David vs Goliath?

AFP | Jim WATSON
JOHANNESBURG - David took on Goliath at the White House, in what was, for South Africans, a highly anticipated showdown of biblical proportions.
President Cyril Ramaphosa was the proverbial David and President Donald Trump, Goliath.
Famously, Goliath is a large figure that was always expected to wipe the floor with the much smaller David, a lowly shepherd, only to be taken out by a careful and sophisticated use of the sling and a single stone.
Is this what we witnessed in the Trump-Ramaphosa meeting on Wednesday?
Looking back, there is quite a lot that came out of that meeting. We have now come to expect an ambush from the US President, and we're sadly starting to become desensitised to this type of behaviour.
AFP | Jim WATSON
However, there are a few questions that stand out, mainly about the delegation that was present in the briefing, put together by President Ramaphosa himself. Pro-golfers Ernie Els and Retief Goosen, industrialist Johan Rupert, are among the recognisable civilian names in support of the politicians accompanying Ramaphosa.
GNU partners, Agriculture Minister John Steenhuisen and Trade and Industry Minister Parks Tau, were also joined by COSATU President Zingiswa Losi.
Is this group the sling and stone that Ramaphosa needed?
The SA-US relationship has been strained for some time now, with Trump claiming the South African government is doing very bad things to white Afrikaner farmers, including unsubstantiated claims of 'genocide'.
GCIS
On his return to the White House, Trump has cut HIV/AIDS funding, offered Afrikaners refugee status, and even threatened to slap some of South Africa's politicians with sanctions.
Wednesday's high stakes meeting was a culmination of these tensions, and the stage was set out in something akin to a battleground. The Oval office was rife with the tension you might experience in a war setting, that had many a South African on the edge of their seats.
Was Ramaphosa our David? Was the delegation the tools he needed or merely tools given to him? Could he wield the tools he had for a better future?
GCIS
GCIS
One must commend the South African President for calm composure, and resilience under what must have been a nerve wrecking and tumultuous occasion. Ramaphosa is not just a president, but he is the president of a nation of majority black Africans, who just 31 years ago (and not 35 years) fought and gained their freedom, against the same group now readily accepting prancing around leveraging whatever agenda Trump has through his baseless and unfounded claims.
'Mandela taught us' was a line that rolled off Ramaphosa's tongue, and he managed to make it clear to Trump that South Africa strongly believes in its global moral position and will not back away from issues of moral infractions in the global community. South Africa is, on these matters, an authoritative voice, and South Africa is here to stay.
From there, things seem to go quite sideways, and where we hoped to see David wield his sling and stone, we instead had a cinematic experience of a South Africa that seemed quite alien to its citizens. This, we now know was amateurish creativity designed to amplify the Trump genocidal tune and have the world dance at his feet, much like the jovial and uniquely South Africa dancing of Malema's chant of the historically (and constitutionally) justified struggle song.
Rather than vehemently defend the right to our history and the sovereign liberty of our courts to decide whether such matters constitute hate speech or any other such bad things as Trump seems to parrot, Ramaphosa and Steenhuisen proceeded to unscrupulously detach themselves from Malema.
The EFF leader has in his own right contributed tremendously to the South African political arena, however one chooses to judge that contribution.
So, it is right to draw inspiration from Mandela, but not from the struggle movement that gave us the very same Mandela, and still fuels and drives many of our vehicles of self-expression and self-determination?
Perhaps this is because we are a violent nation, and the wisdom of Mandela is necessary to tame and guide us away from our own violent tendencies. Is this what South Africans, the US and the world must understand from the utterances of COSATU president Zingiswa Losi.
Without taking away from her attempt to fabricate unity among the members of the delegation, that display of diplomacy is in poor contrast to the defamation of South Africa's public image, calling the country a violent nation.
To say we understand her sentiments in attempting to clearly indicate that the issue, is not about some hallucinated genocide, but rather an issue of crime – an infamous byproduct of inequality, unemployment, and poverty; this would be far too much leniency than she has given South Africa's government.
GCIS
GCIS
But let's not throw the baby out with the bath water just yet. South Africa is now perfectly poised to fight crime on a scale hitherto unseen. Elon Musk shall save us and equip all our police structures with Starlink, and then there will be no more genocides or gang wars. Johann Rupert was only missing some tattered clothing and a bowl, in what was reminiscent of Oliver Twist's famous plea for more soup.
It is yet unclear, however, how a satellite internet network is going to help us fight crime any more than conventional internet networks. Maybe this satellite internet network is going to give us premium access to such AI tools as Grok that can tell us exactly how the white farmers are being killed en masse, and perhaps even generate some documentaries for us that capture the perpetrators, and we shall be free to arrest at will, those even in contravention of our own constitutional edicts.
'When you have nothing to say, say nothing.' This is not a directive for one to continue to utter sounds and syllables against all evidence to the contrary, but perhaps all those hours in the open air of the golf course and one learns to speak the language of the trees and the grass, whispering a purer and higher form of nothing.
AFP | Jim WATSON
No one is saying that Afrikaners and white farmers should not have a voice and express what they feel is genuinely a concern for their social group. However, they are not unique in their fears about the criminal element in South Africa. All South Africans share various fears about their livelihood and position in the country.
But it is hypocritical of them to not place the matter into the pertinent context. We are a young nation, still battling to find ourselves with the truly atrocious and violent war crimes by the Afrikaner minority of the National Party, still fresh in our collective minds.
We are not, however, a violent nation. We are a recovering nation. The delegation failed, dismally, to leave this point unambiguously clear to the global community in what was a fantastically unique opportunity.
Sadly, the sling came apart, the stone – a mere lump of sand – crumbled, and this David could not be the shepherd we really needed.
By: Smangaliso Mkhuma

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Citizen

15 minutes ago

• The Citizen

Iran strike: Another fuel crisis looming?

Sharp curbs on exports reminiscent of 1973 may follow. Participants shout slogans during an anti-war demonstration in Boston, Massachusetts, on 22 June 2025, protesting US strikes on Iranian nuclear sites. Picture: Joseph Prezioso / AFP Will the history of just over 50 years ago repeat itself in the form of another Middle East oil boycott or shortage, following the US intervention in the war between Israel and Iran? That's the question consumers – and especially motorists – as well as experts are pondering in the wake of the weekend air strikes by American bombers of Iran's nuclear facilities. In 1973, the Arab-Israeli war saw the Arab-dominated Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Countries putting in place sharp curbs on exports. This not only forced a massive rise in fuel prices, but saw many countries in the West hit by sudden fuel shortages. Drastic steps taken in SA during fuel shortage In South Africa, the government took drastic steps, including lowering the national speed limit from 120km/h to 80km/h and banning fuel sales after hours and over weekends. The trauma of that fuel shortage led directly to the then National Party government establishing a Strategic Fuel Reserve for the country. ALSO READ: Did the US strikes succeed, and how will Iran respond? Economist Dawie Roodt said SA can expect some more clarity on what exactly to expect in the days to come. 'We will have to wait and see,' he said, adding it might affect petrol prices and inflation rate and weaken the rand. 'This could be quite a thing for South Africa. It just depends on how long it goes on and how serious it is,' he said. Senior political lecturer at North-West University Dr Benjamin Rapanyane said conflicts like this one have a way of disrupting international peace and the flow of trade. 'The worst-case scenario would be the disruptions of shipments in the Strait of Hormuz. This may have a devastating impact on Africa in general and South Africa in particular,' he said. ALSO READ: US joins Israel-Iran conflict with overnight bombing campaign Political analyst Piet Croucamp said it could mean nothing or something. 'Nothing in the sense of let's stay out of it, which is hardly possible given the court case SA has against Israel,' he said. 'There's a universal condemnation of Israel for what they have been doing in Gaza and also the attack on Iran, which is against the United Nations resolutions.' Croucamp said it might be hard for SA to stay out of it. 'So many people around the world are concerned about the consequences of what is being done to Iran, but we are also concerned about Gaza,' he said. 'We dare not shut up. We have to say something. Not from a moral high ground because we cannot afford that, too, but it doesn't mean that we don't get to say something.' ALSO READ: What Israel–Iran conflict means for South African economy Political analyst Roland Henwood said there were no immediate implications. 'Indirectly, it will depend on how the situation develops. Politically, the reaction from SA, Brics and other international organisations and governments will be important to follow,' he said. 'If SA reacts very strongly against America and in favour of Iran, it may have negative political consequences. Other outcomes will include the effects of increased oil prices.' Henwood said this may have short-term or long-term implications for the country. 'So far, the reactions from the rest of the world have been rather muted. We will have to see how this situation develops,' he added.

IOL News

30 minutes ago

• IOL News

Political leaders demand stricter laws for whistle-blower safety

There is a need for laws that protect whistle-blowers. Image: Meta AI World Whistle-blowers Day on June 23 is dedicated to raising awareness about the crucial role that whistleblowers play in exposing wrongdoing and promoting transparency. THERE have been heightened calls for the Government of National Unity (GNU) to provide better protection to whistle-blowers. During a recent mini-plenary session, members of parliament (MP) from various political parties debated the need for strengthening whistle-blower protection by enacting robust laws that guarantee anonymity, job security, and legal support for individuals who reported corruption. Visvin Reddy, an uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) Party member of parliament, said they tackled corruption head on. 'We don't silence whistle-blowers. We protect them because in a country drowning in lies, the person who tells the truth is the bravest one of all. I will say this loud and clear, if Babita Deokaran had spoken out under an MK government, she would still be alive today. She would be protected, not hunted; celebrated not assassinated; and the people stealing from our people, they would be behind bars, and not behind desks.' Reddy said those who spoke the truth, faced losing their jobs or lives. 'Take Babita for example, she worked in the Gauteng health department. She saw money meant for hospitals and nurses being looted through dodgy PPE tenders. She did the right thing and what did she get? She was killed in front of her home. The big fish behind it, where are they? They are still free. 'There are officials in licensing departments who are watching bribes being taken daily. There are municipal officials who see tenders given to cronies while people go without water. They stay silent because they know the risk. Over 10 years, the AG (Auditor General) has flagged billions in corruption. That's why the MK Party says enough is enough. We are not here to protect the corrupt. We are here to protect the brave souls who speak up,' he said. Reddy said there was a need for laws that protected whistle-blowers, guarantee anonymity and job safety, provide legal support and emergency relocation if needed. 'We propose a whistle-blower protection act, an independent whistleblower agency, a national whistle-blower heroes fund and jail time for leaking a whistle-blower's identity. All whistle-blower reports need to be automatically investigated by a corruption unit free from political interference. Let us honour Babita and let us protect the next brave voice. This is not about politics; this is about the soul of our nation,' he said. Dereleen James, an ActionSA MP said: 'If the GNU even cared one iota about protecting whistle-blowers they would have done it by now. If they were remotely serious about strengthening protections for the brave South Africans who risk everything to expose corruption then the Zondo Commission's recommendations would not be gathering dust three years later. Untouched, unimplemented and just forgotten.' She said the GNU was not a unity of purpose. 'It's a coalition of coverups and the so-called progressive. The GNU does not want to protect whistle-blowers because they are protecting themselves. They drag their feet on funding the NPA because they are terrified of being prosecuted. They do not want to fight corruption because they are corrupt. The GNU does not want justice, they want silence. Silence from Babita Deokaran, silence from every South African who dares speak the truth. 'Well not on our watch. This is why ActionSA will be introducing a Zero Tolerance Corruption Bill to take on public enemy number one which is corruption. The bill is a warning shot to every crooked politician who thinks they will be shuffled from one coy cozy position to the next. We are coming for you. To every official who thinks that looting the State can be followed by a quiet retirement or diplomatic posting, your time is up. The bill will ensure that anyone convicted of corruption will never hold public office again. Once you break the bond of public trust, you are out forever. 'We will be introducing whistle-blowers rewards based on international best practice. If the State won't protect whistle-blowers, then let us do so. We will give whistle-blowers the means, the safety and the legal support they need to come forward and take down the syndicates that have embedded themselves at the heart of government. The truth is, the GNU is not a solution to our crisis, it is the crisis. The so-called progressive caucus is not a solution. They are the wolves eyeing the sheep and ActionSA will not sit quietly while South Africans are expected to accept corruption that goes unpunished,' she said. Glynnis Breytenbach, a Democratic Alliance MP said: 'In this country are at a crossroads in democracy. One where the integrity of our institutions, the trust of our citizens and the sanctity of our constitutional values are under immense strain.' She said the matter of whistle-blower protection in South Africa was an issue not only of legal and administrative reform, but of moral imperative. 'Whistle-blowers play an important role in our society. They are not saboteurs, they are not enemies of the state, they are brave men and women who often at great personal cost shine a light on corruption, maladministration, abuse of power and gross human rights violations. They are guardians of public interest, uncompensated sentinels of our democracy. 'Whistle-blowers act in the spirit of Section 195 of our Constitution which enshrines principles of transparency, accountability and good governance. They ensure that State power is exercised lawfully, ethically and in the service of the people. When they step forward to expose wrongdoing they are often met not with gratitude or protection but with intimidation, harassment, unemployment isolation and in far too many cases, death,' she said. Breytenbach said that the current state of whistle-blower protection in South Africa was inadequate and incoherent. 'The main legislative instrument, the Protected Disclosures Act (PDA) was a progressive step forward at the time of its enactment. But over two decades later it has not evolved sufficiently to address the sophisticated threats whistle-blowers face today. The act applies primarily to employees in the workplace context. It does not extend adequately to contractors, consultants, volunteers or community members who may witness corruption or wrongdoing. 'The PDA offers no proactive physical protection or financial support. It only provides post-op remedies which are often difficult, expensive and time consuming to pursue. No independent whistle-blower protection authority exists. Oversight is fragmented across the public protector the SAPS, the Hawks and other bodies, none of which are solely or effectively tasked with whistle-blower protection. As a result many whistleblowers have had their identities leaked often by those entrusted with their safety. 'One of the proposals is a private bill which is being prepared by the DA to be introduced in the near future. We must always remember the words of Archbishop Desmond Tutu, who said, 'If you are neutral in situations of injustice, you have chosen the side of the oppressor'. I urge this parliament to act boldly, decisively and immediately. Let us institutionalise the values of our constitution. We should not wait for another name to be added to the tragic lists of those betrayed by the very system they try to save,' she said. Marlon Daniels, a Patriotic Alliance MP, said whistle-blowers, who had the courage to expose corruption often at great personal risk are not just informants. 'They are patriots. They are defenders of justice and deserve our full protection. If the information they provide us is factual, if it exposes the fraud or abuse of power then we must stand with them without any hesitation.' Daniels said whistle-blowers also played a critical role in holding the powerful accountable. 'Without whistle-blowers, State capture would have remained hidden. Billions of taxpayers money would still be looted with impunity and public trust in government would be completely eroded. Yet, what happens to those who speak out? They face intimidation, job losses and even threats to their lives. This is unacceptable. If we are serious about fighting corruption we must ensure that those who expose it are protected and not persecuted. 'We demand robust whistle-blower protection laws that guarantee anonymity. Whistle-blowers must be able to report corruption without fear of exposure. No individual should also lose their livelihood for doing the right thing and as far as legal support goes, the State must provide legal defense to whistle-blowers against frivolous lawsuits or retaliation. 'South Africa is at a crossroads. We can either side with those who steal from the poor or we can stand with the brave men and women who risk everything to expose the truth. The Patriotic Alliance chooses the side of justice. If South Africa is to be saved from corruption we must empower the whistle-blower. Let us pass these laws and defend the brave. Let us rebuild this nation,' he said. THE POST

Mail & Guardian

39 minutes ago

• Mail & Guardian

Environment minister reflects on his – and the GNU's – first year in office

Minister Dion George. (Photo: Environmentza/X) When George, who was sworn into office on 3 July under the coalition President Cyril Ramaphosa put together after his ANC lost its outright parliament majority — said serving in this government 'has required all of us to work collaboratively – sometimes across vastly different perspectives — toward a common goal: delivering real outcomes for the people of South Africa'. In a media briefing to assess how his department has fared over the past year, George said the GNU has created a situation where departments are increasingly working across silos, 'where ideas are strengthened through debate and collective intelligence', and where the urgency of service delivery is matched by a 'shared will to get things done'. This week analysts George said his department had approached its work 'with a recognition that our environmental mandate is not separate from the economic one, or the social one. They are deeply interconnected.' Protecting natural resources, wildlife Among George's 'big six' priority areas is protecting natural resources and wildlife. Here, he cited his department's significant achievement regarding the protection of the critically endangered 'After learning about the sharp population declines and the human impacts causing them, I called for open, lawyer-free discussions that brought together conservation organisations like BirdLife South Africa and Sanccob [Southern African Foundation for the Conservation of Coastal Birds, industry leaders in the fishing sector and our departmental experts,' he said. This collaborative approach led to a court-ordered agreement to implement island closures around key breeding colonies. 'We amended the small pelagic fishery permit conditions to enforce these closures, ensuring sustainable fishing near vital penguin habitats,' he said. These changes were implemented almost immediately. His department is also tackling the harm caused by bunkering in Algoa Bay, near St Croix Island, once home to the largest African penguin colony in the world. Ship-to-ship refuelling has caused oil spills and underwater noise pollution. After a A coordinated approach has led to prosecutions and a continued decline in rhino poaching incidents, with George noting his department's attention is also turning to species such as 'The lives of these animals are not commodities. They are a vital part of our ecological and cultural identity,' he said. George said his department's efforts were showing that jobs can be created, new industries stimulated and growth unlocked, 'while caring for the planet'. He noted that in the fourth quarter of last year, the agriculture, forestry and fishing sectors recorded a 'remarkable' 17.2% growth, contributing two-thirds of the total GDP growth for that quarter. In the first quarter of this year, these sectors grew by 15.8%. 'These are not just numbers,' he said. 'They reflect thousands of jobs and livelihoods sustained. We increased the number of fish species available to The department's harbour revitalisation programme has created more than 2 300 work opportunities while through expanded support for sustainable aquaculture, 'we're seeing green technology spark new enterprises along our coasts'. George said the recent floods in KwaZulu-Natal and Mthatha in the Eastern Cape are only the latest signs that the time for talk regarding climate change is over. This is why the department finalised the The department secured George said these were not blanket waivers. 'Each exemption comes with firm conditions, including health interventions for affected communities, real-time emissions monitoring, and a firm commitment to transition to cleaner energy sources. We are holding polluters accountable.' The department is working with the presidency and the department of mineral resources and energy to develop a competitive power market, 'bringing independent power producers into the fold. The goal is clear: to deliver both energy security and environmental sustainability.' South Africa has contributed to international environmental governance, and continues to lead. George said it played a major role in negotiating the At the last climate summit in Baku, South Africa 'brokered a deal that balanced the need for ambitious climate action with the reality of our economic conditions', he said, adding that this agreement unlocked green investment for local projects that will support South Africa's just energy transition. 'And in our G20 Presidency year, we are hosting major environment and climate sustainability meetings, positioning South Africa as a leader on the African continent and beyond. These engagements not only strengthen our global voice but also attract investment and expertise.' George said another of his key focus areas has been making his department's systems more efficient, transparent and responsive. It had launched the regulatory efficiency strategy for environmental turbocharge, a set of reforms to speed up approvals for energy and infrastructure projects, 'while still protecting the environment'. His department had identified 11 renewable energy development zones where significantly simplified environmental impact assessments had reduced approval times from 300 days to 147. 'For lower sensitivity areas, we've introduced fast-tracked authorisations that can be processed in around 70 days,' the minister said. The new national web-based environmental screening tool is 'already helping developers identify low-impact sites for projects, streamlining planning and protecting biodiversity'. Since his appointment, George has finalised 162 environmental appeals, '106 of them since our 100-day feedback session', which is a 'testament to our commitment to fairness, transparency and turnaround times'. Although the department is operating in a constrained fiscal environment, it has launched a departmental spending review and implemented firm cost-containment measures. 'But, more importantly, we have begun thinking creatively about revenue generation,' he said. 'Each branch of our department is tasked with identifying savings and new funding streams.' This includes sourcing international donor support for enforcement and anti-poaching, innovative financing mechanisms for green projects and working with the treasury on sustainable budget models. The minister said the South African Forestry Company or Safcol, SANParks and the South African Weather Service are receiving strategic attention to address governance weaknesses and boost their effectiveness. 'We also celebrated the achievement of a clean audit at iSimangaliso Wetland Park — a symbol of what good governance can look like across our sector,' while flagship projects to elevate the country's environmental brand, improve delivery and stimulate economic opportunity have been initiated. George said the department is finalising the national carbon credits and biodiversity offsets framework, which will allow companies to 'offset emissions responsibly', while directing funds into conservation and community development.