I was a lifelong thrifter, committed to buying second-hand. Then I became addicted

This First Person column is the experience of Jennifer LoveGrove, who lives in Toronto. For more information about CBC's First Person stories, please see the FAQ.
When I got home from work, there were packages piled at my door. My partner was on his way to my place. There wasn't time to open them, to try on the new outfits, to post another thrift haul on Instagram. Worse, I couldn't admit I'd bought something else — something surely perfect this time! — despite all the neglected outfits bursting from my closet. Cringing, I shoved the packages under the couch and out of sight.
That's when I knew I had a problem, one more embarrassing than dangerous. It happened gradually, while wearing ratty sweatpants, during the years between the pandemic and turning 50. I had become addicted to shopping.
I've been a thrifter for as long as I can remember. I grew up in a small town and loved yard sales. As a child, I'd try on my grandmother's shoes and jewelry, and as a teen I was thrilled to get like-new, hand-me-downs from a fashionable aunt. In high school, we'd cram into the car of whomever agreed to take us vintage shopping in nearby Hamilton.
When I was younger, buying second-hand was not only affordable, but one-of-a-kind fashion was a way I expressed my creativity. Buying used offered uniqueness; no one else in theatre class would be wearing the same 1960s paisley dress with the sleeves cut off and a Dead Kennedys band logo glue-gunned onto the back.
Decades later, with the growing awareness of fast fashion's substantial role in the climate crisis, I became even more committed to buying second-hand. Swaps, thrift stores and sites like Poshmark and Facebook Marketplace provided the familiar thrill of the hunt and unique finds, while aligning with my values of sustainability.
But when the pandemic hit, my relationship to shopping changed. With plans cancelled or indefinitely postponed, I was alone, depressed and had nothing to look forward to. Learning to play the drums helped, but a painful injury knocked me down again.
Despite having nowhere to wear new outfits, I began to cheer myself up by shopping.
It began, ironically, with a local Facebook group dedicated to mindful consumption of second-hand fashion, which provided not just great outfits but social contact and even exercise in the form of bike rides to go pick up purchases.
I was still committed to second-hand fashion, but suddenly I couldn't get enough. When packages arrived, opening them boosted my mood, but the lift was temporary. A vintage leather skirt offered hope that I'd someday attend another concert, but it didn't fit. The beautiful cashmere cardigan was a steal but unbearably itchy against my sensitive skin.
Not only was I over-buying used clothing, I began buying new, too. If I liked something used but it wasn't in my size or sold to someone else, I'd obsess, unable to let go, stalking it like prey. A pair of high-rise wide-leg Levi's launched my enthusiasm into obsession. The used ones from Facebook didn't quite fit, and though I checked Poshmark frequently for my size, I lost patience, finally succumbing to buying them new.
WATCH | Second-hand shopping cool among people focused on sustainability:
Sustainability driving thrifting boom
6 years ago
Duration 2:43
I should have stopped then; instead I doubled down. I just hadn't found the right outfit yet, the style or look that would make me feel better.
My shopping — and credit card debt — was out of control. One used Free People tunic was practical; did I need it in three colours? I was ashamed. Once committed to ethical consumption, I'd become the opposite. A hypocrite.
After lockdowns and isolation were behind me, my shopping addiction persisted until I eventually realized I'd become the kind of shopper that I'd spent most of my life obnoxiously judging: impulsive, undisciplined, unoriginal.
Change of life changed my shopping — again
The moment I found myself hiding the unopened packages under the sofa coincided with the distressing changes of menopause. My body and my moods felt alien to me. Nothing fit and everything ached. I was so bloated, I convinced myself it was a third-trimester Post-Menopausal Immaculate Conception (it wasn't).
The body-shaming voice in my mind, fed by patriarchy and the 1990s heroin-chic propaganda of my youth, had surged back. If only I could find something flattering — soft pants, wrap dress, linen tunic — I would feel good again.
I resented my body, but I felt worse for caring at all. Clearly I'd failed as a feminist if I'd internalized harmful fatphobia.
But once I stopped berating myself, I was able to see the emotional layers.
As a young thrifter, I was expressing a creative and ethical identity. During the pandemic, I wasn't buying outfits, I was buying hope. After perimenopause invaded my body, I was buying comfort.
I was trying to buy back my past self.
That realization made the addiction less shallow, but it didn't make it vanish. I still needed to curb the impulses and regain my confidence.
Now, before clicking the checkout button, I force myself to answer a series of questions: Did I truly need this, would it last, did I have something similar?
I'm learning to (mostly) avoid temptation. Resisting the urge to buy The Dress That Will Solve All My Problems is one challenge; accepting my aging body — with its fluctuating sizes, random acne, sore shoulders and anxiety — is another.
New outfits don't bestow body acceptance, but playing the drums and cycling — physical activities I love — are healthier mood-boosters. So is telling my inner critic to shut up.
Despite the best intentions, I learned how easily my behaviour can veer away from what I aspire to if I'm not vigilant. I'm still paying for all this, literally, but I'm upcycling my old concert T-shirts into new looks, purging my closet and feeling more myself.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

National Post

22 minutes ago

• National Post

Security and defence high on the agenda as Mark Carney attends EU and NATO summits

Article content At the NATO summit, Carney will take part in bilateral meetings with other leaders. The summit agenda includes a social dinner hosted by the king and queen of the Netherlands and a two-and-a-half-hour meeting of the North Atlantic Council. Article content NATO allies are expected to debate a plan to hike alliance members' defence spending target to five per cent of national GDP. NATO data shows that in 2024, none of its 32 members spent that much. Article content The Canadian government official who briefed reporters on background says the spending target and its timeline are still up for discussion, though some allies have indicated they would prefer a seven-year timeline while others favour a decade. Article content Canada hasn't hit a five-per-cent defence spending threshold since the 1950s and hasn't reached the two per cent mark since the late 1980s. Article content NATO says that, based on its estimate of which expenditures count toward the target, Canada spent $41 billion in 2024 on defence, or 1.37 per cent of GDP. That's more than twice what it spent in 2014, when the two per cent target was first set; that year, Canada spent $20.1 billion, or 1.01 per cent of GDP, on defence. Article content Article content In 2014, only three NATO members achieved the two per cent target — the U.S., the U.K., and Greece. In 2025, all members are expected to hit it. Article content Any agreement to adopt a new spending benchmark must be ratified by all 32 NATO member states. Article content Former Canadian ambassador to NATO Kerry Buck told The Canadian Press the condensed agenda is likely meant to 'avoid public rifts among allies,' describing Trump as an 'uncertainty engine.' Article content 'The national security environment has really, really shifted,' Buck said, adding allies next door to Russia face the greatest threats. 'There is a high risk that the U.S. would undercut NATO at a time where all allies are increasingly vulnerable.' Article content Trump has suggested the U.S. might abandon its mutual defence commitment to the alliance if member countries don't ramp up defence spending. Article content 'Whatever we can do to get through this NATO summit with few public rifts between the U.S. and other allies on anything, and satisfy a very long-standing U.S. demand to rebalance defence spending, that will be good for Canada because NATO's good for Canada,' Buck said. Article content Carney has already made two trips to Europe this year — the first to London and Paris to meet with European allies and the second to Rome to attend the inaugural mass of Pope Leo XIV. Article content

CTV News

an hour ago

• CTV News

Lemonade stands to selling toys: A Belle River family fights ‘king' of cancers

Landon Bevan, 6, and members of his family organized a lemonade stand in Belle River on June 21, 2025 to raise funds for their Grandpa's pancreatic cancer treatment. (Robert Lothian/CTV News Windsor) In a day of blistering heat, six-year-old Landon Bevan was all smiles as he stood on his driveway handing out lemonade; after all, he knew it was for an important cause. Bevan and his brother Rhyen crafted the idea to host a lemonade stand in an effort to help their grandpa, Roy Knight, pay for medical treatment for pancreatic cancer. 'We had to, like, pull up the tents and put the balloons on the side of the garage,' Landon explained. 'I made a couple of the signs that my mom stuck into the ground.' The aspiring doctor also pitched ideas to create a stand where he tells jokes for money, or even sell his toys if need be. 'He's pretty smart for a six-year-old,' Knight said with a smile. Throughout Saturday afternoon, visitors stopped by the Belle River home to grab a lemonade or a raffle ticket. Funds support Knight's efforts to travel to Florida and receive NanoKnife surgery, a form of treatment not regularly offered in Canada. The stay is estimated to cost about $80,000. While Knight is seeking community help to try and prolong his life, Roy and his daughter Ashley Bevan believe his story shines a spotlight on the need for added pancreatic cancer research and support in healthcare. Treatment In Canada, pancreatic cancer is often treated by chemotherapy, radiation, or the Whipple procedure. Knight began chemotherapy in the days after receiving the diagnosis in February and has been seeing medical experts in London. 'Chemo really takes a toll on somebody, you know, out of the two weeks, I only have four good days in those two weeks,' Knight explained. Since his diagnosis, Knight has stayed with Ashley, a nurse practitioner, to ensure he was receiving the care he needed. 'Having pancreatic cancer is awful,' Ashley said 'Hearing that that's the cancer that it is, knowing that it's the king of all cancers.' Through countless hours of reading, she learned it's 'very muddied waters' when it comes to pancreatic cancer research and treatment. According to the Canadian Cancer Society, in 2024 pancreatic cancer was expected to be the third most deadly form of cancer in the country. 'There really does need to be more research done on pancreatic cancer treatment guidelines,' Ashley said. The family learned of 'NanoKnife,' a treatment which uses pulses of electricity to destroy cancer cells without damaging nearby organs and cells, per Ontario Health. Currently, the procedure is used in Canada for prostate cancer. However, the surgery is not regularly available in Canada for pancreatic cancer, and Bevin said clinical trials require requests from Canadians. 'When I asked, how do we request them to do a research trial? [The research coordinator] said, there needs to be a need and that the public needs to ask for it,' she noted. The family wants to see the treatment reconsidered for clinical trials, and if successful, used as a regular response to pancreatic cancer. 'I think to myself like we're just one family of many who are going through this exact thing,' Ashley said. Diagnosis Ahead of his cancer diagnosis, Knight said he spent many months with abdominal pain. He went to an emergency room on multiple occasions, but the cancer was not detected until they urged medical officials to do a biopsy. 062225 From left, Ashley Bevan, Landon Bevan, and Roy Knight spoke to CTV News about the need for more cancer research and treatments in Canada. (Robert Lothian/CTV News Windsor) 'They assured us that it was not cancer. Then we got the call on his birthday that it was,' Ashely said. The family wants to see more procedures and resources available to ensure Canadians have access to screening processes, which could help lead to early detection for some forms of cancer. As for Knight's surgery, they've tentatively set it for July 24th in Florida, pending they raise enough money. 'You know you just want to go on as long as you can, and hopefully this NanoKnife helps to see the kids grow up,' Knight said.

CBC

an hour ago

• CBC

U.S. science funding uncertainty reshapes grad school choices for Canadians

Social Sharing After graduating with a bachelor degree in mathematics from the University of Waterloo, Kareem Alfarra had hopes of continuing his studies in the United States. The American schools he looked at were better funded and had more opportunities than those in Canada, he said, and he'd already connected with some professors he'd like to work with. Alfarra, 22, applied to nine American universities, hoping for options, but he ended up being waitlisted and rejected for all of them. Most of them told him informally that budget uncertainties in the U.S. were making it difficult for them to accept graduate students, he said. He says one school even told him that in any normal year, he would have been accepted. "I was on top of the wait list … and I would have loved to go," he told CBC. Rather than waiting to hear, Alfarra decided to accept an offer at the University of Toronto, citing the funding uncertainty and political instability of the U.S. "I was very angry with the situation knowing that perhaps a year earlier or a few years later I would've gotten in." While that's just one student's story, universities on both sides of the border say that uncertainty brought on by the Trump administration is reducing options and upending research opportunities for graduate students — including Canadians. 'Closing off career pathways' More than 10,000 Canadians went to graduate school in the U.S. last year, according to data from the Institute for International Education, with 40 per cent pursuing science and health degrees. But there are two key federal sources that U.S. universities rely on to fund their labs and take in graduate students — the National Science Foundation (NSF) and National Institutes of Health (NIH) — that have been frozen or cut by the Trump administration. It's been a back and forth battle, with cases before the courts, and it's unclear where things will land. But the uncertainty is enough for some universities to reduce their admissions, inevitably trickling down to Canadian applicants. WATCH | How Trump's freeze on health research funding might hurt Canadian science: Canadian scientists worry after Trump pauses federal health spending 5 months ago Duration 2:01 In a statement to the CBC, the American Association of Universities described the stakes. "Federal research funding cuts are actively closing off career pathways for all prospective doctoral students from across the world, including those from the United States and Canada," said Emily Miller, vice president for research and institutional policy at the association. "Universities make a significant financial commitment when they offer admission to an aspiring scientist or researcher — a commitment that is critical to student success and one they cannot meet without federal research support." A 'turbulent' landscape For 23 year old Canadian Jaeden Bardati, research funding was a big component in his decision to pursue his PhD in astrophysics at Caltech in Pasadena, Calif., two years ago. "Which is kind of ironic now," he said. on research and development in 2022; in the U.S., that figure was nearly 3.6 per cent in the same year. Bardati would ultimately like to be where the top researchers in his field are, which historically had been the U.S., he says, but that may change. Budget uncertainty makes some researchers worried whether they can maintain their labs or pay the students that work in them. Bardati says some of his classmates have been encouraged to graduate early or to fund themselves to be able to stay. "The landscape is very turbulent … the word that's been used around here is turbulent," said Bardati, which makes it difficult for students and researchers to plan for the future. "They're essentially trying to find a new home at the moment. And they're thinking, 'should I go to Europe or should I go to Canada?'" U.S. students applying north Katie Marshall, associate professor in comparative physiology at the University in British Columbia, is already starting to see the effects of this shift. She's received five applications from U.S. students to come work in her lab. "Usually, I wouldn't start seeing these kinds of applications until the fall," she said. "It's definitely unusual." Marshall also noted that the funding cuts in the U.S. are affecting research in Canada, because cross-border collaboration means Canadian researchers have gotten funding from U.S. agencies. "With less money, there's just fewer spots [for graduate students]." "When I look at who I'm going to accept, I'm looking at their research experience, " said Marshall. "If I've got a great American student, it's really hard for me to say no." While Canada can't fill the gap left by the US, it is a good time to invest in Canadian research to create more opportunities, said Marshall, noting that there has been some recent increases already.