The bloodstained origins of the Italian Renaissance
War – huh – what is it good for? According to Duncan Weldon, throughout most of history it's been fantastic for economic growth and development and has perhaps fuelled technological innovation and more.
Blood and Treasure is a delightfully quirky approach to military history. Colonial Spain was thought to be cursed by the gold brought home from its colonies in the New World, since the crown somehow bankrupted itself multiple times during this period, despite the riches. Weldon contends that since the gold meant that Spain's monarchs did not need to approach parliament for money, it left them untethered from their economies and constraints.
He also offers an alternative theory for why the Renaissance originated in Italy, suggesting that it was a result of the particular way in which Italian city states waged almost perpetual war on each other by means of mercenaries. Commanders of such companies would infinitely prefer to drag out a conflict and avoid major battles – in which they might die. Huge fortunes were thus amassed, which translated into social status through patronage of the arts.
Given that the book covers a vast period and range of geographies, it is perhaps best viewed as a collection of vignettes, each containing a lesson about how combat interacted with the everyday economy. The most convincing example of the destructive, coercive force of war being also a major driver of growth and better living conditions can be seen in a study of India. Weldon describes how researchers pinpointed the dates and locations of conflict in the subcontinent going back 1,000 years. They then used satellite imagery from 1992 to 2010 to assess the level of night-time electric lighting across the country (creating proximate measures for economic development where no such granular data existed) to check for a correlation. They found that areas where there had been intensive fighting tended to be more economically developed, even centuries later. The conclusion was that warfare leads to a strengthening of local governments and institutions, which in turn is conducive to growth.
When the book turns to more recent times, such intriguing, counterintuitive stories disappear. Pre-industrial societies, Weldon explains, worked below their capacity, so when extra materials were needed for warfare it resulted in growth. Post-industrial societies do not have spare capacity waiting to be used, so modern warfare, in its destructiveness, ends up killing growth.
In a sense it is convenient that the story changes, given the difficulties that might result from claiming any modern conflict would actually be a good thing when the casualties are those who might otherwise be alive today. But it inevitably means that the book's later pages are less lively.
Blood and Treasure risked falling between two stools – being military history targeted at people who don't normally read it, satisfying neither warfare nerds nor those looking for a post-Freakonomics hit. Thanks to an obvious deep love of the subject, a deft choice of examples and some thoroughly satisfying human stories, Weldon has at least made warfare a good thing to read about.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
2 days ago
- Daily Mirror
Martina Navratilova fears losing US citizenship after Donald Trump move
Martina Navratilova has lived in the United States since she was 18 years old but fears her citizenship could be taken away following Donald Trump's immigration raids Tennis legend Martina Navratilova fears losing her US citizenship amid Donald Trump's immigration crackdown. The US president pledged to "launch the largest deportation programme of criminals in the history of America" during his campaign and his administration has since carried out extensive raids across the nation. Trump's moves have sparked protests in California, New York, Philadelphia and Houston. Navratilova, 68, relocated to the States in 1975 at 18, leaving her native Czechoslovakia behind. Her ambition to become the world No.1 in tennis was the driving force behind her move to the US. She previously confessed that she "couldn't do it under those circumstances at home". In 1981, she became a US citizen and in 2008, she regained her Czech citizenship, thus becoming a dual citizen. However, Navratilova, who resides in Miami, Florida with her wife Julia Lemigova, expressed her ongoing fear that the citizenship she's held for nearly 45 years could be stripped from her. Speaking to BBC's Amol Rajan, the Wimbledon champion said: "Everything is up in the air right now, and that's the whole point. Everybody's walking on eggshells, not knowing what's going to happen." Immigration officers have raided workplaces and even arrested and held tourists in detention citizens, including Italian content creator Khaby Lame. The 25-year-old is the world's most popular TikTok star with 162million followers but was detained at a Las Vegas airport for 'immigration violations'. Tennis legend Navratilova didn't mince her words about Trump either. She declared: "I'm not loyal to [US President] Donald Trump," and went on to say she wouldn't choose America today if she were making the move now. "If I were now still in that same position [as in 1975] and I had to go live somewhere, it would not be America, because it's not a democracy at the moment," she stated. Navratilova has left an indelible mark on Wimbledon, with her legacy spanning 49 years. Her first victory at the All England Club was clinched in 1976 when she triumphed in the doubles with none other than Chris Evert, her fiercest competitor. This marked the beginning of her extraordinary run at Wimbledon, where she secured a record nine titles – more than any other man or woman in the history of the sport. The tennis legend amassed an Open Era record of 59 titles, including 18 singles, 31 women's doubles, and 10 mixed doubles. Navratilova's net worth is claimed to be a cool £18.6m.
Daily Mirror
2 days ago
- Daily Mirror
Tory council chief sparks outrage with 'poor people' steak dinner joke
Norfolk County Council leader Kay Mason Billig has defended the Facebook post - in which she took a picture of a tomahawk steak - claiming it was a "private joke" A Tory council chief is facing calls to quit after posting a pic of a tomahawk steak with the caption: "Wonder what all the poor people are doing?" Norfolk County Council leader Kay Mason Billig posted the photograph of her meal with a £21 bottle of Italian red wine, potatoes in peppercorn sauce and salad to her Facebook friends. But the caption sparked a furious reaction, with tens of thousands of people in Norfolk forced to rely on food banks and her own council runs an £11.8m fund to help people struggling to afford to eat. Mrs Mason Billig, who is entitled to more than £51,000 in allowances from County Hall each year, told the EDP website the sharing of the post beyond her friends was a "personal attack" and a private joke had been misunderstood. Mrs Mason Billig, who lives in Chedgrave, near Loddon, with her husband Michael, the former director of Procastle Properties, said: "My husband and I have sometimes called ourselves 'the poor people'. "It's a private joke as we live fairly modestly, so when we have a treat, we will sometimes post about it. This is asking if friends wonder what we (the poor people) are doing. It's not intended to be about anyone else and is no reflection on people who are less well off than ourselves. "It's a bad state of affairs when I can't even joke about myself without it being twisted into something it isn't. I am deeply disappointed that someone has decided to be this horrible when they must certainly know it's actually self deprecation. What a sad world we live in." But Steve Morphew, leader of the Labour group at County Hall, said: "People like to have council leaders who show they are in touch, care about the plight of others and show humility and pride in the public positions they hold. This is a nauseating example of the exact opposite. I find nothing amusing here." And the EDP reported one senior Norfolk Conservative said they thought Mrs Mason Billig, who is also a South Norfolk district councillor, should quit. They said: "I think she should resign. We are entitled to a private life and to let our hair down, but I don't think anybody should degrade those less well off than others. "Under Conservative party guidance, there's a case that she has brought the party into disrepute and the party should be carrying out an investigation. This falls well below the Nolan Principles for Public Life.' Another Tory said: "Most politicians are wise to avoid social media. It's hard to win votes, but easy to lose them." Mrs Mason Billig, who has been County Hall leader since May 2023, was criticised earlier this week for comments made during a debate over Norfolk County Council's vision for a single council for when all eight of the county's councils are abolished and new ones created. She said children could die should plans to abolish all eight Norfolk councils and create new ones result in two or three different councils delivering social services.
Metro
2 days ago
- Metro
Timothy Weah reveals Juventus stars forced into 'weird' Donald Trump meeting
Juventus star Timothy Weah has revealed he was forced to attend a 'weird' meeting with Donald Trump at the White House. The Italian giants are in the US as part of the Club World Cup, getting their group campaign off to a winning start with a 5-0 victory over Al Ain in the early hours of Thursday morning. Before the game, the squad and staff visited the Oval Office, lining up behind Trump's desk in front of the press. What followed was a series of awkward exchanges as Trump grilled the squad on a number of issues, including the subject of transgender women in sport. Juve midfielder and USA international Weston McKennie was seen looking to his countryman Weah for help after being asked 'could a women make your team, fellas?' McKennie was rescued when Manuel Locatelli broke a brief period of uncomfortable silence saying, 'Yeah.' Weah, son of the legendary George Weah, later revealed he did not want to attend the 16-minute summit. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video 'It was all a surprise to me, honestly — they told us that we have to go and I had no choice but to go so I showed up,' Weah told reporters after the 5-0 win later that day. 'I was caught by surprise, honestly. It was a bit weird. When he started talking about the politics with Iran and everything, it's kind of like, I just want to play football man.' His Juventus and USA teammate McKennie meanwhile has previously criticised Trump during his first term following the Black Lives Matter protests in 2020. 'I don't think that Trump is the right one for the job as the president,' he told Bild. More Trending 'I stand by these words. I believe he doesn't understand the responsibility he has for the entire country. I think he's ignorant. I don't support him a bit. I don't think he's a man to stand by his word. In my eyes, you can call him racist.' Trump signed the controversial and hugely divisive 'Keeping Men Out of Women's Sports' executive order in February after campaigning heavily on the issue in 2024. The order prompted the National Collegiate Athletic Association to change its gender eligibility policy to only permit biological females to compete in the women's category. MORE: Ellen DeGeneres shares rare look at sprawling UK home after leaving US over Trump MORE: Kylian Mbappe in hospital after missing Real Madrid's opening Club World Cup game MORE: Trent Alexander-Arnold tells Liverpool fans how long he's been learning Spanish after Real Madrid debut
