Still no charges in Robert Pickton prison death a year after fatal assault
New
B.C. serial killer died after an attack by another inmate in the Port-Cartier maximum security prison
Image | http://i.cbc.ca/1.1878200.1380865332!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/16x9_620/hi-bc-120509-robe
Caption: Police found the remains or DNA of 33 women on Robert Pickton's Port Coquitlam, B.C., farm. A year after his death following a prison assault, prison justice advocates are asking for an inquiry into his death. (CBC)
A year to the day after serial killer Robert Pickton died following an assault by another inmate in a Quebec prison, there have been no charges against the alleged assailant and few answers about what happened.
Pickton died in hospital on May 31, 2024, after being assaulted at the Port-Cartier maximum security prison 12 days prior. The 74-year-old was convicted in 2007 of six counts of second-degree murder but was suspected of killing dozens more women at his pig farm in Port Coquitlam, B.C.
The Correctional Service of Canada first issued a release on May 20 last year about a "major assault" on an inmate, adding "the assailant has been identified and the appropriate actions have been taken." The agency later confirmed the injured inmate was Pickton, and that he had died.
Quebec provincial police identified the suspect as a 51-year-old inmate, but did not release a name.
WATCH | Pickton dies after fatal prison assault:
Media | Serial killer Robert Pickton is dead
Caption: Robert Pickton had been in hospital since May 19 after being the target of what Correctional Service Canada called a "major assault" at the maximum-security Port-Cartier Institution in Quebec. The 74-year-old B.C. man had been found guilty of murdering six women in the Vancouver area, but had bragged about killing 49.
Open Full Embed in New Tab Loading external pages may require significantly more data usage than loading CBC Lite story pages.
Earlier this week, the force said its investigation remained open.
"Some expert reports are still ongoing. As this is an active file, we will not comment further," the Sûreté du Québec wrote in an email. By phone, a spokesperson said the police file had not yet been handed over to the Quebec Crown prosecutor's office, who will decide whether charges will be laid.
Image | Robert Pickton court sketch
Caption: This is a artist's drawing of Robert Pickton appearing on a video link to B.C. Supreme Court in New Westminster on May 25, 2005. Pickton was suspected of killing dozens of Indigenous women at his pig farm. (Jane Wolsack/The Canadian Press)
Open Image in New Tab
Spokesperson Audrey-Anne Bilodeau added police sometimes take more time to investigate when a suspect is already behind bars because there is no risk to the public.
Correctional Service Canada said it expects to publish the results of investigations into the death "in the near future," spokesperson Kevin Antonucci wrote in an email.
"Time was required to ensure that they were fully translated and vetted in accordance with the Privacy Act."
Calls for public inquiry
Advocates for prisoners' rights expressed concern about the lack of answers about what happened and said the death raises questions about inmate security.
"We're concerned about a number of deaths have occurred at the hands of other prisoners without any clear answers," Catherine Latimer of the John Howard Society said in a phone interview.
Latimer cited a fatality report published earlier this year by Alberta Justice Donna Groves into the death of a 21-year-old inmate who was knifed to death inside his cell by another inmate at the Edmonton Institution in 2011.
The report raised a number of questions, including why the two inmates were allowed out of their cells at the same time despite belonging to rival gangs and being under orders not to be around other inmates.
Groves called for a public inquiry into the death, saying it's the only way to get to the bottom of three guards' actions that day, including concerns they were running a prison "fight club."
Latimer said the report shows there is a serious problem with "incompatible or vulnerable prisoners" being exposed to others who want to kill them. "Pickton really raises that," she said.
Pickton, she added, would likely have been considered "vulnerable" because the nature of his offences would have made him a potential target.
Prison deaths tough to investigate
Howard Sapers, who spent 12 years as Correctional Investigator of Canada, said sudden prison deaths – particularly criminal ones – are often long and tough to investigate.
"There are difficulties in terms of accessing crime scenes, preserving crime scenes, obtaining witness statements, so all of those things tend to frustrate investigations," he said.
He added such investigations are often not a priority – at least in terms of speed – due to a lack of generalized public safety risk.
He said federal investigators probing Pickton's death will be looking at whether protocol and policy was followed in areas such as contraband and weapons, underground trade in weapons and drugs, gang conflicts and known threats against an individual.
Tom Engel, the former president of the Canadian Prison Law Association, agreed that Pickton's reputation would have meant he was at high risk of being assaulted by other inmates.
"The question has to be asked, 'Well, how could this happen when he's at high risk?'" he said in a phone interview.
LISTEN | Questions over prison safety:
Media | Breakaway : Is Canada's federal prison system safe for all inmates?
Caption: The assault on serial killer Robert Pickton at the Port Cartier prison is raising questions about the safety of inmates within federal prisons. Alison speaks with Senator Kim Pate, who says she is very concerned about the lack of respect for human rights towards those who are sentences in our country.
Open Full Embed in New Tab Loading external pages may require significantly more data usage than loading CBC Lite story pages.
Engel said he wasn't surprised by the lack of charges so far. He said investigations can be lengthy, in part because correctional staff and inmates can be reluctant to fully co-operate with police.
The announcement of Pickton's death last year was met with public expressions of satisfaction and joy rather than concern. Families of victims used words such as "healing," "overjoyed" and "justice" to describe the death of a man who preyed upon vulnerable women in Vancouver's Downtown Eastside, many of them Indigenous.
But Engel believes the fate of prison inmates should be a concern.
"Members of the public who believe in human rights, who believe in the rule of law, who believe that the Criminal Code of Canada applies to everybody should care about this, because you can't have this kind of lawlessness going on in a prison," he said.
Sapers noted prisons can be dangerous for both inmates and correctional staff. And he said many of the solutions, which include more investment in staffing, training, prison infrastructure and programming to meaningfully occupy prisoners, benefit both groups.
"Often people don't make the link to safe environments for people who are in custody are also safe environments for people who have to work there, and I think it's a really important point to make," he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
25 minutes ago
- CTV News
‘I'll remember it for the rest of my life': Bridge patrol officer's life-saving actions earn her multiple awards
For Payton Deeble, more than one life was changed after a medical emergency on Halifax's Angus L. Macdonald bridge. 'It really kind opened my eyes to how just a small action can make such a big impact in somebody's life,' said Deeble. On Feb. 8, the 27-year-old bridge patrol officer with Halifax Harbour Bridges (HHB) was in the middle of her Saturday night shift when she responded to a stalled Dartmouth-bound vehicle on the Macdonald. 'When I approached the car, I noticed that the driver was kind of slumped back with his eyes open,' she recalled. 'He didn't give a response. I tapped on the window, and nothing. Knocked, nothing.' Deeble alerted HHB's operations centre that there was a driver unconscious in his vehicle and to call EHS. 'I started to get a lot more aggressive on the car, just banging on the window. And then luckily enough, a driver that was going through the other lane stopped and asked if I needed any help, and I said, yes. So, he got out with me, and we smashed out the back window in his vehicle.' Payton Deeble Payton Deeble is pictured with an Automated External Defibrillator. (Courtesy: Halifax Harbour Bridges) From there, Deeble and the Good Samaritan unlocked the doors and placed the unconscious man, a senior, on the bridge deck. Deeble grabbed the Automated External Defibrillator (AED) from her patrol car, while a passenger with the helping stranger performed chest compressions. 'He had no pulse,' adds Deeble. 'We got his shirt off, placed the AED on him, and started going through the motions. We did the first shock on him, and we still didn't get a pulse. And second shock, we still didn't get a pulse. And by the third shock, we did get a very weak pulse on him. And by that time, luckily enough, EHS was arriving.' From there, paramedics took the senior to hospital where he was treated for a blocked artery. 'I knew I couldn't even have a second thought about how intense the situation was or about if I was scared or nervous or anything. I just knew I needed to act, and I needed to act right away because seconds were vital. I knew I needed to do something right away, and I needed to help this man.' Fortunately, the senior made a full recovery and celebrated his birthday a few days later. He and his wife later met with Deeble privately to thank her for her actions. 'It was surreal,' adds Deeble. 'It was such a heart filling moment, from seeing him in such a state on the bridge deck to seeing him doing better. It was amazing.' It's also rare. Deeble has been with the HHB for four years. 'I know there's been a few people there who have been there for a very long time. We've seen some really, really intense situations. But from most of the people I spoke with, this was a very, very one-off situation that a lot of people haven't seen on the bridges before.' Steven Proctor, the communications manager for HHB, says it's a 'very uncommon' situation. 'Bridge patrol responds to a bunch of different things that are often unexpected,' explains Proctor. 'Their routine is broken down vehicles, distracted driving, speeding, that kind of thing. They also respond to incidents on the sidewalk, but it's very rare to come across something like what Peyton experienced.' Payton Deeble Payton Deeble is pictured with a Canadian Security Lifesaver award. (Courtesy: Halifax Harbour Bridges) Months later, Deeble has received two security awards for her actions. The GardaWorld Award of Excellence, and a national award from the Canadian Security Lifesaver Association. 'It was such a nice feeling just to have that recognition. I never expected anything like that, you know? I just was doing my job.' Her coworkers say the accolades are well deserved. 'What a life experience to keep it together in a life-or-death situation,' says Proctor. 'To face it head on, having all your training kick in, and have a positive result? I think it's fantastic. She's learned she can stand up to just about any critical situation. Bridge patrol is more than an enforcement tool, they're actually out there helping people.' While she doesn't know who stopped to help her that night, she says she appreciates them. 'If it wasn't for that teamwork, I think it would have been a lot more challenging for me,' adds Deeble. 'I'll remember it for the rest of my life. One hundred per cent.' For more Nova Scotia news, visit our dedicated provincial page
CTV News
27 minutes ago
- CTV News
Man injured in 2023 Winnipeg mass shooting dies in hospital; family wants attempted murder charge upgraded
A man shot during a 2023 mass shooting in Winnipeg has died in hospital and his family is speaking out. Jon Hendricks reports. The sole survivor of a mass shooting that killed four people nearly two years ago has died in hospital and his family is asking for the charge against the alleged shooter to be upgraded to second-degree murder. Shawn Marko died in hospital from pneumonia on June 1. He had been hospitalized since the shooting in a Langside Street home on Nov. 26, 2023. According to his sister Melissa, he had been celebrating his birthday with four friends when someone entered the home and shot everyone inside. Two people were pronounced dead at the scene, while two others died in hospital. 'He told us everything that happened,' Melissa said. 'He was the last one to be shot. All the other ones were shot first. He had all the (four victims) blood on him and everything.' Shawn was shot three times, with one bullet lodging in his spine. His large intestine and pancreas were removed, along with half of his bladder and stomach. He would remain hospitalized until his death. 'He phoned me and he was gasping for air, even with the oxygen on,' Melissa said. 'And he told me, 'I'm not going to make it this time.' And he was dead the very next morning.' Jamie Felix has been charged with four counts of second-degree murder and one count of attempted murder in Marko's case. He remains in custody and none of the charges against him have been proven in court. Melissa now wants the attempted murder charge upgraded to a murder charge. 'He would never have been in the hospital had he not been shot,' she said. 'He was shot just like everybody else. He just lasted longer.' However, upgrading a charge isn't straight forward. Theodore Mariash, the lawyer representing Felix, said the Crown will have to meet the legal standard of proof as to whether or not the actions of the accused were a significant contributing cause of the death. 'With the other four victims it's very clear that, you know, their deaths are as a result of a homicide. But, with respect to Mr. Marko, it's not so cut and dried,' Mariash said. A spokesperson from the Government of Manitoba said in a statement to CTV News that 'Decisions about whether the charge will be upgraded will be made after all the relevant evidence has been obtained and reviewed.' Melissa said she is remembering her brother as the kind of person who loved being around other people, and who people loved being around. 'He loved just hanging around with his friends,' she said. 'They didn't have to be doing anything, they would just hang around.'
CTV News
27 minutes ago
- CTV News
Teen suffers life-altering injuries following machete attack, robbery
Portage Avenue and St. James Street in Winnipeg is pictured on June 20, 2025. (Jamie Dowsett/CTV News Winnipeg) Winnipeg police are looking for witnesses after a teenager was attacked with a machete and robbed by a group of youths one week ago. The incident took place Friday at 7:36 p.m. near Portage Avenue and St. James Street. Paramedics said they witnessed a youth attack another youth with a machete and called police. When officers arrived, they found the injured teen, who was also robbed during the attack. He was taken to hospital in unstable condition and treated for 'life-altering' injuries. The teen was later upgraded to stable condition. Police said several other youths were involved in the robbery. No arrests have been made. Anyone with information or who may have witnessed the incident are asked to call police at 204-986-6219 or Crime Stoppers.
