the E-4B Nightwatch. Officials have not issued a statement confirming the passengers or the purpose of this mission. However, given that the aircraft serves as a presidential airborne command post, its use is typically reserved for urgent situations involving top-level leadership. In light of recent comments, where Trump said, 'I may do it, I may not do it – nobody knows what I'm going to do,' regarding a strike on Iran's nuclear program, the movement of this plane is viewed by many as a sign of increased alertness within U.S. national security operations. Tensions between Iran and Israel have escalated rapidly. In recent days, President Trump demanded Iran's unconditional surrender, signaling a hardline stance. Meanwhile, Iran's Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, rejected the U.S. threat outright, stating, 'The Iranian nation isn't frightened by such threats.' Amid this back-and-forth, Israel is reportedly preparing for broader military engagement with Iran, heightening the risk of a regional conflict. While the U.S. has not confirmed whether it will join Israel's offensive, the movement of military assets like the E-4B could indicate strategic posturing. The plane is run by the U.S. Air Force's 1st Airborne Command and Control Squadron, based at Offutt Air Force Base in Nebraska. This elite unit is trained to keep the chain of command alive, even if Washington is under attack. The aircraft is part of a four-plane fleet that's been in service for decades — and is now undergoing a $13 billion modernization effort to prepare for future threats. That's the question many are now asking — especially after the Doomsday Plane's sudden appearance. Tensions between the U.S. and Iran have been rising sharply in recent weeks, with President Donald Trump making renewed threats and reports of increased military posturing in the region. The E-4B's flight path — combined with its rare 'ORDER01' callsign — suggests this wasn't a routine drill. While no official comment links the flight directly to Iran, military analysts believe it could be a strategic signal to Tehran: the U.S. is prepared for any scenario, including full-scale retaliation. If diplomacy fails and conflict escalates, the Doomsday Plane ensures American leadership can still function from the sky — even in the middle of a war. Military experts are closely watching the signals coming from Washington. The deployment of the E-4B Nightwatch, though not unprecedented, often points to crisis scenarios or preparation drills for potential wartime leadership continuity. Given that the E-4B was last significantly used on 9/11, its recent activity sends a powerful message. As one of the few U.S. military aircraft that can remain operational even during a nuclear conflict, its flight near D.C. in this political climate is deeply symbolic. Whether this is a preemptive readiness exercise or a precursor to actual conflict, remains uncertain. However, with Middle East tensions rising and the White House weighing options, this development suggests a serious level of preparedness. The U.S. Doomsday Plane (E-4B Nightwatch) landed near D.C. after an unusual flight from Louisiana. It serves as a mobile command post during nuclear or national emergencies. The flight happened as President Trump considers striking Iran's nuclear facilities. Rising Iran-Israel tensions and U.S. military movements suggest heightened alert. No official word yet on the mission or whether Trump was aboard the plane. Q1. What is the Doomsday Plane E-4B Nightwatch used for? It's used as a flying command center for emergencies like nuclear war. Q2. Why did the Doomsday Plane land in Washington now? It landed amid Trump's possible Iran strike plans and rising Middle East tensions.