2 days ago
Democrats' wary response to transgender ruling shows party's retreat
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
Even Democrats who condemned the ruling tried to turn the focus to other issues. Schumer suggested on the social platform X that Republicans were using the topic 'to divert attention from ripping health care away from millions of Americans.'
Advertisement
The careful calculus reflected how the fraught topic of transgender issues has tormented Democrats for months, with Republicans putting them firmly on the back foot. Many party leaders now believe that liberal politicians took positions in recent years that deviated too far from the beliefs of the average voter.
Last year, Donald Trump painted Vice President Kamala Harris as too far to the left by pointing to her past positions on transgender care, including support for taxpayer-funded transition operations for prisoners and migrants, which she expressed on a questionnaire in 2019. (Trump elided the fact that appointees in his first administration provided gender-affirming care for a small group of inmates.)
Advertisement
'Kamala is for they/them. President Trump is for you,' declared a widely circulated Trump ad. The line of attack was considered by some Democrats to be one of the most effective against Harris.
Since her loss, they have made some efforts to pivot, conscious of polling like a New York Times survey in February that found that nearly 80 percent of Americans — including 67 percent of Democrats — believed that transgender female athletes should not be allowed to participate in women's sports. A survey from SCOTUSPoll in April found that 64 percent of Americans, including 38 percent of Democrats, supported states' being able to ban certain treatments for transgender minors.
But many elected Democrats still see themselves as important defenders of transgender Americans, and plenty of rank-and-file lawmakers had full-throated condemnations of the ruling Wednesday.
'Trans youth and their health care are under attack — and now our highest court has joined in on the assault,' Representative Summer Lee of Pennsylvania wrote on social media.
Representative Brittany Pettersen of Colorado added: 'As a mom, I can't imagine the pain these families navigate as they're denied the care their children need. Trans kids, like all kids, deserve the freedom to reach their greatest potential.'
Governor JB Pritzker of Illinois, who has a transgender cousin, appeared to be the most forthcoming of the party's potential 2028 contenders, writing on X that 'Illinois has enshrined protections to meet this very moment.'
Advertisement
'In a time of increasing overreach and hateful rhetoric, it's more important than ever to reaffirm our commitment to the rights and dignity of the LGBTQ+ community,' he added. 'You have a home here always.'
In recent months, other ambitious Democrats have sounded a different tune, with Newsom making headlines in March when he suggested that transgender athletes' participation in women's sports was 'deeply unfair.'
Pete Buttigieg, who ran for president in 2020 and later served as transportation secretary, offered a nuanced answer at a town hall in Iowa last month when asked about transgender rights.
'While I think we do need to revisit some of the things that we have had to say policy-wise that haven't kept up with the times as a party, that doesn't mean, ever, throwing vulnerable people under the bus,' said Buttigieg, who is gay.
Asked whether Buttigieg had spoken about the ruling or would issue a statement, a spokesperson for him replied, 'He has not.'
Even Democrats without evident presidential aspirations have shifted on transgender issues this year. As Senator Catherine Cortez Masto of Nevada voted against a bill barring transgender women and girls from participating on girls' sports teams, she said she supported 'fair play and safety' but not 'transgender athletes competing in girls' and women's sports when it compromises those principles.'
And Representative Seth Moulton of Massachusetts, one of the first to break with his party on transgender athletes, faced a backlash in November when he said in an interview: 'I have two little girls. I don't want them getting run over on a playing field by a male or formerly male athlete.'
Representative Sarah McBride of Delaware, the first openly transgender member of Congress, has focused less on her identity and more on issues like paid family leave and the minimum wage. In a statement Wednesday, she said that the Supreme Court ruling 'undermines doctors' and that 'politicians and judges are inserting themselves in exam rooms.'
Advertisement
In a podcast interview this week with Ezra Klein, a New York Times opinion columnist, McBride suggested that activists took their feet off the gas after gay marriage was legalized and public perception shifted in favor of LGBTQ+ rights. That has allowed, she added, 'for the misinformation, the disinformation — that well-coordinated, well-funded campaign — to really take advantage of that lack of understanding.'
A member of the Supreme Court, Justice Sonia Sotomayor, was perhaps the most prominent voice defending transgender people on Wednesday.
In her dissent, Sotomayor wrote that 'the court abandons transgender children and their families to political whims.'
