A ‘bottomless pit of plagiarism': Disney, Universal sue Midjourney for copyright infringement
AI-powered image generator Midjourney is accused of making and distributing without permission 'innumerable' copies of characters such as (from left) Darth Vader from Star Wars, Elsa from Frozen, and the Minions from Despicable Me. PHOTOS: LUCAS FILM, STARHUB, UNIVERSAL PICTURES
LOS ANGELES - Walt Disney and Comcast's Universal filed a copyright lawsuit against Midjourney on June 11, calling its popular AI-powered image generator a 'bottomless pit of plagiarism' for its use of the studios' best-known characters.
The suit, filed in federal district court in Los Angeles, claims Midjourney pirated the libraries of the two Hollywood studios, making and distributing without permission 'innumerable' copies of characters such as Darth Vader from Star Wars, Elsa from Frozen, and the Minions from Despicable Me.
The studios claim the San Francisco company rebuffed their request to stop infringing their copyrighted works or, at a minimum, take technological measures to halt the creation of these AI-generated characters.
Instead, the studios argue, Midjourney continued to release new versions of its AI image service that boast higher quality infringing images.
Midjourney recreates animated images from a typed request, or prompt.
In the suit filed by seven corporate entities at the studios that own or control copyrights for the various Disney and Universal Pictures film units, the studios offered examples of Midjourney animations that include Disney characters, such as Yoda wielding a lightsaber, Bart Simpson riding a skateboard, Marvel's Iron Man soaring above the clouds and Pixar's Buzz Lightyear taking flight.
The image generator also recreated such Universal characters as How To Train Your Dragon's dragon, Toothless, the green ogre Shrek, and Po from Kung Fu Panda.
'By helping itself to plaintiffs' copyrighted works, and then distributing images (and soon videos) that blatantly incorporate and copy Disney's and Universal's famous characters - without investing a penny in their creation - Midjourney is the quintessential copyright free-rider and a bottomless pit of plagiarism,' the suit alleges.
'Midjourney's infringement is calculated and willful.'
Disney and Universal asked the court for a preliminary injunction, to prevent Midjourney from copying their works, or offering its image- or video-generation service without protections against infringement. The studios also seek unspecified damages.
The suit alleges Midjourney used the studios' works to train its image service and generate reproductions of their copyrighted characters. The company, founded in 2021 by David Holz, monetises the service through paid subscriptions and generated US$300 million (S$385 million) in revenue in 2024 alone, the studios said.
This is not the first time Midjourney has been accused of misusing artists' work to train their AI systems.
A year ago, a California federal judge found that 10 artists behind a copyright infringement suit against Midjourney, Stability AI and other companies had plausibly argued these AI companies had copied and stored their work on company servers, and could be liable for using it without permission.
That ruling allowed the lawsuit over the unauthorised use of images to proceed. It is in the process of litigation.
In a 2022 interview with Forbes, CEO Holz said he built the company's database by performing "a big scrape of the Internet."
Asked whether he sought consent of the artists whose work was covered by copyright, he responded, 'there isn't really a way to get a hundred million images and know where they're coming from.' REUTERS
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
International Business Times
3 hours ago
- International Business Times
AI Startup Midjourney Launches Image-to-Video Creation Model V1- Here is All You Need to Know
Right after getting into legal trouble with entertainment giant Disney, AI startup has launched its image-to-video generation model V1. The new tool allows users to convert images into short video clips and is available to the users for free. The new offering is available today via Midjourney's website, and it's available to all customers, including those who want to use a free account. Faster video rendering is limited to those users who pay for a subscription, which begins at $10 a month. The move positions the platform in competition with AI-powered video creation. V1's launch is a significant step forward for Midjourney, which has spent the majority of its time creating visually rich static images. With the new tool, the start-up is going after users who want to animate the visuals they create, offering features that strike a balance between simplicity, customization, and affordability. Despite the fact that the tool is available to all the Midjourney users free of cost at the preliminary level, one aspect of concern is the GPU usage by the tool, as the process of video generation is more resource-intensive, requiring eight times more GPU time per second of video. Hence, the users have to allocate GPU time carefully, especially when using the fast mode available under standard subscriptions. The company has also provided Relax Mode to heavy users or creative professionals, but it is accessible only to Pro-tier users and higher. This mode allows unlimited videos at no extra cost, but with longer waiting times, it can at times be up to 10 minutes for one animation. "The pricing model still gives you a massive cost advantage," the company says—reportedly being over 25 times cheaper than any of the current AI video generation tools on the market. Though the new tool is not far from controversy, like many other artificial intelligence models. Midjourney was sued for copyright infringement by major media companies, including Disney and NBCUniversal. The lawsuit claims that the platform enables unauthorized derivative works by reproducing characters and images from popular franchises. The studios said Midjourney has essentially become a "virtual vending machine" for pirated offerings, citing instances using characters from Star Wars, Toy Story, Marvel, and The Simpsons. The company has not publicly addressed the lawsuit or issued a public statement about the legal questions raised about V1. Midjourney founder David Holz has called the video model a "stepping stone" to more sophisticated applications, such as real-time, three-dimensional environments that users can interact with. As far as the actual animation process is concerned, Midjourney V1 is designed to be user-friendly as seen below: Users begin by uploading an image—either created within Midjourney or imported from another source. After the image is generated, an "Animate" button lets users transform the static image into a video. The system produces four 5-second video clips from the chosen image. These clips can be extended by four-second increments, up to a total of 21 seconds. Currently, the videos are silent, with no audio features supported. At present two animation modes are available: First, automatic mode , which applies system-suggested motion effects to the image. Second, manual mode lets users guide the animation through descriptive prompts. which applies system-suggested motion effects to the image. Second, manual mode lets users guide the animation through descriptive prompts. Users can also choose between two camera movement styles: Low Motion keeps the camera largely stationary, and High Motion introduces dynamic movement of both the subject and the camera. This new offering introduces an intuitive way to blend static visuals with motion, enhancing creative storytelling possibilities on the platform. Netizens were quick to upload the videos generated by the tool, which shows the kind of interest this tool has generated as seen above.
Nylon
2 days ago
- Nylon
A merch haven awaits you onboard the Disney Adventure
Already planning what to do when you get onboard the Disney Adventure? Here's another thing to add to your growing list of activities, that would be a priority for most — Merch! Image courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. Featuring nearly 17,000 square feet of dedicated retail space, the Disney Adventure will be introducing several first-of-their-kind retail experiences which include Disney Cruise Line's first World of Disney, the first National Geographic Store at sea, and the first-ever dedicated Duffy and Friends shop! As the first Disney Cruise ship to call Asia its home, the Disney Adventure will also feature exclusive product designs that celebrate the beauty, artistry, and diversity of the region with new merchandise lines that will complement a wide-range of signature Disney and Disney Cruise Line souvenirs, apparel, accessories, jewelry, homeware, and toys. Image courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. Often hailed as the ultimate Disney Parks shopping destination, this iconic store will make its debut onboard the Disney Adventure — its first Disney Cruise Line appearance. Reimagined for the high seas, this World of Disney will be an expansive complex of three interconnected locations housing a vast collection of Disney and Disney Cruise Line merchandise from plush characters to Mouse Ear headbands, to clothing and accessories, to souvenirs, toys, drink ware, as well as authentic Disney artwork that can be shipped directly to your home. Image courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. Image courtesy of Disney Cruise courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. Image courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. Image courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. Here is where you'll also find never-seen-before designs including a merchandise line that will pay tribute to Singapore's famous skyline and landmarks, and another that features a geometric tile print inspired by the nation's native flora and fauna. There's even a vibrantly hued collection that is inspired by the ancient architectural styles of Jaipur, India! Image courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. Making its first-ever appearance on a Disney Cruise Line onboard the Disney Adventure, the National Geographic Store offers an immersive retail experience complete with large vivid illuminated photographs and topographic floor graphics to reflect a sense of exploration and immersion into the natural world. Image courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. Image courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. Image courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. To celebrate its debut onboard, Disney Cruise Line and National Geographic will offer an exclusive, new co-branded collection that comprises of apparel and outdoor accessories such as hats and bags. This will be in addition to the classic range of National Geographic-branded apparel and athleisure wear in store. Image courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. Fans of Duffy and Friends would be excited for this exclusive dedicated store that will be making its inaugural appearance at sea. Image courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. Image courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. Image courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. Image courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. Decked out in Duffy's nautical theme, the shop will offer a whimsical collection of sought-after merch such as plush toys, apparel, and souvenirs, as well as a items from a new Disney Adventure exclusive line which features Duffy and his Friends. In addition to the new retail additions, Disney Adventure will also house guest-favourite retail venues from across the Disney Cruise Line fleet such as Diamonds & Wishes, which offers luxury offerings like jewelry and timepieces from world-class brands; Treasures Untold, which is a boutique inspired by Ariel's grotto; and Castle Collection, a kiosk that offers a delightful range of Disney souvenirs, including signature plush toys and Mouse Ear headbands. Image courtesy of Disney Cruise Line. For concierge guests, you will get exclusive access to two elegant boutiques within the expansive concierge area, each inspired by the gilded palace and sparkling treasures of Agrabah from Aladdin. Palace Treasures will feature a trove of luxury goods and fine jewelry from brands that include the Disney and Crown of Light co-branded collection, while the 3 Wishes boutique will be where you find one-of-a-kind apparel, souvenirs and collectibles that are Disney, Disney Cruise Line, and Disney Adventure-branded — some of which are unique designs you cannot find anywhere else on the ship!
Nylon
3 days ago
- Nylon
LEGO creates She Built That campaign to empower a new generation of girl builders
It's always been said that girls grow up with Barbie dolls and boys grow up with LEGO but over the years, this stereotype has changed and LEGO is looking to redefine and reclaim what it means to be a builder, and celebrate the female creativity. Image courtesy of LEGO. In a recent global research commissioned by The LEGO Group, it found that 80% of adults polled believed that society still viewed boys as naturally better builders than girls; which often led to girls and mothers undervaluing their own building skills compared to boys and their fathers. The study also uncovered a confidence gap in children, with girls rating themselves lower in building abilities than boys, and finding it hard to think of themselves as someone who is good at building things. Through the She Built That campaign, The LEGO Group aims to challenge societal stereotypes that stifle any girl's potential and inspire the next generation of female builders. Image courtesy of LEGO. With creative play, LEGO hopes to unlock every girl's creative confidence and inspire them to see themselves as creators and pioneers through their bigger portfolio of LEGO that caters to diverse interests and passions so that girls can create endless worlds across various themes such as LEGO Friends, Disney, Botanicals, Creator, and Gabby's Dollhouse. 42671 LEGO Friends Plant Café & Flower Shop. Image courtesy of LEGO. 42663 LEGO Friends Friendship Camper Van Adventure. Image courtesy of LEGO. Among these exciting and fun LEGO sets is the 42671 LEGO Friends Plant Café & Flower Shop that is designed to inspire the creation of friendship stories using elements such as a flower store, café with outdoor seating and LEGO Friends Aliya, Esma and Nugget the Cat. There's also a 42663 LEGO Friends Friendship Camper Van Adventure for girls who love camping and adventures. 43267 LEGO Disney Princess Castle & Royal Pets. Image courtesy of LEGO. 43278 LEGO Disney Princess Mini Arendelle Castle & Elsa's Ice Palace. Image courtesy of LEGO. For girls who love their Disney princesses, the detailed 43267 LEGO Disney Princess Castle & Royal Pets and 43278 LEGO Disney Princess Mini Arendelle Castle & Elsa's Ice Palace are the ones to get with their interactive play elements such as the movable furniture and the inclusion of well-loved characters Ariel, Rapunzel, Mulan, Elsa, Anna, and the first-ever Mushu character. 43249 LEGO Disney Stitch. Image courtesy of LEGO. 43257 LEGO Disney Angel. Image courtesy of LEGO. Disney fans can also build and bring their beloved 43249 LEGO Disney Stitch and 43257 LEGO Disney Angel to life for more storytelling or as a fun display. 10347 LEGO Botanicals Petite Sunny Bouquet. Image courtesy of LEGO. 103349 LEGO Botanical Happy Plants. Image courtesy of LEGO. 31169 LEGO Creator Typewriter with Flowers. Image courtesy of LEGO. Girls who would like to flex their creativity muscles can consider the 10347 LEGO Botanicals Petite Sunny Bouquet or the 103349 LEGO Botanical Happy Plants to arrange and create their own beautiful, cheerful floral display. There's even a 31169 LEGO Creator Typewriter with Flowers for those who like to build a combination of things. As part of the campaign, LEGO has also re-imagined Run D.M.C.'s hip-hop track 'It's Like That' into a vibrant celebration of girls' creativity together with its Global Girls Crew featuring US teen scratch sensation and spinner-to-the-stars DJ Livia, 15-year-old British drumming prodigy Nandi Bushell, Chinese alt-pop icon Canine, and Dutch-Surinamese vocalist Pink Oculus. Check out the music video below.
