Manager sacked after standing up with no pants on work video call claimed he was being racially discriminated against for being made to work on a bank holiday
A £60,000-a-year manager who was sacked after exposing his genitals during a work video call because he stood up with no pants on has had his case thrown out.
The digital production manager for Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) was fired on January 30 last year after a disastrous virtual meeting in which he inadvertently flashed his colleagues.
But the employee took the firm to a tribunal, claiming unfair dismissal as well as racial discrimination.
His dismissal centred around a Microsoft Teams work call with a consultancy firm on May 8 2023 - which was a Bank Holiday because of King Charles III's Coronation.
During the call, the manager stood up to adjust a cable behind his computer, but stunned his colleagues as he was wearing nothing from the waist down and his genitals were on show.
A tribunal at London Central heard that an investigation was launched after a complaint was lodged by colleagues.
After his line manager started a probe, the worker claimed: 'That was a bank holiday and l did not realise when l folded the laptop camera was on and pointing to the floor and then immediately shut down the camera so that don't know what was seen in the floor [sic].'
The unnamed employee, who joined the FSCS in 2020, admitted he did not always 'wear full dress' at home and added: 'It is just an accident and apologies.'
The manager argued that he was not culpable for what happened because the meeting took place on a Bank Holiday, adding: 'Expecting me to work during public holidays is a racial discrimination.'
The tribunal heard that he holds dual Australian and British citizenship but he is Indian as he was born there.
Sabah Carter, a senior figure at the FSCS, rejected the suggestion the dress code did not apply on public holidays.
She found his actions had damaged the company's reputation and said he 'had not offered any reassurance that the incident wouldn't happen again'.
And she noted he had 'not shown any remorse or apologised for his actions but rather sought to blame the external contractors on the call'.
Ms Carter also pointed out his inconsistent evidence who initially admitted his genitals were visible before claiming he was wearing 'nude-coloured underwear'.
As well as claiming unfair dismissal, he also claimed racial discrimination on over being passed over for a promotion.
The employee said: 'The entire process and outcome is nothing but racial discrimination, mental harassment, unfair dismissal.'
But the tribunal ruled that he had not been made to work on the bank holiday and had actually chosen to.
'Even if he were required to work inappropriately, that is no reason for appearing in a state of undress,' they noted.
Although the panel accepted he had initially apologised for the incident, they found he later 'sought to obscure or deflect blame' and did not 'consistently show remorse'.
The tribunal panel threw out all of his claims for unfair dismissal and racial discrimination.
They concluded that his application for a promotion had been 'poor and failed to reveal sufficient relevant experience'.
'The position applied for was approximately twice the claimant's salary and FSCS was seeking relevant experience, particularly in heading departments,' they noted.
Employment Judge Hodgson concluded: 'We find that the claimant chose not to wear either trousers or underwear... instead he deliberately chose to be naked from the waist down.
'This led to an obvious risk. If at any point he should need to stand, it was likely that he would reveal his genitals, if his camera was on.
'The claimant was an employee in a leadership role. He was dealing with external consultants. He should have realised that being naked was inappropriate, regardless of any policy.
'If he chose to wear no clothes from the waist down, he should have taken care to ensure that this fact did not become apparent.
'The claimant's action caused embarrassment to the employer and was inconsistent with his position and role.'
Throwing out the claim, the judge said: 'All the claims of race discrimination fail. The claim of unfair dismissal is not well founded and is dismissed. The claim of wrongful dismissal fails and is dismissed.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
27 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Minibuses for rural routes are in production
It was interesting to read the letter (13 June) from Mike Parker regarding rural buses, making the argument that minibuses suitable for rural routes should be manufactured. And that such a business would be ideal for an entrepreneur. Ironically, it was only a few days before that letter, on 4 June, that Rachel Reeves made her transport funding announcement of £15.6bn from the premises of Mellor Bus in Rochdale, which, along with its sister company, Treka Bus in Brighouse, West Yorkshire, make a range of buses, including 16-seater ones suitable for rural routes. Mellor and Treka are both part of the Woodall Nicholson group. That group's business was acquired in 2023 by a Belgian entrepreneur, Guido Dumarey, to add to his portfolio. So there are suitable buses and there is an entrepreneur – let's hope he keeps those businesses manufacturing in the UK. It is a pity that the chassis used for the buses are of European origin (Mercedes and Iveco/Fiat) as there are no UK manufacturers of suitable chassis – now there's an opportunity. But, as both Ford and DAF stopped making that type of chassis in the UK years ago, I can't see any obvious candidate. Maybe Renault/Stellantis would or could make one available from their Ellesmere Port factory. Richard BramallSheffield Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
BBC News
29 minutes ago
- BBC News
McCarthy Stone pulls out of Baildon retirement village scheme
The developer has announced it is pulling out of a multimillion-pound regeneration Stone was due to build a 47-apartment development on the former Ian Clough Hall site in without providing any details at to why, the firm said it had "made the decision not to proceed".Bradford Council confirmed the news and said it would be looking to put the site back on the market. A spokesperson from McCarthy Stone said: "Regrettably, we have had to make the decision not to proceed with the Baildon site but continue to explore options to bring our retirement living offering to the area in the future." The hall, off Hallcliffe, has already been demolished, but work on the building has not started despite a planning application being approved in October, according to the Local Democracy Reporting Clough Hall, which included Baildon Library, was demolished in 2023 – with Bradford Council selling the site for the work was announced, the council revealed plans to open a new library in the neighbouring Baildon Club building, which the local authority had purchased, but due to council budget concerns, those plans were later ward councillor Debbie Davies said the news that McCarthy Stone had withdrawn from the site had come as a now fears that site could remain empty, similar to the stalled Westfield shopping centre development that plagued Bradford city centre for years. 'Baildon's hole in the ground' She added: "We are very disappointed that the new library project - that the sale of the land was meant to fund - is on hold with the former Baildon Club standing empty in a prominent position in Baildon and deteriorating by the day."We also now have our own 'hole in the ground' as Bradford did for many years and rather than unsightly fencing around the site we would like to see some basic landscaping done as it is nearly two years since the Ian Clough Hall was demolished and potentially could remain that way for a lot longer." Listen to highlights from West Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
The Sun
35 minutes ago
- The Sun
I was zombie £300-a-night coke addict who snorted while pregnant & let kids fend for themselves – but I didn't care
ZOEY Clarke used to make sure her two children were in bed by 7pm sharp. But, unlike most mothers, her motivation wasn't so that her kids were well rested for a busy day at school - no, Zoey wanted them away from her so she could binge on drugs. 7 Shockingly, Zoey admits she was so addicted to the Class A drug that she snorted it while pregnant with her daughter Storm, now 15. 'I look back now and can't believe the person I became in the grips of my addiction," Zoey, a hairdresser who lives in Chessington, with Storm and son Sonny, 19, told Fabulous. 'I loved my kids but I neglected them. They had takeaways every night – McDonalds and Domino's were favourites and I'd give them sweets and chocolate whenever they wanted it. Neglected children 'To my shame Storm's teeth were so decayed by the time she was three from all the junk food that she needed every single tooth removed. "I lied and said she had a healthy diet and must just be susceptible to sugar. I was a master at lies and deceit and manipulation – every addict is.' Thankfully Zoey's been clean now for eight years - but admits that every waking moment used to revolve around her cocaine habit. 'I didn't have time for my children, all I could think about was taking drugs,' she says. 'There were never bedtime stories, I'd hustle them into bed and then I'd stay up all night, taking £300 worth of cocaine. 'In the morning I'd have my first of eight red bulls, take the kids to school, still high, invariably forgetting their packed lunch – I'd turn up with a bacon sandwich at school later. 'I'd pick them up late, I missed mufti days and forgot permission slips for school trips. 'It was chaos, the school must have realised something was wrong, but I don't think they knew how to tackle it. 'After school I'd take them to buy some vouchers for their gaming devices, and then get them a takeaway, and make sure they were in bed by 7pm – I wanted them shut away from me.' Zoey is now rebuilding her relationships with her children - but it has been a long journey. Decaying teeth 'I feel so lucky that they've stood by me, but rebuilding the relationships was tough,' she says. 'Sonny only told me he loved me for the first time a few months ago. 'They were understandably full of resentment, I wasn't there for him, I never even helped with their homework or took them to the playground. 'There was nothing normal about their childhood as recovery isn't easy either. I had to learn to be a mum to them and earn their trust that the 'new' version of me was here to stay. And even now they worry about my health.' 7 7 Their worries are justified. On March 15th Zoey had her fourth stroke. Her first was in 2020 and she had two more in 2021 and 2022. Doctors have told her it's due to the abuse she put her body through while in the grips of addiction. She remembers: 'We'd been for a day out in Brighton and I was cooking supper, I picked up the saucepan with rice in it and my hand started shaking, I sat down feeling horrendous and my whole arm started tingling. 'I knew what was happening, and a friend drove me straight to the hospital where I stayed in the high dependency unit for two days. 'I'm recovering but my arm is still weak. I've been put on new meds and I just have to hope that I won't have another one. 'But it's hard for them, seeing me in a hospital bed and we're all aware that strokes can be fatal.' Zoey's addiction started in 1997 when she was just 17 and met her ex-partner, the father of her children. She says: 'I'd tried drugs a couple of years earlier on a night out and hated it. 'But this time I took a line with a rolled up bus ticket in the loos of a pub and I loved it. I felt euphoric. 'At the time a lot of friends used recreationally and it didn't seem like a big deal.' However Zoey soon started using it regularly and within six months she was addicted. She says: 'I can't explain why as I didn't really enjoy it – the image is that it's a party drug. 'But I'd use on my own, taking it at work – I had various jobs from being a barmaid to running a sunbed salon – it was all day every day, lining it up on the sunbeds or in the toilet. 'I'd go home to my partner at night and carry on. 'Over the years I tried to stop many times – I hated using. I went to Narcotics Anonymous meetings and I longed to be clean, but I couldn't find anything that worked.' In desperation in May 2005 Zoey tried to take her own life – she felt it was the only way she could stop. Her partner found her and she pulled through but was sectioned and then went into residential rehab for 12 weeks. Many people would question why Zoey chose to have children when she fell pregnant shortly after getting out of rehab. She explains: 'I was clean at the time and I had severe endometriosis and polycystic ovary syndrome and I'd always desperately wanted children and it felt like my only chance. 'I was under the care of social services because of my suicide attempt and I had drug tests throughout my pregnancy and afterwards. 'When Sonny was born he was put into the custody of my parents and so I left the flat I shared with my partner and moved in with them. 'I wish I could say I bonded with Sonny, but I struggled. I wasn't in the right place mentally after all I'd been through. After a year social services allowed me to have custody of Sonny and I moved back in with my partner. 'To my shame I started using again, I hadn't tackled the root causes of my addiction and so I fell of the wagon. I only took it once he was asleep, telling myself that it was OK if he didn't see me high. 'I cared for him in that I'd always change his nappies and he was fed regularly – but it was just the basics. 'As an addict you don't even love yourself, let alone anyone else. I just existed.' And when she fell pregnant with Storm she kept on using. How cocaine destroys your health, face and life The nose One of the most recognisable signs of cocaine overuse is a collapsed nose. The drug is snorted via the nose. Because it is a vasoconstrictor, meaning it narrows the blood vessels, blood flow is reduced. As the nasal tissue becomes starved of oxygen in the blood, it becomes damaged. FRANK, a national drug advisory service, says: 'Over time, snorting cocaine damages the cartilage in your nose that separates your nostrils. 'Heavy users can lose this cartilage and end up with one large nostril and a misshapen nose.' Users may also have difficulty with breathing and damage to nasal passages can also lead to chronic sinus infections. The mouth and facial deformity Chronic cocaine use doesn't only affect the nose - it can also harm the roof of the mouth or the hard palate, causing palatal perforation, according to UK Addiction Treatment Centres. Palatal perforation can lead to severe issues, such as difficulty speaking or voice changes, problems with eating and drinking and higher risk of infections due to the open gap between the nose and mouth. With the potential loss of nose cartilage, destruction of nasal tissue and sinuses and the mouth, the face may change shape with chronic cocaine use. Use of the drug can also cause the face to bloat and eyes to become bloodshot. Mental health Regular use of cocaine can dampen a person's mood. It can make them feel depressed, run down, anxious or paranoid, FRANK warns. It says: 'Cocaine can bring previous mental health problems to the surface too, and if a relative has had mental health problems, there might be an increased risk for you.' Infections Constant cocaine use will weaken your body's immune system. This makes it harder to fight off any infection - or blood-borne diseases that may occur when sharing needles. Heart The heart comes under a lot of pressure from cocaine use. It increases blood clots, which in turn can lead to heart attacks, pulmonary embolisms, strokes and deep vein thrombosis. 'It can also cause inflammation and death of the heart muscle, deterioration of the heart's ability to contract, as well as aortic ruptures, angina and permanently increased blood pressure,' says the Priory Group. Life-ruining The impact of cocaine use goes beyond obvious health issues. It can cause social withdrawal, financial problems, loss of job or reputation and risky behaviour, such as unsafe sex or driving when high. If you or someone you know is struggling with cocaine use, seeking professional help is crucial to prevent further harm. Try visiting Talk to FRANK, the NHS website, Narcotics Anonymous or Cocaine Anonymous. She says: 'I tried so hard not to, and be clean for a few days but then I'd succumb, I hated myself but I couldn't stop. 'I wanted to be a proper mum – a loving and supportive one like my mum had been to me. 'But addiction ruled my life. I was half a person, staying up taking line after line all night and a zombie during the day fuelled by Red Bull and Nurofen for my crippling headaches. I could barely get the kids up.' It was tragedy that started Zoey on the path to getting clean. She says: 'A good friend had terminal breast cancer, she was fighting so hard to live and be around for her son. 'Sadly she lost the battle. It made me realise I was wrecking my body and wouldn't be alive for my kids if I carried on. I'm very lucky that they've forgiven me for the neglect they went through Zoey Clarke 'On December 30th 2017 I looked at my children at the kitchen table, they looked so worried and the house was a tip. A switch flipped in my head and I knew I couldn't do it to them anymore. 'They deserved a proper mum, who loved and cared for them.' On New Year's day Zoey split up with her ex and asked her mum and doctor for help – she's been clean ever since. She says: 'I asked my mum for support. I knew I needed someone to be accountable to so I asked her to drug test me three times a week. 'She's always been there for me, she used to help with the children and we're very close. I can't say it was easy either mentally or physically but slowly with therapy I got there and started being the mum my children deserved.' Physically the drug took its toll. Zoe was diagnosed with diabetes, as she hadn't looked after her diet at all while using and she's also got a hole in her nose. But she's doing all she can to stay fit and healthy – she's careful with her diet and monitors her blood sugar and takes insulin. She also does Facebook Lives every week to help other people struggling with addiction. And most importantly she spends quality time with her children. 'I'm so proud of them,' she says. 'I'm very lucky that they've forgiven me for the neglect they went through. "I look at myself now and think you selfish disgusting human being, they didn't deserve it, no child does. 'That's why I'm speaking out. I'm in no doubt about the way drugs have affected my children. I live with it every day. 'Your children might not see you using or understand why their life isn't normal. But they know it isn't and suffer.' 7
