Did Covid lockdowns really cause temperatures on the moon to drop?
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission.
Scientists have been arguing about a curious topic recently: Did temperatures on the moon dip due to the world's Covid-19 lockdown?
Last year, a pair of researchers claimed that the shockwaves of the shutdown could be felt as far as the moon, causing a slight dip in lunar surface temperatures. Now, a new paper disputes that finding, saying that it's not possible to definitively attribute that drop to the reduction of global emissions associated with the lockdown.
After several studies revealed that the shutdown had a significant effect on air quality around the world, two researchers in India investigated whether the atmospheric changes could have had an effect on the moon.
"We thought it would be a rare opportunity to investigate the effects of [Covid] on the moon," Durga Prasad, a scientist at the Physical Research Laboratory (PRL) in Ahmedabad and lead author of the study, told Space.com by email.
Prasad and study co-author G. Ambily, also of PRL, reviewed data collected from a variety of spots near the lunar equator by NASA's Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter (LRO). They discovered that surface temperatures dropped in the evening by 8 to 10 degrees Kelvin between April and May 2020. The duo attributed this drop to the global shutdown at the height of the pandemic.
As is often the case in science, not everyone agrees with their conclusions.
"The process in reality is very complex, and I believe not all factors were considered," Shirin Haque, a researcher at the University of the West Indies in Trinidad, told Space.com by email. Haque and her colleague presented a dissenting view of the original data. "That is what may have led them to the conclusion they arrived at."
Related: Dramatic effect of coronavirus lockdowns seen from space
As Covid-19 emerged at the dawn of 2020, China, the country of origin, was the first to shut down some of its cities. Over subsequent months, other countries followed suit, leading to a worldwide shutdown after the World Health Organization declared the outbreak to be a pandemic in March. By June, countries had begun relaxing their grip as the world descended into what many would call "the new normal.'
Several independent studies revealed that the shutdown had a significant effect on Earth's atmosphere — a conclusion backed up by anecdotal evidence. Photographs of major cities such as Los Angeles revealed unusually clear skies during the spring of 2020. As people stayed home, the greenhouse gases created by car and air travel were dramatically reduced.
When sunlight reaches Earth, part of it is absorbed into the surface while the rest is reflected as radiation. The heated planet also emits its own radiation. Both are affected by greenhouse gases trapped in the atmosphere. Together, this emission creates a slight glow known as terrestrial radiation, or Earthshine.
During the lunar day, the moon feels the energy of both the sun and Earth. At night, with its back to the sun and its face pointed at day-time Earth, the nearside lunar surface feels only the warmth from our planet. Previous studies have shown that Earthshine can affect the lunar nighttime temperature. The process of terrestrial light reflecting off the moon was first suggested by Leonardo da Vinci.
"When aerosols are decreased, less solar radiation is scattered back to space," Prasad said.
The researchers turned to LRO's Diviner Lunar Radiometer Experiment, an instrument designed to measure temperatures on the lunar surface. They found six sites on the nearside of the moon with similar roughness and brightness values, all near the equator, to minimize how much radiation directly hit the moon. The temperatures were taken between 10 p.m. and 4 a.m. local time on the moon in order to minimize the amount of leftover heat the surface had absorbed during the day. Temperatures were taken from 2017 to 2022 — multiple years on either side of the lockdown peak of April to May 2020.
"Six months is a good span of data for interpretation," Prasad said. The results were published last September in the journal Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (MNRAS).
Related: New moon glows with 'Earthshine' in incredible time-lapse photo series
But it's not an open-and-shut case.
Haque was sent the article by a friend, who wanted to know if the finding was true.
"My initial reaction was one of surprise, and I assumed it was published in a suspect forum — but it was in a leading astronomy journal," she said.
Haque began to discuss the new result with other astronomers. "Everyone's initial reaction was one of disbelief and suspicion," she said. So she and colleague William Schonberg, of the Missouri University of Science and Technology, decided to look into the new results, as "we both found it too incredible to be true."
Their findings were also published in MNRAS, in January 2025.
Whether Earthshine heats up the lunar surface was not in doubt — that process had been documented by earlier research. Haque and Schonberg also observed the drop in surface temperature over the nights between April and May 2020. What they question is the role of the worldwide shutdown in that cooling.
They pointed to the timing of the temperature drop. While the Prasad-Ambily paper highlights the measurements taken between April and May, the Haque paper notes that the temperature starts to drop in 2019, before the worldwide lockdown took place. The drop is gradual, they argue, not sudden.
Prasad disagrees.
"Schonberg and Haque have claimed that the temperature began dropping earlier by visually analyzing the trendline" on a figure in the Prasad-Ambily paper, he said. That trendline is plotted only for visual clarity and is an averaged interpolation of all observations. What is more important, he said, is the clusters of data during April and May.
"It is not a decrease but a sudden drop," Prasad said. "The authors have misunderstood/misinterpreted the representation of our data."
In their research, Schonberg and Haque noted that there was no information on how the trendline itself was obtained, which they called "unfortunate." Furthermore, they pointed out, "if the trendline was potentially misleading, then they should not have included the trendline."
The new paper also pointed to another significant temperature drop in 2018, one that Prasad and Ambily had also noted. That drop clearly wasn't related to the Covid shutdown, and the authors suggested that it could be significant.
Prasad emphasized that his and Ambily's paper only analyzed the period during the lockdown and was not concerned with the earlier cooling. "Our analysis is particularly focused only on the April-May period of all the years, since it was the strict lockdown period in 2020," he said.
"We believe that it is not possible, at this time, to state with any amount of certainty, that the temperature dip we all observed as being the result of decreased human activity on Earth during the Covid-19 lockdown," Shonberg said. "We believe it's a matter of correlation being confused with causation."
Related: Air pollution levels will bounce back as Covid-19 restrictions loosen, scientists say
RELATED STORIES:
— The moon: Everything you need to know about Earth's companion
— No, the coronavirus didn't come from outer space
— New moon glows with 'Earthshine' in incredible time-lapse photo series
Prasad and Ambily stand behind their interpretation of the data.
"We never mentioned that the observation is only due to Covid lockdown," he said. "As we did not find any other reason supporting this unique observation, we have attributed that Covid lockdown seems to be the most plausible reason."
Haque and Schonberg said they appreciate that their colleagues are open to other causes. However, they said that the very title of the original article — "Effects of Covid-19 global lockdown on our moon" — appears to negate that uncertainty.
"The title of their work does not appear to convey the sense of uncertainty that they would seem to prefer that readers take from their article," Haque and Shonberg said. The conclusion also appears unambiguous, claiming that the dip in lunar temperature "clearly" relates to a global lockdown, they added.
Prasad emphasized that future studies are needed to better understand the results of their observations.
"In the absence of any other concrete explanation for the observation of anomalous dip coinciding exactly with that of the strict lockdown period, Covid 19 lockdown is likely to be the only cause," he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Just 1 dose of magic mushroom compound eases depression for at least 5 years in most patients, small study suggests
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission. DENVER—Psilocybin, the main psychoactive ingredient in magic mushrooms, can alleviate depression for at least five years after a single dose, a new study finds. The research, presented June 18 at the Psychedelic Science 2025 conference in Denver, focused on patients with major depressive disorder (MDD), which is often called clinical depression. The serious mood disorder causes a persistent feeling of sadness and a loss of interest or pleasure in activities that were once enjoyable. The most common treatments for MDD include talk therapy and medications such as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, and both can take a long time to show any benefits. When early studies hinted at psilocybin's potential as an antidepressant, a team of researchers undertook the first-ever randomized clinical trial to explore the use of the psychedelic for treating severe depression. The trial included 24 patients, half of whom received psilocybin at the very start of the trial and half of whom received the same dose eight weeks later—the "waitlist" group. Each patient also received 11 hours of psychotherapy. Even in that short time frame, "there was a significant reduction in depression in the immediate-treatment group compared to those on the waitlist," study co-author Alan Davis, director of the Center for Psychedelic Drug Research and Education at The Ohio State University, told Live Science. Once all of the patients had completed the four-week study, the psilocybin appeared to be four times more effective than traditional antidepressant medications, based on previous research data. One month after the treatment, 17 patients had relieved symptoms, including 14 who were in full remission from depression. Patients also responded much faster to psilocybin than is typical for conventional antidepressants. But do these benefits of psilocybin last? Related: Magic mushrooms temporarily 'dissolve' brain network responsible for sense of self Very few long-term studies of psilocybin for depression have been conducted to date, said Dr. Charles Raison, a professor of human ecology and psychiatry at the University of Wisconsin-Madison who was not involved in the research. "They are very difficult to do because people drop out," Raison told Live Science in an email. "But also because they go on all sorts of other treatments that obfuscate the degree to which any longer lasting benefits result from the psychedelic or because the participant got therapy or restarted an antidepressant." To investigate whether the benefits for psilocybin lasted and if the patients had experienced any side effects, the researchers contacted the original trial participants several years later to request their enrollment in a follow-up study. Twenty-one patients enrolled, and their clinicians rated any changes in the participants' levels of depression from before the original treatment to the present day. The patients also filled out a series of self-reported, online questionnaires and met up with clinicians to document their ability to engage in everyday tasks, their levels of anxiety and their general mental health. The researchers assumed that the three patients that didn't sign up for the follow up, and the three that didn't complete the questionnaires had not remained in remission. Even so, the researchers found that 67% of the participants who had suffered from depression half a decade earlier remained in remission after a single psychedelic therapy session. These patients also reported less anxiety and less difficulty functioning on a daily basis. In general, the two-thirds of the patients who responded well reported lasting positive changes in their mindsets, emotional health and relationships. "I'm excited by these deeper aspects of their lives that really speaks to the importance of these interventions beyond just reduction of depression," Davis said. RELATED STORIES —Psychedelics rapidly change the brain. Here's how. —Australia clears legal use of MDMA and psilocybin to treat PTSD and depression —'Magic mushroom' treatment for depression inches closer to approval Most of the patients shared that, following the original treatment, they'd engaged in self-reflection and therapy to help understand themselves and navigate life's challenges. Davis hypothesizes that the psychedelic experience catalyzes a deeper therapy process and would like to conduct future studies comparing the relative influences of psilocybin and psychotherapy in alleviating depression. "The biggest caveat of this study is the small sample size, and the fact that the original trial showed larger antidepressant effects than subsequent larger multi-site studies seem to be showing," Raison said. In a multi-site clinical trial with 233 participants, 37% of the 79 who received a single 25 mg dose of psilocybin, coupled with psychotherapy, went into remission from major depression. While these trials report less widespread antidepressant effects, they support the idea that psilocybin can effectively treat depression, Davis said, and he is keen to see how the findings of multi-site trials hold up five years post-treatment.
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Vera C. Rubin debut images: How to see the groundbreaking space photos from the world's largest camera
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission. The new Vera C. Rubin Observatory is set to release its debut images — taken with the largest digital camera ever built — on Monday (Jun. 23). The world-first images and videos will be ultra-high-definition and will show off the observatory's highly anticipated, cutting-edge capabilities for the first time. Here's what you need to know. If you want to watch from home, a news conference will be streaming on YouTube in English and Spanish at 11:00 a.m. EDT on Monday. The link to watch is posted on the observatory's website, and is also embedded here. If you'd prefer to bask in the awe of the cosmos with friends, you may be able to attend a watch party near you — or even host one of your own. Groups will gather across the globe in planetariums and universities to admire the highly detailed images and videos as they are released. The observatory has shared links to a map of all registered watch parties, as well as a link to sign up to become a host. During the news conference, the observatory team will introduce the Rubin Observatory before showcasing the new images and discussing their significance. Watch parties may also hear from local scientists and special guests. Be sure to check out the details of a watch party before you attend to learn about any extra programming. The observatory, perched high on a mountain in the Chilean Andes, will peer at interstellar comets and dangerous asteroids, as well as larger objects, like twisting galaxies and exploding supernovas. Related: 'People thought this couldn't be done': Scientists observe light of 'cosmic dawn' with a telescope on Earth for the first time ever Inside Rubin lies the world's largest digital camera and six of the largest optical filters ever produced. Together, they allow researchers to observe different facets of the universe in many wavelengths of light and remarkably high detail. The camera will take a new high-resolution photo of the sky around every 40 seconds. The images will then be transmitted via fiber optic cables to a supercomputer in California, which will analyze the photos. When stitched together, the images can act as a time-lapse video of space, one that is planned to span 10 years. RELATED STORIES —Space photo of the week: Observatory, or alien planet? Boggle your mind with this 360-degree image —Vera C. Rubin Observatory: The groundbreaking mission to make a 10-year, time-lapse movie of the universe —3,200-megapixel camera of the future Vera Rubin Observatory snaps record-breaking 1st photos Using its groundbreaking instruments, the observatory is expected to contribute to current understanding of widely debated phenomena, including dark energy and dark matter — two components that are thought to make up a vast majority of the universe, but remain poorly understood. The new images could be the first of many that vastly improve our understanding of the cosmos. Whether you join a watch party or tune in from the comfort of your couch, these photos are not to be missed.
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Hurricanes and sandstorms can be forecast 5,000 times faster thanks to new Microsoft AI model
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission. A new artificial intelligence (AI) model can predict major weather events faster and more accurately than some of the world's most widely used forecasting systems. The model, called Aurora, is trained on more than 1 million hours of global atmospheric data, including weather station readings, satellite images and radar measurements. Scientists at Microsoft say it's likely the largest dataset ever used to train a weather AI model. Aurora correctly forecast that Typhoon Doksuri would strike the northern Philippines four days before the storm made landfall in July 2023. At the time, official forecasts placed the storm's landfall over Taiwan — several hundred miles away. It also outperformed standard forecasting tools used by agencies, including the U.S. National Hurricane Center and the Joint Typhoon Warning Center. It delivered more accurate five-day storm tracks and produced high-resolution forecasts up to 5,000 times faster than conventional weather models powered by supercomputers. More broadly, Aurora beat existing systems in predicting weather conditions over a 14-day period in 91% of cases, the scientists said. They published their findings May 21 in the journal Nature. Researchers hope Aurora and models like it could support a new approach to predicting environmental conditions called Earth system forecasting, where a single AI model simulates weather, air quality and ocean conditions together. This could help produce faster and more consistent forecasts, especially in places that lack access to high-end computing or comprehensive monitoring infrastructure. Related: Google builds an AI model that can predict future weather catastrophes Aurora belongs to a class of large-scale AI systems known as foundation models — the same category of AI models that power tools like ChatGPT. Foundation models can be adapted to different tasks because they're designed to learn general patterns and relationships from large volumes of training data, rather than being built for a single, fixed task. In Aurora's case, the model learns to generate forecasts in a matter of seconds by analyzing weather patterns from sources like satellites, radar and weather stations, as well as simulated forecasts, the researchers said. The model can then be fine-tuned for a wide range of scenarios with relatively little extra data — unlike traditional forecasting models, which are typically built for narrow, task-specific purposes and often need retraining to adapt. The diverse dataset Aurora is trained on not only results in greater accuracy in general versus conventional methods, but also means the model is better at forecasting extreme events, researchers said. Related stories —Google's DeepMind AI can make better weather forecasts than supercomputers —Is climate change making the weather worse? —What is the Turing test? How the rise of generative AI may have broken the famous imitation game In one example, Aurora successfully predicted a major sandstorm in Iraq in 2022, despite having limited air quality data. It also outperformed wave simulation models at forecasting ocean swell height and direction in 86% of tests, showing it could extract useful patterns from complex data even when specific inputs were missing or incomplete. "It's got the potential to have [a] huge impact because people can really fine tune it to whatever task is relevant to them … particularly in countries which are underserved by other weather forecasting capabilities," study co-author Megan Stanley, a senior researcher at Microsoft, said in a statement. Microsoft has made Aurora's code and training data publicly available for research and experimentation. The model has been integrated into services like MSN Weather, which itself is integrated into tools like the Windows Weather app and Microsoft's Bing search results.
