‘Expensive and complicated': Most rural hospitals no longer deliver babies

A mother prepares her infant son for bed. Since 2020, 36 states have lost at least one rural labor and delivery department. In rural counties, the loss of hospital-based obstetric care is associated with increases in births in hospital emergency rooms, less prenatal care and higher rates of babies being born too early. (Photo by)
Nine months after Monroe County Hospital in rural South Alabama closed its labor and delivery department in October 2023, Grove Hill Memorial Hospital in neighboring Clarke County also stopped delivering babies.
Both hospitals are located in an agricultural swath of the state that's home to most of its poorest counties. Many residents of the region don't even have a nearby emergency department.
Stacey Gilchrist is a nurse and administrator who's spent her 40-year career in Thomasville, a small town about 20 minutes north of Grove Hill. Thomasville's hospital shut down entirely last September over financial difficulties. Thomasville Regional hadn't had a labor and delivery unit for years, but women in labor still showed up at its ER when they knew they wouldn't make it to the nearest delivering hospital.
'We had several close calls where people could not make it even to Grove Hill when they were delivering there,' Gilchrist told Stateline shortly after the Thomasville hospital closed. She recalled how Thomasville nurses worked to save the lives of a mother and baby who'd delivered early in their ER, as staff waited for neonatal specialists to arrive by ambulance from a distant delivering hospital.
'It would give you chills to see what all they had to do. They had to get inventive,' she said, but the mother and baby survived.
Now many families must drive more than an hour to reach the nearest birthing hospital.
Nationwide, most rural hospitals no longer offer obstetric services. Since the end of 2020, more than 100 rural hospitals have stopped delivering babies, according to a new report from the Center for Healthcare Quality & Payment Reform, a national policy center focused on solving health care issues through overhauling insurance payments. Fewer than 1,000 rural hospitals nationwide still have labor and delivery services.
A small town tries to revive its hospital in the middle of a rural health crisis
Across the nation, two rural labor and delivery departments shut their doors every month on average, said Harold Miller, the center's president and CEO.
'It's the perfect storm,' Miller told Stateline. 'The number of births are going down, everything is more expensive in rural areas, health insurance plans don't cover the cost of births, and hospitals don't have the resources to offset those losses because they're losing money on other services, too.'
Staffing shortages, low Medicaid reimbursement payments and declining birth rates have contributed to the closures. Some states have responded by changing how Medicaid funds are spent, by allowing the opening of freestanding birth centers, or by encouraging urban-based obstetricians to open satellite clinics in rural areas.
Yet the losses continue. Thirty-six states have lost at least one rural labor and delivery unit since the end of 2020, according to the report. Sixteen have lost three or more. Indiana has lost 12, accounting for a third of its rural hospital labor and delivery units.
In rural counties the loss of hospital-based obstetric care is associated with increases in births in hospital emergency rooms, studies have found. The share of women without adequate prenatal care also increases in rural counties that lose hospital obstetric services.
And researchers have seen an increase in preterm births — when a baby is born three or more weeks early — following rural labor and delivery closures. Babies born too early have higher rates of death and disability.
The decline in hospital-based maternity care has been decades in the making.
Traditionally, hospitals lose money on obstetrics. It costs more to maintain a labor and delivery department than a hospital gets paid by insurance to deliver a baby. This is especially true for rural hospitals, which see fewer births and therefore less revenue than urban areas.
'It is expensive and complicated for any hospital to have labor and delivery because it's a 24/7 service,' said Miller.
A labor and delivery unit must always have certain staff available or on call, including a physician who can perform cesarean sections, nurses with obstetric training, and an anesthetist for C-sections and labor pain management.
You can't subsidize a losing service when you don't have profit coming in from other services.
– Harold Miller, president and CEO of the Center for Healthcare Quality & Payment Reform
'There's a minimum fixed cost you incur [as a hospital] to have all of that, regardless of how many births there are,' Miller said.
In most cases, insurers don't pay hospitals to maintain that standby capacity; they're paid per birth. Hospitals cover their losses on obstetrics with revenue they get from more lucrative services.
For a larger urban hospital with thousands of births a year, the fixed costs might be manageable. For smaller rural hospitals, they're much harder to justify. Some have had to jettison their obstetric services just to keep the doors open.
'You can't subsidize a losing service when you don't have profit coming in from other services,' Miller said.
And staffing is a persistent problem.
Harrison County Hospital in Corydon, Indiana, a small town on the border with Kentucky, ended its obstetric services in March after hospital leaders said they were unable to recruit an obstetric provider. It was the only delivering hospital in the county, averaging about 400 births a year.
And most providers don't want to remain on call 24/7, a particular problem in rural regions that might have just one or two physicians trained in obstetrics. In many rural areas, family physicians with obstetrical training fill the role of both obstetricians and general practitioners.
Even before Harrison County Hospital suspended its obstetrical services, some patients were already driving more than 30 minutes for care, the Indiana Capital Chronicle reported. The closure means the drive could be 50 minutes to reach a hospital with a labor and delivery department, or to see providers for prenatal visits.
A fifth of Americans are on Medicaid. Some of them have no idea.
Longer drive times can be risky, resulting in more scheduled inductions and C-sections because families are scared to risk going into labor naturally and then facing a harrowing hourlong drive to the hospital.
Having fewer labor and delivery units could further burden ambulance services already stretched thin in rural areas.
And hospitals often serve as a hub for other maternity-related services that help keep mothers and babies healthy.
'Other things we've seen in rural counties that have hospital-based OB care is that you're more likely to have other supportive things, like maternal mental health support, postpartum groups, lactation support, access to doula care and midwifery services,' said Katy Kozhimannil, a professor at the University of Minnesota School of Public Health, whose research focuses in part on maternal health policy with a focus on rural communities.
Medicaid, the state-federal public insurance for people with low incomes, pays for nearly half of all births in rural areas nationwide. And women who live in rural communities and small towns are more likely to be covered by Medicaid than women in metro areas.
Experts say one way to save rural labor and delivery in many places would be to bump up Medicaid payments.
As congressional Republicans debate President Donald Trump's tax and spending plan, they're considering which portions of Medicaid to slash to help pay for the bill's tax cuts. Maternity services aren't on the chopping block.
But if Congress reduces federal funding for some portions of Medicaid, states — and hospitals — will have to figure out how to offset that loss. The ripple effects could translate into less money for rural hospitals overall, meaning some may no longer be able to afford labor and delivery services.
Abortion-ban states pour millions into pregnancy centers with little medical care
'Cuts to Medicaid are going to be felt disproportionately in rural areas where Medicaid makes up a higher proportion of labor and delivery and for services in general,' Kozhimannil said. 'It is a hugely important payer at rural hospitals, and for birth in particular.'
And though private insurers often pay more than Medicaid for birth services, Miller believes states shouldn't let companies off the hook.
'The data shows that in many cases, commercial insurance plans operating in a state are not paying adequately for labor and delivery,' Miller said. 'Hospitals will tell you it's not just Medicaid; it's also commercial insurance.'
He'd like to see state insurance regulators pressure private insurance to pay more. More than 40% of births in rural communities are covered by private insurance.
Yet there's no one magic bullet that will fix every rural hospital's bottom line, Miller said: 'For every hospital I've talked to, it's been a different set of circumstances.'
Stateline reporter Anna Claire Vollers can be reached at avollers@stateline.org.
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Yahoo

16 hours ago

• Yahoo

Feds demand Oregon Health Plan data in crackdown against immigrant coverage

PORTLAND, Ore. (KOIN) – Federal officials are seeking the personal data of the Medicaid-funded Oregon Health Plan as part of a crackdown on coverage for undocumented immigrants. The request, as first reported by , comes after the Department of Homeland Security provided immigration officials with similar data from California, Illinois, Washington state and Washington, D.C. 'Just wrong': Oregon advocates say SCOTUS decision targets transgender youth Oregon, like these states, has expanded medical coverage to undocumented residents through state-funded programs. On Monday, Gov. Tina Kotek said her office is reviewing the order. 'I think it's very important, to a degree that we can, that we do not share personal information,' Kotek said. 'Always comfortable with aggregated information, but when we start sharing personal medical information that could be misused, that's a challenge for me.' The state of Oregon has until the end of July 2025 to comply. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Miami Herald

19 hours ago

• Miami Herald

In Southern California, many are skipping health care out of fear of ICE operations

LOS ANGELES – Missed childhood vaccinations. Skipped blood sugar checks. Medications abandoned at the pharmacy. These are among the health care disruptions providers have noticed since Immigration and Customs Enforcement operations began in Southern California earlier this month. Across the region, once-busy parks, shops and businesses have emptied as undocumented residents and their families hole up at home in fear. As rumors of immigration arrests have swirled around clinics and hospitals, many patients are also opting to skip chronic-care management visits as well as routine childhood check-ups. In response, local federally qualified health centers — institutions that receive federal funds and are required by law to provide primary care regardless of ability to pay — have been scrambling to organize virtual appointments, house calls and pharmacy deliveries to patients who no longer feel safe going out in public. 'We're just seeing a very frightening and chaotic environment that's making it extremely difficult to provide for the health care needs of our patients,' said Jim Mangia, president of St. John's Community Health, which offers medical, dental and mental health care to more than 100,000 low-income patients annually in Southern California. Prior to the raids, the system's network of clinics logged about a 9% no-show rate, Mangia said. In recent weeks, more than 30% of patients have canceled or failed to show. In response, the organization has launched a program called Healthcare Without Fear to provide virtual and home visits to patients concerned about the prospect of arrest. 'When we call patients back who missed their appointment and didn't call in, overwhelmingly, they're telling us they're not coming out because of ICE,' said Mangia, who estimates that 25% of the clinic's patient population is undocumented. 'People are missing some pretty substantial health care appointments.' A recent survey of patient no-shows at nonprofit health clinics across Los Angeles County found no universal trends across the 118 members of the Community Clinic Assn. of L.A. County, President Louise McCarthy said. Some clinics have seen a jump in missed appointments, while others have observed no change. The data do not indicate how many patients opted to convert scheduled in-person visits to telehealth so they wouldn't have to leave home, she noted. Patients have also expressed concerns that any usage of health services could make them targets. Earlier this month, the Associated Press reported that the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services shared the personal data of Medicaid enrollees with the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, including their immigration status. No specific enforcement actions have been directly linked to the data. 'The level of uncertainty and anxiety that is happening now is beyond the pale,' McCarthy said, for patients and staff alike. County-run L.A. General Medical Center issued a statement on Thursday refuting reports that federal authorities had carried out enforcement operations at the downtown trauma center. While no immigration-related arrests have been reported at county health facilities, 'the mere threat of immigration enforcement near any medical facility undermines public trust and jeopardizes community health,' the department said in a statement. Los Angeles County is among the providers working to extend in-home care options such as medication delivery and a nurse advice line for people reluctant to come in person. 'However, not all medical appointments or conditions can be addressed remotely,' a spokesperson said. 'We urge anyone in need of care not to delay.' Providers expressed concern that missing preventative care appointments could lead to emergencies that both threaten patients' lives and further stress public resources. Preventative care 'keeps our community at large healthy and benefits really everyone in Los Angeles,' said a staff member at a group of L.A. area clinics. He asked that his employer not be named for fear of drawing attention to their patient population. Neglecting care now, he said, 'is going to cost everybody more money in the long run.' A patient with hypertension who skips blood pressure monitoring appointments now may be more likely to be brought into an emergency room with a heart attack in the future, said Dr. Bukola Olusanya, a medical director at St. John's. 'If [people] can't get their medications, they can't do follow-ups. That means a chronic condition that has been managed and well-controlled is just going to deteriorate,' she said. 'We will see patients going to the ER more than they should be, rather than coming to primary care.' Providers are already seeing that shift. When a health team visited one diabetic patient recently at home, they found her blood sugar levels sky-high, Mangia said. She told the team she'd consumed nothing but tortillas and coffee in the previous five days rather than risk a trip to the grocery store. Copyright (C) 2025, Tribune Content Agency, LLC. Portions copyrighted by the respective providers.

Time Business News

a day ago

• Time Business News

Boost Revenue with Emergency Medical Services Billing: Top Solutions for EMS Providers in 2025

Emergency medical services (EMS) are a lifeline, literally. EMS providers face unique, high-pressure challenges daily, from saving lives in the field to managing time-sensitive transports. Yet, beyond the flashing lights and rapid response is a lesser-known but equally critical challenge: billing. In 2025, maximizing revenue through proper emergency medical services billing is more essential than ever. While the demand for emergency care rises, so does the complexity of billing. Regulations evolve, coding gets stricter, and reimbursement protocols are increasingly demanding. That's why EMS providers from rural squads to large urban fleets, must reimagine how they handle billing if they want to keep their operations financially viable and future-ready. Let's unpack the key strategies and solutions that EMS providers should prioritize to stay ahead. Understanding Emergency Medical Services Billing in 2025 EMS billing isn't just about sending an invoice; it's a specialized process requiring intimate knowledge of medical coding, insurance structures, compliance standards, and state-specific regulations. It is imperative that every service, regardless of whether it is an advanced life support (ALS) transport call or a basic life support (BLS) call, be coded accurately and submitted for timely reimbursement. Key components of effective emergency medical services billing include: Accurate documentation by EMS personnel Proper coding (HCPCS Level II and CPT codes) Payer-specific guidelines Compliance with Medicare/Medicaid regulations Timely submission and resubmission of claims Failure in any of these areas leads to claim denials, revenue leakage, and increased administrative strain. H2: Why Billing for EMS is So Challenging? Unlike clinic or hospital billing, billing for EMS comes with its own set of complications: On-the-go documentation: EMS crews must document services in the field, sometimes in chaotic or rushed environments. Multiple payers involved: Medicaid, Medicare, private insurers, and sometimes patients themselves. Complex service classification: ALS vs. BLS, emergency vs. non-emergency, mileage calculations, and supply charges. Variable compliance rules: Federal, state, and even municipal codes may influence how services are billed. In short, EMS billing requires both speed and precision, something many in-house teams struggle to maintain. H2: The True Cost of Poor EMS Billing Practices A mishandling of billing can result in the EMS agency losing more than just financial resources: Delayed cash flow impacting payroll and operations Reduced reimbursement rates from repeated errors Increased audits and compliance fines Decreased morale from overworked administrative teams It's for that reason that you should develop a strong relationship with a team that specializes in billing services for emergency response teams in order to achieve the best results. H2: How Emergency Medical Services Billing Solutions Are Growing As we move deeper into 2025, EMS billing has embraced a tech-first, compliance-driven approach. The best solutions combine automation, expert oversight, and real-time analytics to maximize collections and minimize denials. Here's what modern EMS billing looks like: Cloud-based claim systems with secure access Auto-flagging of errors before submission Detailed reporting dashboards for transparency Mobile-friendly documentation platforms for field EMTs Real-time eligibility checks for better billing accuracy Billing services for EMS that adopt these tools aren't just staying compliant, they're also getting paid faster and more consistently. H2: Must-Have Features in EMS Billing Services If you're considering outsourcing or upgrading your emergency medical services billing, make sure the solution includes: Dedicated EMS billing specialists trained in field-specific codes Credentialing support for providers Denial management and appeals handling Compliance monitoring aligned with federal/state law Revenue cycle analytics to help forecast and improve cash flow The services may even include patient communication tools as well as bilingual support, enhancing the patient's post-care experience as well as reducing the chances of missed payments. H2: Benefits of Outsourcing Emergency Medical Services Billing Instead of burdening your internal team with an increasingly technical and time-consuming task, outsourcing to a specialized EMS billing provider can deliver serious benefits: Faster reimbursement turnaround Higher clean-claim rates Reduced staffing pressure Full compliance assurance Access to industry insights and analytics One such company providing comprehensive billing support is Med Tek. Known for helping EMS teams streamline operations and increase collections, Med Tek has enabled providers to shift their focus back to emergency care, where it truly belongs. H2: Real-World Impact: A Look at the Numbers Agencies that implement efficient billing services for EMS have reported the following results: Up to 35% faster claim processing Over 90% clean claim rate on first submissions A 25-40% increase in overall collections within the first year These results don't happen by chance, they're a product of process optimization, smart tools, and real EMS expertise. H2: How to Choose the Right Billing Partner for Your EMS Agency? If you are looking for a new billing partner, ask these questions before making a commitment: Do they specialize in EMS billing or just general medical services? Can they show proven success in billing for EMS agencies of your size? Are they offering tech-enabled solutions with compliance monitoring? Will they provide performance metrics and regular reporting? Do they assist with credentialing and payer enrollment? Choosing the right partner is about more than price; it's about reliability, transparency, and long-term results. H2: The Future of EMS Billing: What to Expect Looking ahead, EMS billing will become even more data-driven. Artificial intelligence will play a greater role in claim scrubbing, predictive analytics will guide revenue strategies, and real-time tracking will be standard. EMS providers that invest in these advancements now will gain a head start on financial health, operational clarity, and regulatory readiness. Whether you're a municipal EMS department or a private ambulance service, having a proactive billing partner could be the most impactful decision you make in 2025. H2: Final Thoughts Financial clarity is just as important as operational readiness when it comes to today's high-stakes emergency medical environment. Emergency medical service providers can not only sustain their mission, but also expand it by focusing on better billing practices for emergency medical services. A strong strategy can help unlock growth and peace of mind, whether you need help navigating compliance, increasing collections, or managing billing services for emergency response units. Don't let outdated billing hold you back. Make 2025 the year you upgrade how your agency handles reimbursement and starts flourishing, not just surviving. Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only. Please consult with a certified EMS billing consultant for personalized recommendations. TIME BUSINESS NEWS