Anchorage judge rules state's brown-bear killings are unconstitutional
Four brown bears line up at the top of the falls on the Brooks River on Sept. 6, 2021, to fish for salmon. Brooks Falls draws bears from around the region, as well as Katmai National Park and Preserve tourists who travel there to view the bear crowds. (Photo by L. Law/National Park Service)
The Alaska Department of Fish and Game's decision to kill almost 200 brown bears in order to boost a struggling caribou herd violated due process and was unconstitutional, an Anchorage Superior Court judge ruled Friday.
Judge Andrew Guidi's 10-page decision means at least a temporary end to the state's controversial bear-killing program, which was intended to aid the struggling Mulchatna caribou herd.
'Unless they want to seek a stay of this decision, they've got to stop killing bears,' said attorney Joe Geldhof, who represented the Alaska Wildlife Alliance in a lawsuit that prompted Friday's decision.
The Alliance sued the state in 2023 to challenge the application of Alaska's 'intensive management' project in Southwest Alaska.
Originally designed to kill wolves in order to boost the populations of prey species that hunters pursue, the program was expanded in 2022 to cover bears that have been preying on the Mulchatna caribou herd.
That herd, which contained 200,000 animals at its peak in 1997, has declined to about 13,000 animals and is closed to hunting.
Anchorage attorney Michelle Bittner filed a separate lawsuit, also challenging the state's bear-killing program.
Both lawsuits argued that the state's Board of Game failed to follow adequate due process standards before beginning the program.
Before a judge could consider the merits of either case, state attorneys argued that Bittner did not have the standing to bring a lawsuit on the issue. That argument went all the way to the Alaska Supreme Court, which ruled in February that Bittner could bring her case.
That cleared the way for the Alaska Wildlife Alliance's lawsuit to advance as well, with oral arguments taking place in March.
Ruling Friday on the merits, Guidi concluded that the Board of Game violated due process and did not provide adequate public notice when it began its bear-killing program.
'The notice provided by the BOG contemplating extension of an existing wolf control program to lands managed by the federal government that was altered to include a bear removal program on state lands substantially changed the subject matter of the proposal,' Guidi wrote. 'These changes went far beyond varying, clarifying or altering the specific matter of the proposal addressed in the original notice. As a result, the BOG failed to adhere to mandatory due process standards.'
Guidi also found that the Board of Game violated the Alaska Constitution's principle of sustained yield because it valued the sustainability of caribou herds but didn't adequately study what would happen to bear populations.
'The issue of the bear population and distribution is an obvious salient issue touching on sustainability,' he wrote. 'Addressing the sustainability of a constitutionally protected resource like bears almost certainly requires the BOG to engage in more than a rudimentary discussion about a bear population or engage in conclusionary opinions when considering a proposal to initiate a program calling for the unrestricted killing of bears.'
A spokesperson for the Alaska Department of Law, which represented the Board of Game in the lawsuit, said the state is reviewing the order and considering its options for how to proceed.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
14-06-2025
- Yahoo
WVU Board of Governors backs Hutson in split leadership vote
Jun. 13—MORGANTOWN — If it was a power grab — as one outgoing member suggested — it was a successful one. In Gordon Gee's final meeting as the school's president, the West Virginia University Board of Governors voted 9-6 Friday to select Robert "Rusty " Hutson Jr. as the body's next chairman, effective July 1. Hutson, who joined the BOG in September after being appointed by former Gov. Jim Justice, was selected over sitting Chairman Richard Pill. The co-founder and CEO of Diversified Energy Company, Hutson is a former chairman of the Fairmont State University Board of Governors. His selection ran counter to the recommendation of the BOG's nominating committee, which tapped Pill, Vice-Chair Patrice Harris and Secretary Robert Reynolds to keep those positions for the coming year. Following the vote for chairman, Harris declined the nomination for vice-chair and nominated Reynolds, who was unanimously approved. After Charles Capito and Susan Lavenski refused nominations for secretary, Paul Mattox accepted and was approved by the body. Mattox, a former state transportation secretary, was reappointed to a newly created seat on the BOG by Gov. Patrick Morrisey in May after his previous seat was eliminated by legislation. The selection of BOG leadership occurred in the first meeting since the West Virginia Legislature stripped faculty, staff and student representatives of voting power. Based on comments offered during the meeting, all four backed the Pill, Harris, Reynolds leadership team. While the discourse remained civil, there was an undertone of friction throughout the meeting as seemingly innocuous comments about "transparency " and "honor " landed as clear references to the recent public infighting surrounding, among other things, the process for selecting the university's next president. Frances "Frankie " Tack, attending her final meeting as a faculty representative, offered the most pointed remarks, explaining that the BOG has "weathered an array of dysfunctional practices " in the past year. She predicted those practices would continue Friday, explaining it was "unprecedented " for the body to not follow the recommendation of the nominating committee when selecting leadership. Further, Tack said the body traditionally promotes leadership — from secretary, to vice-chair to chair — from among experienced members for the sake of continuity. "So what's changed in the 2024-2025 year ? In a word, membership, " she said, later adding, "If there are attempts to nominate officers other than those the BOG members of the nominating committee have vetted and voted to bring forward to this board, you will know a power grab is being attempted ... " Hutson later countered that his interest in leading the body shouldn't be viewed as an indictment of Pill's leadership. "It's about whether I feel like I can add value to a very challenging time moving forward, that my skill set may be different than what Rick's is. It has nothing to do with whether I think Rick's done the best job or I could do the best job, " he said. "It has to do with the way I feel like the board can be managed going forward — and the challenges, and the issues that I believe are going to be on the horizon. That's all it's about." Almost lost in the proceedings was the fact the meeting was the last in Gee's tenure. He'll leave the university on July 14. Incoming President Michael T. Benson starts the following day. Pill was overcome with emotion in expressing his gratitude for Gee's efforts at WVU. In his final president's report — which took place prior to the selection of leadership — Gee spoke glowingly of Pill, Harris and Reynolds, and cautioned the body against allowing division to fester within the board, particularly in a time when the public regard for higher education is on shaky ground. "I make a plea to all of you today to think about the fact that the university is more important than you. You have individual interests, but the university is more important than any one person. The university is certainly more important than me, " he said.
Yahoo
12-06-2025
- Yahoo
Mat-Su mayor files to run as a Republican for Alaska governor
Jun. 12—Edna DeVries, mayor of the Mat-Su Borough, announced on Thursday that she is running as a Republican to be Alaska's next governor. DeVries, 83, has been mayor of the Mat-Su since 2021. She moved to Palmer in 1969 and was mayor of the city for over five years. She served two years as a state senator in the 1980s. In a Thursday interview, DeVries said there are many issues facing Alaska and that she wants to focus on "listening to people, transparency in government and limited government." DeVries, a conservative, said that she feels "very strongly" about election integrity and touted a 2022 ban on voting machines in the Mat-Su borough. She said that she supports following a statutory Permanent Fund dividend, and said Alaska needs to "rein in spending" to address its fiscal challenges. "We need to live within our means. And I don't see the state doing that right now," she said. DeVries said that she is a supporter of school choice. She was critical of a substantial education funding boost approved by the Legislature this year. She said that "we need to have some accountability." DeVries on Thursday filed a letter of intent with the Division of Elections to run as governor next year. That is the first step in launching a campaign, allowing the candidate to raise and spend money. DeVries said filing that letter is "sort of a testing of the waters." "Let's see what the response is out there, and get out and talk to the people to see if they see the same needs in our state as I do," she added. Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy, a Republican, is in the penultimate year of his second term. The Alaska Constitution forbids governors from holding office for a third consecutive term. Three other Republicans have filed letters of intent to run for governor in the November 2026 election: Lt. Gov. Nancy Dahlstrom, former Fairbanks Sen. Click Bishop, and business owner Bernadette Wilson.
Yahoo
05-06-2025
- Yahoo
University of Florida trustees stand by their controversial choice for college president
Century Tower on the Gainesville campus of the University of Florida. (Photo by Jay Waagmeester/Florida Phoenix) University of Florida trustees on Thursday stood by their selection of Santa Ono as the next president, despite his nomination being denied by the State University System Board of Governors (BOG). Mori Hosseini, chair of the UF Board of Trustees and a proponent of Ono, defended the UF trustees' decision to forward Ono to the BOG for final approval. 'Our Board of Trustees stands by the integrity of the search, the strength of the candidates it produced, and the principles that guided our work,' Hosseini said during a lengthy board meeting. 'This outcome is deeply disappointing to our Board of Trustees.' Ono was rejected by the Board of Governors in a 6-10 vote after he was questioned for hours about his conflicting stances on diversity, equity, and inclusion. The UF board voted unanimously in favor of Ono the week prior. Back to the drawing board: UF presidential finalist nixed for conflicting DEI stances Had he received the job, Ono's contract would have provided him about $3 million annually. 'We believe Dr. Ono was uniquely qualified to lead this university at this moment,' Hosseini continued. 'The symbolism and substance of the sitting president of a university as prestigious as University of Michigan, choosing to come to University of Florida should not be lost. It was a powerful signal that Florida's model for higher education grounded in merit, academic excellence, institutional neutrality, and accountability to students and taxpayers is earning the trust and interest of top team leaders across the country who are ready to advance this vision.' The UF presidency is being filled on an interim basis by former President Kent Fuchs. The permanent job has been open since July, when former U.S. Sen. Ben Sasse resigned from the presidency. 'We will continue to pursue the kind of bold principle and forward thinking leadership that Gator nation deserves,' Hosseini concluded. SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
