The plan to turn 34th Street into a ‘busway' is a road to nowhere
The next unwelcome upheaval coming to Manhattan's streets has nothing to do with congestion pricing. The Department of Transportation's latest strike against motorists is a 'proposal' to turn 34th Street, from Third Avenue to Ninth Avenue, into a 'busway.'
There are quotation marks around 'proposal' because the scheme is certain to be a done deal by August. The DOT always gets its way, never mind a rubber-stamp City Hall review.
6 Despite its potential to cause havoc and chaos for millions of daily NYC commuters, the DOT wants to transform a major slice of 34th Street into a 'busway' and boost sluggish public transport.
deberarr – stock.adobe.com
Advertisement
The 34th Street project's purpose is to speed up buses — currently cruising at a mere 3 mph on the major crosstown artery — by 15%, the DOT said.
But banning 34th Street to through car traffic is of a piece with the insidious agenda the DOT has inflicted on New Yorkers for years: limiting or disallowing auto traffic at any particular location in the name of reducing congestion — but with the unstated, actual goal to increase congestion on neighboring streets and avenues. The purpose: To prove that cars are evil and bikes are better.
Now, if cars can't use most of 34th Street — duh — they'll have to go somewhere else. Once the change takes effect, expect presently crowded 32rd, 33rd, 35th and 36th Streets to bear the brunt of the spillover.
Advertisement
6 The goal of the 'busway' scheme, says proponents, is to increase bus speeds from its current snail-like 3mph.
Corbis via Getty Images
The 34th Street diktat stinks even on its own supposedly mass transit-friendly terms. As The Post's Gabrielle Fahmy reported this week, regular, actual bus users argued before Community Board 5 that the new busway will do little or nothing to make bus travel faster. That's because the MTA, which works in lockstep with the DOT, won't do what's needed most: provide more buses.
The passengers weren't mistaken. I counted precisely two so-called Select crosstown buses, one in either direction, on a half-hour stroll along 34th Street's commercial heart between Fifth and Seventh avenues Wednesday afternoon. Of course, simply adding buses would remove the supposed need to warp a thoroughfare that's a critical part of the city's commercial DNA.
6 Despite the outsized influence of the city's 'bike-lobby,' a mere 61,000 commuters arrive to New York City each day on cycles.
Gregory P. Mango
Advertisement
Although 34th Street won't have a bike lane, the gridlock points that inevitably pop up when cars are diverted are cited by the DOT's bike-lobby stooges as proof that the problem is too many cars, and by Gov. Hochul and former governor and mayoral candidate Andrew Cuomo, who inflicted 'congestion pricing' on us.
But the cycling lobby, led by an uncompromising organization called Transportation Alternatives, cowed elected officials into ignoring the reality of how most city dwellers reach their jobs.
According to the latest US census, 1.87 million Big Apple residents take public transit to work. Just over one million more go by car, either as drivers or as part of a car pool.
6 In tandem with the MTA, the New York Department of Transport is likely to approve the 'busway' plan, even if it is not in the best interest of Tri-State commuters.
Advertisement
In contrast, the number of city dwellers who get to their jobs by bike was 61,600 in 2023, as per the DOT. That's a 'whopping' 2.2% of total city residents: a percentage that would be lower still if the data included commuting patterns of the tens of thousands of suburbanites who pour into Manhattan each day.
Yet the relatively tiny bike-riding cohort enjoys special privileges at everyone else's expense. Metastasizing bike lanes, which now stretch 1,500 miles in the five boroughs, are the largest reason for the nightmare that streets are today for ordinary motorists, taxi and truck drivers — and, even, yes, for buses.
Other tricks the DOT has up its woke sleeves are 'plazas' inserted where there's no need for them; no-left-turn rules that trap hapless motorists on 23rd Street for blocks on end; and Third Avenue traffic lights from East 60th to East 96th streets re-timed to reduce speeds from 25 mph to 15 mph, the latter speed ideally suited to cyclists.
6 The pro-bike non-profit Transportation Alternatives is behind the plan to reconfigure the 34th Street corridor.
When bike lanes, barriers and 'plazas' reduced Broadway to a single auto lane south of 34th Street, was it surprising that the traffic merely spilled over to surrounding avenues and streets?
Congestion pricing? Hah! Notoriously gridlocked West 47th Street between Sixth Avenue and Times Square remains a horn-honking horror ever since Broadway south of West 48th Street was closed to cars several years ago, forcing them to turn left onto Seventh Avenue.
6 Even with the most optimal outcome, there is little doubt that the 34th Street 'busway' plan will shift traffic congestion to adjoining side-streets.
Andriy Blokhin – stock.adobe.com
Advertisement
The DOT, enabled by spineless mayors, was hijacked by anti-auto, climate-obsessed ideologues with little interest in the agency's traditional mission to simply make streets as safe and sane as possible. Little wonder DOT commissioner Ydanis Rodríguez touts the city's 'bike infrastructure accomplishments as a climate-justice solution,' City & State reported.
Let's hope the next mayor will have the guts to make the DOT return to its core mission. But given the candidates' pro-cyclist sympathies, the Dodgers will return to Brooklyn sooner.
scuozzo@nypost.com
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
32 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Mayor Adams to hold reelection kickoff event, aide misuses city email account to advertise it
NEW YORK — Mayor Eric Adams is hosting a kickoff event for his reelection campaign this coming week — and an aide in his office violated city rules by using his government email account to advertise the gathering, the Daily News has learned. The 'special campaign announcement' is set to take place Thursday morning on the steps of City Hall, per a poster the aide, Grant Yanney, sent to a list of dozens of city government colleagues and others, according to a source who provided The News with a copy of the message. 'MEA needs our support! Save this image and blast out to your folks via text and Gmail,' Yanney, a director in Adams' office of talent and workforce development, wrote in the Saturday message, using his City Hall email account. 'Special note: If you can take an early lunch, please save the date and make plans to join Mayor Adams on City Hall steps.' The poster Yanney attached to the message says it was produced by Adams' campaign and includes the phrase 'Reelect Eric for mayor. Delivers. Never quits,' a new slogan for his reelection bid. 'Join us for a 'special' campaign announcement with Eric Adams for 2025,' the poster says. 'RSVP to be part of this exciting event. Let's work together towards a bright tomorrow.' Under local law, municipal employees like Yanney cannot use 'any city resources,' including email accounts, for 'any political activity,' according to the city Conflicts of Interest Board. The board in 2007 fined a city public school principal $5,000 for sending a letter to parents of her students urging them to support an elected official's reelection. COIB Executive Director Carolyn Miller wouldn't comment on Yanney's situation due to the panel's confidential enforcement process. Miller did confirm 'public servants are prohibited from using City resources, including City email accounts, for any campaign-related activity.' Yanney, who has worked for Adams since joining his Brooklyn borough president's office in 2021, acknowledged he shouldn't have sent the message from his city government account, calling it an 'honest mistake.' 'I accidentally sent the email from my work account instead of my personal Gmail,' he wrote in an email to The News, adding he was multitasking at the time, dealing with personal matters. Additional details about Thursday's campaign kickoff event weren't immediately available. Reps for Adams' office and campaign didn't immediately return requests for comment.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Mayor Adams to hold reelection kickoff event, aide misuses city email account to advertise it
NEW YORK — Mayor Eric Adams is hosting a kickoff event for his reelection campaign this coming week — and an aide in his office violated city rules by using his government email account to advertise the gathering, the Daily News has learned. The 'special campaign announcement' is set to take place Thursday morning on the steps of City Hall, per a poster the aide, Grant Yanney, sent to a list of dozens of city government colleagues and others, according to a source who provided The News with a copy of the message. 'MEA needs our support! Save this image and blast out to your folks via text and Gmail,' Yanney, a director in Adams' office of talent and workforce development, wrote in the Saturday message, using his City Hall email account. 'Special note: If you can take an early lunch, please save the date and make plans to join Mayor Adams on City Hall steps.' The poster Yanney attached to the message says it was produced by Adams' campaign and includes the phrase 'Reelect Eric for mayor. Delivers. Never quits,' a new slogan for his reelection bid. 'Join us for a 'special' campaign announcement with Eric Adams for 2025,' the poster says. 'RSVP to be part of this exciting event. Let's work together towards a bright tomorrow.' Under local law, municipal employees like Yanney cannot use 'any city resources,' including email accounts, for 'any political activity,' according to the city Conflicts of Interest Board. The board in 2007 fined a city public school principal $5,000 for sending a letter to parents of her students urging them to support an elected official's reelection. COIB Executive Director Carolyn Miller wouldn't comment on Yanney's situation due to the panel's confidential enforcement process. Miller did confirm 'public servants are prohibited from using City resources, including City email accounts, for any campaign-related activity.' Yanney, who has worked for Adams since joining his Brooklyn borough president's office in 2021, acknowledged he shouldn't have sent the message from his city government account, calling it an 'honest mistake.' 'I accidentally sent the email from my work account instead of my personal Gmail,' he wrote in an email to The News, adding he was multitasking at the time, dealing with personal matters. Additional details about Thursday's campaign kickoff event weren't immediately available. Reps for Adams' office and campaign didn't immediately return requests for comment.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Mayor Adams to hold reelection kickoff event, aide misuses city email account to advertise it: source
Mayor Adams is hosting a kickoff event for his reelection campaign this coming week — and an aide in his office violated city rules by using his government email account to advertise the gathering, the Daily News has learned. The 'special campaign announcement' is set to take place Thursday morning on the steps of City Hall, per a poster the aide, Grant Yanney, sent to a list of dozens of city government colleagues and others, according to a source who provided The News with a copy of the message. 'MEA needs our support! Save this image and blast out to your folks via text and Gmail,' Yanney, a director in Adams' office of talent and workforce development, wrote in the Saturday message, using his City Hall email account. 'Special note: If you can take an early lunch, please save the date and make plans to join Mayor Adams on City Hall steps.' The poster Yanney attached to the message says it was produced by Adams' campaign and includes the phrase 'Reelect Eric for mayor. Delivers. Never quits,' a new slogan for his reelection bid. 'Join us for a 'special' campaign announcement with Eric Adams for 2025,' the poster says. 'RSVP to be part of this exciting event. Let's work together towards a bright tomorrow.' Under local law, municipal employees like Yanney cannot use 'any city resources,' including email accounts, for 'any political activity,' according to the city Conflicts of Interest Board. The board in 2007 fined a city public school principal $5,000 for sending a letter to parents of her students urging them to support an elected official's reelection. COIB Executive Director Carolyn Miller wouldn't comment on Yanney's situation due to the panel's confidential enforcement process. Miller did confirm 'public servants are prohibited from using City resources, including City email accounts, for any campaign-related activity.' Yanney, who has worked for Adams since joining his Brooklyn borough president's office in 2021, didn't immediately respond to an email seeking comment. Additional details about Thursday's campaign kickoff event weren't immediately available. Reps for Adams' office and campaign didn't immediately return requests for comment.
