Harvey Weinstein NYC trial judge calls mistrial in accuser Jessica Mann's rape case

Chaos in the jury room led a judge Thursday to call a mistrial for the one remaining charge against disgraced film mogul Harvey Weinstein, a rape allegation by one-time actress Jessica Mann a day after he was found guilty of sexually assault in his Manhattan retrial.
After an eight-week trial in Manhattan Supreme Court, jurors found Weinstein, 73, guilty of criminal sex act against former TV production assistant Miriam Haley, but acquitted him of the same charge against a second accuser, Polish model Kaja Sokola.
But the jury couldn't reach a decision on the third accuser, one-time actress Jessica Mann, and the jury foreman refused to rejoin his fellow jurors after reporting Wednesday that he felt threatened by one of them telling him he'd 'see me outside.'
The mistrial means prosecutors will have to decide whether to pursue Mann's allegations at a third trial, again subjecting her to days of direct testimony and cross-examination on the witness stand. Mann testified at Weinstein's 2020 trial as well.
Deliberations went off the skids when it came to Mann, with the jury foreman asking on three separate occasions to speak to the judge and attorneys away from his fellow jurors.
The foreman on Wednesday told Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Curtis Farber that another juror had threatened him, 'You gonna see me outside' during a shouting match, because he wouldn't change his position.
That led to calls for a mistrial by Weinstein's lawyer, Arthur Aidala, who said the juror was the victim of a crime and the judge should call 911.
Farber released the jury for the day and asked them to return Thursday, but not before asking if they had reached a verdict in any of the charges — and they had, regarding Haley and Sokola.
Later, the foreman told Farber that the jury had reached a decision on Haley and Sokola days earlier, on Friday, and their decision was unanimous. When the judge asked him if he'd been coerced, he said 'no,' and responded, 'My own decision.'
The foreman said he'd be willing to return to the court building, but didn't commit to rejoining his fellow jurors in the jury room.
Mann accused Weinstein of raping her in 2013, but said she maintained a complicated relationship with the film producer for years after. Haley and Sokola said Weinstein forcibly performed oral sex on them in separate incidents in 2006.
Weinstein was charged with third-degree rape regarding Mann, which is punishable by up to four years in prison.
The criminal sex act charge he was convicted up is a far more serious offense, and carries a maximum 25-year sentence. Criminal sex act, which used to be called sodomy, involves forced anal or oral sex.
Mann and Haley also took the stand in Weinstein's 2020 trial, which ended in a guilty verdict and a 23-year prison sentence. But last year, the New York State Court of Appeals overturned that conviction, saying the trial judge should have never allowed other women whose allegations were not included in the charges to testify against him and establish a pattern of predatory behavior.
Regardless of the trial's outcome, Weinstein wasn't going to go free — he was sentenced to 16 years behind bars after his conviction at a 2022 trial in Los Angeles on separate rape and sexual assault charges.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Yahoo

12 hours ago

• Yahoo

The Internet is Pointing Out This Massive Flaw in Johnny Depp's #MeToo 'Crash Test Dummy' Argument

Johnny Depp would like you to know that he's not staging a comeback — mostly because, as he told The Sunday Times on Saturday, 'I didn't go anywhere.' He's been busy directing films, painting skeletons, sipping red wine under a Hunter S. Thompson poster in Soho, and, more recently, positioning himself as a victim of cancel culture and, somehow, the #MeToo movement. 'I was like a crash test dummy for MeToo,' he told the paper. 'It was before Harvey Weinstein.' The quote came buried under layers of aesthetic melancholy and disdain for modern Hollywood, but it didn't take long for the internet to call out what many saw as the core problem with Depp's narrative: it simply doesn't hold up. More from SheKnows Does Amber Heard Have a Partner? Inside Her Dating Life After Welcoming Twins Let's break this down. Depp's ex-wife, Amber Heard, accused him of abuse in 2016 — a year before The New York Times published its Pulitzer-winning exposé on Weinstein, the catalyst most historians of the movement consider its public launch. But even setting aside that timeline, Depp's assertion doesn't square with his own story. In court, he claimed that Heard weaponized her accusations to gain #MeToo relevance. If she was, as he argued during the 2022 Virginia trial, 'seeking fame,' how could Depp simultaneously have been the movement's unknowing test subject? This is what people online have latched onto in the wake of his new interview. As one X user wrote, 'Weird how during the trial, he claimed that Amber wanted MeToo fame… and now it's that he was a pre-test crash dummy. Cannot keep his narrative straight even now, just says whatever he needs to so he can victimize himself.' The victim claim also rings false to many who observed Depp's life during and after the trials. Yes, he lost his Fantastic Beasts role in 2020. But even in the thick of it, Depp was still starring in movies (Minamata, Jeanne du Barry), fronting Dior campaigns, playing guitar with his band Hollywood Vampires, and being awarded lifetime achievement prizes in Spain. In 2025 alone, he's directed a new film, Modi, acted alongside Penélope Cruz in Day Drinker, and booked five different projects — all filmed in Spain, which also happens to be where Heard now lives. Some fans have even raised concerns about the frequency of Depp's appearances in her adopted country, calling it, quote, 'extremely creepy.' Meanwhile, Heard — who moved to Madrid in 2023 to focus on raising her daughter — has largely stayed out of the public eye. She was awarded $2 million in her countersuit against Depp's attorney, but endured widespread harassment online and in person, with Depp's fans reportedly camping outside courtrooms and screaming threats. This context has not been forgotten. Reddit commenters have responded to Depp's latest claims with blunt disbelief: 'Can this man just go away please,' one wrote. 'You won one of your lawsuits in the most heinous and retrograde way possible. Why do you still have to paint yourself as some wronged victim??' And yet, that's the through-line of Depp's narrative — a story shaped less by consistency than by a persistent desire to cast himself as misunderstood, unfairly judged, and deeply wronged. Even as his Dior ads air, his artwork sells for millions, and Hollywood producers line up to toast him, he insists on seeing his career as a cautionary tale. Which, to be fair, it might be. Just not in the way he of SheKnows 23 Age-Gap Couples Who Met When One of Them Was Still a Child Everything to Know About Leonardo DiCaprio's 27-Year-Old GF Vittoria Ceretti A Look Back at Prince William's Sexiest Photos in Celebration of the Future King

USA Today

2 days ago

• USA Today

Three-week rollercoaster: Klaudia Sygula hit full reset after unfortunate circumstances rocked UFC debut

Klaudia Sygula hasn't been on the roster for long, but there have been more ups and downs than many UFC athletes encounter in their entire careers. If the name isn't ringing a bell, Sygula (6-2 MMA, 0-1 UFC) gets why. Her debut wasn't great. She knows it, but says that wasn't her. Even as she tries to explain the circumstances of her second-round TKO loss to Melissa Mullins in November, she cuts herself off at even the slightest chance her reasoning could be construed as an excuse. But she pushes through, because a story is a story. Three weeks before that November fight, is when the UFC offer – her dream – came true. Sygula was initially an economics major. She's smart, her grades were good, and school was the priority. When she first signed up for a karate gym, the coach scolded her because of her lack of dedication. But her passion was in the classroom until MMA took over her life and became her obsession. So when that offer came through from Mick Maynard, Sygula couldn't say no. But the time period leading up to that seven-and-a-half minutes inside the cage was a fight within itself. "To be honest, my debut was not good," Sygula recently told MMA Junkie. "One day after I got the UFC contract, my coach ended up in prison. It was not an easy situation for me." Renowned Polish coach Andrzej Koscielski was arrested in October. His arrest was reportedly linked to a 22-year-old murder cold case. Koscielski remains in prison. "He's still in prison. It is not an easy situation," Sygula said. "I think I shouldn't talk more about it. At this moment, it was really hard for me because I was left alone and I had to rely only on myself, so it was not easy." It's never ideal to have to find a new training home as a fighter. But three weeks before your big break fight? Even worse. Sygula's boyfriend and another relatively inexperienced training partner made the trek over to the United States – but it's a trip that almost didn't even happen. It wasn't until Tuesday of fight week that Sygula secured her travel papers. "I took this fight as a replacement," Sygula said. "I wasn't in good shape. I'm not looking for excuses, but the situation was not easy. I didn't have visa. It was hard to take a replacement. I had 12 kilograms to cut. It was not a good camp and I was not in good shape – and this was my debut in the UFC. I didn't show myself and it hurt the most." "I got my fight three weeks before, but I got my visa on Tuesday. On Wednesday, I had flight. On Thursday, I was in Las Vegas. I had to make my weight. On Friday, was the weigh-ins and Saturday, the fight. At that moment, I thought, 'It's not important for me. I'm ready and everything is OK.'" The loss was a disappointment for Sygula, who had to reroute her whole career in the wake of victory. However, as fate as it, Sygula wasn't the only Polish fighter on her debut card. Former UFC title challenger Karolina Kowalkiewicz fought on the same card and lost. The two met up in the hotel afterward, and Sygula found the positive change she was in dire need of. "(Kowalkiewicz) came with her coach Marcos 'Parrumpa' (De Matta) and that is how I met him," Sygula said. "Unfortunately, we both lost our fights. After the event, we met together in her room to talk about this, to cry together, to eat something. I talked a lot with her coach, with coach Marcos. He convinced me to come to Florida, to ATT. He said one important sentence that stayed with me, which was if I want to be a professional fighter, I have to have professional people around me. I was thinking a lot about this. I thought that I have to change something if I want to stay in the UFC, if I want to change something. I made the decision that I'd come to ATT for the first time to see how it works, to see how their coaches are and how their sparring partners are." For this camp, Sygula found herself brushing shoulders, grappling, and sparring with the likes of Dakota Ditcheva, Kayla Harrison, Bia Mesquita, Yana Santos, and others. She enters her second promotional appearance Saturday at UFC on ABC 8 in Baku, Azerbaijan feeling like a totally different fighter. "I'm sure they will see me, 'real' Klaudia," Sygula said. "Because in the first fight, I didn't show anything. As I've said before, the UFC deserves more. The people, my supporters, they deserve more. I hope that this time, they will see, 'real' Klaudia. I think that will be a better version of me."

Chicago Tribune

5 days ago

• Chicago Tribune

Daywatch: Cook County preparing for $211M budget deficit for 2026

Good morning, Chicago. Cook County is predicting a $211.4 million budget shortfall for 2026, a relatively modest gap that officials said was more of an estimate than usual thanks to extraordinary uncertainty coming out of Washington. County Board President Toni Preckwinkle, who has been able to boast budgets free of taxes, fees or layoffs for the last several years, told reporters at a Tuesday briefing that the 2026 projection is the most 'problematic,' and cautioned that 'this is our best guess.' The county is expecting a general fund shortfall of $102.6 million, thanks mostly to higher wages and fringe benefits when its current contracts with union employees expire. Its health fund, meanwhile, is projecting a $108.8 million deficit thanks to a significant drop in patient revenues. Read the full story from the Tribune's A.D. Quig. Here are the top stories you need to know to start your day, including: the next step in a fierce preservation battle over Pilsen's St. Adalbert Catholic Church and hot Chicago condiments to buy over and over again. Today's eNewspaper edition | Subscribe to more newsletters | Asking Eric | Horoscopes | Puzzles & Games | Today in History The head of Chicago's U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement field office defended the conduct and decorum of federal agents who have ramped up arrests of undocumented immigrants, which has incited clashes with elected officials, immigration advocates and protesters. On Monday, three U.S. citizens were detained by ICE after allegedly assaulting an officer in Chicago, according to a Department of Homeland Security spokesperson. In an interview yesterday with the Tribune, Samuel Olson, ICE's Chicago field office director, explained that 'the last thing (the agents) want to do is to have to arrest somebody who's assaulting them or impeding them from doing their jobs.' A downstate congresswoman and a north suburban state senator are the first Illinois elected officials to publicly acknowledge being named in notes kept by the 57-year-old alleged shooter charged with assassinating the Democratic leader of the Minnesota House and her husband. The calls over police dispatch came fast and furious, like they always do. 'Shots fired at the police!' one officer shouted. But there was just a single shot fired, and it was a cop who pulled the trigger, resulting in the first time in nearly four decades that a Chicago police officer was mistakenly fatally shot by a fellow cop while on duty. Now, the better part of two weeks after tactical Officer Krystal Rivera died in the friendly fire incident, investigators are still searching for the suspect who sparked a brief foot pursuit that ultimately led to the fatal gunfire in a Chatham apartment building. The City Council's Zoning Committee unanimously approved a plan to give the shuttered St. Adalbert Catholic Church a landmark designation, teeing up a final vote today. But the Polish parishioners who long sought the preservation status left City Hall infuriated by what they described as a last-second 'backroom deal' that sets up the sale of the Archdiocese of Chicago land to a nondenominational church. The Birth Center of Chicago, in the North Center neighborhood, told patients in recent days that it planned to temporarily suspend services, said Ariel Swift, director of outreach and education for the birth center's parent company Birth Partners Inc. The birth center will stop delivering babies after June and likely halt prenatal care in early July, Swift said. A north suburban toy company challenged President Donald Trump's tariffs in front of the Supreme Court on Tuesday in a long shot bid to press the justices to quickly decide whether they are legal. Chicago's outdoor public pools will be open daily this summer, for the first time since the COVID-19 pandemic led to a lingering lifeguard shortage. In a rare scheduling quirk in the middle of June, the St. Louis Cardinals and Milwaukee Brewers were both in town for the first time this season, playing on opposite sides of town, writes Paul Sullivan. The Cubs played host to the Brewers last night at Wrigley Field, while the White Sox took on the Cardinals at Rate Field. It was a National League Central smorgasbord, though the hors d'oeuvres were perhaps a little more enticing on the North Side, where a rat was spotted wandering the concourse a few hours before the game, looking for dining options. In Chicago, small-batch makers are producing some of Ahmed Ali Akbar's favorite sauces right now — he brings them out when he hosts and frequently ends up sending guests home with a spare bottle and the sauce's story. Anne Burrell, the Food Network star best known for hosting the channel's hit show 'Worst Cooks in America,' died yesterday. She was 55.