Man takes case against Ryanair after flight took off without his family
Almost 100 people missed a
Ryanair
flight from Bordeaux to Cork last July because of an
Microsoft IT outage
which forced the airline to revert to manual check-ins, a small claims court hearing in Balbriggan, Co Dublin was told.
Some passengers who were at the airport hours before departure were classified as no-shows with Ryanair telling the court it had no obligation to cover the costs of those who made alternate arrangements to get home.
The case was taken by David Hickey from Cork who told District Court Judge Stepanie Coggins that on July 19th, 2024 his family of five were due to travel from Bordeaux to Cork on a Ryanair flight departing at 9.05 am.
He said they checked in online but could not check in their luggage in at the airport as a result of the IT outage which impacted airlines globally.
READ MORE
The flight subsequently took off leaving the Hickey family and dozens of others in the departures hall.
The family made their way back to Cork via London and Mr Hickeywanted the airline to cover the cost
of their return travel amounting to just under €2,000.
Today was his third time travelling up from his home for the case.
'I was here on February 21st and the case was settled pending payment,' Mr Hickey told Judge Coggins.
However, he subsequently received correspondence from Ryanair that - contrary to what its solicitor told him in court - it would not be settling the case.
It cited concerns that his wife was also considering a claim which would take the total claim over the €2,000 limit set for the small claims court.
Judge Coggins asked Mr Hickey if he could give assurances that no further claim from his wife would be lodged allowing the case to be concluded on the basis of the previously agreed settlement. Mr Hickey was given time to consult with her.
When he returned to the stand he said the couple would forgo any future claim and Judge Coggins was on the verge of confirming a settlement when Ryanair's barrister Jennifer Goode JC said she had been instructed to defend the claim.
'That is not what you said earlier,' Judge Coggins said. 'I am very disappointed,' the judge continued, stressing that it was 'categorically not' the basis on which she had instructed Mr Hickey to consult with his wife.
Outlining Ryanair's defence Ms Goode highlighted the airline's 'delicate' ecosystem which could be thrown off if departures were delayed to accommodate late arriving passengers or baggage.
Giving evidence via video link from France, Bertram Moulet Delpech of Bordaux Airport outlined what happened last July when aviation systems crashed.
He said the Cork-bound plane had taken off with only 87 of the passengers on the fully booked flight on board.
Judge Coggins expressed incredulity that over 90 people 'don't get to board a flight and Ryanair think that is okay?'
Ms Goode expressed sympathy to impacted passengers describing it as a 'horrible situation' but pointed to EU rules governing flights and case law highlighting the limits to which airlines can be held responsible if passengers don't get to board flights.
Judge Coggins asked if there was any specific case law governing the circumstances the Hickey family were in and Ms Goode conceded there was not.
'I wouldn't like to be quoted as describing it as nit-picking but this is what is going on,' Judge Coggins said. 'This flight took off half full and people were not able to board because of software issues,' she said.
She added, that people had 'incurred costs [and] the airline is saying that has nothing to do with them.'
She expressed the view that 'there has to be some obligation on behalf of Ryanair' and concluded the hearing by saying she would need time to consider a ruling.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
37 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Ryanair chiefs cancel flights to busy city from June to September as airline issues apology
RYANAIR has issued a warning to passengers as the airline has been "forced" to cancel flights to a major capital city. The Irish airline has decided to stop all flights to and from Amman in Advertisement 2 Ryanair has decided to stop all flights to/from Amman in Jordan Credit: Alamy Flights going to and from Amman have been scrapped from June 13 to September 30. The A spokesperson said: " "Affected passengers will be notified of their options by email. Advertisement Read more in Travel "Ryanair apologises for these cancellations, which are beyond our control, and passengers are advised to download the Ryanair app to check for the latest flight updates." It comes after about 650 flights to and from Europe were cancelled following airspace closures in response to military strikes between Israel and Iran. And about 1,800 flights were also affected. Separately, Ryanair has Advertisement Most read in News Travel The "Now or Never" sale has to be booked by tomorrow, June 18, to avail yourself of the discounts. The sale is valid on 'It's very important' - Ryanair's 'baggage sizers' warning to Irish passengers ahead of busy Easter break amid €75 fine And there are a number of sunshine spots on offer if you're looking to escape the You can head to Advertisement There are also a number of You can travel to Bristol from €20.16, Glasgow from €23.79, Leeds Bradford from €25.49. Or, head to London Luton, London Stansted or Manchester from €25.49. Other Advertisement You can travel to French hotspots including Paris Beauvais from €36.54 or Nantes or Biarritz from €42.49. These deals and more are available to book on the 2 The Irish airline has decided to stop all Amman flights Credit: Getty Images - Getty
Irish Examiner
7 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Cork Airport named best in Europe for third time
Cork Airport was named the best airport in Europe, under five million passengers, at the Airport Council International (ACI) Europe Best Airport Awards held in Athens on Thursday night. It is the third time Cork Airport has won the award, having won it previously in 2017 and 2019. The award acknowledges Cork's excellence in passenger experience, operational efficiency, route development, sustainability and innovation. "This recognition is thoroughly deserved," Olivier Jankovec, ACI Europe director general, said. "The airport team has worked tirelessly to enhance operational efficiency, offer exceptional passenger experience, and deliver on ambitious environmental and sustainability goals. Their success is clearly reflected in increased air connectivity and passenger numbers, which means a growing contribution from the airport to the regional economy, tourism and competitiveness. Last year, Cork Airport saw 10% passenger growth to 3.2 million passengers, forecast to rise this year to 3.4 million passengers. In May, it announced a €200m investment by Dublin Airport Authority in the development of new infrastructure, including an extended mezzanine floor, larger duty-free shop, bigger executive lounge, additional car park spaces, more boarding gates, new aircraft stands, and a new pier to facilitate growth up to five million passengers. Taoiseach Micheál Martin congratulated Cork Airport. "It is clear that Cork Airport is going from strength to strength every year and this award is a reflection of the hard work and dedication of Niall MacCarthy and all his team there." Niall MacCarthy, Cork Airport's managing director, said: 'This award is a fantastic endorsement of the incredible people who make Cork Airport what it is — from our frontline teams to those behind the scenes, and everyone in between. It's also a reflection of the strong partnerships we've built with all our stakeholders, and the loyalty of our passengers who continue to choose Cork Airport.' Dublin Airport Authority chief executive Kenny Jacobs said the award was a huge recognition of the brilliant team on the ground. "This award's not just for the airport — it's for Cork, for Munster, and for Ireland. We have big plans for Cork, and this is a great boost," he said. Read More Rory Gallagher Avenue unveiled at Cork Airport to honour legendary guitarist's enduring legacy
Irish Independent
11 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Big increase in winter flights at Dublin Airport expected after cap suspended
The number of seats that will be available on flights in and out of the capital will rise to just under 17.9 million for the season, a 23pc increase on last winter. Last winter, just under 14.4 million seats were set to be made available by carriers as the Irish Aviation Authority (IAA) decided to limit numbers to ensure Dublin Airport adhered to its annual 32 million passenger cap. While the number available next winter is expected to shoot back up to 17.9 million, that is still below the near 18.4 million that were being made available for winter 2023-2024. Aer Lingus intends to have more than 4.7 million seats available this winter. That's 560,000 more than last winter. Ryanair will have 7.54 million, compared with the 6.25 million it had last season. Other international operators, from Gulf carriers Emirates and Etihad to US airlines including United, Delta and American, will have hundreds of thousands of extra seats available between them. Dublin Airport's passenger cap is due to a planning condition attached in 2007 to the construction of Terminal 2. However, this year Dublin Airport will handle about 36.3 million passengers, following decisions by the High Court that effectively paused the cap while certain matters related to aircraft take-off and landing slot allocations are being examined by the European Court of Justice. It is not likely to deliver a ruling on those matters until summer next year. Dublin Airport's slots are managed by UK-based firm Airport Coordination. Its initial co-ordination report for the coming winter period, which covers October 26 to March 28 next year, shows the dramatic increase in the planned seat availability now that the IAA cannot, for the time being at least, limit the number at Dublin Airport. The report shows there was demand for 103,020 take-off and landing slots for the season, with 102,754 allocated. New slots for the period were requested by a slew of airlines, from Aer Lingus and Ryanair, to Hainan Airlines, Emirates and Etihad. Ryanair remains by far the biggest operator at Dublin Airport for the season, with 39pc of allocated slots for the winter. Aer Lingus has 23pc. Emerald Airlines, which operates the Aer Lingus Regional service, has just under 13pc. The largest non-Irish long-haul carrier out of Dublin is United Airlines, with 1,080 slots for the winter, followed by Emirates and Qatar Airways. The report from Airport Coordination notes that some new destinations which intended to be operated next winter include routes to Albania's capital, Tirana, as well as to Rabat in Morocco and a direct service to Derry. The Government has pledged to have the cap removed. While Transport Minister Darragh O'Brien has suggested legislation will be brought forward in the autumn to address the cap, it could take some time before it is removed. Dublin Airport is set for its busiest ever summer, with passenger numbers expected to surpass 10 million for the season. It expects to have a number of days where passenger numbers will significantly exceed 100,000.
