50 years after Emergency: India confronts its sterilisation past, potential of demographic future
In 1976 alone, more than eight million sterilisations were conducted across India, most of them vasectomies. Many of these were not voluntary.
As India marks the 50th anniversary of the Emergency imposed by then prime minister Indira Gandhi on June 25, 1975, memories of mass sterilisation campaigns — many carried out under coercion — continue to haunt survivors and influence public health discourse even today.
New Delhi, Jun 22 (PTI) In the 1970s, before the Emergency was officially imposed, children in some rural areas often ran around unclothed — until fear gripped families so tightly that even toddlers were dressed, not for modesty, but out of fear of forced sterilisation.
'It was a dark, dark period — no less than a war. We didn't know what would happen the next day. I remember being so afraid that my family didn't travel outside Delhi until the Emergency ended,' 78-year-old Ishrat Jahan, a resident of Okhla, Delhi said.
Amina Hasan, now 83 and living in Aligarh, still shudders at the memory.
'We were poor but had dignity. They took that away. In our area, men started hiding in fields and wells when officials came around. We felt hunted,' she recalled.
The pressure was relentless and indiscriminate. In 'Unsettling Memories', anthropologist Emma Tarlo documents how civil servants, factory workers and police personnel were often coerced into undergoing vasectomy.
'The officers said you could keep your job only if you got sterilised. I didn't have time to think,' a worker told her. 'I agreed because I had to save my job and bring up my family.' The stigma attached to male sterilisation was severe that in many communities, it was equated with emasculation. One anti-Emergency slogan scrawled across North India at the time summed up the sentiment: 'Nasbandi ke doot, Indira Gandhi ki loot' (Agents of sterilisation, Indira Gandhi's loot).
One of the most violent episodes unfolded at Delhi's Turkman Gate, a historic Muslim locality. In April 1976, when residents resisted demolitions linked to urban 'beautification' drives and refused to undergo sterilisation, police opened fire.
Entire families were displaced, homes were razed, but the area remains an enduring symbol of Emergency excesses.
Poonam Muttreja, Executive Director of the Population Foundation of India, said coercive measures during the Emergency 'set back reproductive rights for both men and women'.
'India's population for a long time was viewed through the narrow lens of fear and scarcity. But today, there's growing recognition that our people are our greatest asset,' she said.
'India's strength lies in its youthful population — its demographic dividend. But being the most populous country also brings enormous responsibility. It's not just about numbers — it's about investing in every life through education, health and opportunity,' she added.
Since the late 1970s, India has shifted from coercive family planning to voluntary participation and awareness. Today, female sterilisation accounts for the majority of procedures, although critics point out that the burden has disproportionately shifted to women.
The past, however, still casts a long shadow. Some states have proposed limiting government benefits to families with only two children.
'Yes, we are seeing troubling signs on both extremes. On one hand, there are calls for coercive population control — such as punitive two-child policies or conditional welfare schemes,' Muttreja said, adding that on the other end there is growing pronatalist rhetoric driven by fear of long-term population decline, with some suggesting incentives for more births.
Both approaches risk instrumentalising women's bodies for demographic goals, she said.
As India seeks to harness its population as a source of economic strength, experts stress the need for caution.
'The way forward lies in ensuring choice, not control,' Muttreja said.
'India's fertility rate is already below replacement level. The focus should be on addressing unmet need for contraception, improving healthcare access and empowering women through education and economic opportunity,' she added.
Population stabilisation will come not from pressure, but from trust, dignity and protecting reproductive rights, she said.
As the country remembers the Emergency, it also stands at a demographic crossroads — between past trauma and future potential. PTI UZM OZ OZ
This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
13-yr-old girl killed in bomb blast in Kaliganj
Kaliganj (Nadia): A 13-year-old girl standing outside her home with her mother was killed in a crude bomb blast in Molandi area of Kaliganj's Bara Chandghar village on Monday. Tamanna's mother, Sabina Yasmin, said a Trinamool Congress victory procession was passing by the house — before counting of bypoll votes had ended — when socket bombs were hurled in their direction. Witnesses said one of the bombs exploded near Tamanna, a Class 4 student and daughter of a CPM supporter, killing her on the spot. Aktar Sk, who was named by Sabina in her FIR, was arrested and police have launched a manhunt for other suspects. Krishnanagar SP Amarnath K, along with senior police officers, went to the spot and spoke to Sabina. "Prima facie, it appears that bomb splinters could have led to the death. One FIR-named accused has been arrested. We have identified more suspects," he told reporters. "There was a clash in this spot in 2023 in which the local OC was hurt," the SP added. Sabina said: "My daughter never leaves my side. She does not even go out to play. She sleeps with her head on my hand. She was holding my hand today when there was a sudden loud noise. My daughter was thrown to one side while I fell to the other. When I got up, one side of me was burning. Then I saw Tamanna lying there." by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Trade Bitcoin & Ethereum – No Wallet Needed! IC Markets Start Now Undo Blaming Trinamool for her child's death, Sabina said: "They did this because we didn't vote for them." CM Mamata Banerjee immediately assured strong action against the perpetrators. In a post on X, she said: "I am shocked and deeply saddened at the death of a young girl in an explosion at Barochandgar in Krishnanagar police district. My prayers and thoughts are with the family in their hour of grief. Police shall take strong and decisive legal action against the culprits at the earliest." Bengal Police, in a statement, said: "Raids are on in full swing to arrest those responsible for this extremely unfortunate death. Our prayers and thoughts are with the family members of the deceased." Bengal chief electoral officer Manoj Kumar Agarwal told mediapersons that he had asked for a report on the incident. Questioned about victory processions, he said the CEO's office was not informed of permission for such rallies, approval was sought from district police or the district magistrate. "I have already requested a report, what happened is extremely unfortunate," he added. BJP's IT cell head Amit Malviya said: "TMC's celebration ends with blood on its hands. Again. From TMC's victory rally in Muslim-majority Kaliganj bypoll, bombs were hurled, and in the chaos, a little girl—Tamanna Khatun, a Class 4 student—was killed. Let that sink in. A child. Murdered. While TMC danced to the tune of their 'victory'." Trinamool spokesperson Kunal Ghosh said: "What happened is a criminal act and will be punished. There are clear and unambiguous instructions by the state to the police that none should be spared. However, it also needs to be probed whether any overzealous person did it or there was a hidden agenda to malign Trinamool Congress."
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Who is Zohran Mamdani? New York City's Mayoral candidate proposes free child care, rent relief, and tax hikes for rich
With just a day to go until New York City's pivotal Democratic mayoral primary, State Assemblyman Zohran Mamdani is generating buzz as a progressive candidate, pushing a bold left-wing agenda and rising from relative obscurity to challenge the high-profile comeback bid of former Governor Andrew Cuomo. At just 33, Mamdani has positioned himself as the face of a new political generation — one focused on lowering the city's cost of living, expanding social services, and challenging the status quo. His campaign got a major boost with an endorsement from Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who called him 'the strongest to lead the pack,' citing his grassroots coalition of working-class New Yorkers. Still, Mamdani faces an uphill battle against Cuomo's well-financed campaign and deep name recognition. Cuomo has secured the backing of major unions and used the first televised debate to attack Mamdani's limited government experience, dismissing his record as 'three bills in 27 minutes of service.' Mamdani's personal story is central to his appeal. Born in Kampala, Uganda, he moved to New York City at age 7. He's the son of filmmaker Mira Nair and Columbia University professor Mahmood Mamdani. After becoming a US citizen and graduating from college, he helped found his university's Students for Justice in Palestine chapter — signaling early political engagement that would later shape his platform. Elected to the New York State Assembly in 2020, Mamdani represents parts of Queens and is best known legislatively for championing a pilot program offering free city buses. His mayoral platform expands on that vision, calling for free child care, rent freezes, new affordable housing, and higher taxes on the wealthy. Mamdani's platform and identity — he would be New York City's first Muslim and Indian American mayor — have earned him strong backing from younger, progressive voters. But his self-identification as a democratic socialist, and his support for the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement against Israel, could alienate more moderate Democrats and the city's influential Jewish electorate. During the first debate, Mamdani said Israel 'has the right to exist' but 'as a state with equal rights for all,' a stance that may deepen skepticism among centrist voters. He has also made headlines for saying he would have Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu arrested if he visited the city, citing an ICC war crimes warrant. Despite growing momentum, Mamdani remains unknown to many voters. He acknowledged in a campaign video that 'a third of New Yorkers still haven't heard of us' — a vulnerability he frames as an opportunity for growth. At a recent housing rally, Mamdani received a standing ovation for his speech. Yet, even among voters critical of both Cuomo and incumbent Mayor Eric Adams, his name is still catching on. Adams, facing political headwinds after a federal corruption probe (which the Trump administration later dropped), has opted to run as an independent in the general election, skipping the Democratic primary entirely. Mamdani insists that his campaign can bridge the city's ideological divides. 'There is no ideological majority in New York City,' he told the Associated Press. 'If you speak to the people directly about issues they care about, such as the sky-high cost of living, you can successfully build a coalition.' With the June 24 primary looming, Mamdani is betting on his grassroots network, social media presence, and populist messaging to propel him past a crowded field — and unseat one of New York's most well-known political figures. Whether that's enough to overcome Cuomo's name recognition and institutional backing remains to be seen.
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Asean stonewalling progress of FTA review talks with India: Official
New Delhi, Jun 23 (PTI) Asean nations are stonewalling the progress of the ongoing negotiations on the review of the existing free trade agreement in goods signed in 2009, and the talks are moving "very" slowly, an official said on Monday. The review of the agreement is a long-standing demand of Indian industry and India is looking forward to an upgraded pact, which will address the current asymmetries in bilateral trade and will make trade more balanced and sustainable. "So far, nine rounds of talks have been completed. They are going very slow. Very less progress is there. Asean is stonewalling the talks," the official, who did not wish to be named, said. After the implementation of the agreement, India's exports stood at only about USD 38-39 billion annually, while imports from the 10-nation Asean bloc have jumped to USD 86 billion, the official added. Asean countries have opened less number of tariff lines or product categories for India. India has offered duty concessions on over 71 per cent of the tariff of lines to Asean countries. Asean members include Brunei, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, and Vietnam. Indonesia has opened 41 per cent of its tariff lines, Vietnam 66.5 per cent and Thailand 67 per cent. "Is this a good agreement," the official wondered. The official added that the Indian industry is not at all happy with the agreement. A free trade agreement in goods between India and the 10-nation bloc ASEAN (Association of Southeast Asian Nations) was signed in 2009. The ASEAN trade deal came into force in January 2010. In August 2023, both sides announced a complete review of the existing agreement in goods by 2025. ASEAN as a group is India's one of the major trade partners with about an 11 per cent share in the country's global trade. India is asking for a review to eliminate barriers and misuse of the pact. Recently speaking at the India Global Forum (IGF) session on UK-India Science, Technology and Innovation Collaboration at the Science Museum in London, Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal said, "There was a point of time 15 years ago when we were more focused on doing FTAs with countries who were our competitors. So if I am doing an ASEAN agreement, it really is silly because (that is) opening up my market to my competitors, many of whom have now become the B team of China". "So effectively and indirectly, I have opened up my market for goods that find their way from China into India," the commerce minister has said.
