Supreme court widens court options for vaping companies pushing back against FDA rules
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court sided with e-cigarette companies on Friday in a ruling making it easier to sue over Food and Drug Administration decisions blocking their products from the multibillion-dollar vaping market.
The 7-2 opinion comes as companies push back against a yearslong federal regulatory crackdown on electronic cigarettes. It's expected to give the companies more control over which judges hear lawsuits filed against the agency.
The justices went the other way on vaping in an April decision, siding with the FDA in a ruling upholding a sweeping block on most sweet-flavored vapes instituted after a spike in youth vaping.
The current case was filed by R.J. Reynolds Vapor Co., which had sold a line of popular berry and menthol-flavored vaping products before the agency started regulating the market under the Tobacco Control Act in 2016.
The agency refused to authorize the company's Vuse Alto products, an order that 'sounded the death knell for a significant portion of the e-cigarette market,' Justice Amy Coney Barrett wrote in the majority opinion.
The company is based in North Carolina and typically would have been limited to challenging the FDA in a court there or in the agency's home base of Washington. Instead, it joined forces with Texas businesses that sell the products and sued there. The conservative 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals allowed the lawsuit to go forward, finding that anyone whose business is hurt by the FDA decision can sue.
The agency appealed to the Supreme Court, arguing that R.J. Reynolds was trying to find a court friendly to its arguments, a practice often called 'judge shopping.'
The justices, though, found that the law does allow other businesses affected by the FDA decisions, like e-cigarette sellers, to sue in their home states.
In a dissent, Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, joined by Justice Sonia Sotomayor, said she would have sided with the agency and limited where the cases can be filed.
The Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids called the majority decision disappointing, saying it would allow manufacturers to 'judge shop,' though it said the companies will still have to contend with the Supreme Court's April decision.
Attorney Ryan Watson, who represented R.J. Reynolds, said that the court recognized that agency decisions can have devastating downstream effects on retailers and other businesses, and the decision 'ensures that the courthouse doors are not closed' to them.
___
Follow the AP's coverage of the Supreme Court at https://apnews.com/hub/us-supreme-court.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Fed governor breaks ranks with Powell, signals rate cuts could begin next month
The Federal Reserve has held off on cutting interest rates in 2025 to date, although one member of the board of governors is signaling that could change as early as next month. Federal Reserve Governor Christopher Waller said in a Friday interview with CNBC's "Squawk Box" that he believes the central bank is in a position to start lowering rates starting next month. "I think we're in a position that we could do this as early as July," Waller told the outlet. "That would be my view, whether the committee would go along with it or not." Waller's remarks come after the Fed on Wednesday announced it would hold its benchmark interest rate steady at a range of 4.25% to 4.5% for the fourth consecutive meeting. Fed Chair Jerome Powell said the central bank is monitoring inflation data and the labor market amid the uncertainty created by the Trump administration's tariff policies. Federal Reserve Leaves Key Interest Rate Unchanged For Fourth Straight Meeting Powell explained that the Fed's "current stance of monetary policy leaves us well positioned to respond in a timely way to potential economic developments." Read On The Fox Business App He added that the labor market is "at or near maximum employment" while persistent inflation remains "somewhat above our 2% longer-run objective." Waller's view is that the central bank shouldn't wait for a deterioration in the labor market to take action, arguing that, "If you're starting to worry about the downside risk [to the] labor market, move now, don't wait. Why do we want to wait until we actually see a crash before we start cutting rates?" Nearly One-third Of $36T National Debt Needs Refinancing As Trump Demands Rate Cuts "So I'm all in favor of saying maybe we should start thinking about cutting the policy rate at the next meeting, because we don't want to wait till the job market tanks before we start cutting the policy rate," Waller told CNBC, adding that the Fed should "start slow" in lowering interest rates "just to make sure that there's no big surprises." "We've been on pause for six months to wait and see, and so far, the data has been fine," Waller said. "I don't think we need to wait much longer, because even if the tariffs come in later, the impacts are still the same. It should be a one-off level effect and not cause persistent inflation." Trump Urges Fed's Powell To Cut Interest Rates By Full Percentage Point: 'Rocket Fuel!' President Donald Trump has been a vocal critic of the Fed's reluctance to cut interest rates in the face of economic uncertainty that stems in large part from tariffs and trade policy. Trump has also lambasted Fed Chair Powell, calling him a "stupid person" and "numskull" in recent weeks as he lobbies for interest rate cuts. Following Waller's comments, the odds of a rate cut at the Fed's next meeting in July ticked slightly higher but remained a relative long shot, rising from 12.5% to 14.5%, according to the CME FedWatch tool, which tracks the probability of rate moves. The tool showed that the market sees the subsequent meeting in September as a more likely time for the next rate cut, with a 61.8% chance of a 25-basis point cut at that article source: Fed governor breaks ranks with Powell, signals rate cuts could begin next month
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Nvidia and Foxconn Plan to Deploy Humanoid Robots at Houston AI Server Factory -- Reuters
Nvidia (NVDA, Financials) and Foxconn are in talks to deploy humanoid robots at a new AI server manufacturing plant in Houston, marking a potential first for both companies in integrating human-like robotics into mass production, Reuters reported Friday, citing two unnamed sources. Warning! GuruFocus has detected 4 Warning Signs with NVDA. If finalized, the deal would be Nvidia's first use of humanoid robots in manufacturing and Foxconn's first AI server plant to utilize them on a production line. The Houston facility, which is scheduled to begin operations in early 2026, is being designed with extra space to accommodate such automation. Foxconn has tested humanoid robots made in-house and by China's UBTech, though it's unclear which model will be used in Houston or how many will be deployed. Foxconn has trained its robots to perform tasks such as picking and placing objects and inserting cables, according to a company presentation in May. Foxconn executive Leo Guo said last month the company will unveil two humanoid robot models at its November tech eventone with legs and another with a wheeled autonomous mobile base. Nvidia, which supplies the computing platforms for many humanoid robotics developers, announced in April it would manufacture AI supercomputers in Texas through partnerships with Foxconn in Houston and Wistron in Dallas. Both plants are expected to scale production within 12 to 15 months. Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang said in March that humanoid robots would become commonplace in factories within five years. Automakers such as Mercedes-Benz, BMW, and Tesla (TSLA, Financials) are also investing in the space, while China has identified humanoid robotics as a strategic sector. Both Nvidia and Foxconn declined to comment. This article first appeared on GuruFocus. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Robotaxis Could Redefine Tesla or Rattle Its Stock
Tesla's (NASDAQ:TSLA) much-anticipated robotaxi pilot, set to roll out June 22 in Austin, is pivotal for the company's next growth chapter. Success could redefine its revenue model; failure could dent valuation and long-term prospects. Jacob Falkencrone, Saxo's global head of investment strategy, warns that the launchElon Musk's next trillion-dollar chapteris as much about regulatory navigation as true autonomy. Roughly ten Model Y robotaxis running Tesla's Full Self-Driving software will operate in geo-fenced zones under remote human oversight, reflecting cautious, phased deployment rather than a turnkey self-drive revolution. Skepticism lingers amid Democratic lawmakers urging a delay until new Texas safety laws kick in on September 1, and an ongoing NHTSA probe into Tesla's autonomous systems. Historically, Tesla share prices spike on hype and retreat on reality. A smooth pilot could position Tesla as a mobility services leader, slashing urban travel costs by up to 70% and potentially eclipsing its core car-sales business. Conversely, any misstepsregulatory pushback, tech hiccups, or safety incidentscould spook investors and create tactical buying windows. Early user feedback, regulatory responses, and incident reports will be key barometers. Investors should watch those signals closely to gauge whether robotaxis truly deliver transformative upside or morph into another Musk-driven mirage. This article first appeared on GuruFocus.
