The critical response to Miley Cyrus's Something Beautiful exposes pop's gender double standards
With her latest album Something Beautiful debuting at number four in the Billboard 200 and in contention to reach the top of the UK album charts, Miley Cyrus's commercial appeal appears as strong as ever.
Something Beautiful is Cyrus's 9th studio album, described by the singer-songwriter as an attempt to bring the divine into the day to day. It's an ambitious, sprawling record, but, despite its commercial success, its eclecticism has led to a polarised reaction among critics.
Negative reviews are, of course, not uncommon, and we need look no further than The New York Times' 1969 review of Abbey Road to see that even the most celebrated and acclaimed artists aren't immune to the critic's poison pen. But, while some degree of criticism is inevitable for all artists, when it comes to discussing experimentation and musical identity, female and male artists seem to be treated differently.
Looking for something good? Cut through the noise with a carefully curated selection of the latest releases, live events and exhibitions, straight to your inbox every fortnight, on Fridays. Sign up here.
During her Billboard Music Awards woman of the year speech in 2016, Madonna commented that 'there are no rules – if you're a boy. If you're a girl, you have to play the game.' In the same year Björk observed that female artists are criticised if they sing about anything other than their boyfriends. She might have been exaggerating a little, but Björk's and Madonna's points are clear: if you're a woman in music, you should stay in your proverbial box.
Most of the negative reviews that Something Beautiful received were along these lines. Pitchfork, for example, criticised Cyrus's 'nonsensical lyrics' (translation: stick to writing about relationships). The i Paper claimed her weird and experimental choices created a distance from her listeners (translation: don't do anything your fans won't like). They also condemned the lack of accessible, radio-friendly pop (translation: be one-dimensional). And the Guardian said that it fell short of the hits that made her a star (translation: as Beach Boy Mike Love allegedly said, 'don't fuck with the formula').
For two of Cyrus's male contemporaries, Justin Bieber and Harry Styles (both around one year her junior), it's a very different story. While the Guardian also notes the absence of 'hits' on Bieber's 2020 album Changes, instead of presenting it as a negative as it did with Cyrus, it's seen as a sign of maturity on a fitfully lovely album by a pop star who no longer wants chart domination.
In the case of Styles' 2019 album Fine Line, artistic innovation was praised by the Guardian, which observed that the most endearing moments occur when he experiments. And where Pitchfork lambasted Something Beautiful's genre-hopping eclecticism for being tonally confused, Fine Line is praised for the 'incredible' sound produced due to its 'flock of influences'.
Cyrus has been told by critics that she must choose between being an accessible pop star or an unconventional artist and 'can't have it both ways'.
Even if she did decide to plump for one camp or the other rather than ably straddling both, it'd still be debatable as to whether the ever-fickle critics would be satisfied.
Pitchfork's 2020 review of Cyrus's album Plastic Heart suggests it'd be a 'no' in their case, at least. Complaining that the heavier songs on the album sounded like 'canned, Muzak versions of rock songs', the publication proposed that Cyrus might sound like an actual rock star if paired with someone like producer Jonathan Rado.
When Cyrus and Rado did collaborate on Something Beautiful, however, they remained unimpressed. You just can't please some people. Thankfully, Cyrus is either oblivious to such noise or chooses to ignore it, and recently teased that Something Beautiful is merely 'the appetizer' for a 'an extremely experimental' upcoming album.
In an era where formulaic pop music dominates the charts and AI-generated content threatens to make things even more generic, we should be encouraging the idiosyncrasies of our female artists, not labelling them as having identity problems when they are brave enough to be different.
In her woman of the year' speech, Madonna also noted that, as a female artist, 'to age is a sin: you will be criticised, you will be vilified, and you will definitely not be played on the radio'. Perhaps, then, Cyrus's biggest offence isn't her refusal to become a stereotype or her desire to experiment and make music that she likes. It's daring to grow up.
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.
The authors do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Anne Burrell's death under investigation as possible drug overdose: report
New details of Food Network star Anne Burrell's shocking passing have emerged. The New York Police Department is reportedly investigating Burrell's sudden death as a possible drug overdose, according to a document viewed by The New York Times on Friday. The internal document reportedly said that Burrell was 'discovered in the shower unconscious and unresponsive surrounded by approximately (100) assorted pills.' The New York Police Department is reportedly investigating Burrell's sudden death as a possible drug overdose. Getty Images for DuJour A spokesperson for the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner also confirmed on Friday that Burrell's autopsy had been completed, but any findings connected to the cause and manner of her death were still pending. On Thursday, as the NYPD continued to investigate Burrell's sudden and unexplained death, sources told The Post that the Food Network host's body had been discovered next to dozens of pills inside her Brooklyn home. Burrell, who was perhaps most popular for hosting the Food Network shows 'Worst Cooks in America' and 'Secrets of a Restaurant Chef,' passed away on Tuesday, June 17, at the age of 55. Her loved ones were the first to confirm the shocking news in a statement that afternoon. 'Anne was a beloved wife, sister, daughter, stepmother, and friend – her smile lit up every room she entered,' Burrell's family said. 'Anne's light radiated far beyond those she knew, touching millions across the world,' they added. 'Though she is no longer with us, her warmth, spirit, and boundless love remain eternal.'
USA Today
4 hours ago
- USA Today
Fuerza Regida on making history, performing in LA amid turmoil
Beyond hard work and humility, manifestation has been part of Fuerza Regida's recipe for success. Frontman Jesús "JOP" Ortiz Paz remembers watching "Tengo Talento, Mucho Talento" (the Latino version of "America's Got Talent") with his parents at home in San Bernardino, California, and saying, "I'm going to be on that TV. I'm going to be right there," he tells USA TODAY. "Ah, you're crazy," Paz, 28, says his parents responded. That was during a June 2023 interview with USA TODAY ahead of Fuerza Regida's sold-out show at BMO Stadium in Los Angeles, part of their "Otra Peda" tour. Fast forward two years, and the band finds itself reaching new career heights. Fuerza Regida − Paz, along with Samuel Jáimez, Khrystian Ramos, José "Pelón" García and Moisés López − makes its historic debut at both New York's Madison Square Garden June 20 and LA's Hollywood Bowl June 21. They'll be performing their latest album, the 12-track "111XPANTIA," in its entirety. "Us bringing corridos to these venues, I'm pretty sure it's for the first time, so we're really happy that our genre is growing and growing," Paz says ahead of the shows. "We're excited, we've been breaking all these records and making history." Interview: Fuerza Regida on Mexican music going global and why they're the pioneers In May, the all-genre Billboard 200 album charts, saw for the first time Spanish-language albums in the No. 1 and No. 2 spots at the same time − Bad Bunny's "Debí Tirar Más Fotos" and Fuerza Regida's "111XPANTIA," respectively. More than that, it marked Fuerza Regida's highest-charting album to date, and the highest-charting Spanish-language album by a duo or group, or a regional Mexican music album, ever, according to Billboard. With nearly a decade in the industry under their belt, reaching the top of the charts isn't new territory for the group members anymore. Their 2023 album "Pa Las Baby's Y Belikeada" peaked at No. 2 on Billboard's Latin Albums chart and reached the Top 15 of the Billboard 200, and also earned them a pair of awards — Top Duo/Group and Top Latin Duo/Group at the 2023 Billboard Music Awards. With 2024's "Pero No Te Enamores," the band's eighth studio album, Fuerza Regida dabbled in Jersey club music, reggaeton, hip-hop and bachata and embarked on a 76-date tour. Manifestation brought Fuerza Regida new album '111XPANTIA' to life Before Fuerza Regida made its mark in arenas and stadiums all over the United States and Latin America, the band was performing small gigs in backyards and at quinceñeras in 2016. Now, the band boasts numerous chart-topping albums, sold-out stadium and arena shows, multiple brand deals (including their latest partnership with Dos Equis for the Ni Perdón Ni Permiso campaign) and performances on late-night talk shows like "Jimmy Kimmel Live." In January, Paz became the first performer to bring regional Mexican music to Paris Men's Fashion Week during KidSuper's runway show ("It was my first time in Europe and we love fashion as well, so I was like a little kid at Toys 'R Us," Paz says). In 2018, he founded the independent record label Street Mob Records, which has signed other rising stars in the genre, including Chino Pacas, Calle 24, Clave Especial, and more. Still, Fuerza Regida keeps both feet planted on the ground. "We just keep on working hard, that's the key," Paz says. "We just act like we still haven't done anything − act like you haven't hit, act like you just started." López, who plays tololoche for the band, echoed a similar sentiment: "(We) stay working 24/7 and stay hungry," he says. "I've been saying that since I started my career, we work harder than a lot of other artists out there, and that's why I think we're more successful," Paz adds. "We don't just do the artist stuff. I also have my record label, and everything we have is because of all the hard work we've put in. So, of course, you gotta' have a little bit of talent, but the rest is all hard work." Paz and López also break down the meaning of the album's name, "111XPANTIA," which serves as a double entendre for manifestation. "111" is usually regarded as an "angel number" or a lucky sign whenever one comes across it, and "ixpantia" is the Nahuatl word for manifestation. "It was time to name an album that," Paz says. "Manifesting has been ever since I can remember. Everything I've wanted, I've almost got and the days go by, you want more things, you want better things for your family and better things for your business." The entire project is dedicated to the manifestation of dreams and constant hard work. It also marks a return to their corrido roots featuring stand-out tracks like "Peliculiando," "Por Esos Ojos," "Marlboro Rojo" and "Godfather." 'We've always fought for our music and our culture' In recent years, Latin musicians including Peso Pluma, Grupo Firme, Grupo Frontera, Junior H, Àngela Aguilar and Becky G have worked to put Mexican music, in all its variations, on the mainstream map. It's no longer just regional, as it's long been categorized in award show categories, but rather international and intentional. "We've just always fought for our music and our culture" to be respected like any other genre, Paz says. "It took a little longer for Mexican music," he adds. "Back in the day, Mexican music was just a little more in this bubble, and I feel like a couple years back, Fuerza Regida and a bunch of other pioneers − I don't want to just include myself − made this genre what it is now." Paz recognizes that many other bands and solo artists went through their own struggles and battles to be recognized, but now "we're accomplishing the goal of making our culture hit now." How Fuerza Regida shows up for the immigrant community during turmoil Although the show must go on, Fuerza Regida's Hollywood Bowl debut comes at a raw time in the city amid ongoing protests rejecting the continued presence of federal immigration enforcement. On June 10, Fuerza Regida shared a statement on Instagram, sending their "love and strength to our Latino community during this difficult time." "We've been deeply moved by the events of this past week," the band wrote. "These are our people, our fans, the very communities that inspire our music. We see your strength and resilience." Days later, they released limited-edition merch and 100% of profits from sales were donated to "support our communities impacted by the recent ICE raids," read the band's Instagram post. More: Jimmy Kimmel slams Trump, calls him 'arsonist with a hose' over ICE sweeps in LA This isn't the first time this year Fuerza Regida has put their money where their community is. Earlier this year, after Los Angeles was dealt another blow with the wildfires that ravaged the neighborhoods of Pacific Palisades and Altadena, the band helped provide shelter to 270 people. "Family is No. 1, and I feel like the way you're raised, it reflects a lot on how you're going to be and my parents raised me pretty well and taught me to always care about the community," Paz says. "If we're blessed, we gotta' share a little bit of the blessings."
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Madonna Exposed By 'Hamilton' Star Anthony Ramos For Disrespectful Audience Behavior
may be the Queen of Pop, but her alleged conduct during a "Hamilton" performance has Broadway star calling her out nearly a decade later. During a candid appearance on "Watch What Happens Live!," Ramos, who starred in the original 2015 Broadway cast as both John Laurens and Alexander Hamilton's ill-fated son Philip, recalled a particularly "terrifying" celebrity audience member, Madonna. "The most terrifying was Madonna with her iPad in her face," Ramos said bluntly when host Andy Cohen asked about star-studded audiences. "She was like this the whole time," he added, mimicking her staring at a device. "I was like, 'Damn, shorty. If you not enjoying it that much, you know the door's right there. You ain't gotta stay here.'" Ramos isn't the first "Hamilton" cast member to shade Madonna over the infamous 2015 incident. Creator appeared to reference her in a now-deleted tweet at the time, writing, "Tonight was the first time I asked stage management NOT to allow a celebrity (who was texting all through Act 2) backstage. #noselfieforyou." Although Miranda didn't name names, rumors quickly swirled that he was referring to Madonna. The speculation was so widespread that her publicist publicly denied the claims, saying, "It's not true. She was invited backstage four different times," and that she "texted post-show when they were doing their fundraising pitch. Madonna had already made a generous donation." Still, other "Hamilton" cast members didn't hold back. , who played King George III, slammed Madonna directly in a 2015 interview with Dot429, saying, "You couldn't miss it from the stage. It was a black void of the audience in front of us, and her face there perfectly lit by the light of her iPhone through three-quarters of the show." He added that she wasn't invited backstage because "that b-tch was on her phone." Before she was called out by "Hamilton" stars for allegedly texting through a Broadway performance, Madonna faced backlash for another phone faux pas, and this one reportedly got her banned from a movie theater. Back in 2013, the Queen of Pop made headlines after allegedly texting during a screening of "12 Years a Slave" at the New York Film Festival. According to Page Six at the time, when another guest asked her to put her phone away, Madonna snapped back, "It's for business…enslaver!" The screening featured the powerful historical drama starring Chiwetel Ejiofor, Michael Fassbender, and Brad Pitt, a film that tells the harrowing true story of Solomon Northup, a free man sold into slavery in the 1800s. Despite her alleged outburst, sources told Us Weekly that Madonna appeared emotional during the film. "Some people are shocked by this, because Madonna was visibly tearing up," one insider said. "Everybody there thought that she was very moved by it." In fact, she seemed eager to show her support for the project afterward, reportedly posing for photos with the film's director Steve McQueen while dressed in an all-black lace ensemble, gloves and all. Still, the controversy sparked enough noise that Alamo Drafthouse CEO Tim League tweeted that Madonna had been banned from their theaters unless she issued a public apology. While she never addressed the incident directly, the moment became part of a growing pattern of criticism aimed at the "Material Girl" for her screen-time habits during live performances, one that would flare up again in 2015 when "Hamilton" stars accused her of texting throughout the second act. Though she has a long history with Broadway, starring in "Speed-the-Plow" in 1988 and famously portraying Eva Perón in the 1996 film adaptation of "Evita," her performances have sparked polarizing opinions. Broadway legend , who originated the role of Eva on stage, once said, "Madonna is a movie killer. She's dead behind the eyes… She cannot act her way out of a paper bag." While Madonna's music career remains iconic, her off-stage reputation, at least in theater circles, continues to stir up drama worthy of its own Broadway plot twist.
