Watchdog says military police still resisting civilian oversight
The National Defence building is seen in Ottawa on Wednesday, March 30, 2022. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld)
OTTAWA — The Military Police Complaints Commission says resistance to civilian oversight in the Canadian Forces Provost Marshal's office 'worsened' last year.
The Military Police Complaints Commission released a report Tuesday accusing the provost's office -- which commands all military police in Canada -- of 'shutting down' complaints based on a 'dubious' interpretation of the National Defence Act.
In its report, the watchdog said the provost's office has been failing to advise complainants of their right to have their cases reviewed by the complaints commission as required by law, and is routinely refusing to respond to complaints made in interference cases.
Interference cases come up when a military police member files a complaint alleging that a member of the Canadian Armed Forces or a senior official in the Department of National Defence has attempted to influence an investigation.
'These issues not only persisted but have worsened. In 2024, the (Canadian Forces Provost Marshal) interpreted the National Defence Act in a way that avoids civilian independent oversight. The situation escalated from resistance to outright refusal to respect the oversight regime mandated by Parliament,' the watchdog's report said.
'This includes shutting down complaints without having the authority based on dubious interpretations of the National Defence Act as detailed in this report. These roadblocks are hindering the civilian oversight of the military police.'
Tammy Tremblay, Military Police Complaints Commission chair, declined an interview request.
The report calls for law reform to ensure the commission has the ability to access 'information necessary to investigate complaints.'
'Without this legislative reform, there is a risk that the barriers the MPCC faces in exercising its mandate continue to dilute the will of Parliament in establishing an oversight system for the military police,' the report said.
The report also says that individual members of the military police 'respect and understand' the watchdog's mandate and the problem of 'refusal of civilian oversight' stems from senior leadership.
Brig.-Gen. Vanessa Hanrahan took over command of the Canadian Forces Provost Marshal's office in December, replacing Maj.-Gen. Simon Trudeau, who had held the position for the previous six and a half years.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 17, 2025.
David Baxter, The Canadian Press
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Globe and Mail
an hour ago
- Globe and Mail
Ottawa advises Canadians to leave Iran or stay near a bomb shelter
Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand says she has spoken with Iran's Foreign Minister and pressed him to ensure the safe departure of Canadians from the country. Ottawa is advising Canadians to leave Iran if they can do so safely, warning that Iranian authorities have detained dual nationals in the past to exert influence on their government. Global Affairs' warning came in updated travel advice on Saturday, just before President Donald Trump announced the U.S. strikes on Iranian nuclear facilities. The warning also advised Canadians remaining in Iran to 'stay close to a bomb shelter or be prepared to shelter in a hardened structure away from windows.' Canada has not had diplomatic relations with Iran since 2012 and has had to rely on other foreign embassies to help Canadians in the country. According to Global Affairs, Canada has boosted the number of consular staff in neighbouring countries and in the past week has sent diplomatic staff to the borders in Turkey and Armenia to help Canadians crossing from Iran. Speaking to reporters in Brussels on Sunday, Ms. Anand urged Canadians in Iran to register with Global Affairs, saying they would be contacted directly by government officials with advice about how to get back to Canada. She says that in her call with Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi she 'emphasized the importance of the safety and security of Canadian citizens in the region.' U.S. military officials say they are not pursuing war with Iran after striking key nuclear sites Ottawa has been helping Canadians in Israel and Iran find seats on commercial flights to Canada after they cross into neighbouring countries since the conflict between Israel and Iran escalated earlier this month. But Canadians visiting Israel, who included former Conservative MPs Michelle Ferreri and Rick Perkins, have said they had to make their own way to Jordan to board flights after the bombing started. In the past few days, Global Affairs has been arranging buses to the borders for Canadians. But in a statement on Sunday evening, it said that day's planned departure from Israel over land had to be postponed until Monday. It said it is in 'regular communication with Canadians who have requested assistance in Iran, Israel and the West Bank.' After the U.S. strikes on nuclear facilities in Iran, 'we are reviewing our mission security posture across the region in close collaboration with our international partners,' it added. Global Affairs has deployed more than 20 members of its Standing Rapid Deployment Team to Israel, the West Bank, Jordan, Turkey, Azerbaijan, Greece, Cyprus and Armenia to help hundreds of personnel already on the ground. But it said Canada is unable to provide assistance within Iran because it has no embassy there. Canadians fleeing war in Iran face obstacles in absence of diplomatic ties Ottawa facing criticism for not doing more to help Canadians leave Middle East On Sunday, after the U.S. strikes on Iran, Israel reopened its airspace during the day to allow flights. Israel's Airports Authority said flights departing Israel would expand on Monday. Israeli airline El Al is reported to have already received 25,000 inquiries about leaving the country. In Iran, the airspace remains closed. Mona Ghassemi, president of the Iranian-Canadian Congress, said on Sunday that 'enough is not being done' by Ottawa to help Canadians leave Iran. 'From what we have heard, it seems to be not enough as Iranians reaching the emergency number were told it was up to them to get to the border to get a flight from a neighbouring country,' she said, adding that because there is an internet blackout, it is hard to reach people in Iran at the moment. More than 4,000 Canadian citizens were registered as being in Iran earlier this month. Maryam Marissen, a Canadian-Iranian from Vancouver with relatives in Iran, said a Canadian cousin is trying to leave the country, but without the internet, it is hard for them to access information, including security updates and travel advice from Ottawa. She said Canadians with family or friends in Iran have been trying to keep them updated about the situation by phone. 'It's really troubling,' she said. 'Right now, people are just relying on news outlets, and there is a lot of confusion. You really would have to have people on this side, finding the information for you and trying to get it to you.' In an interview on Friday, Setareh Shariati described how she had travelled to Tehran on June 1 for knee surgery that she had been waiting months to receive in Canada. Taking leave from her job at the University of British Columbia, she didn't expect to spend her recovery in a war zone. She is a permanent resident in Canada, but Ms. Shariati said she was denied services from the Canadian embassy in Turkey, which is only supporting citizens. She said recent surgery prevents her from being able to drive to the Iranian border, and even then, she's unsure where she'd go or how she'd get to Vancouver. A 20-litre per car per day gas ration further complicates leaving Tehran. The city is more than 1,000 kilometres away from the nearest bordering countries. 'The roads leading out of the city are basically lost to traffic. Everyone is trying to leave, and gas is really hard to come by,' Ms. Shariati said.
Cision Canada
an hour ago
- Cision Canada
Monday, June 23, 2025
OTTAWA, ON, June 22, 2025 /CNW/ - Note: All times local Hoboken, Belgium Brussels, Belgium 3:15 p.m. The Prime Minister will meet with the Prime Minister of Belgium, Bart De Wever. Note for media: Pooled photo opportunity at the beginning of the meeting 5:00 p.m. The Prime Minister will arrive at the Canada-European Union Summit. Note for media: Open coverage 5:05 p.m. The Prime Minister will meet with the President of the European Council, António Costa, and the President of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen. Note for media: Pooled photo opportunity at the beginning of the meeting 5:30 p.m. The Prime Minister will participate in the Canada-European Union Plenary Meeting. Note for media: Pooled photo opportunity at the beginning of the meeting 7:10 p.m. The Prime Minister will hold a joint media availability with the President of the European Council, António Costa, and the President of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen. Note for media: Open coverage 7:45 p.m. The Prime Minister will participate in a working dinner hosted by the President of the European Council, António Costa, and the President of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen. Note for media: Official photographers only This document is also available at SOURCE Prime Minister's Office
CBC
3 hours ago
- CBC
After U.S. strikes in Iran, Torontonians with family in Iran, Israel worry for loved ones
Social Sharing U.S. strikes on Iran this weekend are reverberating in Toronto, as with some in the city fear for their loved ones in the Middle East while others protested outside the U.S consulate in reaction. On Saturday, the U.S. military attacked key Iranian nuclear sites in Fordo, Natanz and Isfahan, the latest development in an escalating conflict between Israel and Iran. Mina Morshed, a Toronto woman who has family in Tehran, told CBC TV's Rosemary Barton Live that her parents and sister are in Tehran and she spoke to them a few days ago. She said she has tried to tell them that they are not alone. "I am worried about my parents, family, friends," Morshed said. WATCH | Iranian Canadian in Toronto worries for family in Tehran after U.S. strikes: Iranian Canadian says she's worried about family, hopes for peace 4 days ago Duration 6:04 Those with family in Israel have similar concerns. Laurent Attali, a Toronto-born Montrealer now living in Etobicoke, said he has been trying for days to get his two daughters and their families, who live near Tel Aviv, out of Israel. He said he bought them two sets of plane tickets that were cancelled by the airlines. Attali said the latest plan is for them to go by bus from Tel Aviv to the Amman airport in Jordan, but it's not a good solution, as Amman is considered hostile to Israelis because of Palestinian supporters who live there. He said he thinks the Canadian government could charter a boat or plane from Israel to get Canadians people out. Now, Attali said he has been glued to the television to figure out where the bombs are being dropped in Tel Aviv to see if the sites are near where his family and friends live. "For us, since that evening, we have been 10 to 15 hours a day [watching] the TV. We are all the time at the TV," he said. Protestors gather outside U.S. consulate Sunday Meanwhile, hundreds of people gathered outside the U.S. consulate on Sunday afternoon to protest U.S. military action in Iran. Organizers of the "Hands Off Iran" rally said in a media advisory that the demonstrators condemn Western involvement in the conflict, and are also calling on the Canadian government to sanction Israel and to implement an arms embargo on Israel. Parsa Golesorkhi, an organizer of the rally, said he has been watching his hometown of Tehran get bombed in what he called an "unprovoked, illegal and criminal act of aggression" by Israel and now, the United States. "We are here first of all to condemn this aggression against our people — and we are not just as Iranians, but standing with our allies from different communities, from the Palestinian community, from the Jewish community," Golesorkhi said. Noah Shack, CEO of the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs, based in Toronto, said attacks on Iranian nuclear sites are justified given the danger that they pose to the world. "The Iranian nuclear program poses a threat not just to Israel but to the broader Middle East and indeed the world," he said. "This is a dangerous regime and the world is safer without them having access to nuclear weapons." Prime Minister Mark Carney, in a post on X, said on Sunday that the U.S. military action was "designed to alleviate" threats posed by Iran, but the situation in the Middle East remains "highly volatile." "Stability in the region is a priority," Carney said. "Canada calls on parties to return immediately to the negotiating table and reach a diplomatic solution to end this crisis."
