Judge rejects auditor general's bid to access Vitalité's internal audits on travel nurses
A New Brunswick judge has rejected the auditor general's bid to access Vitalité Health Network's internal audits of its controversial travel-nurse contracts.
Auditor General Paul Martin sought a court order to compel the regional health authority to disclose the documents as part of his investigation into the management and use of private agency nurses by Vitalité, Horizon and the Department of Social Development between Jan. 1, 2022, and Feb. 29, 2024.
But Court of King's Bench Chief Justice Tracey DeWare dismissed his application, saying she's not satisfied the Auditor General Act provides an explicit waiver of Vitalité's claims of litigation privilege or solicitor-client privilege.
These privileges are "foundational to our legal system," DeWare wrote in her decision, dated June 2.
"The Court can only endorse a legislative interpretation which abrogates these privileges in circumstances where the intention of the Legislature can be clearly discerned to have contemplated the scope of such an exceptional authority."
Vitalité is entitled to costs of $2,000, she ruled.
CBC News requested an interview with Martin, including whether he intends to appeal. In response, his office sent an emailed statement, saying he received notice of the dismissal last week and is "currently assessing the next steps."
Vitalité did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
In a scathing report last June, Martin concluded Vitalité spent $123 million in travel-nurse contracts dating back to 2022, when the regional health authority signed its first deal with Canadian Health Labs. The Ontario-based agency charged about $300 an hour per nurse — roughly six times what a local staff nurse earns.
"The contracts with private nursing agencies were not reflective of best practices and did not demonstrate value for money," Martin said at the time.
As part of that audit, launched in March 2024, Martin requested "various information and documents" from Vitalité, including internal audit reports on the use of agency nurses.
Internal audits were to probe 'irregularities'
Vitalité refused to provide the internal audit reports. It had commissioned the audits after it "noticed irregularities in some of the services rendered by the agency nurses which were not in conformity with the terms set out in the governing contracts," according to DeWare's decision.
No details are provided, but "in order to investigate potential deficiencies in the services rendered by the nursing agencies, [Vitalité] commissioned an internal audit of the performance of one of the contracts spanning the period between August 2022 and June 2023."
Vitalité alleges these audits "confirmed the existence of deficiencies in the performance of the agency nurses' contract with one of the agencies — Canadian Health Labs," DeWare wrote.
The company has since launched three lawsuits against Vitalité for allegedly breaching three of its contracts — two expired and one still in force. It's seeking compensation, including punitive, aggravated and special damages.
Vitalité has filed statements of defence, as well as counterclaims in all three cases.
Martin argued act covers privileged information
Martin applied to the court for an injunction on Oct. 9. "Under the Auditor General Act, I have rights of access to any information relating to the performance of my duties," he wrote in a sworn affidavit. This includes privileged information, he argued.
Section 13 (a) of the act says the auditor general is entitled to "free access at all convenient times to information, including files, documents, records, agreements and contracts, despite that they may be confidential or private, that relates to the fulfilment of his or her responsibilities."
According to Martin, changes the legislature made to that section in 2014, including the auditor general's ability to obtain "private and confidential" information, were specifically made to address this type of situation, DeWare wrote. Discussions surrounding the amendments demonstrate there was a clear desire to enhance the auditor general's authority to obtain necessary information, Martin argued.
Vitalité says disclosure would prejudice litigation
Vitalité countered that disclosure of the internal audit reports "would prejudice its ability to prosecute" the action against Canadian Health Labs, according to Deware, and that Section 13 (a) of the act "does not explicitly displace or supersede otherwise valid claims of litigation or solicitor-client privilege."
If the New Brunswick Legislature had intended for the section to override litigation or solicitor-client privilege, it would have explicitly stated so in the statute, as it does in the Ombudsman Act, Vitalité argued.
DeWare noted the Ontario Court of Appeal recently upheld a trial court decision that the Auditor General Act of that province, which, similar to New Brunswick's, does not contain a specific waiver of a valid privilege, "did not authorize access nor compel disclosure of privileged information."
The Supreme Court of Canada also considered a similar issue when interpreting a section of Alberta's Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act in 2016, said DeWare. The country's highest court ruled legislative language must be interpreted restrictively when determining if solicitor-client privilege may be set aside.
Act not explicit, judge rules
"While I appreciate the [auditor general's] argument, the addition of the words 'confidential and private' to section 13 indicates an expanded scope to the information which could be sought, it falls short of explicitly stating an intention to have access to 'privileged' documents," DeWare said.
She pointed out that with the 2014 amendments, the legislature didn't adopt the "explicit" language of Nova Scotia's Auditor General Act — "solicitor-client privilege, litigation privilege, settlement privilege and public interest immunity."
"The language of the Nova Scotia statute could not be any clearer."
Section 13 (a) of the New Brunswick act "does not grant the Auditor General the authority to require production of documents or information which are properly subject to a solicitor-client or litigation privilege," DeWare ruled.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Globe and Mail
25 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
'Only Lean Teams Remaining': Intel Stock (NASDAQ:INTC) Slips as Intel Outsources Marketing
Imagine my surprise to discover that, last year, almost to the day, I made the joke that I was about to make here today. There, I pointed out a Dilbert strip that noted that cutting 'marcom', or marketing / communications, is part of a 'death spiral' for businesses. Chip stock Intel (INTC) decided to let history repeat itself nearly 11 months later by outsourcing its marketing department altogether. Intel shares dropped similarly to what happened the last time they cut marketing, and lost modestly in Friday afternoon's trading. Confident Investing Starts Here: Easily unpack a company's performance with TipRanks' new KPI Data for smart investment decisions Receive undervalued, market resilient stocks right to your inbox with TipRanks' Smart Value Newsletter Back in August 2024, Intel was planning to cut its marketing department as part of a move to cut costs, a move that has only expanded with the arrival of CEO Lip-Bu Tan. And now, the cuts continue, as Intel moves its marketing operations to Accenture (ACN). As it turns out, Intel will be turning to a combination of Accenture and artificial intelligence (AI) to do the job. Worse, Intel believes that Accenture will '…do a better job connecting with customers than Intel's own marketing organization has,' reports suggest, which is absolutely not a phrase you want on your resume. The result? 'The transition of our marketing and operations functions will result in significant changes to team structures, including potential headcount reductions, with only lean teams remaining,' noted a statement from Intel. There is also a possibility that some elements of Intel's marketing will be obliged to train their replacements. Another Price Cut As bad as the news was for Intel's marketing operations, it did get better for Intel's customer base. Reports noted that Intel had once again cut prices on the Core Ultra 7 265KF processor. This is the second such cut in as many months, reports note. The processor is now not only priced at its lowest level ever, but is now 40% cheaper than it was when it first hit shelves. The downside, for those considering a processor buy, is that the F variants—of which this is one—does not include a graphics processing unit (GPU) included. Thus, those using this processor will need a separate graphics card to go with it. Still, with that kind of price cut, a better graphics card could be added to the list for about the same price, and potentially, some savings as well. Is Intel a Buy, Hold or Sell? Turning to Wall Street, analysts have a Hold consensus rating on INTC stock based on one Buy, 26 Holds and four Sells assigned in the past three months, as indicated by the graphic below. After a 30.88% loss in its share price over the past year, the average INTC price target of $21.30 per share implies 0.35% upside potential. See more INTC analyst ratings Disclosure Disclaimer & Disclosure Report an Issue
CTV News
30 minutes ago
- CTV News
Saskatchewan exempts Canada Disability Benefit from income assistance programs
The SAID program provides long-term income support and services to those with disabilities. (Pexels) The Government of Saskatchewan has announced that the Canada Disability Benefit will be exempt from its core income assistance programs. This means that people with disabilities can receive up to $200 per month in additional federal income without affecting their provincial income assistance benefits. Social Services Minister Terry Jenson says this will put more money in the pockets of Saskatchewan income assistance clients. 'Our government is committed to supporting people with disabilities, and we brought our Saskatchewan perspective to collaborations with the Government of Canada on this new program,' Jenson said in a news release. The province says as part of the 2025-26 budget, Saskatchewan Income Support (SIS) and Saskatchewan Assured Income for Disability (SAID) benefits have increased by two per cent. The SAID program provides long-term income support and services to those with disabilities. SAID benefits include a living income benefit, disability income benefit, and exceptional need income benefit, varying depending on individual needs. As of April 1, 2025, annual earned income exemptions have been updated to $7,500 for singles, $8,700 for couples, and $9,500 for families
Globe and Mail
40 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Here's Why Wall Street Is Bullish on AI Stock Vertiv Holdings (VRT)
Vertiv Holdings (VRT) stock has recovered strongly from the lows seen in April and has risen more than 11% over the past month, as concerns about a slowdown in AI (artificial intelligence) spending have eased. VRT stock has rallied more than 30% in the past year. The data center infrastructure company is gaining from the strong demand for its energy-efficient cooling and power solutions that are required to support the ongoing AI boom. Confident Investing Starts Here: Vertiv: Riding the AI Wave Vertiv impressed investors with solid Q1 earnings beat. The company's Q1 2025 revenue grew 24%, while adjusted EPS (earnings per share) increased by about 49%. The AI infrastructure company also raised its full-year guidance, reflecting confidence in navigating macro challenges and mitigating the impact of tariffs announced by the Trump administration. 'Our partnership with Nvidia continues to place us at the heart of industrial-scale AI factory deployments,' said VRT CEO Giordano Albertazzi. Recently, Vertiv further strengthened its collaboration with chip giant Nvidia (NVDA) and announced an energy-efficient 142kW cooling and power reference architecture for the latter's GB300 NVL72 platform. Overall, VRT is confident about its growth ahead, with a 10% rise in Q1 2025 backlog to $7.9 billion compared to the end of 2024. Analysts Raise Price Target for VRT Stock on AI Demand Recently, Bank of America analyst Andrew Obin reiterated a Buy rating on Vertiv stock and increased the price target to $140 (17.8% upside potential) from $135. The 5-star analyst emphasized that the rapid advancement of AI is transforming the data center infrastructure landscape, driving robust demand for power, cooling, and advanced hardware. BofA expects data center spending to grow at a 13% CAGR (compound annual growth rate) from 2024 to 2028, reaching $532 billion. In fact, he expects infrastructure-related spending to climb at an even faster 16% CAGR. Notably, Obin believes that Vertiv, Eaton (ETN), and Johnson Controls (JCI) are well-positioned to leverage the shift toward high-density racks and advanced cooling solutions like direct-to-chip liquid cooling. He also named GE Vernova (GEV) as a top pick in the power generation space, citing its potential to meet rising demand. With only 5% of existing data centers equipped to handle AI workloads, Obin expects a massive upgrade cycle ahead. Also, with AI-driven demand showing no signs of slowing, Obin is upbeat about these stocks. Meanwhile, Citi analyst Andrew Kaplowitz increased the price target for VRT stock to $130 (9.4% upside potential) from $98 and reaffirmed a Buy rating. Following a meeting with the management, the 5-star analyst stated that he is confident that Vertiv remains well-positioned for huge industrial market outgrowth, thanks to durable AI/data center-related growth (Citi forecasts overall global data center IT load growth at 14% CAGR through 2030) and its focus on innovation. Kaplowitz also highlighted VRT's efforts to mitigate tariff headwinds over time. Citing the possibility for margin expansion, strong underlying fundamentals, and increased confidence in improving performance, Kaplowitz increased the EV/EBITDA target multiple for VRT stock to 21x from 16x. Is VRT a Good Stock to Buy? Overall, Vertiv Holdings stock scores a Strong Buy consensus rating based on 12 Buys and two Holds. The average VRT stock price target of $116.93 indicates a possible downside of 1.6% from current levels, following the strong rally over the past year.
