Squabbling jurors return split verdict in Harvey Weinstein trial, can't agree on rape charge
Disgraced Hollywood perv Harvey Weinstein was convicted Wednesday of a top charge in his Manhattan sex-crimes retrial — but squabbling jurors so far have failed to reach a verdict on a lesser count.
The shocking, if unfinished, outcome also saw Weinstein acquitted on the second top count – a twist that nonetheless likely won't keep the 73-year-old former movie mogul from spending the rest of his life behind bars.
It capped nearly a week of jury deliberations marked by infighting — including hours before the partial verdict when the foreman dramatically said he felt bullied and that another juror had threatened him.
This prompted Weinstein to push for Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Curtis Farber to halt the trial — claiming he felt like he was being put at risk.
'You are endangering me, your honor. I am not getting a fair trial,' he whined.
The 12 angry jurors, seven women and five men, appeared poised to be sent home, when they told Farber they had reached a verdict on two of three charges against Weinstein.
The wheelchair-bound ex-Miramax studio boss held his head down when jurors announced they had found him guilty of a first-degree criminal sex act for allegedly assaulting Miriam 'Mimi' Haley, a former TV production assistant.
But when Weinstein was found not guilty on the same charge for the assault of Polish former model Kaja Sokola, his head sprang up and he looked at his attorneys, as if he was surprised.
Jurors didn't reach a verdict on a count of third-degree rape tied to allegations made by ex-actress Jessica Mann, and were told they'd have to come back Thursday for more deliberations.
'Frankly, it wasn't intended to be easy… but please continue to deliberate with a goal to reach your verdict,' Farber said.
The Tinseltown creep's first trial in Manhattan ended with a conviction, too — in a watershed moment for the #MeToo movement against sexual violence.
But New York's highest court overturned that verdict last year in a shocking decision and ordered a new trial in the same courthouse.
Whatever the full verdict, Weinstein is likely to be locked up for life.
The first-degree criminal sex act conviction carries a sentence of up to 25 years behind bars. The rape charge he still awaits a decision on carries a 4-year maximum prison sentence.
Weinstein has also been sentenced to 16 years in California on a rape conviction there.
Haley and Mann, who both testified in Weinstein's first Manhattan trial in 2020, returned for dramatic second stints on the witness stand.
The trial also saw a new alleged victim, Sokola, who testified that Weinstein forcibly performed oral sex on her at a Tribeca hotel in 2006, days shy of her 20th birthday.
'For myself, it closes a chapter that caused me a lot of pain,' Sokola said after the verdict was read Wednesday. '(Prosecutors) finally put the man who deserves to be in jail, in jail, for the rest of his life.'
Weinstein's first trial was marked by dramatic moments outside the courtroom, where dozens of women danced and chanted on the sidewalk in flash mob protests against sexual assault.
But this time around, the circus-like atmosphere seemed largely confined to the courtroom.
Weinstein's theatrical defense lawyer Arthur Aidala made nearly two dozen motions for mistrials throughout the seven-week trial and as jurors' deliberations descended into acrimony.
They reached a boiling point Wednesday after the foreman asked to speak to the judge about a situation that 'isn't very good.'
After a 20-minute closed-door conversation, Farber said the foreman outlined he felt threatened by another juror.
'Juror No. 1. made it very clear that he wasn't going to change his position… but he indicated that one other juror made comments to the effect that 'I would meet you outside one day' and there's yelling and screaming,' Farber said.
An apoplectic, beet-red Aidala called for a mistrial and melodramatically contended, 'There's a crime going on in there.'
'I should call 911 on his behalf,' Aidala offered.
Weinstein then asked to address the court, using the chance to call for an end to the fractious deliberations.
But the judge swatted down Weinstein, noting he has been in law for more than 30 years and jurors fighting is not different from anything else.
'I'm not going to allow any injustice to happen to you… I am very much guarding your right to have a fair trial,' Farber told him.
Soon afterward, jurors announced they'd reached the partial verdict.
The foreman later said jurors reached their decision on the two counts Friday, but still were hung up on the rape charge for Mann's accusations.
Mann, formerly an actress, sobbed while describing Weinstein raping her inside a Midtown hotel room in 2013, and discovering the sex fiend's erection-inducing drug needle in the trash afterward.
In her own dramatic testimony, Sokola had recalled for jurors how Weinstein name dropped A-list celebrities such as Gwyneth Paltrow after the shocking attack, before giving his teenage victim — who had screamed in horror — a demented word of purported advice.
'He said that I have to work on my stubbornness,' Sokola said. 'I have to listen to him if I want to proceed with that career.'
Haley, a former TV production assistant, told jurors that the Weinstein — who boasted the power to decide who appeared in films and who got jobs on sets — sexually assaulted her at his SoHo loft in 2006.
The Finland native stormed out of the courtroom in tears during a painstaking cross-examination from Weinstein's lawyer — snapping, 'Don't tell me I wasn't raped by that f–king a–hole!'
Haley, after the verdict, lambasted Weinstein's defense attorneys for inspiring chaos in the courtroom.
'The defense set a very disruptive and chaotic tone from the very start of this trial,' she said. 'I'm so grateful (the jury) saw through the nonsense and the antics.
'Testifying in the face of constant disruptions, victim shaming and deliberate attempts to distort the truth was exhausting and at times dehumanizing.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Washington Post
32 minutes ago
- Washington Post
‘The Berlin Diaries' is a twisting and resonant search for lost family
Playwright Andrea Stolowitz is a central character in her own 'The Berlin Diaries.' She is played by Dina Thomas in a delicately moving production at D.C.'s Theater J — except when she's played by actor Lawrence Redmond, who also inhabits the long-dead grandfather whose inherited journals set the show's affairs in motion. Except when Redmond is stepping into the role of the playwright's Uncle David. Or one of a dozen other characters, based everywhere from Brazil to South Africa to New York to the Pacific Northwest. With me? Fret not: If the play's structural quirkiness initially feels adventurous to the point of mild madness, it quickly reveals a method, even as its novelty settles into something like normalcy. In fact the dialogue-juggling — in which the two actors often divide a thought mid-phrase while inhabiting the same character — deftly suggests the sort of wait-who-was-that? conundrums that any genealogist grappling with a knotty ancestral puzzle might get tangled in. For instance, I bear the same name as both my father and my grandfather, and there's another handful perched a few generations back in the family tree. This means that 'No, the Thomas who was killed when a branch fell on him in 1762 was a farmer; his son Thomas was the Presbyterian minister,' is the kind of thing I find myself clarifying mid-story, as if anyone other than a desperate family-history nerd could possibly follow. One intriguing dynamic with 'Berlin Diaries' is precisely that Andrea Stolowitz, or at least the character with her name, doesn't seem that sort of nerd at all. She's a mildly jaded playwright and teaching artist whose family isn't all that large or all that close, and who's not particularly interested in the diary her mother has been saving all this time. Yes, they're Jewish, and yes, they emigrated from Germany — but as Uncle David shrugs, 'Everyone made it here alive. … There's nothing to find out.' Unconvinced, but also under-inspired, and entirely uncertain what she's actually looking for, Andrea does what teaching artists do when confronted with things like old diaries: She writes a grant proposal and takes off for Europe. Unsurprisingly, she'll uncover rather more than Uncle David's shrug suggests, and in its clean 90 minutes 'Berlin Diaries' chronicles developments as concrete as confusion about a street address and as esoteric as the singular frisson that comes with stumbling across a headstone and knowing that a faded name on a dusty page really lived and died in this actual place, at that actual time. And its protagonist will confront the reality that even now, even after decades of diligent documentation, even given the famously meticulous recordkeeping that accompanied the Holocaust, it's possible for people — for whole swaths of whole families — simply to be verschollen, lost. Theater J's handsome production, steered with a light touch and admirable clarity by director Elizabeth Dinkova, deploys warm woods (in a set by Sarah Beth Hall) and plenty of papers (props are from Pamela Weiner), along with one of the most quietly lyrical visual vocabularies I've seen in a theater lately. (Colin K. Bills is responsible for the lighting, and Deja Collins the subtle and exquisite suite of projections.) Redmond and Thomas navigate a tricky script with the ease of veterans and a wry, low-key charm that helps find an appropriate unifying tone for a narrative that involves the soberest of considerations — but also at least one anatomical joke and (rather boldly) the employment of mild sarcasm in the vicinity of the words 'never forget.' And Stolowitz manages, without belaboring or dwelling on grim specifics, to convey the quiet horror of discovering the name of a lost relative in the same moment you realizing that that person's story is largely and irremediably lost. 'He who forgets what he cannot change is happy,' muses Andrea at one point, echoing a line from her grandfather's journal, though it's not clear she can bring herself to agree. 'The Berlin Diaries' will resonate, and vividly, with audiences who caught Tom Stoppard's similarly aching family chronicle 'Leopoldstadt' at the Shakespeare Theatre Company late last year – and I should imagine with any member of a Jewish American generation whose parents and grandparents simply couldn't bear to pass on the stories of the lost. The Berlin Diaries, through June 29 at Theater J. About 90 minutes without intermission.
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Three dead, one critically injured in Wisconsin shooting; police investigate
JANESVILLE, Wis. (WFRV) – Authorities are investigating a shooting that left three people dead and one critically injured Tuesday morning at an apartment complex in Wisconsin. According to the Janesville Police Department, officers were dispatched at 11:04 a.m. to a report of a family issue at an apartment on the 2600 block of N. Pontiac Drive. While responding, dispatch received multiple additional calls reporting shots fired at the same location. Former Wisconsin father accused of murdering three daughters may have changed appearance Officers entered the apartment and found four adult victims. Three were pronounced dead from gunshot wounds, while the fourth victim was found critically injured. Officers performed life-saving measures at the scene, and the surviving victim was transported to a nearby hospital with life-threatening injuries. Police say the investigation remains active and that there is no known threat to the community. Wisconsin investment advisor charged with stealing over $15 million from investors 'Incidents like this are not just news stories or case numbers,' said Janesville Police Chief Chad Pearson. 'They are life-altering events, and they lead to lasting impacts on the victims, loved ones, and those who live or work in the surrounding community, and every first responder that steps into these difficult situations.' Officials say more information will be released in the coming days. No additional details are available at this time. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
CBS News
38 minutes ago
- CBS News
Arrest made after Miami Beach condo resident pistol-whipped during home invasion, police say
An arrest has been made in a Miami Beach condominium home invasion in which a man was pistol-whipped, and money and a phone were stolen, according to Miami Beach police. Investigators the same suspect committed an armed burglary shortly before that. According to police, on Tuesday, June 17, officers were sent to Flamingo Towers at 1508 Bay Road to check out reports of an armed robbery. A woman who lives in the building said she was walking to a trash chute when an armed man, who police identified as 31-year-old Brian Lopez of Hialeah, pulled a gun on her and demanded that she take him to her unit, according to police. Once there, Lopez allegedly threatened the woman, a person who lives with her (identified in the police report as J.K.), and someone who was staying with them. He demanded that they get on the ground and hand over their belongings, investigators said. "Initially, J.K. resisted the defendant's commands and refused to get on the ground. The defendant then pistol whipped J.K. by striking him on the top of his head, causing a minor laceration," according to the report. Investigators said J.K. was forced to transfer $1,500 via cell and Lopez stole one of their cellphones. He then allegedly demanded that they take him to their vehicle. When the group made it to the lobby, J.K. screamed for help and Lopez took off, according to the report. He was taken into custody a short time later. During the course of their investigation, police said they determined that Lopez had also committed another burglary in the building prior to this incident. In that incident, Lopez is accused of stealing a man's wallet, phone and keys to his unit. Lopez is facing one count of armed home invasion, three counts of armed robbery with a deadly weapon, and one count of armed burglary with battery. During his first court appearance on Friday, the judge found there was probable cause for the charges and ordered that he be held without bond.
