HC Orders Demolition of Encroachment on Road, Slaps Rs5 Lakh Fine on Developer
Nagpur: The Nagpur bench of Bombay high court on Tuesday ordered
Nirmal Ujjwal Credit Co-operative Society
to demolish
illegal constructions
—including a substation, transformer, and water treatment plant — erected on a 24-metre-wide Development Plan (DP) road in a township at mouza Harpur on Umred Road. The court also imposed a Rs5 lakh fine, directing it be paid to Raman Science Centre and Planetarium within one week.
A division bench comprising justices Avinash Gharote and Abhay Mantri was hearing a petition filed by local resident Pranali Puttewar. The court found that despite the society's undertaking in 2019 to remove the encroachments, it failed to act, in violation of prior directives and land-use laws.
Rejecting arguments that the structures served residents and involved no commercial exploitation, the court held that construction on land earmarked as a public road under the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning (MRTP) Act cannot be justified or regularised without a formal modification of the development plan.
The bench cited the 2017 demolition notice issued by Nagpur Municipal Corporation (NMC) and emphasised that the society knowingly encroached on land meant for public use. It further dismissed the society's reliance on the Gunthewari Act, ruling that the layout approvals were not granted under its provisions.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
2025 Top Trending local enterprise accounting software [Click Here]
Esseps
Learn More
Undo
The court concluded that allowing such encroachments would set a dangerous precedent, undermining urban planning. It directed that the illegal structures be removed within four months, with Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Company Ltd (MSEDCL) providing assistance. Should the society fail to act, the NMC must carry out the demolition within a reasonable time thereafter.
"We cannot condone the illegality committed by the society of making illegal construction of substation/transformer/water treatment plant on the land of 24 meters wide DP road, as it would be setting an absolutely bad precedent, on the basis of which, builders would have a free hand to present a fait accompli, after having committed an illegality," the judges said while allowing the petition.
High Court Ruling – Key Points
- Nirmal Ujjwal Credit Co-operative Society ordered to demolish illegal structures on 24-metre DP road
- Structures include electric substation, transformer, water treatment plant
- Rs5 lakh fine imposed; to be paid to Raman Science Centre within one week
- Demolition within four months at society's cost
- MSEDCL to assist in removing electrical infrastructure
- If society fails, NMC will carry out demolition
- Court rejects justification citing public benefit
- Gunthewari Act defence dismissed, no approvals granted
- Encroachments condemned as 'bad precedent'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
HC judge calls for deeper engagement with law
Dimapur: Justice Y Longkumer, judge of Gauhati High Court, Kohima bench, on Friday called for deeper engagement with law, greater professional development and renewed commitment to justice by the lawyers. She said the panel lawyers, who often serve as the first line of access to justice for the marginalised and under-represented, now play a unique and essential role as educators, advisors and counsellors for common citizens at a time when the Indian legal system is undergoing a pivotal transition with the introduction of new criminal laws. Longkumer was speaking at the one-day orientation programme organised by the Nagaland State Legal Services Authority on new criminal laws — Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA) — for panel/retainer lawyers and Legal Aid Defence Counsel System lawyers in Kohima. She said the Indian criminal justice system is undergoing significant reforms with the introduction of the BNS, BNSS and BSA, replacing the IPC, CrPC and Indian Evidence Act. "These new legislative reforms are not just mere cosmetic changes but represent a new way of thinking on how the justice system is perceived, delivered and experienced by the common citizens," Longkumer said. She said the lawyers, who serve in the legal services panel, are often the first line of access to justice for the marginalised and under-represented, and their role now is more important than ever. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Top Cardiologist Says This Food Can Do Wonders For Your Health Gundry MD Learn More Undo "You have to learn to adapt to changes with professionalism and as it is with any legal transition, there will be challenges and uncertainties in the interpretation," the judge said. On existing practical difficulties, Longkumer cited the existence of different interpretations and sources, questions and the practical burden of unlearning and relearning while observing that now they have to change their mindset and start to unlearn the IPC, CrPC and learn the new laws.
Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
Online scammers dupe Panchkula resident of Rs 18L in stock trading fraud
1 2 3 Panchkula: The cybercrime police have registered a case against unknown individuals for allegedly duping a resident of Rs 18 lakh under the guise of offering high returns through online stock trading. No arrests have been made so far. Jagmendra Singh, 56, a resident of Sector 12A, filed a complaint stating that he was defrauded after responding to a Facebook advertisement promoting online trading. Upon engaging with the ad, he was introduced to a scheme called block trading, which promised daily profits of 10–20%. After sharing his contact details, Singh received a WhatsApp message from a woman named Aarti Bhalla, who claimed to be an assistant to Shripal Shah from Kotak Securities. She shared a profit plan for 2025, including stock details and company credentials such as Sebi registration and CIN numbers. Singh was then sent a form link and added to a WhatsApp group with around 150 members. Between May 10 and May 16, he observed daily stock recommendations and selling guidance within the group. Aarti Bhalla later guided him to install the Kotak QIB application, and a block trading specialist persuaded him to invest. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 40세 미만이라면 이 매혹적인 게임을 하지 마세요 경복의 바다 게임 플레이 Undo On May 16, Singh invested Rs 50,000 in Vivanta Industries shares, transferring the amount to an account claimed to be Sebi-certified. The app displayed his balance, encouraging more investments. He then invested Rs 1 lakh more on May 18 and sold shares on May 19, noting a profit balance of Rs 58,727.25 on the app. Encouraged by the apparent gains, Singh made additional transfers of Rs 60,000, Rs 1,99,000, Rs 1,00,000, Rs 2,00,000, and Rs 70,000 to various accounts. On June 4, he invested Rs 11 lakh in the IPO of Scoda Tube Ltd, bringing his total investment to Rs 18,79,000. The app showed a balance of Rs 1,10,80,241. However, when Singh attempted to withdraw Rs 1,20,000 on June 10, for his son's wedding, the transaction failed. He was informed that his funds were locked in an IPO and that he needed to deposit an additional Rs 8,02,414 to unlock them. Realising he had been scammed, Singh filed a complaint with the cyber police. After verifying the facts, the police registered a case against unknown persons and are scrutinising the accounts to which the money was transferred.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Clerk, colleague among 6 held for Rs 8 lakh robbery
Ghaziabad: Police arrested six persons after several gunfights in connection with the robbery of more than Rs 8 lakh from a cashier of an ice cream company in Kavi Nagar. Two of the accused were employees of the company, including the clerk who first reported the crime. On Monday, Amit Kumar was on his way to deposit Rs 8.15 lakh at a bank in Rajnagar for his company when he was allegedly approached and attacked by two assailants on a bike under the Nehru Nagar flyover. The accused threw chili powder in his eyes and threatened him with a weapon then fled with the bag of money. Kumar's employer filed a police complaint the same day and an FIR was registered under BNS section 309 (4) (robbery) against unknown persons. DCP (City) Dhawal Jaiswal said that Kavi Nagar police along with a SWAT team from the Crime Branch arrested Suraj Yadav (23), a resident of Lal Kuan, Nitin Kumar (20) of Hapur, and Manish Singh (24), a resident of Wave City, following a gunfight. Cops recovered Rs 4.3 lakh of the stolen money as well as three pistols with live and spent cartridges from their possession. Suraj and Nitin suffered gunshot injuries to their legs during the incident. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Mental Wellness Starts with a Simple Step Affordable Online Counseling | Search Ads Learn More Undo While being taken to the police station, Manish attempted to escape by snatching a pistol from a constable near the NDRF ground and firing shots, during which he was also injured in retaliatory police firing. Two other accused, Ankush alias Kale (20) of Masuri village and Brijesh Kumar (24) from Hapur, managed to escape, prompting a blockade and search operation. Later, they were both arrested by Madhuban Bapudham police near Bunkar Mart. Cops recovered Rs 1 lakh of the stolen money, illegal weapons, and the motorcycle used in the crime from their possession. The arrested accused told police during interrogation that the clerk, Amit Kumar, was also involved in the robbery, and cops subsequently arrested him as well. Accused Manish and Amit Kumar were cousins and both worked at the ice cream company. Amit had colluded with the other accused to steal the money he was supposed to deposit at the bank.
