How to miss a miracle: Just don't try

The National Development Plan was visionary, but today its only value is as a mirror.
The plan was the government's flagship strategy to create a more equal society and an environment of accelerated economic growth … Picture: Shutterstock
I found a dusty copy of the original National Development Plan (NDP) published in August 2012 while moving offices last week.
Paging through the 500-page glossy book, I was again reminded that it was an excellent document – well ahead of its time. But the irony is stark, as it now represents one of the biggest pipedreams in South Africa's democratic history.
The plan was the government's flagship strategy to create a more equal society, with all proposals centralised to establish an enabling environment where businesses could grow and flourish to accelerate economic growth.
The goal was average economic growth of over 5.4% between 2011 and 2030. Unemployment was targeted to drop to 14% by 2020 and to 6% by 2030.
The government adopted the plan amid dancing girls and fireworks, proudly labelling it the magic blueprint for a prosperous future in South Africa.
Read more SA expresses sadness, offers condolences to India after Air India crash [VIDEO]
Well, that didn't quite happen.
But it isn't a surprise. I also remember the ANC's elective conference in Mangaung a few months later, in December 2012, where Jacob Zuma was re-elected as ANC president.
During his victory speech in a packed and boisterous venue, he feverishly brandished the plan in the air and shouted above the noise: 'This is the plan that will take South Africa forward.'
The crowd noise tapered off and turned to discontented mumbling. A Cosatu official I had been speaking to bent down and muttered: 'It's a DA plan. It will never happen. Over my dead body.'
That was nearly 13 years ago.
It might as well have been the blueprint for the tallest building in the world, where the only execution was the theft of the building materials.
ALSO READ: What is the National Development Plan, and will its hopes become a reality?
No execution, but reviews continue …
The National Planning Commission still exists, and it regularly publishes reviews of the original plan's failures.
The cynic in me says it could be one commission Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana can cut as part of his austerity plan.
The NDP still sports a beautiful cover, with crisp, glossy pages and an expertly crafted layout – a really professional document. Yet, despite its elegance, it has become a prime example of how a visionary and audacious plan, without execution, is ultimately not worth the paper it's printed on. It's a waste of money.
Today, South Africa has no clear blueprint for its future.
The government of national unity (GNU) is positive, but the leadership is currently focused on stabilising coalitions and tackling short-term crises. Beyond the immediacy, there is a vacuum of long-term strategic thinking.
A positive development, however, is the GNU's stated focus on growth and job creation – core goals that echo the original intent of the NDP.
ALSO READ: SA's expanding safety net: Millions more to receive social grants by 2030
Worth another (good) look
Perhaps the plan's lasting value lies in its function as a mirror.
If politicians and policymakers were to reread it today – really read it – they might come to a sobering realisation: the country's current economic policies are not working.
This will require an aggressive reassessment of key policies: revisiting empowerment policies and frameworks, policies not to nationalise plundered and dysfunctional state-owned enterprises but to re-establish powerful, independent institutions like the Scorpions to combat corruption, and fundamentally rethinking how South Africa fights crime to restore the rule of law.
We don't need another glossy plan. We need brave decisions, practical policy shifts, and the political will to act.
This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

IOL News

18 minutes ago

• IOL News

ANC to reshuffle its leaders in ailing Msunduzi Municipality

Msunduzi Municipality mayor Mzimkhulu Thebolla's political future is uncertain after being excluded from the reginal task team list in the Moses Mabhida region. Image: Supplied The embattled ANC-led Msunduzi Local Municipality in Pietermaritzburg is likely to have new political supervisors by the end of week following the exclusion of both regional chairperson Mzimkhulu Thebolla and regional secretary Samora Ndlovu from the leaked regional task team list. According to the unconfirmed list, Thebolla who is also Msunduzi mayor did not make it to the top five positions allocated to the task team which will oversee the work of the ANC deployees in the six municipalities under the party's Moses Mabhida region. His secretary, Ndlovu is also exempt from the list. The region encompasses Msunduzi, Umshwathi (New Hanover), Umkhambathi (Camperdown), Mooi Mpofana (Mooi River), Umngeni ( Howick) and Richmond municipalities. On top of the list appears the name of Nathi Mdladla who is said to be in the leadership of Umkhonto weSizwe Military Veterans Associations and former Msunduzi mayor Chris Ndlela. Attempts to get Thebolla and Ndlovu to respond were unsuccessful. The municipality under these two leaders has been besieged by administrative and poor service delivery problems which led to Premier Thami Ntuli's intervention with the appointment of a team led by former Human Public Works MEC Ravi Pillay. The municipality and the region are one of the strategic centres of the ANC, it has the second biggest budget after eThekwini and the region also is the second largest in the province. There is talk that the municipality will be merged with the other five smaller municipalities to form a metro. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading The ANC held a service delivery summit in Durban on Sunday and the provincial task team coordinator Mike Mabuyakhulu said the process to appoint a new regional task team had been completed but the party will publicly announce the names next week after formally informing branches. 'In line with the ANC protocols, we are not going to announce the names of the people that will lead our regions as task teams before informing our branches first. Next week we will begin that process and announce the names,' said Mabuyakhulu. Despite the ANC's insistence that regional task teams are an opportunity for renewal, others view the move as a strategic decision by Luthuli House to have direct control over branches in the province ahead of the party's elective conference in 2027.

IOL News

36 minutes ago

• IOL News

Managing Diversity in South Africa: Learning from the UAE experience

South Africa's rich diversity is enshrined in its progressive Constitution, yet social cohesion remains a challenge, writes Daryl Swanepoel. Image: IOL / Ron AI South Africa is a country of profound diversity, in race, ethnicity, language, culture and religion. Its Constitution, one of the most progressive in the world, recognises and protects this diversity. It provides for human dignity, equality, non-racialism and non-sexism, as well as the right to freely practice one's culture and language. Institutions such as the Commission for the Promotion and Protection of the Rights of Cultural, Religious and Linguistic Communities (CRL Rights Commission) exist precisely to protect these constitutional values. Yet, despite these mechanisms, the country continues to face serious challenges in achieving genuine social cohesion, with high levels of poverty and inequality, largely still shaped along racial lines, contributing to tensions between communities. Historical divisions from apartheid continue to manifest in mistrust, exclusion and lack of cross-cultural understanding. Moreover, the lack of a comprehensive social cohesion strategy has meant that efforts to unify South Africa's people are sporadic, reactive, and often symbolic rather than systemic. Even though initiatives such as the 2012 National Cohesion Summit and government frameworks like the National Development Plan (NDP) identify social cohesion as a priority, implementation has been weak. Social cohesion remains elusive not because the constitutional architecture is flawed, but because the country lacks a focused, strategic approach to operationalise it in daily governance, education and community life. South Africa is in urgent need of a new, practical model that can guide it toward meaningful unity in diversity. For this, the experience of the United Arab Emirates (UAE) offers valuable lessons. The United Arab Emirates provides a striking example of how a society can consciously build mechanisms to manage diversity. With a population consisting of more than 200 nationalities and multiple religious and cultural groups, the UAE is one of the most diverse nations in the world. Unlike South Africa, the UAE did not emerge from a formalised system of racial oppression, yet, due to the diversity that comes with the range of nationalities now in the country, it faces immense challenges in integrating its multicultural population within a cohesive national framework. To respond to this challenge, the UAE government adopted a deliberate, structured approach and in 2016, it established a Ministry of Tolerance and Coexistence, which is dedicated to promoting harmonious relationships among the country's various cultural, religious and ethnic groups. It is not a ceremonial office; it plays an active role in policymaking, education and public engagement to foster shared values and social understanding. The UAE's approach is proactive and institutionalised. It goes beyond symbolism, embedding tolerance and intercultural respect into its national vision. One of its flagship initiatives was the Year of Tolerance in 2019, during which numerous programmes, campaigns and interfaith events were held. A key outcome was the establishment of the Abrahamic Family House, a complex in Abu Dhabi housing a mosque, church and synagogue, a powerful physical symbol of religious co-existence. Importantly, the UAE's model embraces both a unifying national identity and the preservation of individual cultural identities, rather than enforcing rigid assimilation. The state encourages diversity within a shared framework of mutual respect, which duality balances common civic values and cultural particularity. The UAE also links social cohesion to national development. It understands that diversity, if managed well, is an asset that can strengthen innovation, global engagement and social stability. Hence, tolerance is not only treated as a social imperative, but also as a contributor to economic resilience and political continuity. Recommendations for South Africa: From fragmentation to unity Drawing from the lessons of the UAE and recognising South Africa's unique history and democratic values, several strategic recommendations emerge to strengthen social cohesion domestically: Establish a dedicated social cohesion institution South Africa lacks a central agency mandated to coordinate social cohesion efforts across government, civil society and the private sector. A national structure, akin to the UAE's Ministry of Tolerance, should be established to drive strategic planning, monitor progress and champion inclusive values across all spheres of society. Develop a national social cohesion strategy The current approach is fragmented. South Africa must adopt a comprehensive, well-resourced national social cohesion strategy aligned to the Constitution. This strategy should integrate the work of existing institutions, set measurable goals and be embedded within national and provincial governance plans. It should also prioritise conflict resolution, intercultural education and multilingual communication. Reimagine civic education to promote unity in diversity Educational curricula must be transformed to teach young people the value of diversity, inclusion and active citizenship. Cultural literacy, empathy and human rights should be key components of schooling, alongside fostering pride in South Africa's rich cultural tapestry. As the UAE does, this education must not just reside in theory but be reinforced through national campaigns and visible leadership. Institutionalise public symbols and dialogue platforms South Africa should follow the UAE's example by introducing national dialogue platforms and visible public initiatives to promote cross-cultural understanding. For example, hosting an annual National Year of Social Cohesion could mobilise schools, faith institutions and media around a shared theme of unity. Public art, festivals and symbols must reflect the country's collective history and future aspirations. Strengthen the role of the CRL Rights Commission The CRL Rights Commission already exists to support cultural, religious and linguistic communities. However, its potential is underutilised. It should be capacitated further to lead local dialogue initiatives, mediate cultural disputes and advise government on inclusive policies. As with the UAE's tolerance ministry, the CRL must be a visible champion for unity. Promote equitable access to services and opportunity At the root of many social tensions is economic exclusion. The state must accelerate efforts to redress inequalities in housing, education and employment. Spatial integration, equitable service delivery and inclusive urban design are essential to break historical divides and build shared spaces where cohesion can flourish. Partner with religious and cultural leaders Faith-based and cultural institutions remain powerful influencers in South African society. A formal partnership model should be developed where government and these groups co-develop community programmes, especially in areas prone to conflict or marginalisation. The UAE's success is partly built on engaging religious leaders to promote peace and coexistence. Similarly, cultural leaders from across all groups should be consulted, engaged and involved in promoting social cohesion. Conclusion: A Cohesion compact for a shared future Social cohesion is not a luxury. It is the foundation of democratic stability, national development and collective dignity. South Africa has the legal frameworks, the civil society energy and the multicultural richness to become a global model of inclusion. What it lacks is coordination, leadership and strategic vision. The UAE has shown that it is possible to intentionally build unity amidst diversity, not by flattening difference, but by nurturing respect and belonging. South Africa should not replicate its political system, but it must replicate the deliberateness of its social cohesion agenda. By embedding inclusion into our institutions, education, public symbols and development priorities, we can transform our diversity from a source of tension into a wellspring of strength. The Constitution lights the path; it is now time to walk it, together. * Daryl Swanepoel is a research fellow at the School for Public Leadership Stellenbosch University and the Chief Executive Officer of the Inclusive Society Institute. This article draws its inspiration the Institute's recently published report 'Managing Social Cohesion in diverse communities: Can South Africa draw lessons from United Arab Emirates'. ** The views expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of IOL or Independent Media.

Eyewitness News

an hour ago

• Eyewitness News

A R700m National Dialogue limits the butterfly that SA is dying to become

South Africa is dying to become a butterfly. Mzansi has been locked in its chrysalis for far too long. This is evident in the social regression at the hands of leadership that continues to shoot in the dark. An adult butterfly goes through three stages before it can spread its wings and fly, namely the egg, larva (caterpillar), pupa (chrysalis) and adult. If the chrysalis represents transformation, let the adult butterfly take the place of social freedom since 1994, and it's clear that what could become an admirable creature is suffocating. It is still blood-curdling to think that for 31 years of democracy, the country is still grappling with inequality, high unemployment, of which the youth bear the brunt, rampant crime, gender-based violence (GBV), to name some of our stagnation thorns. President Cyril Ramaphosa, on Youth Month, announced a National Dialogue that will cost taxpayers R700 million. According to the Presidency, the National Dialogue seeks to afford all citizens the opportunity to thrash out the country's challenges and ways to remedy them. The first National Convention, the Presidency says, will play out as an all-inclusive process for citizens to partake as individuals or organised groups, the first of which will take place on 15 August, thus setting the agenda for the National Dialogue. It will be followed by nationwide discussions involving different 'sectors on issues that citizens feel deserve national attention', added the Presidency. Thereafter, the Presidency explains, a second National Convention will take place at the start of 2026 to consolidate the discussions into 'a common national vision and implementation programme'. HOW MANY TALK SHOPS DOES SOUTH AFRICA NEED? Are you telling me that at least R700 million is due to be spent on restructuring a society that bleeds absurd inequality? I believe the government is using the National Dialogue as a ruse to make citizens feel included and heard. But how long must we wait for tangible change? Time is running out for transformation and the reversal of our past injustices can be upended. What happened to the National Development Plan (NDP) 2030? (Another talk shop running out of time.) The 489-page NDP forward statement reads that it was devised "for the country to eliminate poverty and reduce inequality by 2030 through uniting South Africans, unleashing the energies of its citizens, growing an inclusive economy, building capabilities, enhancing the capability of the state and leaders working together to solve complex problems". Look around and see how far we are from the finish line. Advertise a vacancy and see the clout in terms of applicants because the official unemployment figure from Stats SA for the first quarter of 2025 is 32.9%. Moreover, the youth aged between 15 and 34 comprise 50.2% of the country's working-age citizens. There's also the invisible cohort that does not fit the youth bracket, who face being overlooked and disregarded, in an economy that has seen poor growth. To date, the economy saw growth of 0.6% in the fourth quarter of 2024, after a revised reduction in the previous year. Unemployed graduates, youth seeking any form of work and those who have given up on the toil of searching for a means to buy bread and butter it. They are in despair, they resort to all sorts of ways to honour their existence, and at times they choose destruction that takes many forms. Drugs, alcohol abuse, heavy depression, crime and leaning on nothing because there's no structure to fall back on. Many of the government's decisions are attacks on citizens. Go to the South African Social Security Agency (SASSA) on Harrisson Street at 5am and see the elderly queuing for the offices to open as they brave the chills because it's a few hours before the agency opens. This is due to a failure of the system of changing to Postbank black cards that was planned in the dark, and therefore renders beneficiaries hopeless. Sometimes, it's so dark that you don't realise that there are people until you see vapour escaping as they breathe or speak. Not far from there, there's the Department of Home Affairs, where the same scenario plays out. It's ineffable to observe this! In KwaZulu-Natal, Premier Thami Ntuli had no idea that schools were not properly financed before exams commenced. I could go on and on, but I doubt there's even a sense of urgency or pressure to see it materialise due to the snail's pace at which the nation is moving. SOME OF SOUTH AFRICA'S PILLARS OF DIALOGUE South Africa does have bodies whose agenda it is to remedy its social fabric and advancement in the current democratic dispensation through dialogue and outreach programmes. They include the Ahmed Kathrada Foundation, the Nelson Mandela Foundation, and the Thabo Mbeki Foundation, all of which have since been represented in the National Dialogue after the Presidency cleared the air about media reports on their exclusion. "Media reports that certain foundations belonging to the stalwarts of the liberation struggle have been sidelined or overlooked are inaccurate," said the Presidency. How about channeling funds for youth empowerment initiatives, pragmatic ways of including the previously disenfranchised, and shortchanged by a system built to break them, in the mainstream economy, sorting out the mess that is the South African Social Security Agency, among others. SOUTH AFRICA IS WAITING TO SOAR Those elected to power really need to think hard about how citizens are overburdened by decision-makers, who are tone deaf, in a country that has so much potential for all to enjoy a decent existence free of suffering and despair. South Africa wants to merrily spread its wings and for its people to see and feel its beauty and enchantment. And this can only happen when the leadership makes honest assessments of blatant failures that are jolting to the transformation project and social justice.