Enoch Godongwana's budget: a delicate balance of debt control and social investment unveiled
The bottom line is that a scalpel has been deftly wielded instead of a chainsaw, but economists and the markets will welcome the Treasury's commitment to spending within its limited means.
With a scalpel in one hand and undisclosed tax measures for 2026 concealed by a glove in the other, Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana delivered a Budget on Wednesday that aimed to fill the revenue hole dug by the burying of the proposed VAT hikes while keeping mounting state debt levels under control.
But the minister insisted that containing debt did not translate into the pain of austerity.
'This is not an austerity Budget,' the minister said in his prepared remarks.
'It is also a redistributive budget. It directs 61 cents of every rand of consolidated, non-interest expenditure towards the social wage… This budget invests over R1-trillion in critical infrastructure to lift economic growth prospects and improve access to basic services.'
Pointedly, he noted that '… this is done without compromising the fiscal strategy of sustainable public finances'.
The long-stated aim of stabilising debt in 2025/26 at a peak level as measured as a percentage of gross domestic product (GDP) remains firmly in place, with the ratio now seen at 77.4% of GDP this fiscal year compared to 76.2% in March. This will be its highest level since the dawn of democracy in 1994.
'We have achieved this difficult balance by reducing additional spending over the medium term by R68-billion… the size of the proposed increases to allocations is reduced, in line with what we can afford.'
These 'downward revisions' to additional spending that were proposed in March over the next three years, an inflation-linked fuel levy adjustment, and undisclosed tax proposals for 2026 to boost state coffers by R20-billion — which are clearly in the drafting phase — were the key measures outlined to bridge the gap created by the scrapping of the VAT boost.
The Treasury insists there are no spending cuts, but 'downward revisions' to additional spending amount to the same thing when compared with what was outlined in March. If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it ain't no chicken.
Painful Investment
The bottom line is that a scalpel has been deftly wielded instead of a chainsaw, but economists and the markets will welcome the Treasury's commitment to spending within its limited means.
Godongwana was diplomatic and gracious over the VAT fracas that ultimately produced this third try at a Budget.
'The debate and negotiations have deepened our understanding of policy trade-offs and institutional processes, while giving citizens unprecedented visibility into our democracy's evolution,' he said.
'Negotiation, debate and compromise, as we have seen unfold over the last weeks, has been a necessary, if sometimes painful, investment in the productivity of future government reform in the new political environment.'
There will be a slight increase in the gross borrowing requirement to R588.2-billion from the R582-billion foreseen in Budget 2.0. That will include payments to Eskom of R80.2-billion, R30-billion less than the 2024 Budget estimate.
The Budget deficit for this fiscal year is now seen amounting to 4.8% of GDP and is projected to narrow to 3.4% by 2027/28.
'Compared to the March estimates, tax revenue projections have been revised down by R61.9-billion over the three years. This reflects the reversal of VAT increase and the much weaker economic outlook,' the minister said.
The Treasury has slashed its forecast for South African economic growth in 2025 to 1.4% from 1.9% in March, a reflection of ongoing domestic challenges and a worsening global outlook in the face of US President Donald Trump's chaotic tariff policies and trade wars.
The mysterious R20-billion tax measure
The tax measures to raise an additional R20-billion next year remain under wraps.
Although an additional R20-billion is set down in the Budget documents for collection in 2026, Chris Axelson, acting head of tax at the National Treasury, was somewhat coy when questioned by journalists during the Budget lockdown.
'We aren't going into specifics on that right now. There are a variety of options, including options put forward by the public.'
It's clear that the measures will not include any VAT revisions after the recent hullabaloo that almost tore asunder the Government of National Unity (GNU).
In his speech, the minister said that in total an additional R7.5-billion that had been allocated to the South African Revenue Service (SARS) over the next three years, and that any resulting windfall from improved revenue collection would mean the mystery tax measures would not need to be implemented.
'As SARS utilises this investment to raise additional revenue, which I believe can be at least R35-billion, the R20-billion to close the current revenue gap will not have to be raised through taxes,' Godongwana said.
He said SARS was also aiming to '… target illicit trade in tobacco and other areas, which should boost revenue over the medium term'.
All in all, it seems that a viable Budget has been pulled out of Godongwana's fedora against a fraught and fraying political and economic backdrop.
In baseball, after three strikes you are out, and the minister's bat on the third try has hit the ball. In cricket terms it may not be a six, but a boundary beckons. DM
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
How to miss a miracle: Just don't try
The National Development Plan was visionary, but today its only value is as a mirror. The plan was the government's flagship strategy to create a more equal society and an environment of accelerated economic growth … Picture: Shutterstock I found a dusty copy of the original National Development Plan (NDP) published in August 2012 while moving offices last week. Paging through the 500-page glossy book, I was again reminded that it was an excellent document – well ahead of its time. But the irony is stark, as it now represents one of the biggest pipedreams in South Africa's democratic history. The plan was the government's flagship strategy to create a more equal society, with all proposals centralised to establish an enabling environment where businesses could grow and flourish to accelerate economic growth. The goal was average economic growth of over 5.4% between 2011 and 2030. Unemployment was targeted to drop to 14% by 2020 and to 6% by 2030. The government adopted the plan amid dancing girls and fireworks, proudly labelling it the magic blueprint for a prosperous future in South Africa. Read more SA expresses sadness, offers condolences to India after Air India crash [VIDEO] Well, that didn't quite happen. But it isn't a surprise. I also remember the ANC's elective conference in Mangaung a few months later, in December 2012, where Jacob Zuma was re-elected as ANC president. During his victory speech in a packed and boisterous venue, he feverishly brandished the plan in the air and shouted above the noise: 'This is the plan that will take South Africa forward.' The crowd noise tapered off and turned to discontented mumbling. A Cosatu official I had been speaking to bent down and muttered: 'It's a DA plan. It will never happen. Over my dead body.' That was nearly 13 years ago. It might as well have been the blueprint for the tallest building in the world, where the only execution was the theft of the building materials. ALSO READ: What is the National Development Plan, and will its hopes become a reality? No execution, but reviews continue … The National Planning Commission still exists, and it regularly publishes reviews of the original plan's failures. The cynic in me says it could be one commission Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana can cut as part of his austerity plan. The NDP still sports a beautiful cover, with crisp, glossy pages and an expertly crafted layout – a really professional document. Yet, despite its elegance, it has become a prime example of how a visionary and audacious plan, without execution, is ultimately not worth the paper it's printed on. It's a waste of money. Today, South Africa has no clear blueprint for its future. The government of national unity (GNU) is positive, but the leadership is currently focused on stabilising coalitions and tackling short-term crises. Beyond the immediacy, there is a vacuum of long-term strategic thinking. A positive development, however, is the GNU's stated focus on growth and job creation – core goals that echo the original intent of the NDP. ALSO READ: SA's expanding safety net: Millions more to receive social grants by 2030 Worth another (good) look Perhaps the plan's lasting value lies in its function as a mirror. If politicians and policymakers were to reread it today – really read it – they might come to a sobering realisation: the country's current economic policies are not working. This will require an aggressive reassessment of key policies: revisiting empowerment policies and frameworks, policies not to nationalise plundered and dysfunctional state-owned enterprises but to re-establish powerful, independent institutions like the Scorpions to combat corruption, and fundamentally rethinking how South Africa fights crime to restore the rule of law. We don't need another glossy plan. We need brave decisions, practical policy shifts, and the political will to act. This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.
TimesLIVE
2 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Iran tensions make thermal coal a winner against pricier LNG
Thermal coal may end up as a major beneficiary of escalating hostilities in the Middle East as the fuel used to generate electricity becomes cheaper than one of its main competitors liquefied natural gas (LNG). Much of the focus of the potential fallout from the conflict between Israel, and now the US, and Iran is the threat to crude oil and refined fuels shipped through the Strait of Hormuz. All of Qatar's LNG also goes through the narrow waterway separating the gulfs of Persia and Oman, and this amounts to almost 20% of the global seaborne supply of the super-chilled fuel. While there hasn't yet been any disruption of Qatar's LNG, the threat that Iran may attempt to block the strait or attack shipping has seen spot LNG prices rise in Asia, the biggest market. LNG for delivery to North Asia rose to $14 (R253.10) per million British thermal units (mmBtu) in the week to June 20, a four-month high and up from $12.6 (R227.79) the week before. The weekly price assessment also came before the US joined Israel's bombing campaign against Iran, with President Donald Trump claiming on June 21 that the strikes had 'completely and totally obliterated' three nuclear facilities. The involvement of the US makes it more likely that LNG prices will continue to rise to reflect the increased risk premium. But even at the current level, LNG is no longer competitive against thermal coal in the two major markets where fuel-switching can occur, Japan and South Korea. The price of Australian thermal coal with an energy content of 6,000 kilocalories per kilogram at Newcastle Port rose to a four-month high of $109.41 (R1,978) a tonne in the week to June 20, according to data from globalCOAL. This is the grade of thermal coal most used by Japan and South Korea, as well as Taiwan. Using LSEG data to convert the price of coal into mmBtu shows Australia's Newcastle benchmark is now about $12.18 (R220.30) per mmBtu, or a 13% discount to the spot LNG price. The most recent low for spot LNG was in early May when the price dipped to $11 (R198.93) per mmBtu, at which point it was cheaper than Newcastle coal, which was $11.47 (R207.38). But spot LNG prices have rallied harder than those for coal in recent weeks, a trend that is likely to continue for as long as tensions remain high in the Middle East. As it has only been 10 days since Israel started its bombing campaign against Iran it's still too early to see a sustained trend in the volumes of coal being purchased by Japan and South Korea. However, there are signs that coal imports are starting to increase, with commodity analysts Kpler tracking Japan's arrivals at 6.57-million tonnes in June, up from 6.39-million in May. More interestingly, Kpler is already estimating that Japan's thermal coal imports will jump to 7.23-million tonnes, which would be the most since March. It's likely that the July number will be revised higher as more cargoes are assessed. There is also an element of seasonality to Japan's thermal coal imports, which tend to rise in the winter and summer peak demand periods. This means it will be important to look at the year-on-year changes to see if Asia's third-biggest coal buyer is buying more of the fuel. Japan imported 10.05-million tonnes of thermal coal in July last year, and given that the volume already assessed for this coming July is more than 70% of that total, it's likely that imports next month will show an increase from July 2024. It's also worth noting that Asia's two biggest coal importers, China and India, don't have much ability to swap LNG for coal given their limited use of natural gas for power generation. But on a longer-term note, both countries are likely to view the unrest in the Middle East as another compelling reason to reduce dependency on imported crude oil and LNG as rapidly as possible. If that means using their vast domestic reserves of coal, supplemented by imports, to electrify transportation at a faster pace, it's likely that this is a path they will pursue irrespective of climate change concerns.
The Citizen
4 hours ago
- The Citizen
Tips for first-time homebuyers to get a foot on the property ladder
Tips for first-time homebuyers to get a foot on the property ladder The Western Cape remains one of South Africa's most sought-after regions for property investment, attracting strong interest from both local and international homebuyers. However, for first-time homebuyers, especially those looking at Cape Town, homeownership is a challenge as the province records the highest average purchase price. Still, data reveals that activity in the entry-level market persists, suggesting that many homebuyers are finding creative ways to get a foot on the property ladder. According to the latest oobarometer data from ooba Home Loans, the Western Cape's average purchase price in Q1 2025 was R2.33m – well above the national average of R1.66m. Yet, the province continues to draw first-time homebuyers, with the demand for property in the region showing no signs of slowing. 'We're seeing many young professionals and investors gravitating towards the Western Cape for its lifestyle, infrastructure and perceived safety, but affordability in the metro remains a challenge, especially for those trying to enter the market for the first time,' explains Grant Smee, CEO of Only Realty Property Group. Who Is Buying in the Western Cape, and Where? Lightstone data shows that 40% of the Western Cape's housing stock is priced under R750,000, and while appearing to be a more accessible price point, most of these properties can be found in smaller towns and rural areas. 'Investment properties are also in high demand, with the Western Cape recording a year-on-year increase of 0.5% to reach 12.9% in the first quarter [ooba Home Loans]. There is a growing trend of first-time homebuyers purchasing in the Boland and Overberg regions in smaller, outlying towns,' says Smee. 'These areas offer a more balanced lifestyle and slightly more accessible pricing, while still benefiting from the broader Western Cape infrastructure.' He says entry-level homebuyers investing in Cape Town's CBD are also increasingly choosing more affordable micro-apartments and sectional title units in high-density, mixed-use developments: 'These offer security and lifestyle perks like on-site retail, communal workspaces and gyms.' Attracting Foreign Investors Meanwhile, the Western Cape remains a top choice for foreign homebuyers, with its global appeal and in-demand lifestyle at comparatively more affordable prices than elsewhere. However, Smee notes they're investing in a higher price bracket. 'According to Lightstone data, the province leads in luxury price bands, with international homebuyers accounting for over 40% of purchases above R10m, around 25% in the R5m to R10m range and approximately 15% in the R3m to R5m bracket.' He adds: 'Compared to global cities, the Western Cape offers strong value. For instance, the average price of a home in one of the region's upmarket suburbs sells for around R10m. To purchase an apartment in London – with considerably less living space – homebuyers will pay upwards of R12m.' The Australian Property Investor also highlighted South Africa's comparatively low housing prices, with South Africans paying around R17,000 per square metre for a median-priced home, compared to Australia's R113,000 for the equivalent. Alternatives for First-Time Buyers Smee notes that while the Western Cape remains a strong performer in the property market, savvy buyers are increasingly exploring outlying regions that offer better value for money than central Cape Town. Areas such as the West Coast, the Garden Route, and the northern and southern suburbs present attractive alternatives. 'The Western Cape's so-called 'Zoom' towns – so-called for their remote working appeal—include Pringle Bay, Betty's Bay, Kleinmond, Malmesbury, Hermanus, and Gansbaai,' he explains. 'These areas provide easier entry points for buyers and remain within comfortable reach of Cape Town.' However, he adds that excellent opportunities exist beyond the Western Cape as well. 'Mpumalanga, for instance, is currently leading the pack when it comes to home loan applications from first-time buyers [ooba Home Loans]. Nelspruit, in particular, is booming with new estate developments that offer a secure, lock-up-and-go lifestyle, community atmosphere, and budget-friendly pricing.' Gauteng also continues to hold strong appeal. 'Popular nodes like Waterfall, Bryanston, and Hyde Park are drawing interest from buyers seeking well-established infrastructure and upscale living,' he says. Meanwhile, KwaZulu-Natal's North Coast – most notably Umhlanga, Ballito and Salt Rock – has become a magnet for investment. 'Over the past decade, this region has experienced massive growth, with estate developments, excellent schools, security, and community-driven living making it an increasingly worthwhile investment,' he adds. The Eastern Cape is quietly gaining momentum, too. Towns like Kenton-on-Sea and Jeffreys Bay are becoming hotspots for short-term rental investors, thanks to their appealing lifestyle offerings and growing popularity. 'These regions combine access to economic centres with strong lifestyle appeal, without the Cape Town price tag,' Smee explains. 'For buyers willing to expand their horizons beyond the Western Cape, there are standout opportunities, many in secure estates or fast-growing nodes. And with many of these areas doubling as holiday destinations, they open the door to 'reinvestment' opportunities, whether for short-term letting or longer-term leasing.' Practical Tips for Accessing the Market 'For homebuyers determined to get a foothold in the Western Cape property market, there are many options available,' he notes. 'This investment is well worth it too as the average growth of property in the province is around 7.4%.' He shares his top tips for those wanting to get a foot on the property ladder as follows: Enter into a joint home loan: Co-buying with a friend, partner or sibling can boost affordability and borrowing power. Co-buying with a friend, partner or sibling can boost affordability and borrowing power. Save smart and plan long-term: Set clear savings goals and budget realistically for transfer and attorney fees. Set clear savings goals and budget realistically for transfer and attorney fees. Start on the outskirts: Neighbourhoods just outside key metro areas often offer more accessible prices and are poised for growth. Neighbourhoods just outside key metro areas often offer more accessible prices and are poised for growth. Buy a fixer-upper: Properties in need of a bit of work can often be negotiated at lower prices and renovated over time. Properties in need of a bit of work can often be negotiated at lower prices and renovated over time. Buy-to-let as a stepping stone: Purchase an investment property in a growing node while renting where you live. 'The Western Cape is a great place to invest, but it could require a bit more creativity and long-term thinking for first-time homebuyers to make it work. Alternatively, if the Western Cape doesn't meet your criteria, regions like the Eastern Cape, KwaZulu-Natal and Mpumalanga have potential. It's not about compromising your goals, but rather being strategic,' says Smee. Issued by Jess Gois
