When everyone is having a menty B
If you've been on Instagram recently, you may have seen Insta stories of giddy teens dumping water – which don't even contain ice – on their friends in the name of #SpeakYourMIND.
Influencers give pretty speeches in which they claim 'Mental health is important!' and give a cheerful thumbs-up of support.
According to its own mission statement, Active Minds, the American non-profit organisation behind this latest ice bucket challenge, claims to foster a 'diverse movement of peer mental health champions' that 'transform mental health norms across society'.
And while that is a well-intentioned cause, what exactly does it have to do with mental health awareness?
The non-profit's website bats around words such as depression, anxiety, advocacy and change, but it's unclear what exactly this organisation is doing with the US$300,000 (about RM1.29mil) raised by the ice bucket challenge – and the actual impact of these efforts is murky to discern at best.
Besides, if the success of the original ice bucket challenge in raising awareness of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) was questionable, why do we think it would work for mental health now?
A little knowledge is not enough
The problem nowadays with mental health isn't that it's taboo to discuss; it's how much we've turned mental health terms into buzzwords and online trends that spread misinformation.
Youths may think their limited exposure to, and experience with, mental illness, be it in health class or through a stint of now-very-common depression or anxiety, means that they understand all there is to the endless ocean that is mental health.
This false security in knowledge means that they aren't likely to seek out more information and may dismiss people who tell them to educate themselves.
For example, when I asked people at my lunch table to stop gossiping about a classmate's recent suicide, I was told that I was overreacting and that they 'understood' because of going through a rough patch during Covid-19 – despite knowing that I had a close friend die under similar circumstances the week before.
And now these youths are being turned into 'champions'.
Don't get me wrong.
It's a good thing that there are 'more than 15,000 young adults... (who are) passionate advocates and educators for mental health,' as Active Minds reports.
But this may be like having someone with melanoma (a skin cancer) advocating for those dealing with leukaemia (a blood cancer) and claiming they have personal connections to this battle because of their experience with melanoma.
Instead of actually educating themselves about serious mental illnesses, these youths may be convinced to douse themselves in water and throw around terms such as 'Menty B', meaning 'mental breakdown'.
Romanticising mental illness
The danger of using these terms so flippantly, particularly as internet slang, is illustrated by the 'prevalence inflation hypothesis', as presented in a 2023 paper by researchers from Britain and Australia.
I repeatedly hear kids say they're having a panic attack when in fact they're mildly stressed by an upcoming test – so much to the point that I may not get the help I need for an actual panic attack.
As kids hear these disorders referenced more often, through trends such as the ice bucket challenge, they may 'misinterpret milder and more transient forms of distress as mental health problems,' the researchers conclude.
ALSO READ: The difference between being mentally unhealthy and mentally ill
Active Mind's #SpeakYourMIND promotes exactly this.
If we hear the concept enough times, we may start applying it to our daily lives, leading to incorrect self-diagnoses.
We're following the trend of romanticising mental illnesses.
As a Texas State University student put it: 'We are a culture of extremes, and attempts to destigmatise mental illness have inadvertently glamorised it', so much so that it's seen as having ''beautifully tragic' qualities'.
Life-threatening conditions have been turned into what can only be called microtrends, but many people still don't under- stand what those illnesses entail.
Seasonal affective disorder, better known as SAD, isn't just when you feel tired in the winter.
People who have schizophrenia aren't dangers to society, and bulimia and anorexia certainly aren't the same thing!
We must reform our use of mental health language so that we're not propagating stereotypes and allowing them to be turned into an 'interesting' facet of our personalities.
This all begins with a more critical look at what the #SpeakYourMIND ice bucket challenge actually is: a dumb trend for people chasing internet virality while trying to look cute, who are not raising awareness for mental health. – By Abigail AuYeung/Chicago Tribune/Tribune News Service
Abigail AuYeung is a senior (final-year student) at Hinsdale Central High School near Chicago in the United States.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
7 hours ago
- The Star
'Dopamine detox': Why it pays to put your phone away
A bit of chocolate here, a few minutes on Instagram there – these daily rituals bring us little boosts of happiness. But only in the short term. Sooner or later, feelings of overstimulation and stress start to creep in. — Photo: Zacharie Scheurer/dpa BERLIN: What do you do while sitting in a doctor's waiting room? Or after settling into a train seat on your commute home from work? Or standing at the kitchen stove as the noodle water creeps towards a boil? If you're like many people, you reach for your smartphone to check the latest on social media. From a psychological standpoint, it's an easily explicable behaviour: Video snippets are entertaining and ever-ready diversions. They give you a quick hit of happiness, but it quickly subsides. Responsible for this is the "feel-good" chemical messenger dopamine, a key component of the brain's reward system, explains Dr Steffen Häfner, a specialist in psychosomatic medicine and psychotherapy. Its release reinforces behaviours favourable for survival, reproduction and well-being, such as eating, sex and social interactions. A between-meal chocolate bar or cup of coffee also provide a dopamine fix. So what's wrong with pleasurable feelings? Well, too much of a good thing can be bad for you – ask a chocolate lover. As for smartphone use, subjecting your brain to lots of stimuli can lead to overstimulation, "the release of large amounts of dopamine potentially heightening psychological stress, unease or difficulty concentrating," Häfner says. When you reach the satiation point, your brain needs greater amounts of stimuli to get the kick it craves, "similar to an addiction mechanism," as Häfner describes it. A possible sign of overstimulation is reluctance to put away your smartphone in favour of, say, playing a time-consuming board game or watching a feature-length film. Activities like these don't give you a quick dopamine kick and therefore lack appeal. So what's the way out of overstimulation towards a healthy balance? "Dopamine detox." It's not about abstaining from pleasurable activities, but rather reducing stimuli so that your nervous system can relax again. Here are four ways to do it: Cut down on your evening screen time, or eliminate it altogether. Deactivate push notifications. Don't always listen to podcasts or music while you're doing something else, but focus on them. Above all, incorporate "analogue" activities into your day, such as reading, painting or taking walks. Should you keep catching yourself seeking a quick dopamine kick by eating sweets, drinking coffee or shopping online, you can refrain from these things for a while. As difficult as it may be in the beginning, it'll pay off if you stick to it. You'll find that your powers of perception sharpen again, and pleasure doing everyday things will return. Handling stimuli mindfully, Häfner says, can help reduce stress and boost your psychological resilience. – dpa
The Star
2 days ago
- The Star
Uncooked rice, ultra-processed food included in free meals programme
A student of state junior high school (SMPN) 1 Denpasar in Bali shows a variety of food items received as part of the government free meals programme on March 17, 2025. - Antara JAKARTA: The government's free nutritious meal programme has once again come under public scrutiny following reports of uncooked ingredients and ultra-processed foods being distributed in South Tangerang, Banten, as schools begin their holiday break this week. A foundation operating the Cempaka Putih Nutrition Fulfillment Service Unit (SPPG) in East Ciputat, South Tangerang, Banten, admitted to including uncooked rice in its meal packages, alongside protein sources, fruit and ultra-high temperature milk so the food 'could be taken home and stored for longer periods'. The kitchen stated via its Instagram account, @sppg_yasmit_cemput, earlier this week that the menu was adjusted due to most schools being on break. However, the National Nutrition Agency (BGN) that oversees the programme emphasised that it had never instructed any SPPG to distribute raw food items. 'Distributing raw food is not part of the free nutritious meal policy. There should be no such initiative,' BGN head Dadan Hindayana told The Jakarta Post on Thursday (June 19), adding that the agency had ordered the Cempaka Putih SPPG to immediately halt the practice. 'SPPG units are responsible for continuing to provide meals during school holidays, but only if students and teachers are willing to come to the school. If they don't, then no service should be provided,' Dadan explained. While the BGN has yet to issue an official policy on how the free meals programme should operate during the school break, Dadan confirmed the agency was currently drafting technical guidelines to address such situations. 'If students are able to come to school, meals will be provided as fresh, ready-to-eat food,' the agency emphasised. Otherwise, the distribution will be adjusted to prioritise other eligible groups, including pregnant women, breastfeeding mothers and toddlers. The programme, a flagship initiative from President Prabowo Subianto's election campaign last year, seeks to tackle the country's persistently high stunting rate, which affects more than 21 per cent of children across Indonesia's population of approximately 282 million. The government initially allocated Rp 71 trillion (US$$.3 billion) from the 2025 state budget for the programme, later increasing it by an additional Rp 100 trillion to expand its coverage. In May, it announced that the BGN would receive around Rp 217 trillion next year for the implementation of the free meals programme, the largest allocation among 98 ministries and agencies. Despite receiving high-level attention from the President, the programme continues to face challenges, including food safety concerns. The latest incident occurred at a kindergarten in Kulon Progo, Yogyakarta, where several students reportedly suffered vomiting and diarrhoea after consuming free meals on Tuesday. The Kulon Progo Health Agency promptly dispatched a team to investigate the incident. Agency head Sri Budi expressed hope that the responsible SPPG unit would learn from the case and improve its operational standards, particularly regarding sanitation, food ingredient selection and storage. 'Schools must also remain vigilant. They need to inspect the food provided to children to prevent similar incidents from recurring,' he said, as quoted by - The Jakarta Post/ANN
The Star
2 days ago
- The Star
Actor Eric Dane says disease has taken all function in right arm
ALS has robbed Eric Dane (pic) of functioning in his right arm and is creeping through his left, the actor said in an emotional interview about the diagnosis he revealed in April. The symptoms began rather subtly about a year and a half ago, the Euphoria and Grey's Anatomy star told Diane Sawyer on Good Morning America in an interview that aired Monday morning. He is looking to raise awareness about the disease. 'I started experiencing some weakness in my right hand,' said Dane, 52. 'And I didn't really think anything of it at the time. I thought maybe I'd been texting too much, and my hand was fatigued.' It didn't go away, however, leading to a string of specialist visits that culminated nine months later with a diagnosis of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, also known as Lou Gehrig's disease for the Yankees Hall of Fame player who died of it in 1941. 'A few weeks later I noticed it had gotten a little worse,' Dane recounted. 'So I went and saw a hand specialist, who sent me to another hand specialist. I went and saw a neurologist, and the neurologist sent me to another neurologist, who said, 'This is way above my pay grade.' ' Now, his right arm has 'completely stopped working,' the actor said. 'I feel like maybe a couple more months and I won't have my left hand either.' The letters ALS are burned into Dane's brain. 'I will never forget those three letters,' the veteran actor told Sawyer. 'It's on me the second I wake up.' The rare motor neuron disease affects nerve cells, weakening the muscles and leading to paralysis that eventually extends to the muscles that control speaking, eating and breathing, the Mayo Clinic explains. Dane is weathering this storm with the help of his wife, actress Rebecca Gayheart, and their daughters Billie Beatrice, 15, and Georgia Geraldine, 13. He said the diagnosis really hit home a few months ago during a boat trip with one of his daughters, when he jumped into ocean and realised he couldn't make it back to the boat on his own. 'I realised in that moment, I'm not safe in the water anymore,' he said. His daughter dragged him back, and he made sure she returned to the water to finish her snorkeling session with the guide. 'But I was just heartbroken.' Nonetheless, Dane is determined to keep working as long as he is able. 'I don't think this is the end of my story,' he told Sawyer. 'In my heart I just don't feel like this is the end of me. I'm fighting as much as I can.' At the same time, he allowed, 'There's so much about it that's out of my control.' – New York Daily News/Tribune News Service
