‘Adverse Information' claims by USCIS trigger alarm bells for attorneys and H-1B community
A new request from the US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) while processing H-1B visa applications (Form I-129) and also while processing applications for employment-linked green cards is perplexing attorneys and H-1B beneficiaries who are sponsored for the visa or green card.
The spate of inquiries from USCIS has gained momentum over last week. 'The request for evidence (RFE) states: We have encountered potentially 'adverse information' related to the beneficiary. To continue processing your application or petition, we require an updated address for the beneficiary so that we may collect biometric data. Please submit the beneficiary's current and updated residential address.'
This has prompted the American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA) to issue a 'Practice Alert' for its members and also to reach out to USCIS. It has reminded the immigration agency that if it does have any adverse information, it is required to disclose the same and provide the petitioner with an opportunity to respond.
Kripa Upadhyay, immigration attorney at Buchalter, states 'USCIS is breaking the law. Regulations require it to disclose any derogatory information being used as a basis for an adverse decision. These RFE's provide no information or indication of what the 'adverse information' is.'
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Google Brain Co-Founder Andrew Ng, Recommends: Read These 5 Books And Turn Your Life Around
Blinkist: Andrew Ng's Reading List
Undo
Cyrus D. Mehta, a New York based immigration attorney echoed the same and added, 'It is bizarre and again one wonders whether this is an AI program that has gone rogue.'
Vincent W. Lau, managing partner at Clark Lau, who is the Vice-chair at AILA's 'USCIS Benefits and Policy Committee' told TOI, 'An official answer is still awaited from USCIS. Anecdotally from AILA member reports, we surmise that the 'adverse' information may include prior police activity and USCIS may be trying to use biometrics to verify the identity of the individual.'
'Some of the RFE's seem to be because of prior infractions including working without authorization, but I also have some clients who have had this added to their RFE's without any prior infractions,' said Upadhyay.
While biometrics are collected in several cases, such as citizenship, green cards, employment authorisation, or when applying for visas at consulates abroad, immigration attorneys are also puzzled as H-1B visa holders have not normally been required to submit to biometrics.
'I would not say therefore that it is illegal to request biometrics of H-1B beneficiaries but it has not been part of the petition process. If indeed this is a new trend, practitioners have not received any notice of this and therefore, with the uncertainty and unpredictability in the immigration space right now, it is unsettling. Practitioners and their clients are not sure whether there is more to the request. Is this just a simple request for biometrics or is there more behind the request? Should an individual be concerned and what can one expect when appearing to submit biometrics?, ' states Lau.
Meanwhile, in social media groups of H-1B holders, the fear is palpable: Will I be detained by ICE if I go for my biometric appointment? As of now, there are no answers.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
43 minutes ago
- Time of India
Who is Thomas Fugate? Meet the 22-year-old leading Trump's terrorism unit amid Iran fiasco
Image credits: X U.S. President Donald Trump on June 22, 2025 announced that American forces had carried out airstrikes on three Iranian nuclear sites, marking Washington's formal entry into Israel's ongoing conflict with Iran. 'We have completed our very successful attack on the three Nuclear sites in Iran, including Fordow, Natanz, and Esfahan. All planes are now outside of Iran air space,' Trump wrote on his Truth Social platform. Ever since, the entire world has been in a state of dread, anticipating a full-out war considering the already ongoing wars between Russia and Ukraine and Israel and Hamas. With Iran yet to respond to the bombings, American people have been anticipating counter-attacks in the country and military drafts in case a war breaks out. Amid all this ongoing tension, one would expect the government to be on the frontline of handling situations. But, the people of America can't help but question their safety with a 22-year-old former 'gardener' being appointed as the head of the terrorism unit by the President. Who is Thomas Fugate ? Image credits: X Thomas Fugate was assigned to a major terrorism-prevention post by Trump and his qualifications and ability are being questioned by netizens who are worried for the country. Recently, Senator Chris Murphy criticised the president for appointing Fugate to a role at the Department of Homeland Security where he oversees the Center for Prevention Programs and Partnership (CP3) 'As our nation girds for possible Iranian terrorist attacks, this is the person Trump put in charge of terrorism prevention,' Murphy wrote. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Perdagangkan CFD Emas dengan Broker Tepercaya IC Markets Mendaftar Undo '22 years old. Recent work experience: landscaping/grocery clerk. Never worked a day in counter-terrorism. But he's a BIG Trump fan. So he got the job." It is not just Fugate's age that has left the American netizens unimpressed by his appointment. It is also his lack of experience. As per a June 4 investigation from ProPublica, he got the position after William Braniff, an Army Veteran with more than two decades of experience resigned in protest of the cuts to CP3. On his LinkedIn, Fugate mentioned that he spent several months performing "lawn care work around my neighbourhood." He also worked part-time as a clerk at an H-E-B supermarket. He graduated from the University of Texas at San Antonio just a year ago. Additionally, according to the Independent, Fugate is a former Heritage Foundation intern and self-described "Trumplican." Social media reactions Image credits: X Now, with the war in sight, many others on the internet are questioning Fugate's capabilities in protecting America and Americans from the situation. "DOES THIS MAKE YOU FEEL SAFE? U.S. officials say Iran will likely mobilize terrorist cells worldwide, including on U.S. soil. Just a reminder Trump has placed Thomas Fugate, a 22-year-old kid in charge of counterterrorism. He's a former grocery store clerk" wrote a person on X. "He's not had enough life experience to be able to handle this job. Jeez." added many others pointing out Fugate's life history and lack of experience. "Cause experience with shoplifters really prepares you for dealing with suicide bombers!" added another.
Time of India
43 minutes ago
- Time of India
Enforcement Directorate quizzes DK Suresh for 7 hours in laundering case linked to Aishwarya
Bengaluru: The Enforcement Directorate (ED) Monday questioned former Bangalore Rural MP DK Suresh, brother of deputy chief minister DK Shivakumar, for nearly seven hours in connection with a money laundering case involving Aishwarya Gowda . Emerging from ED's office around 6pm, Suresh told reporters that officials had sought details regarding Aishwarya, who is under investigation for duping individuals by allegedly misusing his name. "They asked me about the ongoing money laundering case involving Aishwarya and others. I clarified that Aishwarya falsely claimed to be my sister and misused my name. I had no financial dealings with her," Suresh said. "She collected money from people using my name. Except for once attending a Rajyotsava event she organised, I had no other association with her. I've already filed a police complaint against her," he added. He has been asked to appear again on July 7, Suresh said, adding he would fully cooperate. The former MP had been summoned by ED on June 19 but he requested a rescheduled appearance citing prior commitments. He arrived at the ED office around 11am Monday, escorted by police amid tight security. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Eat 1 Teaspoon Every Night, See What Happens A Week Later [Video] getfittoday Undo Meanwhile, ED announced that it had provisionally attached properties worth over Rs 3.9 crore belonging to Aishwarya under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act. The assets include Rs 2 crore in immovable properties and Rs 1.9 crore in movable assets. Aishwarya was arrested in April this year after several FIRs were registered against her and her husband Harish KN across multiple police stations in Karnataka. An ED press release stated that the duo, along with others, allegedly lured victims by promising high returns on investments. They, however, failed to return the money or deliver the promised returns and reportedly issued threats when questioned — citing Aishwarya's purported connections with senior politicians.
Time of India
43 minutes ago
- Time of India
Tharoor praises PM: Shashi calls Modi 'prime asset'; hails his 'energy, dynamism and willingness to engage'
Shashi Tharoor with PM Modi. (IANS photo) NEW DELHI: Congress MP Shashi Tharoor on Monday praised Prime Minister Narendra Modi , saying his energy, dynamism and willingness to engage remains a 'prime asset' for India globally. These remarks could strain his relationship with Congress party leadership. Tharoor made these comments in an article in the Hindu and it comes at a time when Congress has been critical of PM Modi government's foreign policy decisions. The party has alleged that Indian diplomacy is being 'shattered' and the country stands 'isolated' globally. Tharoor's supportive stance towards the PM appears to conflict with his party's position, potentially widening existing rifts between him and Congress leadership. Tharoor acknowledged that Prime Minister Narendra Modi's vigour and diplomatic engagement remain valuable for India internationally, though requiring additional support. These comments, made on Monday, might create tension within his party and further strain his relationship with its leadership. The timing of Tharoor's commendation is notable, as it comes when the Congress has consistently criticised the Modi government's foreign policy, claiming that Indian diplomacy is deteriorating and the nation faces international isolation. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 40세 미만이라면 이 매혹적인 게임을 하지 마세요 경복의 바다 게임 플레이 Undo In his article, Tharoor highlighted that the diplomatic efforts following 'Operation Sindoor' demonstrated national unity and successful communication. The Prime Minister's Office shared Tharoor's article on X, noting "Lok Sabha MP and former Union Minister Dr. Shashi Tharoor writes- Lessons from Operation Sindoor's global outreach." The BJP criticised the Congress regarding Tharoor's article, suggesting it contradicted Rahul Gandhi's position. BJP spokesperson Pradeep Bhandari commented on X about Tharoor's recognition of PM Modi's international engagement benefiting India. Tharoor's article emphasised that "Prime Minister Narendra Modi's energy, dynamism and willingness to engage remains a prime asset for India on the global stage but deserves greater backing." He noted that the diplomatic response to 'Operation Sindoor' demonstrated India's ability to effectively communicate its position internationally when united. Tharoor had led a multi-party delegation to various countries to present India's position following the Pahalgam incident.
