UK judges sound alarm over AI-fabricated cases
A judge of the High Court of England and Wales has issued a formal warning to legal professionals, cautioning lawyers that relying on artificial intelligence to generate legal arguments containing fictitious case citations may face criminal prosecution.
Victoria Sharp, president of the King's Bench Division of the High Court, along with fellow judge Jeremy Johnson, reprimanded lawyers involved in two separate cases for apparently relying on AI tools to draft written arguments that were submitted to the court without verification.
'There are serious implications for the administration of justice and public confidence in the justice system if artificial intelligence is misused,' she said in the ruling on Friday.
The cases arose after lower courts flagged suspected use of AI-generated arguments and witness statements containing false information.
In the ruling by Judge Sharp, the court revealed that one attorney, in a £90 million ($120 million) lawsuit concerning an alleged breach of a financing agreement with Qatar National Bank, cited 18 non-existent cases.
Hamad Al-Haroun, the client in the case, apologized for unintentionally misleading the court with false information generated by publicly available AI tools, accepting personal responsibility and absolving his solicitor, Abid Hussain.
Sharp said it was 'extraordinary that the lawyer was relying on the client for the accuracy of their legal research, rather than the other way around.'
In another case, barrister Sarah Forey cited five fabricated cases in a tenant's housing claim against the London Borough of Haringey. The lawyer denied intentionally using AI but acknowledged she may have done so inadvertently while conducting online research for the case.
The judge scolded her saying that 'Ms Forey could have checked the cases she cited by searching the National Archives' caselaw website or by going to the law library of her Inn of Court.'
Sharp warned that presenting false material as genuine could constitute contempt of court or, in the most serious cases, perverting the course of justice – a criminal offense punishable by up to life imprisonment.
The judges referred the lawyers in both cases to their respective professional regulators but declined to pursue more severe penalties.
High-profile figures and scientists have raised concerns in recent years over the potential dangers posed by AI.
Researchers warn that artificial intelligence is advancing rapidly, with some models reportedly becoming self-aware and rewriting their own code. Palisade Research reported last month that in recent tests, a powerful AI model 'sabotaged a shutdown mechanism to prevent itself from being turned off,' raising concerns of a potential real-world AI rebellion.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Russia Today
2 days ago
- Russia Today
Britain's Starmer mistakes South Korean interpreter for president (VIDEO)
UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer appears to have mistaken an interpreter with the South Korean delegation at the G7 summit for the country's president. The mix-up took place during a photo opportunity at the entrance to the summit venue in Canada. A video from the event shows Starmer confidently shaking the man's hand and smiling, while South Korean President Lee Jae-myung stood behind him waiting to be acknowledged. Starmer held the interpreter's hand for several seconds before the mistake became apparent as President Lee stepped forward. The two leaders eventually greeted each other but then apparently had another moment of confusion as to where to stand for the photo. South Korea, along with Australia and India, participated as guests of the event. London has denied claims of an embarrassing diplomatic mistake. Keir Starmer mistakenly shakes hands with a Korean interpreter instead of the President of South Korea (2025) The day before, Starmer had to kneel in front of US President Donald Trump to frantically trying to gather up trade papers that hd been dropped by the American leader. The agenda for the 51st G7 summit included support for Ukraine, the Middle East, sanctions, AI and energy security. During the summit, Trump had claimed that kicking Russia out of the group was a big mistake and suggested that Moscow's presence in the G8, as it was known, could have helped prevent the Ukraine conflict. The Kremlin has argued that the G7 has 'lost its relevance' and no longer reflects global economic dynamics. Former Russian President Dmitry Medvedev applauded Trump's criticism of the group and his decision to leave the event early, but stressed that the G7 is a 'dead club.' Writing on X, he claimed that its members had already looked like 'zombies' over a decade ago.
Russia Today
5 days ago
- Russia Today
British gay couple charged over rape and murder of baby they wanted to adopt
British secondary school teacher Jamie Varley has been charged with the murder and sexual assault of a 13-month-old boy that he and his boyfriend John McGowan-Fazakerley were in the process of adopting. The couple appeared in Preston Crown Court on Monday, nearly two years after the baby boy, Preston Davey, was pronounced dead at Blackpool Victoria Hospital in 2023. Both defendants were initially arrested, but later released on bail. Lancashire Police later re-arrested and charged Varley with a slew of offenses including murder, two counts of assault by penetration of a male child under 13 and five counts of child cruelty. He also stands accused of multiple counts of taking indecent photographs, distributing an image and possession of an extreme pornographic image of the victim, as well as other offenses. His co-defendant McGowan-Fazakerley has been charged with causing and allowing the death of a child, sexual assault of a child, and two counts of cruelty to a child, the police said. The authorities noted that all of the charges were related to the 13-month-old victim. Judge Robert Altham, who presided at Monday's brief hearing, set the trial date for April 14, 2026. Both defendants were remanded into custody and will remain in prison awaiting a plea hearing in October, according to local daily The Blackpool Gazette. The judge noted that while he regretted the delay, it would ensure that all expert witnesses were ready for future proceedings, the newspaper wrote on Monday. Varley has been suspended from work since 2023, according to the Cidari Multi Academy Trust, which now runs the school where he was employed at the time of the alleged crime. 'He has not been permitted onto, or attended school premises, or been permitted to contact pupils or colleagues,' the organization told the Blackpool Gazette in a statement. The trust is reportedly 'considering its position in relation' to Varley's employment. 'Jamie was suspended on full pay as we are legally obliged to do,' Cidari told the local newspaper when asked whether Varley has been receiving a salary since his 2023 arrest.
Russia Today
5 days ago
- Russia Today
Starmer launches long-delayed UK grooming gangs inquiry
UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer has ordered a nationwide inquiry into the authorities' handling of the grooming gangs sex abuse scandal, marking a U-turn after his government had dismissed calls for action just months ago. The gangs, primarily involving men of Pakistani origin, have been active in the UK for decades, engaging in the systematic rape and torture of vulnerable girls. At the start of the year, the government rejected calls for a national inquiry, insisting the matter had already been dealt with during a seven-year investigation. However, speaking to reporters on Sunday on the eve of the G7 summit in Canada, Starmer backtracked, stating: 'I've never said we should not look again at any issue.' The UK's top investigative body, the National Crime Agency (NCA), has been assigned to lead a nationwide effort to reopen historic group-based child sexual abuse cases and track down offenders who evaded earlier police investigations. The operation aims to jail perpetrators and deliver justice to victims whose cases were previously overlooked, officials said. The scandal returned to the spotlight in January, after billionaire Elon Musk accused Starmer of failing to protect children. Musk said Starmer was 'complicit' in the failure of authorities to safeguard victims and prosecute offenders during his tenure as director of public prosecutions between 2008 and 2013. The British authorities have reopened over 800 cases since January and plan to coordinate efforts across local forces, specialist units, and national teams. The move comes along with the formal launch of a statutory public inquiry, empowered to compel witnesses and direct local investigations, following a rapid review that found a new probe was warranted. The inquiry will examine institutional failures – including by councils, police, and elected officials – in protecting vulnerable girls, with particular attention to ignored or mishandled complaints. Authorized under the 2005 Inquiries Act, the inquiry can trigger detailed local case reviews and seek accountability in instances where misconduct or cover-ups are alleged. Reform UK leader Nigel Farage welcomed the 'U-turn,' cautioning that the inquiry must not be used to 'whitewash' and urging justice for the victims. Former MP Rupert Lowe credited Elon Musk for action, saying there would have been 'no inquiry, no justice' without him. Musk responded with a heart emoji.
