View: India's bank frauds need a sensible response
Bank frauds in India have tripled in value. But that's only because some of the cases reported previously were reinvestigated and appeared in the new data. More worrying than the surge in the amount, however, is the rise in the number of payment scams over the past couple of years. The solution lies in rewarding better security.
Most of the stealing from banks occurs the traditional way: via loans obtained with the help of forged documents or bribes. Customers, though, are increasingly at risk of being cheated when they make payments. According to the central bank's latest annual report, more than half of frauds took place in digital or card-based transactions, even though they accounted for only 1.4% of the $4 billion in scams.
And these are just the situations where the sums involved were 100,000 rupees ($1,160) or more. Thanks to a wildly popular smartphone-based payments network, much smaller values are being exchanged online for person-to-person and person-to-merchant transactions. The so-called
Unified Payments Interface
is instantaneous, available 24/7 and mostly imposes no cost on users.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Gorka: Scholarships You Can Apply For (Start Now)
Google Search
Search Now
Undo
It's logging more than a million cases of hustle and con annually, according to separate government data. And this is just what's getting reported. Unless they are extremely careful, the more affluent depositors don't even come to know that they're being slowly bled.
Bloomberg
Live Events
The growth of the UPI, which handles more than $3 trillion a year, puts enormous pressure on the system. It was bound to attract criminals. Payment intermediaries have warned customers of the various ways — from simple phishing attacks to sophisticated cloning of SIM cards — in which they may fall prey to swindlers.
Yet the banking system can't shrug off its responsibility with a 'buyer beware.' It needs stronger guardrails. Anyone can set up a virtual ID to ask customers for money online. That freedom is welcome. But not when it turns out that the bank account linked to 'amazon@pockets' belongs to Ckjxh Fiddbh, which doesn't appear to be a real name. (The example, though, is real, cited in security researcher Karan Saini's investigation.)
Payment frauds happen everywhere. Brazil's PIX, which ranks alongside India's UPI as among the fastest-growing account-to-account transfer systems worldwide, is notorious for its 'PIX gangs.'
What makes India's case problematic is that scamsters have learned to coexist alongside a vast digital identity database, a biometrics-based unique number and card through which 1.4 billion people establish who they are. It hasn't stopped identity theft. India's banks are constantly bombarding customers with 'know-your-customer' checks, asking for the same documents again and again. Yet 'mules' continue to thrive. Accounts of unsuspecting customers are used by, among others, online bookmakers located overseas to provide illegal access to casinos and cricket betting via cryptocurrencies.
The
Reserve Bank of India
's innovation hub has come up with an artificial-intelligence tool called 'MuleHunter.ai.' It's now building a prototype for an intelligence platform covering all digital payments. However, it isn't enough to merely identify suspicious transactions. As analysts have pointed out, the local money-laundering laws do not allow banks to take prompt preventive action, or to restore funds to their rightful owners.
Critical sectors of the economy can't wait for legal changes. The stock-market regulator has decided to add a layer of security to investment funds changing hands online. From October, a @valid suffix on virtual payment handles will be mandatory for brokers, investment advisers, research analysts, merchant bankers, and mutual funds to collect payments from investors.
These are all stopgaps. Ultimately, New Delhi must put the payment industry on a sustainable footing. Five years ago, it decided that UPI transfers to merchants should be free for users to encourage digitization. The goal has been realized. Although the government denied just last week that it has any such plans, it's time to allow banks and apps like Google Pay and PhonePe to recoup their costs.
In fact, the National Payments Corporation of India, the public monopoly that runs the network, should now face competition. Let private operators charge a basic transaction fee to offer institutional-grade security.
The government can maintain its explicit incentives to promote low-value cashless payments at the bottom of the economic pyramid. As for other customers, a high-volume, competitive market would keep a lid on fees, while offering them greater peace of mind.
Banks will also heave a sigh of relief. Payment is a utility they must provide to depositors so they have the liquidity to lend. Frauds are becoming a costly distraction.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
Police intercept mini trucks carrying suspicious powder from pharmaceutical company in Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar
Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar: The anti-narcotics squad of Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar city police intercepted two mini trucks on Saturday carrying suspicious powder concealed within plastic scrap obtained from a pharmaceutical company by a scrap vendor. Police commissioner Pravin Pawar said, "The presence of white powder and small granule-like substances randomly placed in carry bags and stashed in plastic drums has heightened suspicions." Police officers said that no chemical, in any form, can leave the pharmaceutical company without prior clearance from the appropriate channels. Police authorities reported that the intercepted vehicles had left a global generic and speciality pharmaceutical company's manufacturing unit in the MIDC Waluj area. Anti-narcotics squad inspector Geeta Bagwade stated, "There were indications of smuggling and transporting suspicious drug-like substances from a pharmaceutical company located in the MIDC Waluj area. Accordingly, our teams set up a trap and seized the two mini trucks." The officer said the driver failed to provide details or satisfactory answers regarding the powder. Police sources said, given the case's gravity, forensic teams have been requested to expedite testing and analysis to determine the composition of the seized white powder. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Ask A Pro: "I'm 70 with $1.4M in IRAs. Should I convert $120K/Year to a Roth?" SmartAsset Undo In Oct 2023, the MIDC Waluj industrial area made headlines after Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI) teams from Gujarat, Mumbai, and Pune, assisted by the Ahmedabad crime branch, raided an industrial unit and seized narcotics valued at Rs 250 crore.
Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
After Gokulpeth bloodshed, betting mafia threaten another gang war
Nagpur: The city is on the brink of another gang war with tensions escalating between two notorious factions — Swapnil's Beans group and Sumeet's gang, raising fears of a repeat of the deadly Hiranwar-Sheikhu rivalry. With three murders in three years, including the chilling killing of Avinash Bhusari by Bunty Hiranwar's gang at Gokulpeth earlier this year, Nagpur's streets are no stranger to gangland bloodshed. Now, a fresh feud between top cricket bookies Ashish and Chitu threatens to unleash another wave of murders and retaliatory attacks, leaving police scrambling to avert chaos. The spark was ignited at a high-stakes party where Ashish and Chitu, both heavyweight bookies, clashed over dominance in the city's underworld betting scene. Sources reveal the argument turned violent with Chitu, a former murder accused booked under MCOCA, thrashing Ashish, who rose with the alleged backing of the Mumbai underworld. Ashish, supported by the feared Sumeet gang, and Chitu, backed by politically connected Swapnil, have drawn battle lines. Both sides are rallying their armed loyalists for a potential showdown. Sumeet, a dreaded gangster with two MCOCA cases and a sprawling network across eastern Vidarbha, commands a formidable force. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Free P2,000 GCash eGift UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo Twice, his gang, armed with loaded mausers and packed into four cars, rolled into rival territory to confront Swapnil and Chitu, only to find no challenge. "On another occasion, Ashish cornered Chitu at a fellow bookies' party at Pachgaon. Chitu then made a narrow escape as others shielded him," said the insider, adding the two gangs are now baying for each other's blood and exchanging threats on phone. Insiders warn that if the groups clashed, Nagpur's roads would turn into a battlefield, mirroring the January shootout between Pawan Hiranwar, Bunty Hiranwar, and Sheikhu's gang that left one dead. Though Pawan was shot in the rural area, the third retaliatory murder of Avinash took place at Gokulpeth, leaving the city shell-shocked. City police led by CP Ravinder Singal and DCP Crime Rahul Maknikar, are on high alert. Maknikar's team, under senior inspector Sandeep Buwa, recently detained Swapnil and Chitu and issued a stern warning. "Sumeet and Ashish are underground, but we're tracking them. Our surveillance is relentless, and we're prepared to act decisively," Maknikar declared. Despite these efforts, the crime branch is grappling with the fallout of ongoing rivalries and splinter group skirmishes. Sources reveal Ashish's rise was briefly halted by a former police commissioner, who forced him to shift his birthday bash to a rural venue. Meanwhile, Swapnil, also a bookie with a murder case, backs Chitu in this deadly power struggle. With both sides armed and unafraid of violence, Nagpur residents fear the worst.
Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
Two Uzbek women arrestedfor illegal stay in Golf City
Lucknow: Two women from Uzbekistan were found residing illegally in a rented flat in Lucknow's posh Golf City area without valid visa or passport, triggering a multi-agency investigation into suspected human trafficking and tampering of identity through plastic surgery. Lodging an FIR, sub-inspector at Sushant Golf City police station Mahesh Kumar Singh said that acting on a confidential tip-off, the Foreigners Regional Registration Office (FRRO) conducted a raid in a flat where two Uzbek women were found living since June 18 without informing the local authorities or the police. "The women claimed that they lost their travel documents two years ago. However, they failed to produce the copy of the police complaint regarding the loss of documents," Singh said in the FIR. Upon further interrogation, the women disclosed that they came to India with the help of a woman, Lola Kayumova, who was reportedly residing in India for a long time. They claimed that Kayumova introduced them to a plastic surgeon who runs clinics in Patrakarpuram and Ahimamau areas of the city. They said that they underwent plastic surgery procedures to alter their identity and claimed that the surgeon, and another person, whom they identified as Thrijin Raj alias Arjun Rana, arranged for their accommodation and facilitated their stay, despite knowing that their documents were invalid. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like New Container Houses Morocco (Prices May Surprise You) Container House | Search ads Search Now Undo The women have been taken into FRRO custody for further investigation. Deputy commissioner of police, south zone, Nipun Agarwal, said that more evidence was being collected and other associates of the accused were under scrutiny. "We are also looking into the possibility of a wider trafficking network," Agarwal said. He added that the accused have been booked under sections 318(4) (cheating), and 61 (criminal conspiracy) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), Section 5 of the Registration of Foreigners Act, 1939, Section 14A and 7(1) of the Foreigners Act, 1946, and under relevant sections of the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025. "Probe is being conducted into the role of the plastic surgeon and Arjun Rana," the DCP said, adding that the foreign nationals would be deported to their country after the investigation.
