Gareth O'Callaghan: Ageism is the last permitted prejudice - that's why nursing home scandals continue

It's been a frightening fortnight for our elderly folk since the airing of Inside Ireland's Nursing Homes by RTÉ Investigates, which discovered a litany of disturbing practices and dire conditions at two specific nursing homes – The Residence in Portlaoise and Beneavin Manor in north Dublin.
As the architect Frank Lloyd Wright once said: 'The longer I live, the more beautiful life becomes.' I didn't feel that sentiment in the horrors I watched that evening on RTÉ, mixed with a sense of déjà vu.
In the days that followed, from the anger and distress I heard on both radio and television, and the jaded self-serving platitudes of high-ranking politicians, it was starting to sound as though residential abuse of the elderly had never happened here before. And then – as usual – it all went silent.
Perhaps that's because people have shorter memories these days; if the subject matter doesn't impact their lives, they move on unaffected. Critical stories have become little more than morbid curiosities in recent times.
Maybe it's because a critical story relevant to everyone becomes inconsequential faster, reaching its 'best-by-date' because scrolling through hundreds of different topics everyday has left us emotionally numb to the plight of the most vulnerable – namely our elders.
I found myself shouting at the radio as I listened to one man blaming covid for the shocking treatment of elderly individuals in these homes. 'This all started during lockdown,' he said. It didn't.
Leas Cross closed in 2005 several weeks after a damning RTÉ Primetime Investigates – Home Truths programme revealed that 105 residents died there between 2002 and 2004, many from grave neglect, dehydration, and malnutrition. File photo Garrett White / Collins
Ireland has a catalogue of residential abuse that dates back to the days of the asylums for the mentally ill; and with each shocking revelation over the years comes the same clichéd reactions from the politicians.
Perhaps the most publicised was Leas Cross, near Swords in Dublin, which closed in 2005, several weeks after a damning
RTÉ Primetime Investigates – Home Truths
programme revealed Dickensian living conditions. 105 residents died at the nursing home between 2002 and 2004 – many of the deaths resulted from grave neglect, dehydration, and malnutrition.
In response to the scandal, the Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA) was established in May 2007, charged with setting and monitoring standards at private nursing homes to ensure there would never be a repeat of Leas Cross, with the power to seek a District Court Order that could close or suspend the running of these homes if continued operation posed a risk to a resident.
Mary Harney, minister for health at the time, said: 'An independent organisation with teeth is now being created.' In the years that followed, it became clear the teeth weren't doing much biting.
Six members of staff had criminal charges brought against them after revelations of residents with intellectual disabilities being abused by workers at Áras Attracta. File photo: Shay Fennelly
Roll on seven years to December 2014 when RTÉ Investigates – Inside Bungalow 3 was broadcast, featuring harrowing undercover footage of residents with intellectual disabilities being abused by workers at the Áras Attracta facility in Swinford, Co Mayo. Again there was national uproar. A garda investigation later led to criminal charges being taken against six members of staff.
As far back as 40 years ago, residents at the 'plush' Rostrevor House nursing home, which opened its doors in 1984 in Dublin's upmarket Rathgar to mostly wealthy elderly locals, were complaining of ill-treatment at the hands of some staff, including allegations of sexual abuse. It would take decades for the home to be shut down.
One of the many abuse cases at Rostrevor to be later read out in court was of a female resident, aged 101, who had been forced to sleep every night for a year in a Buxton chair – the same type of tilting chair so heavily criticised after the Leas Cross scandal.
Judge Victor Blake, in making the final order of closure of Rostrevor House at Dublin District Court in June 2011, told the court that elderly people had to be protected in their hour of need. Hiqa cited 'an alarming history of falls, injuries and incidents' at the home in their report.
These cases are just a short refresher in how many elderly parents have been treated – at their own or their families' expense – in residential homes that guaranteed that old aphorism of 'tender loving care' down through the years.
I watched with a mix of horror and déjà vu on RTÉ the revelations about The Residence Nursing Home in Portlaoise. File picture: Collins Photos
Let's quickly remind ourselves there are many excellent facilities, whose owners and staff were appalled by what they watched on RTÉ just over a week ago. But there are also homes that, for many of their residents, are nothing less than a living hell.
How many television investigations does it take to show us that there's something both wrong and evil with the system of governance in many of these places that has gone unchecked and remains unchanged for decades?
Ageism - the last permitted bias
Ageism is a stubborn prejudice – a topic very few people want to discuss. It's one of the last socially acceptable discriminations. In 2021, the World Health Organisation (WHO) released the results of a survey which found that one in every two people – half the population – were either moderately or highly ageist.
Ask anyone about global warming, or immigration, or the effects of smartphones on pre-schoolers, and they'll have an opinion and a solution. Ask them about ageism and watch their eyes glaze over because of the widespread stigma associated with it.
From a very young age, we have secretly feared becoming old. It's so engrained in our culture that we don't even notice it – but we should; because one day each one of us will be old, and a target for ageism; the last permitted bias.
It's endemic in society. So why would it not exist in nursing homes that care for elderly people? Prejudice and discrimination are two key dimensions associated with ageism, so it begs the question why are people who exhibit these traits allowed anywhere near fragile ageing patients?
If nursing home workers such as those in the recent investigation display negative assumptions about their patients' value as vulnerable human beings, or their capacity or level of understanding, then why are they working there?
Why aren't staff subjected to a psychometric test at the job interview stage that could be specifically designed to measure behavioural patterns and personality traits to see if they hold any bias against ageing patients?
And what about the language barrier? If workers in Irish nursing homes can't make themselves understood to an elderly patient, or can't understand what the patient is asking for, then what hope is there for a healthy happy environment?
It's anticipated that 135,000 people aged 65 and over will potentially be in need of nursing home care by 2031. That's less than six years from now. According to Hiqa, as of 2023, there was a total of 32,314 nursing home beds in Ireland. It's painfully obvious that as our population gets older, successive governments – including the current one – have continued to ignore a ticking time bomb.
As geriatrician Professor David Robinson said on the recent RTÉ Investigates exposé: 'This is going to shorten people's lives, and their lives will be more miserable.'
So who will mind us when we get too old to mind ourselves; and, more important, how will we be treated? Will the changes to nursing home regulations that took effect at the end of March make any difference? Most important, how will the new governance measures tackle ageist prejudices and abuse from staff?
In the aftermath of Leas Cross 20 years ago, Mary Harney said: 'I can't guarantee this won't happen again, but I can guarantee that it would be picked up on quickly.' She got it badly wrong on the latter. Nothing has really changed, so it will happen again.
Read More
Allowing nursing home residents to live with dignity is very least we can deliver

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Irish Daily Mirror

3 days ago

• Irish Daily Mirror

Inspector who cleared nursing home with abuse allegations worked on same campus

The 'lead' HIQA inspector who cleared controversial Beneavin Manor twice last year, despite almost 200 notifications of alleged abuse, worked in a sister nursing home on the same campus for two years, the Irish Mirror can reveal. In a lengthy statement, the Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA) denied any wrongdoing, saying that the nursing home had changed ownership between the time the person worked there and the completion of the inspections. Beneavin Manor and The Residence in Portlaoise, Co Laois, were featured in an RTÉ Investigates documentary earlier this month. The homes, which are run by Emeis Ireland, were widely criticised after the undercover footage of residents crying out for help, being left in soiled clothes, and being incorrectly handled. An interim report from HIQA, published on Tuesday evening, revealed that there have been 198 notifications regarding suspected or confirmed allegations of abuse to residents in Beneavin Manor between January 2022 and June 2025. The Irish Mirror can now reveal that a HIQA inspector who used to work in Beneavin House was involved in two inspections at Beneavin Manor last year, which found that the nursing home was mostly compliant. Beneavin House, Beneavin Manor and Beneavin Lodge are all situated directly beside each other in Glasnevin. All are now owned by Emeis. The inspector is listed as the 'lead' inspector in two inspections at Firstcare Beneavin Manor on May 15 2024 and November 7 2024. The May report found that Beneavin Manor was 'compliant' or 'substantially compliant' under most regulations. However, it was found non-compliant with three regulations, including governance and management, contracts for the provision of services, and food and nutrition. The November report noted they were 'compliant' and 'substantially compliant' on all regulations. According to LinkedIn, the person listed as the lead inspector on both reports worked as a Clinical Nurse Manager at Beneavin House Nursing Home between June 2015 and June 2017. They then worked as director of nursing in two other nursing homes before moving to HIQA to become an inspector in September 2020. In a lengthy statement, HIQA stated that the nursing home had changed ownership and the inspector had never worked for Beneavin House under the new ownership. A spokesperson said that HIQA has a conflict of interest policy and 'inspectors of social services employed to inspect nursing homes have often worked in nursing homes in the public or private sector or a combination of both' and that a 'key requirement of any applicant for a job as an inspector is at least three years' experience working in a supervisory or management position in a health or social care service, regulatory, or other setting deemed relevant by the Authority'. They continued: '[Name] commenced work as an inspector of social services in September 2020. 'As is standard practice and in line with our conflict of interest policy, she was not required to inspect or to have regulatory oversight of those centres where she worked previously. 'As [she] was employed by Beneavin House Ltd, (the then owner of Beneavin House between 2015 and 2017), this centre and the other Beneavin Centres were not included in [her] caseload at that time. 'Given the passage of time and the change in ownership of the nursing homes in 2024, the issue of a conflict of interest was discussed again by [name] and her line manager with both satisfied that there was no longer any conflict of interest or any reason why [she] would not inspect First Care Beneavin Manor or the First Care Beneavin Lodge. 'She has not inspected First Care Beneavin House, the centre where she used to work. 'To be clear, [she] has never worked for Firstcare Beneavin House Ltd, the company that currently owns First Care Beneavin House, which was acquired by Emeis in 2024. 'In addition, [she] has not worked in Beneavin Manor or been employed by Firstcare Beneavin Manor Ltd. '[She] has never been employed by Emeis or any of the companies that are owned or operated by Emeis.'

Irish Independent

4 days ago

• Irish Independent

The Irish Independent's View: Sweeping reforms of nursing-home care must be prioritised

However, when those being let down so badly are some of the most vulnerable people in our country, this is unacceptable. When confronted over the 'scandalous' treatment of older people in privately run nursing homes, as revealed by RTÉ, Taoiseach Micheál Martin replied that he had 'no issue' with bigger fines being imposed. The question mark left hanging in the air was: Why are greater fines for abuses not already in place? Mr Martin must surely recognise that when you are charged with running a country and are confronted by serious failures, it is you who has responsibility to not only prevent such breaches, but to ensure they do not happen again. Faith in the level of state concern for the welfare and protection of older people has been undermined. If it is to be repaired, we need to see tougher measures to guarantee standards of care are being taken seriously and will be rigorously upheld. Where there ought to have been zero tolerance, we have instead seen too many betrayals of trust when it comes to maintaining safeguards for older people in care. As pointed out by Sinn Féin's health spokesperson David Cullinane, 75pc of Ireland's nursing homes are privately run. He was correct to say that 'older people are being failed'. Old age is not a disease – it is strength and survivorship It will also trouble many to learn that Hiqa – the regulator for nursing homes – does not have the 'far-reaching powers' it needs to deal with the private firms that run them. Its chief, Angela Fitzgerald, told the Oireachtas Committee on Health that the watchdog can only direct individual providers to do something and that it does not have 'powers' to direct companies. Also addressing the committee, junior minister Kieran O'Donnell said he too had 'concerns' about the increasing privatisation of the nursing-home sector. He said it was his hope that further safeguards would be brought forward 'as a matter of urgency'. One has to wonder why, two decades after the appalling revelations concerning abuses of the elderly at Leas Cross, there could be any lack of enforcement measures to make all those involved in nursing-home care accountable for mistreatment of any kind. Given that the entire landscape has been transformed with the predominance of private-care concerns, it is extraordinary that stringent enforcement controls were not also put in place. Sweeping reform of regulations and standards must be prioritised if trust is to be restored. American activist Maggie Kuhn, who founded the Gray Panthers movement to campaign for older people, said: 'Old age is not a disease – it is strength and survivorship, triumph over all kinds of vicissitudes and disappointments, trials and illnesses.' After a lifetime's service, older people surely should not have to battle their own State for their basic rights.

RTÉ News​

4 days ago

• RTÉ News​

Does HIQA have sufficient powers?

The recent RTÉ Investigates exposé, on a number of private nursing homes and the fall-out, has raised fresh questions about the extent of HIQA's powers or ability to regulate the sector. A number of important facts emerged from the Oireachtas Health Committee today. Firstly, HIQA said it has no power to fine a nursing home and that cancellation of a home's registration is the "nuclear option". It also said it lacks the authority to go after a parent company, which may own a group of companies, that in turn own a number of nursing homes. HIQA said that recent updates to its regulatory powers, "when fully implemented", will provide powers to investigate specific individual complaints, will mean extra enforcement powers and shorten the timeframe for escalatory actions. Time will tell and these improvements cannot come fast enough to reassure families and residents. We learned today that there are 95 nursing homes under additional restrictive conditions. This is a dynamic situation where restrictions can be imposed and taken away. Many of the homes are run by the HSE, or small stand-alone private homes and not large corporate entities. The big question was why it took RTÉ Current Affairs, rather than HIQA, to uncover the issues at Benevain Manor in Glasnevin and The Residence in Portlaoise. A full HIQA report on the two homes is due to be sent to the Minister for Health and the Minister of State for Older People at the end of the week. The Interim Report found that Beneavin Manor had reported almost 200 incidents related to alleged suspected or confirmed abuse of patients. And The Residence had reported 40 such allegations. HIQA said today around 14% of notifications from Beneavin were moderate risk and that each one was explored. "We don't wait for a television programme for that. We review it," HIQA told the committee. HIQA has sought assurances regarding the other 23 homes than Emeis own. It has also referred matters to An Garda Síochána. HIQA told the committee that 85% of all inspections are unannounced and that in Emeis centres, 91% of inspections were unannounced.