Karen Read trial day 26 recap: Judge denies defense's motion for mistrial
Editor's note: This page summarizes testimony in the Karen Read trial for Tuesday, June 3. For the latest updates on the Karen Read retrial, visit USA TODAY's coverage for Wednesday, June 4.
A German Shepard named Chloe took the spotlight again at the second murder trial of Karen Read, the Massachusetts' woman accused of killing her Boston cop boyfriend.
Though never mentioned by name, the dog, who lived at the home where John O'Keefe's body was discovered in the snow, was the subject of hours of testimony by a critical defense expert.
Marie Russell, an emergency physician and former forensic pathologist, doubled down on claims Tuesday that large, surface-level gashes found on O'Keefe's arm came from canine claws and teeth. Questions from prosecutors about the existence of dog DNA on O'Keefe's clothes spurred calls from Read's defense for a mistrial.
But Judge Beverly Cannone quickly squashed the motion.
Russell's testimony comes days after prosecutors rested their case against Read, who they say backed into O'Keefe with her Lexus SUV at roughly 25 mph, causing him to hit his head on the hard ground, and then left him to die in the snow during a historic blizzard on Jan. 29, 2022.
Read's defense team alleges she was framed for O'Keefe's murder. They say local cops beat O'Keefe, let the ravenous dog attack him and then dropped his bloodied and bruised body outside in the freezing cold. Their theory leans on the idea that the lead investigator in the case, Massachusetts State Trooper Michael Proctor, attempted to cover up for the cops.
Russell was among the first witnesses to testify about Chloe's involvement in O'Keefe's death. During Read's first trial in 2024, Chloe's owner, Nicole Albert, said the dog was sent to a farm in Vermont sometime during the investigation into O'Keefe's death. Albert is the sister of key prosecution witness Jennifer McCabe.
Read is back in court in Dedham, Massachusetts after her 2024 trial ended in a hung jury. The yearslong whodunnit case has sparked massive intrigue from true crime fans across the country, many of whom have feverishly taken sides.
Her second trial is now in its seventh week.
Here's what you missed on Day 26.
Sgt. Nicholas Barros from the Dighton, Massachusetts police department testified about the condition of Read's vehicle when it was towed away on the afternoon of Jan. 29, 2022. His testimony appeared aimed at corroborating the defense theory that investigators mishandled, and potentially planted, evidence.
Barros said a crack roughly the length of a dollar bill was missing from the right side of Read's taillight when he saw the vehicle around 4:20 p.m. He said the taillight wasn't 'smashed out' like it was in a photo Read's defense attorney showed him.
Alan Jackson, one of Read's lawyers, played a clip of the SUV being towed away. Read's taillight appeared to mostly be intact in the video.
But on cross-examination, the prosecution showed Barros a clip of Read's SUV backing out of a driveway in the early morning hours of Jan. 29, 2022 along with a photo of her car covered in snow. The taillight appeared more broken in these photos. Barros said the damage in both seemed consistent with what he saw at Read's parent's house in Dighton.
Investigators uncovered the first pieces of broken taillight near where O'Keefe was found at roughly 5:45 p.m. that day. Canton Police Sgt. Yuri Bukhenik previously testified that he and Proctor viewed the vehicle between when it was dropped off at the station and when the taillight pieces were discovered. At the time, he said neither he nor Proctor were at the crime scene.
Prosecutor Hank Brennan asked Russell whether she considered the small pieces of red plastic found in O'Keefe's sweatshirt when she found that a dog caused his wounds.
Russell said she did not believe the plastic debris caused the parallel abrasions to O'Keefe's arm. She later told the defense the pieces were too tiny to cause O'Keefe's wounds and were not oriented in the right direction.
As an emergency physician and former forensic pathologist, Russell said she believed O'Keefe would have had significant bruising, fractures and a dislocated arm if he had been hit by a car. He did not have those injuries.
The red fragments are among the key pieces of evidence prosecutors have used to connect Read to the crime. They say the pieces came from Read's taillight.
Judge Beverly Cannone denied a motion for mistrial brought by Read's defense team following questioning by the prosecution about dog DNA on O'Keefe's sweatshirt.
While questioning Russell, Brennan asked about holes found in O'Keefe's clothing, which she previously suggested were consistent with a canine tooth sinking into the shirt. Brennan continued to press Russell on whether she knew the sweatshirt had been tested for traces of dog DNA.
Read's defense attorney, Robert Alessi, forcefully objected to the question, causing the judge to dismiss the jury to hear from the defense and prosecution about whether the question warranted a mistrial.
The defense argued Brennan's question introduced the idea of DNA evidence into the trial for the first time, and said the defense had been meticulous about not mentioning DNA. Brennan pushed back, stating the defense team brought up the concept of dog DNA during a December 2024 hearing.
Cannone ruled to allow the prosecution to continue its line of DNA-related questions.
Brennan proceeded to questioned Russell about the lack of dog DNA found on O'Keefe's sweatshirt and suggested dogs typically froth at the mouth, leave 'excessive saliva' and can sometimes shed hair when they bite.
Brennan said O'Keefe's sweatshirt tested positive for pig DNA but not dog DNA and there was 'no identification' of where the pig DNA came from. Russell said the sweatshirt 'ideally' should have been swabbed for DNA immediately after the body was found. O'Keefe's sweatshirt wasn't tested for months, and she questioned whether the delay had an impact.
Brennan suggested the sweatshirt was not immediately tested because there was no evidence when O'Keefe's body was discovered that a dog caused the wounds. Russell said it should have been considered as part of a 'complete investigation.'
Brennan attempted to poke holes in the methodology Russell used to determine whether O'Keefe's wounds came from a dog attack. He questioned whether she could differentiate wounds from the dog's teeth and nails, and she said it was difficult to tell because they cause similar abrasions. Russell also said there is no accepted methodology for identifying dog bites and clarified that she used a mixture of pattern recognition and differential diagnosis in her analysis.
Brennan pointed out that the diameter between the marks on O'Keefe differed. He questioned how that could happen, since the diameter between teeth and nails is stagnant. Russell responded that the skin's elasticity leads to slight differences.
She said she couldn't 'imagine' a vehicle lining up to fit O'Keefe's injuries. When questioned about whether she had examined Read's vehicle specifically, Russell said she hadn't.
The prosecution attempted to sow doubt about Russell's credibility as a witness asking whether Russell received help on her report from Read's defense team. In December 2024, Russell testified defense attorney Robert Alessi helped with the report, according to a transcript presented by the prosecutor. Russell clarified that Alessi helped reorganize the report but did not change any content.
When asked about her communications with Alessi, Russell said she commuted to court with the attorney the morning of June 3. During their ride, she said he recommended that she ask for a transcript of her testimony. Russell said they did not have any other conversations about the case.
The prosecutor suggested that the communication constituted a breach of the witness sequestration rule in the trial, which prohibits the witness from discussing their testimony with anyone until the trial is over.
Russell returned to the stand Tuesday for a second day. She previously testified that wounds found on O'Keefe's arm appeared to have been inflicted by a dog, noting patterns she said were consistent with the hundreds of other canine attacks she's seen in her career. Pointing to a picture of O'Keefe's battered arm, Russell described what she said were multiple groupings of incomplete dog bites, which are among the most common. The bites, she said, didn't penetrate the 'full thickness of the skin.'
She also contested previous testimony from Judson Welcher, the prosecution's crash reconstruction expert who presented a case study from a car crash where a victim sustained several injuries, including skin loss. Russell suggested O'Keefe did not have the same types of injuries.
The prosecution began pressing Russell about her experience and alleged inconsistencies in her statements upon cross-examination. They asked if she had ever identified the origin of a wound as a dog bite without knowing where it came from prior to Read's case. She said she hadn't.
CourtTV has been covering the case against Read and the criminal investigation since early 2022, when O'Keefe's body was found outside a Massachusetts home.
You can watch CourtTV's live feed of the Read trial proceedings from Norfolk Superior Court in Dedham, Massachusetts. Proceedings began at 9 a.m. ET.
Contributing: Michael Loria, USA TODAY
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Karen Read trial day 26: Judge denies defense's motion for mistrial
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
2 hours ago
- USA Today
Man arrested after shooting death at Utah 'No Kings' protest released from jail
A man accused of wielding a rifle at a "No Kings" protest in Salt Lake City before an armed safety volunteer opened fire and accidentally killed a protester has been released from jail, court records show. Utah Third District Judge James Blanch signed an order to release Arturo Gamboa on June 20 after state prosecutors were "unable to make an informed decision" on charges against him before his scheduled release date on June 23, according to court records obtained by USA TODAY. Gamboa, 24, had been arrested on suspicion of murder following a "No Kings" demonstration and march in downtown Salt Lake City on June 14. As prosecutors review evidence as it becomes available, the order states that Gamboa was released under stipulated conditions agreed upon through his attorney. Under those conditions, Gamboa must maintain residence with his father, not possess any firearms, and hand over his passport to his attorney. His release came after Salt Lake County District Attorney Sim Gill requested and received a three-day extension to keep Gamboa in custody, The Salt Lake Tribune and reported. The extension would have detained Gamboa until June 23, but Gill later said his office was unable to decide Gamboa's culpability in the shooting, according to The Salt Lake Tribune. Gamboa was taken into custody after he pulled out a rifle at demonstrators and allegedly moved toward the crowd while holding the weapon in a firing position, Salt Lake City police said. An armed safety volunteer, who police described as a member of the peacekeeping team for the protest, then fired three shots. Juneteenth celebrations shootings: 2 dead, 16 injured after shootings in South Carolina, Oklahoma Gamboa was wounded in the shooting while a nearby demonstrator, identified as fashion designer Arthur Folasa Ah Loo, 39, was killed, according to police. Prosecutors and police said the incident remains under investigation. Police have asked the public to contact authorities with any information related to the shooting as investigators work to "understand the full scope of what occurred." "We are asking for the public's help. If you captured any footage, particularly from the moments immediately before, during, or after the shooting, or if you have video of the shooting itself, or the person arrested, please share that evidence with us," the Salt Lake City Police Department said in a news release. "Even small details may prove vital to this investigation." What happened during the shooting at Utah's 'No Kings' rally? Shortly before 8 p.m. local time, officers reported hearing gunfire at the demonstration, according to an affidavit of probable cause. Police reported that three shots were fired, and a man, who was later identified as Ah Loo, was fatally struck by a round. Officers immediately responded to the scene and were informed that a man wearing a black mask and all black clothing was seen running away, the affidavit states. Officers then discovered the man, who was identified as Gamboa, with a minor gunshot wound, crouched down among a small group of people. Officers discovered that Gamboa had an AR-15 style rifle, a gas mask, additional black clothing, and a backpack, according to the affidavit. Other officers in the area found two men wearing yellow high-visibility vests with handguns in their possession. Police described the two men as members of a "peacekeeping group assigned to assist the planned protest/rally in ensuring everyone's safety," the affidavit states. One of the "peacekeepers" told officers that he saw Gamboa move away from the main crowd to a secluded area behind a wall. Iran strikes: Protests erupt calling for Trump, U.S. to stay out of war in Middle East "The peacekeepers found this behavior to be suspicious and kept (Gamboa) in view," according to the affidavit. "One of the peacekeepers observed (Gamboa) remove an AR-15 style rifle from a backpack he was carrying. He observed (Gamboa) begin to manipulate the rifle and they called out to him to the drop the gun after drawing their own firearms." Gamboa then allegedly lifted the rifle, and witnesses described seeing him begin to run toward the large crowd of demonstrators while holding the weapon in a firing position, the affidavit states. One of the "peacekeepers" fired three rounds, striking Gamboa and Ah Loo. "Detectives have not been able to determine, at this time, why Gamboa pulled out his rifle and began to manipulate it or why he ran from the peacekeepers when they confronted him," police said in a news release after the incident. "Detectives have developed probable cause that Gamboa acted under circumstances that showed a depraved indifference to human life, knowingly engaged in conduct that created a grave risk of death and ultimately caused the death of an innocent community member." There are no regulations for how guns are carried in public in Utah, according to Everytown for Gun Safety, a gun control group. And police have not identified the two "peacekeepers" involved in the incident. Shooting occurred during widespread 'No Kings' protests on June 14 "No Kings" demonstrations across the United States drew large crowds on June 14. The protests were held in opposition to President Donald Trump's policies and coincided with the controversial parade for the U.S. Army's 250th anniversary in Washington, D.C. While the demonstrations were mostly calm and peaceful, some protests were met with violence. The Salt Lake City shooting occurred as thousands of protesters gathered in the city's downtown area. Police initially said the protest drew about 10,000 people, but later updated the estimated attendance to 18,000. In Virginia, a man intentionally drove an SUV through a crowd of departing protesters, striking at least one person, police said. A California man was arrested after allegedly threatening to commit a shooting at the Palm Springs "No Kings" rally, police said on social media. Police in Los Angeles hit protesters with batons, fired tear gas, and ordered a large crowd in downtown to disperse. At the time, police said they were responding to people throwing "rocks, bricks, bottles," and "fireworks." Two people were charged on June 18 after a woman was critically injured when an SUV sped into a crowd of demonstrators in downtown Riverside in Southern California, according to the Riverside County District Attorney's Office and the Victorville Daily Press, part of the USA TODAY Network. Contributing: N'dea Yancey-Bragg, Sarah D. Wire, Jeanine Santucci, and Jonathan Limehouse, USA TODAY
USA Today
9 hours ago
- USA Today
Ezra Miller has 'a lot of remorse' for past controversies, talks Hollywood comeback
After a shaky time in the spotlight, Ezra Miller isn't ready to sprint back to Hollywood. "The Flash" star, whose Hollywood ascent was derailed amid mounting legal issues, addressed their past controversies and future in the entertainment industry in an interview with Lo Speciale Giornale published June 19. Miller, 32, spoke to the Italian outlet shortly after attending the Cannes Film Festival in May for their first major red-carpet appearance since falling from grace. Miller said they appeared at the renowned film festival at the request of their friend, "Die My Love" director Lynne Ramsay, adding that their relationship with the movie industry is on "tentative grounds." "If you've been in the woods for three years, I do not recommend going straight to Cannes, where every photographer and every weirdo, every rich genocidal freak (will) be there, you know what I mean?" Miller said. "It's not an easy reentry." 10 bingeable memoirs to check out: Celebrities tell all about aging, marriage and Beyoncé Miller broke out on the big screen in 2012 with a role in the coming-of-age drama "The Perks of Being a Wallflower," later playing Credence Barebone in the Harry Potter "Fantastic Beasts" franchise (2016-2022) and superhero speedster Barry Allen in "Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice" (2016) and "Justice League" (2017). But in 2022, a series of highly publicized scandals cast a shadow on Miller's rising star. The actor was arrested in Hawaii on a charge of disorderly conduct in March, followed by an arrest on suspicion of assault in April. A few months later, Miller was accused of grooming an 18-year-old activist by the teen's parents and also charged with felony burglary in a separate incident in Vermont (Miller pleaded not guilty). "Not that I don't hold a lot of remorse and lamentation for a lot of things that I did and for a lot of things that happened in that time, but I'm really, really grateful for the lessons that came with that abyss," Miller reflected. Ezra Miller's past legal troubles: What to know about actor's controversies In an August 2022 statement to USA TODAY, Miller said they were undergoing treatment for "complex mental health issues" following the string of criminal and abuse allegations brought against them: "I want to apologize to everyone that I have alarmed and upset with my past behavior. I am committed to doing the necessary work to get back to a healthy, safe and productive stage in my life." "When we go through those crucibles, if we can survive, which was up in the air for me if I'm being real, we then have that capacity to see other people in their crucibles and just to reach towards them," Miller told Lo Speciale Giornale. "That grows more and more rarefied in our world, too. Like, the capacity to do that, the desire to do that, the willingness to do that." "The Flash" premiered in June 2023 and despite earning mixed reviews from critics, the DC superhero flick grossed $271.4 million worldwide. While Miller hasn't appeared in a major project since the film's release, the actor said they've been "writing a lot," including working with Ramsay on a movie that will "likely" be their first new release. Contributing: Anthony Robledo, USA TODAY
USA Today
10 hours ago
- USA Today
Suspect dead following Michigan church shooting: Police
One person was killed and one was injured in a shooting at a church in Wayne, Michigan on June 22, according to local police. City of Wayne police said in a Facebook post that a shooting took place at CrossPointe Community Church and that responding officers determined that a security guard for the church shot and killed the suspect. Detroit ABC affiliate WXYZ reported that the suspect was on his way to the church when another person tried to stop him with their truck. When he opened fire on the truck the security guard intervened, according to the station. US attack on Iran fallout: US warns of 'heightened threat environment' after strikes on Iran nukes USA TODAY reached out to the department but did not receive an immediate response on Sunday. FBI Deputy Director Dan Bongino said in a post on X that the bureau has sent leadership and support teams to Wayne. This is a developing story.
