Canadian Medical Association files lawsuit challenging gender-care legislation
Aerial shot of the Alberta legislature on Monday, May 26, 2025. (Cam Wiebe/CTV News Edmonton)
The Canadian Medical Association (CMA) and three Alberta physicians are pursuing a judicial review of Bill 26, known as the province's gender-care legislation.
A statement from the CMA said the bill directs physicians on how to deliver gender-affirming care to people under 18, down to which medications they can use.
'This is a historic and unprecedented government intrusion into the physician-patient relationship and requires doctors to follow the law rather than clinical guidelines, the needs of patients and their own conscience,' said the statement issued Wednesday morning.
The CMA said it has filed an application with the Court of King's Bench for the judicial review of Bill 26, the Health Statutes Amendment Act, 2024 and its proposed changes to the Health Professions Act R.S.A 2000.
Bill 26 was introduced on Oct. 31, 2024, to preserve choice for minors identifying as transgender while refocusing the health-care system, according to the province.
'Medicine is a calling. Doctors pursue it because they are compelled to care for and promote the well-being of patients,' said CMA president Joss Reimer in a statement. 'When a government bans specific treatments, it interferes with a doctor's ability to empower patients to choose the best care possible.
The CMA said the legislation renders physicians powerless in providing independent expertise, clinical guidance and treatment options when it comes to gender-affirming care.
Jake Donaldson, a Calgary-based family physician who provides gender-affirming care to about 40 adolescents, said the legislation has put him and his colleagues in a state of 'moral crisis.'
'These patients are a vulnerable group that already face significant and disproportionate discrimination, violence and mental health challenges,' said Donaldson in a CMA statement. 'Bill 26 commands physicians to stand on the sidelines and watch them suffer.'
Since the bill and other transgender legislation was introduced, advocacy groups and families have protested and taken legal action against the province, arguing that Bill 26 violates gender-diverse young people's section 7 right to security of the person, their section 12 right to be free from cruel and unusual treatment and their section 15 right to equality.
Part of Bill 26 prohibits gender-affirming 'top' surgeries for minors which went into effect when the bill received royal assent in December 2024. The legislation also bans puberty blockers and hormone therapy for those with gender dysphoria.
Egale Canada and Skipping Stone, both LGBTQ2S+ advocacy groups, have requested for an injunction to block the denial of health care for gender diverse youth while the bill faces a constitutional test.
Sarah Hoffman, NDP shadow minister of health, said she is pleased to see doctors stand with their patients in opposing UCP law.
'When medical experts and parents agree on safe medical treatment, the government shouldn't be preventing it,' said Hoffman in an emailed statement. 'The new CMA legal challenge to Bill 26 is about defending parental and human rights.'
CTV News Edmonton reached out to the Ministry of Justice for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Police warn 'heartbreaking' distraction thefts could rise in the summer
Social Sharing Police in the Lower Mainland are warning the longer, brighter days of summer mean distraction thefts, in which robbers quickly try to confuse victims while stealing from them, are expected to increase. Jewelry, valuables and money are often stolen in the thefts, which have been a problem for years, according to the Vancouver Police Department (VPD). Richard Jeha, a hairstylist and owner of Richard Jeha Salon, said he was robbed of treasured jewelry — a bracelet from a loved one and a cross on a gold chain — that he was wearing, while walking his dog in Vancouver's Kerrisdale neighbourhood earlier this month. Jeha said it was still light out when he was approached by a woman offering him a strange-looking ring. She proceeded to ask him for the bracelet he was wearing. It was a gift from a loved one in Lebanon, Jeha told CBC's On the Coast. The woman said her husband, waiting in a nearby car with a small child, would pay for Jeha's bracelet. "I said, 'No, no, no, I don't want any of that.' ... Anyway, she came from behind me, grabbed my elbow and pushed it into his window." The man in the vehicle grabbed Jeha's hand, which the woman was holding, and slid his hand under the bracelet. "He put his finger and just yanked it off me," Jeha said. The man also stole Jeha's cross necklace, which he had had since he was five years old. Jeha tried to yell at the couple, but to no avail. "It wasn't more than a minute or so that she's in the car, and they took off." Two boys helped Jeha call 911 after the incident. Police concerned about distraction thefts The VPD said the incident is very similar to other distraction thefts, however sometimes people aren't even aware they're being robbed. "This has been going on for years and years and years. It's a very sophisticated group that's doing this," Const. Tania Visintin said. About 70 cases of distraction theft have been reported to VPD since the beginning of the year, according to Visintin. She said distraction thefts commonly occur in residential areas; the south and southeast parts of Vancouver are particular hotspots for this type of crime, possibly because there are more homes. Visintin said a common strategy the robbers use is to approach a victim with a sob story. She noted they can come up to victims in yards or even on porches or patios. "It's not just one group; it's several groups, so it does make catching them very difficult for us. But because there's such an increase right now, we're doing a lot of work, especially behind the scenes, a lot of covert things that I can't unfortunately speak about," Visintin said. "We're taking this as a priority because these are innocent people that are getting targeted, and it's very heartbreaking to see." Police in other Lower Mainland cities have also sent out warnings about distraction thefts. Burnaby RCMP said three thefts in recent weeks have resulted in two victims losing family heirlooms. In March, Surrey Police Service noted there had been more than a dozen incidents of distraction theft in the first three months of the year. If you are approached by a stranger and feel uncomfortable, police recommend yelling and making noise to try attract the attention of others nearby. Jeha said he wished he would have not visibly worn his cross over his shirt. "That was something, a well-learned lesson."
CTV News
2 hours ago
- CTV News
Two motorcyclists suffer life-threatening injuries after head-on crash near Cornwall
An Ontario Provincial Police crest is pictured on an officer's uniform. (Supplied) Two people on a motorcycle were taken to hospital with injuries described as life-threatening after a head-on crash near Cornwall. Ontario Provincial Police say the crash happened on County Road 18 near Chapel Road, about 100 kilometres southeast of downtown Ottawa at approximately 4 p.m. Saturday. The collision involved the motorcycle and an SUV, OPP says in an email to CTV News Ottawa. Emergency responders, including Orgne Air ambulance, was called to the scene. Roads in the area remain closed as of Saturday evening and motorists can expect a 'lengthy' closure, police said in a news release. The public is asked to avoid the area as an investigation continues.
CTV News
2 hours ago
- CTV News
Hit-and-run in Caledon sends boy to hospital
An Ontario Provincial Police vehicle is pictured in this file image. (File Photo/Ontario Provincial Police | Photo Credit: Bobb Barratt) A boy is in the hospital after a hit-and-run in Caledon Saturday afternoon. Ontario Provincial Police say they got a call at 2 p.m. for a collision in the area of Mayfield Road and Petch Avenue, west of McLaughlin Road. A young male riding a motorized scooter was struck by a westbound vehicle, OPP say. He was taken to the hospital with non-life-threatening injuries. OPP say the driver did not remain at the scene. No description of the suspect vehicle has been released. They are asking anyone with information to call 905-584-2241 or 1-888-310-1122.
