Premier League explain controversial Villa decision that saw them miss top four

The Premier League has clarified why Aston Villa was controversially denied a goal in their clash with Manchester United, a decision that ultimately cost them a shot at Champions League qualification. Morgan Rogers was adjudged to have fouled keeper Altay Bayindir during the buildup, leading referee Thomas Bramall to blow his whistle.
Despite replays suggesting Bayindir hadn't fully secured the ball, with Rogers pouncing on a fumble, the ref's immediate whistle meant VAR couldn't step in to reverse the call.
The Premier League Match Centre explained: "The referee's call was a free kick to Manchester United with Bayindir deemed to be in control of the ball before Rogers gained possession. The whistle was blown by the referee before the ball entered the goal, therefore the incident was not reviewable by the VAR."
Ellen White expressed her astonishment on Final Score, remarking: "If the ref has blown his whistle then VAR can't get involved. Why not let the play carry on like the linesmen do for offside?".
Villa's team and coaching staff were left fuming over the decision, which could have significantly boosted their chances for a spot in the Champions League. Despite their frustration, they struggled to recover from the setback, reports the Mirror.
United promptly capitalised on Villa's troubles, surging to the lead in mere moments. Amad soared to head home a Bruno Fernandes cross while Villa tumbled into sixth, their Champions League dreams dimming.
Christian Eriksen coolly slotted from the spot, bolstering United's advantage after Ian Maatsen clumsily bundled over Amad in the box, which led to Unai Emery sarcastically applauding as the official signalled for Eriksen to take his shot.
Earlier, Emery's side were reduced to 10 men, dealing their Champions League aspirations another hit. Goalkeeper Emi Martinez, aged 32, bolted from his line following a dodgy pass by Matty Cash, crashing into United's Rasmus Hojlund well outside the penalty area.
Martinez was briskly issued his marching orders, earning a red card. The Premier League's own Match Centre account on X soon affirmed: "The referee's call of red card to Martinez for denial of an obvious goal scoring opportunity (DOGSO) was checked and confirmed by VAR."
Aston Villa's hopes were quashed as they finished sixth after Chelsea clinched a win against Nottingham Forest, confirming their spot in Europe's elite contest. Villa's failure simultaneously granted Newcastle the fifth qualifying place based on their superior goal difference, despite the Magpies suffering a setback at home to Everton when the season wrapped up.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Sunday World

2 hours ago

• Sunday World

No political overtones to Linfield v Shelbourne, it's all about cold, hard cash

Blues desperate to boost their coffers with Champions League money having failed to attract the finance they need David Healy, right, will be desperate to get the better of Damien Duff and his Shelbourne side in the Champions League. Photo: David Maginnis/Pacemaker Press Shels v Blues, North v South, Duff v Healy, the scene is set for a mammoth showdown between the champions of Ireland next month at Tolka Park. Linfield v Shelbourne in the Champions League has more angles than a protractor, both on and off the field of play. When the Irish League champions meet the League of Ireland champions next month it will be 19 years since their last encounter. The South Belfast team emerged victorious from that Setanta Cup clash, winning 2-0 over the two legs. That result was not as big a surprise as the match between the two clubs the year before when Linfield caused shockwaves by winning the inaugural Setanta Cup in 2005. Under former Linfield hero Pat Fenlon, Shels were top dogs in the League of Ireland having won the title in the two previous years and were big favourites to beat the upstarts from the North. The final was played at Tolka Park on May 21 and home advantage was also thought to swing it in favour of the powerful Dublin club. However, Linfield's feared twin strikers Glenn Ferguson and Peter Thompson struck early in the first half to stun Shels and carry the cup back to Belfast. Linfield were dominant domestically under David Jeffrey back then and are league champions once again under current boss David Healy. Meanwhile, Damien Duff took his first step into club management in 2021 and last year guided the Drumcondra outfit to their first league title since 2006. Shels won it in thrilling fashion, beating Derry City 1-0 on the last day of the title race to pip Shamrock Rovers to the crown. Former Blackburn, Chelsea and Republic of Ireland midfielder Duff has been a colourful addition to the League of Ireland, never shy to duck issues, often with a dash of humour. His Linfield counterpart is also a very strong character and equally willing to make his opinions known. The former Manchester United, Fulham and Northern Ireland striker returned to the province to take on the reins of his boyhood club almost 10 years ago. After a rocky start, Healy went on to win four titles in a row and has won six in total after wresting the Gibson Cup from Larne's grip this year. Duff and Healy know each other through mirrored careers and mutual friend and former teammate Keith Gillespie. Some have tried to dress this clash up as an orange v green affair, North v South, the tired tribalism of the island of Ireland. That is merely wallpaper as far as the managers are concerned, for both have more important matters to worry about. Yes, there are bragging rights for fans and glory for the victors, but when all is said and done, this tie is all about cold, hard cash. Linfield are historically the richest, most successful team in the Irish League, and at one stage that might have applied to the entire island. In recent years, though, Larne, Glentoran and, laterly, Coleraine have overtaken the Blues in terms of spending power, causing much angst in the Linfield boardroom. The powers that be have traditionally held a sense of entitlement, but their 57 titles suggest a sense of superiority would be more apt. They have to be No 1. They have to be champions. Failure is not an option. Deliver or you're out is the maxim at Windsor Park. After losing the title to Larne twice in a row, had Healy not won the league last year, the likelihood was that he would lose his job and the club would revert to part-time status. Linfield posted a loss of £662,000 last year and it is significant that new contract negotiations with Healy were held back until after the Champions League draw was made this week. Having come close on two occasions previously, Linfield are desperate to reach the group stages of European competition, for the lucrative prize money more than the prestige. Linfield last year announced it was exploring the possibility of injecting cash into the club by selling a minority shareholding. This was deemed necessary to compete against Larne, now Coleraine are flexing their financial muscle too. But so far the club's endeavours to bring in new money has proved fruitless, leaving lucrative European prize money as the remaining avenue to bringing millions into the coffers. The Blues are worried about losing their status as the elite club in Northern Ireland, never mind the entire island. Shamrock Rovers have emerged in recent years as the most powerful club in Ireland, North and South, as their European heroics last year proved. Rovers were pitted against Larne in the group stages of the Conference League, the first time any Irish League team had achieved the feat. Tiernan Lynch's side had won the Irish Premiership for two years in a row and had dreams of becoming the elite team in the land. There was much hype about this 'All-Ireland' clash, but on the night at Windsor Park, Rovers gave the Invermen a lesson, exposing a huge gulf in class in the 4-1 win. Trying to glean information from this formline is futile as Shels and Linfield are two different teams. Healy has been relatively quiet in the market since winning the title in May, signing only former Larne right-back Sean Brown. He feels the business he did earlier this year in signing Kieran Offord, Callumn Morrison and Alex Gorrin will bear fruit next season. A significant problem for Linfield is the fact that Shels are midway through their domestic campaign, whereas the Blues lost 4-1 to TNS in a behind-closed-doors friendly on Thursday. This undoubtedly gives the Dublin club another advantage, so Healy is up against it, but this is when he is at his most dangerous. He feeds off being written off, it galvanises him; he's like Popeye after eating spinach, and he loves being the unfancied underdog. Finally, there is the security aspect, but this has been overplayed. It's not Linfield v Rovers or Derry. The two teams have played before without issue and this is not the sort of tie that is likely to attract the mindless minority within Linfield's support. As with most clubs, the supporters who watch their team week in, week out are not troublemakers. They are passionate, vocal and proud, and they despair of the neanderthalic element that turns up for the occasional game. The battle will be won and lost on the field of play.

RTÉ News​

6 hours ago

• RTÉ News​

Club World Cup: Jobe Bellingham nets on first Borussia Dortmund start

Jobe Bellingham scored on his first start for Borussia Dortmund as the Bundesliga giants beat Mamelodi Sundowns 4-3 at the Club World Cup. Bellingham opened his Dortmund account on the stroke of half-time in Cincinnati, with the former Sunderland midfielder's deflected volley providing a 3-1 interval advantage. Lucas Ribeiro gave the Sundowns a shock 11th-minute lead with a brilliant strike. Felix Nmecha capitalised on an error from Sundowns goalkeeper Ronwen Williams five minutes later, and Serhou Guirassy nodded Dortmund ahead before Bellingham's special moment. Khuliso Mudau's own goal added to Sundowns' misery and the tie appeared over. But there was late drama from the South Africans as Iqraam Rayners and substitute Lebo Mothiba set up a grandstand finish. Inter Milan kept alive their hopes of making the last 16 with a late 2-1 comeback victory over Urawa Red Diamonds in Seattle. Ryoma Watanabe converted Takuro Kaneko's square pass to give Urawa a shock 11th-minute lead. Lautaro Martinez headed against the Urawa crossbar in the first half, but the Champions League finalists struggled to break down compact Japanese opponents. Urawa held out until 12 minutes from time when Martinez met Nicolo Barella's corner with a brilliant overhead kick. Inter's winner came in the second of four added minutes after the ball bounced around the Urawa box. Valentin Carboni was the calmest man in the penalty area to sidefoot home from eight yards and give Cristian Chivu his first win as Inter manager.

The Irish Sun

6 hours ago

• The Irish Sun

Ruben Amorim told to raid rivals for ‘headache' £26million striker and warned Gyokeres would ‘struggle' at Man Utd

RUBEN AMORIM has been told the solution to his goalscoring gremlins is a man once written off as an Everton flop — by his own fans. Guinea-Bissau striker 5 Manchester United have been urged to sign Everton's Beto Credit: Getty 5 Viktor Gyokeres has been linked with United throughout the summer Credit: EPA Even when David Moyes' return to Goodison finally ignited his career, many Toffees supporters remained unconvinced. Yet for all the sneers and cynics, one man reckons Beto would actually be the perfect partner for The Old Trafford gaffer has so far failed in attempts for Brentford's But Amorim should forget about chasing Europe's most-wanted hitmen — because the answer is just 35 miles away, down the M62. READ MORE ON FOOTBALL Fernando Lopes is the president of Portuguese amateurs Uniao Tires — where Beto made his footballing breakthrough — and he saw first-hand the star's talent. Lopes insists the Lisbon-born forward should actually have been ahead of He explained: 'Everyone thought Amorim would sign Gyokeres as he had him at Sporting but the Premier League is completely different to Portugal. 'Teams are more physical and compact at the back, it is quicker and more competitive. Most read in Football BEST ONLINE CASINOS - TOP SITES IN THE UK 'Gyokeres would struggle to play as a lone No 9 waiting for service. 'Beto's a more physical player, who fights with defenders and doesn't lose duels. 'Agent Onana' luring £60m+ Bryan Mbeumo to Man Utd instead of Tottenham? | Transfers Exposed 'He is a real headache for opponents — if he gets the service. 'In their golden era, United always scored a lot of goals from set-pieces but haven't had a proper striker for many seasons. 'Nowadays, teams have small, quick strikers or a false forward because there is an obsession for possession of the ball. 5 5 'Beto represents the typical old style, because of his physique, power and work-rate — plus he is very fast. 'When Moyes went to Everton he showed what a handful he is for defenders to stop. 'He'd be like Amorim's ace up his sleeve in a game of poker.' 5 After taking 35 games to hit four Prem goals under Sean Dyche — the man who signed him — he matched that tally in just five when Moyes returned. And Lopes reckons the grit he showed to silence the Goodison cynics would soon win over the doubters if he joined United. He said: 'One of Beto's attributes is the fighting spirit first injected at Tires. He has had the attitude of never giving up since he was a boy. 'I'd love to see him in a more attacking team because if he has the service, he will definitely score around 20. 'His physicality would be a tremendous advantage for United and he's so quick that you have to foul him to stop him. 'I know some will say my head is ruling my heart but for me he is the most effective choice for United — and I know the fans would love him.'